StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Escaping Salem the Other Which Hunt of 1692 - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay describes the events of 1692, that happened in Salem, America. Witchcraft and the things that surround witchcraft trials throughout history have long been a subject of fascination to the American public. This essay focuses on the book Escaping Salem: The Other Witch Hunt of 1692 written by Richard Goldbeer…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
Escaping Salem the Other Which Hunt of 1692
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Escaping Salem the Other Which Hunt of 1692"

? Witchcraft and the things that surround witchcraft trials throughout history have long been a of fascination to the American public. The stories of the Salem witchcraft trials have been told and retold in many different formats, from classrooms all the way to the stage, where Arthur Miller’s retelling in The Crucible is probably the best known. This process of retelling, however, means that very few people know the details of what really happened in the Salem witchcraft trial or in any of the other trials that occurred in America around that time period: the established narrative in American mythology is too strong. The prominence of Salem also overshadows other witchcraft trials, either giving the impression that every trial mirrored Salem exactly or that it was the only witchcraft trial of the period. Author Richard Goldbeer is trying to deconstruct these trends in his book Escaping Salem: The Other Witch Hunt of 1692. In this book Goldbeer describes and analyzes the events surrounding the lesser known witch hunt of 1692 Stamford, Connecticut. He presents a very interesting read in which he strikes a fine balance between accurate and reliable history and telling the story of what happened in Stamford in and, possibly more importantly, entertaining way. This review will begin by briefly describing the contents of the book, then will move on to the successes and failures of the work. This work succeeds in balancing academic concerns with concerns over readability, and does a good job playing off of the myth of Salem to demonstrate how witchcraft trials actually occurred in the vast majority of cases, while connecting the lessons learned from witchcraft trials in the seventeenth century to instances occurring today and demonstrating why it is important to understand what truly happened. The only major failing of this work is a side effect of its success: to preserve readability and narrative structure, Goldbeer does not clearly demonstrate where he got which sources, which makes it hard to analyze the where he gets the information for his narrative excerpts. Escaping Salem is divided into eight different segments: the first, the prologue, gives a small narrative to provide context and give interest to the story and begin to tell the story of why we should care about this particular witchcraft trial compared to the much more publicized one in Salem. It then moves on through the story in a logical and roughly chronological manner, moving to “Katherine Branch’s Fits,” the fits that began the trials, the examination of the causes of her suffering in the section “Who is it that torments her?” before pausing to outline the incredibly detailed legal proceedings that were involved in determining the guilt or innocence of the accused, the different kinds of evidence that can be used and so on (Goldbeer, 16, 33, 51. This section is probably one of the most interesting in the entire book – witchcraft trials are so often portrayed as being filled with hellfire and brimstone preachers, publics willing to believe anything, and judges willing to hide sordid secrets, Goldbeer’s description of the highly elaborate systems involved is truly fascinating (57). There was a very clear legal delineation between the kinds of evidence that could or could not be used to accuse someone of being a witch, and overall the tenor of the discussion held were much more reasonable than one would think (59). Furthermore, it is incredibly interesting to see that overall the judges and public tended to be much more critical in examining evidence of witchcraft than is usually described, and in fact tended to disbelieve accusations of witchcraft rather than lend them credence. The book then goes on to describe the debates held about this particular case, the incredibly emotional debates that followed, and the uneasy truce that follows any witchcraft trial regardless of the outcome. Finally, it closes with a long afterwards that talks about the forces that come to bear on any witchcraft trials in either the modern times or in historic times, and what they say about the societies that have them. Now that the general outline of this book has been discussed, it is important to move on to the things that it succeeded at and the ways in which it failed. This book certainly succeeds in many more ways than it fails, and its failures are, in many ways, nearly impossible to avoid side effects of the positive aspects. By far the greatest success of this work is its readability. So often history written recently is dry, complicated and nearly impossible to read – Goldbeer’s work bucks this trend in several ways, which makes it incredibly readable and accessible to students of a wide variety of age levels. By far the most important of these is the simple and well written narrative framework that pervades the book. It opens like any story does, by setting the scene, and sounds almost like an historical fiction: “It was early evening in June 1692, and dusk was falling over Stamford” (1). It uses highly evocative language as well, with examples from the prologue perhaps being the best ones: “a piercing, blood-chilling scream” initiating the trials, or describing the “horrifying contortions” that people went through when experiencing supposed possession by witches (5). The language used is also relatively simple, which keeps the book accessible and allows it to pass the “McDonalds Test” – if you walked into a McDonalds and handed it to the first person you meet to read, they would probably read and understand everything quite well. Finally, it keeps interest through occasional comparisons to the much better known Salem Trials throughout the prologue, chapters in the middle of the work and especially in the afterwards (153). Finally, this book always makes it clear how the world appeared to the people living in their time, how without scientific explanations for things witchcraft did not seem so strange, and how the mystical was always an essential part of everyday life (10). This work succeeds extremely well because of how highly readable it is, which makes it accessible to a large audience and many age groups, and in its ability to let the reader see through the eyes of those who were actually experiencing the events. More impressively, this accessibility does not come at the cost of accuracy or of depth of analysis, which are both done extremely well. Another of the successes of this book is that it deconstructs the myth of how witchcraft trials actually progressed. This book does not assume its reader comes from an objective point of view, but rather understands that the reader is coming from a culture that is pervaded with mythology surrounding witchcraft trials, and witchcraft trials of Salem most especially. It does this by making constant reference to the Salem trials, from the title (which interestingly mentions Salem but not the town in Connecticut that the book actually talks about) through to the end of the book. It constantly compares the trials happening in Stamford to the ones that had occurred in Salem, for instance, mentioning that “over fifty individuals” were found guilty in Salem (104), and contrasting the “chaos” that had occurred in Salem with the more orderly process that occurred in other witchcraft trials (112). This book does an excellent job in drawing contrasts between the Salem trials and the ones in Stamford, thus allowing the reader to use and connect to their previous knowledge and deconstructing the mythology that surrounds the witchcraft trials in Salem to this day. The only major complaint with this book is a consequence of its readability: sometimes the sources of information Goldbeer draws on are hard to identify. While he makes explicit references to court testimony fairly frequently, when he gives a more narrative style account it is hard to see what elements are conjecture and what are more grounded in fact – essentially it blurs the line between the writing of history and the writing of historical fiction. The book is so accurate, however, and written so well, it is hard to dwell on this small error. Goldbeer’s Escape from Salem is an excellent book and should be read by anyone with any interest in witchcraft trials in general or in the Salem trials in particular. It especially succeeds in how well written it is, how accessible it is, and what an excellent job it does conveying the world of seventeenth century America to the reader, while it fails somewhat in creating a clear delineation between elements of conjecture and elements that are more certainly factual. It is incredibly interesting to learn the truth about how witchcraft trials usually actually progressed, and how the case of Salem was an aberration, not a pattern. Works Cited Goldbeer, Richard. Escaping Salem: The Other Witch Hunt of 1692. New York: Oxford UP 2004. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Escaping Salem the Other Which Hunt of 1692 Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/history/1437617-escaping-salem-the-other-which-hunt-of-1692
(Escaping Salem the Other Which Hunt of 1692 Book Report/Review)
https://studentshare.org/history/1437617-escaping-salem-the-other-which-hunt-of-1692.
“Escaping Salem the Other Which Hunt of 1692 Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1437617-escaping-salem-the-other-which-hunt-of-1692.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Escaping Salem the Other Which Hunt of 1692

Why does witchcraft continue to intrigue successive generations of Anthropologists

According to Detweiler (1975), numerous theories that have been established by different scholars generally demonstrate that witchcraft acts as a form of social control, serves as a way through which life misfortunes are explained and helps in releasing social tension.... Their thoughts regarding the alternative causes of these events give them logical, coherent explanations which fully or partially satisfy their beliefs.... They are famous for their witchcraft called mangu, which plays a significant role in shaping their understanding of the world and occurrences....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Implementation of Marketing Strategies

Unlike the other competitor companies like Ab Sugar, the company alone has the privilege of holding the whole quota of the European Union.... This reform which is supposed to create facilities for the sugar market has in turn created a lot of problems, like imposing various kinds of quotas, various kinds of import tariffs and export tariffs.... For example the companies which are small in size and also do not have very high turnover have problems paying innumerable tariffs....
13 Pages (3250 words) Assignment

Salem Trials in Parallel with the Cold War and Arms Race

A grave social misconduct, unfounded suspicions, academic inadequacies, social injustice and oppression are but few of the characteristics that defines the nature of the Salem trials in 1692.... In America, a massive hunt for communist began.... The arrest, prosecution and execution of the Rosenbergs started the massive hunt for treacherous act which denotes how suspicions play a role in one's decision over the inherent right to be heard and to live freely....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Role of Religious Strife in the Witch Hunts in Switzerland

When examining this perspective of witch craft, it could be seen that the witch culture was one in which many decided to destroy, specifically because of the rituals that broke different laws and went against both church and state in ways that they functioned.... The methodology which was used in this particular study was to examine the rituals of witches and to look at case studies which were developed because of the actions of witches.... The perspective that is developed creates a social and scientific option, which shows how witches were approaching the community, as well as what the society believed in return because of events that were occurring (Demos, 1972)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Book Report/Review

Analysis of Escaping Salem Book by Richard Godbeer

Escaping Salem; The other witch hunt of 1692.... In addition, she suffers severe mental torture, magnified by the fact that her escaping salem the book is a literary dis which covers the early American history of the witch hunt in 1692.... The book escaping salem takes the reader through the Connecticut court room.... scaping salem offers an insightful revelation of life style in the early seventeenth century America....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Escaping Salem: The Other Witch Hunt of 1692

Her fits and torments are dubious at best.... From a legal perspective, the testimonies were not even convincing.... Of all the testimonies given against the two accused—Disborough and Clawson—extremely few provided… One of the numerous battles of Katherine against her supernatural tormentors gives a vital hint why she accused the Devil....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Largest Segments of the Food Industry: Quick Pizza

The paper presents the business idea of creating Quick Pizza.... The ability of Quick Pizza to provide faster service than the industry is a competitive advantage.... Quick Pizza can provide profits for its owners in the short and long term.... The first pizza cart will generate profits.... hellip; Quick Pizza is a proposed franchising concept for a line of genuine NY- Neapolitan style mobile trailer pizzerias....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Analysis of Escaping Salem: The Other Witch Hunt of 1692 by Richard Goldbeer

The author examines "Escaping Salem: The Other Witch hunt of 1692" book by Richard Goldbeer in which the writer describes the events surrounding the lesser known witch hunt of 1692 Stamford.... Author Richard Goldberg is trying to deconstruct these trends in his book Escaping Salem: The Other Witch hunt of 1692.... In this book, Goldberg describes and analyzes the events surrounding the lesser known witch hunt of 1692 in Stamford, Connecticut....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us