We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Nobody downloaded yet

An Analysis of Robert V. Remini's Andrew Jackson Versus the Cherokee Nation - Essay Example

Comments (0)
Summary
(Name) (Professor) (Subject) (Date) An Analysis of Robert V. Remini’s “Andrew Jackson Versus the Cherokee Nation” Robert Remini’s essay “Andrew Jackson Versus the Cherokee Nation” had one thing to say: Although the Cherokees and their leaders were partly to blame for the “monstrous” horror that ensued from the Indian Removal Act, it was President Andrew Jackson who was mainly responsible for such brutality…
Download full paper
GRAB THE BEST PAPER
An Analysis of Robert V. Reminis Andrew Jackson Versus the Cherokee Nation
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
An Analysis of Robert V. Remini's Andrew Jackson Versus the Cherokee Nation

Download file to see previous pages... Their rationale was that since “they no longer threatened white settlements,” then they should not be expelled from their lands in Georgia and relocated to the Indian territory, which is located in present-day Oklahoma (48). In addition to this national sentiment against the proposed Indian Removal Act, various individuals that politically represented the Cherokees – John Ross, John Ridge and Major Ridge – sought audience with Jackson on a possible compromise regarding the looming Indian removal, but to no avail (51-53). Perhaps, two other instances that showed the resolve of the Cherokees was when a number of Cherokee chiefs went to Washington in an effort to prevent the signing of the treaty, and when John Ross encouraged the Indians to ignore the newly signed treaty (53-56). Although the author does not mention it, the Cherokees were partly to blame for what happened to them two years after the Indian Removal Act was signed. Had they only remained obedient to Jackson and the laws of the state, the bloodshed of 1838 would not have been as worse. Much of the blame also rested upon John Ross. Unlike his contemporaries John Ridge and Major Ridge, who were more liberal-minded and were willing to make compromises with the government, John Ross approached the issue rather conservatively and “acted imprudently and made impossible demands on the President” (52). Among the rather outrageous requests of Ross in behalf of the Cherokee people included a five-year protection of the Indians using federal troops as well as $20 million for the “reimbursement for losses” (53). Even after Jackson’s rejection of such requests, Ross remained stubborn and encouraged the Indians to remain in their territory even after the two-year deadline had elapsed (55-56). It was, however, the Indians themselves who suffered the consequences as many of them were slaughtered by federal troops and many more suffered in “The Trail of Tears” (56). If only Ross had not maintained his pride and had only explained to his people the wisdom in obedience, the Cherokees would not have been massacred and would even have perhaps thanked Ross for it. The author, however, puts the blame lightly on the Cherokees and Ross and somehow considers Andrew Jackson the man behind the murders: “He had become obsessed about removal” (56). Sharp Knife, as Jackson was called by the Cherokees, despite the ruling of the Supreme Court in 1831, perhaps influenced the passing of the law in 1830 “prohibiting white men from entering an Indian country” (48). Jackson also asked Schermerhorn to secretly negotiate the treaty with the Treaty Party of the Cherokees in an effort to advance the signing of the Indian Removal Act (53). Moreover, Jackson did not show any mercy or concern for the large delegation of Indian chiefs who went to Washington in 1835 (53-54). Lastly, the man who called himself the “Great Father” of the Indians was the one who “regularly badgered [President] Van Buren about enforcing the treaty” (56). These were all proofs that Andrew Jackson did not play the game fairly and tried to outsmart the Cherokees by resorting to secret tactics just to have the treaty signed and have the Indians removed in no time. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Government impact on the Cherokee nation
The Cherokee Nation and the US government have had every imaginable form of relationship, from trading partners to colonizers to warring bodies violently seeking to eradicate each other. Throughout this entire history, however, the Cherokee people have found some form of the United States government fighting against their very existence.
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Andrew Jackson vs. Henry Clay
Andrew Jackson and Henry Clay were both well-known politicians in the course of United States history, often because of their differing views on politics and policy. Both had strong wills and even stronger ideas about the way that the country should be run, advocating different paths for the growth and development of the country.
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Andrew Jackson
While Jacksonian democracy emerged to promote the rule of the ‘mass’ and the ‘common’ of America, the policies that substantiated Jackson’s regime and their impact apparently became the chief determinants that aid in the assessment of his presidency and the truth of its underlying ethics.
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Cherokee Indian Nation
Today, The Cherokee Nation is the governmental body that is officially recognized by the US government. With the capital located in the W.W. Keeler Complex near Tahlequah, Oklahoma, the tribe has full sovereign status as granted by treaty. The constitution of the Cherokee nation was ratified in 1976 and being similar to the US constitution it allows for three branches of government: The Executive, Legislative, and Judicial.
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay
Andrew Jackson
Yet, a close scrutiny of the Jacksonian type of democracy, as exemplified in the three documents, demonstrates that Jackson is consistent with his view of the role of the federal government and his obligations as President by asserting the 'faithful' execution of the laws to protect the federalist ideals through the power vested in him as the President, by ensuring that the collision of the state and the federal government is avoided and by protecting the welfare of the people through the elimination of the vestige of foreign powers in national policies.
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Andrew Jackson and William T. Sherman
Another person, whose control and charisma was as dominant and evident as that commanded by Jackson was William Sherman, who embraced the challenge of war without batting an eyelid. His strategy of
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Andrew Jackson and John Marshall
After his election as president, Jackson’s power increased, and he became partial supporter of some state rights. Jackson was a delegate of the Tennessee constitution review. On the other hand, John
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Andrew Jackson
Crawford home is thought to have welcomed this future president into the world because the mother travelled later when she was well (Bassett 6). Andrew Jackson believed and stated many times that he was born in South Carolina. He even wrote to James H. Witherspoon to confirm
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Andrew Jackson
His election had a great impact on American politics although it was riddled with challenges and controversies. Jackson was very popular with the people especially after his victory as a military leader in various
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Jackson and The Cherokee ( The Trail of Tears )
His kindness made him donate his dry land for the American people to rest their weary feet. At that period, the Indian was the lord while the white man was the suppliant. However, look at the situation now. The once strong red man has
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Let us find you another Essay on topic An Analysis of Robert V. Remini's Andrew Jackson Versus the Cherokee Nation for FREE!
Contact us:
+16312120006
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us