Nobody downloaded yet

Canadian Politics - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Canada is supposed to be a parliamentary system, but the judiciary and the executive exert undue power in contemporary Canadian politics. The establishment of parliamentary systems in countries worldwide aims to achieve the following target: to ensure that the rules of democracy will be adequately promoted…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.2% of users find it useful
Canadian Politics
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Canadian Politics"

Download file to see previous pages This issue has also appeared in Canada. The country’s governance has structured in such way that all key decisions are taken by parliament; however, actions that are opposed to the country’s parliamentary system have not been avoided. At this point, the following dilemma has been set: should the power of the judiciary and the executive in Canada be controlled so that the power of the country’s parliamentary system to be adequately protected? It is argued that the limitation of the power of judiciary and executive in Canada would be quite necessary in order to ensure that democracy in the country is sufficiently promoted. The above argument is justified and appropriately backed by referring to the relevant literature. Particular emphasis is given on the power of parties and the judiciary to define the terms on which parliamentary decisions in Canada are based. In the study of Charlton and Barker emphasis is given on the potential limitation of the party discipline in Canada, so that the freedom of the members of the parliament to be increased. Reference is made to two, opposite, views. Kilgour, Kirsner and McConnell, note that party discipline in Canada should be reduced, or even eliminated, since it reduces the power of the members of the parliament to vote independently in regard to the issues brought to the parliament for discussion and verification. The party discipline, as applied in the parliamentary system of Canada, means that the members of the parliament have to align their vote with the decisions of their party (Charlton and Barker 2009, p.217), a rule that has caused strong oppositions by the members of the Canadian parliament. Kilgour has been a member of the Canadian parliament since 1979 (Charlton and Barker, 2009, p.217); in 1990 he voted against a bill of his party (Conservatives) in regard to the authorization of Goods and Services Tax (Charlton and Barker 2009, p.217). As a result of the above decision, ‘he was expelled by his party’ (Charlton and Barker 2009). Due to the above fact, he decided to join the Liberal Party (Charlton and Barker 2009). In 2005 he decided to continue his career as an independent member of the parliament, especially due to a claim for ‘governmental failures in using appropriately the funds related to a sponsorship program in Quebec’ (Charlton and Barker 2009, p.217). The case of Kilgour shows that party discipline, as currently applied in Canada, prohibits MPs to criticize the decisions of their parties, even if the indications for failures related to party initiatives are many. In other words, party discipline in Canada should be significantly reduced, only applied in certain cases, or, if possible, eliminated, allowing the development of opposing views within the parliament. In this way, the quality of democracy in the specific country would be improved (Kilgour, Kirsner and McConnell, in Charlton and Barker 2009, p.218). In any case, the problem would not be whether the Canadian parliamentary system would become similar with the American Parliamentary system, where the members of the Congress have increased power to state their view (Charlton and Barker 2009, p.218), or not; instead, emphasis should be given on the level of democracy in Canada, as reflected in the country’s parliamentary system. At the next level, the following issue should be highlighted: in each current form, the party discipline ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Canadian Politics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1397770-argumentative-essay
(Canadian Politics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/history/1397770-argumentative-essay.
“Canadian Politics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1397770-argumentative-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Canadian Politics

Western Alienation in Canadian Politics

...Western Alienation in Canadian Politics Western alienation refers to a phenomenon occurring in Canadian politics. It is founded on the belief that the interests of western provinces: Alberta, British Columbia, Saskatchewan and Manitoba are not served by the Canadian political climate. Quebec and Ontario, central provinces, are fully represented in the senate and the House of Commons because they have a large population and hence vote rich (Alberta 2000, 39). This situation causes the western Canadians to feel disenfranchised and alienated from the main political process. The history of western...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Canadian Politics. Position of women in the work place and globalization

...Why have equity programs failed to put an end to the disadvantaged position of women in the work place? The position of women employees in the workplaces of Canada still lags behind on many account of its announced Equity Programs. Prior to the enactment of the Equity Programs, women employment discrimination was widespread in the Canadian employment sector. However, when the Royal Commission on the Status of Women (RCSW) practically assessed the ground reality of the severity and employment challenges faced by women, the Commission concludes that the “position of women employees in the Government of Canada deserves close examination, not only because the Government employs a large number of women in a different variety...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Free and Fair Elections - Canadian Politics

...of the History and Political Science of the Teacher 0ctober 25, The Democratic Assessment: Free and Fair Elections There is no denying the fact that in a global context, Canada in many respects tends to be a mature, liberal democracy. However, even in mature societies, democratization is a task that tends to be perpetual.1 Canadian electoral democracy indeed is endowed with multiple features that qualify it to be considered a thriving democratic society. Yet, it is a reality that there is no country in the world that affiliates to what may be considered to be ideal standards of democracy.2 Many of the most celebrated democracies of the world, including the Canadian electoral democracy...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Canadian politics

...provinces that hold fifty percent of the Canadian population. Critics of the court however ought to note that the court has no jurisdiction to rule on the usefulness of senate reforms or its abolition as these are purely political matters (Malcolmson 73). It is important to note that it is only the courts as a ‘referee’ that can determine the constitutional rules that do apply to the senate reforms. Hence, it is the prime minister who should be the loudest defender of the courts impartiality. The events of the courts ruling made the Prime Minister to be unapologetic and openly state that the courts are among the institution that are standing among his efforts for reforms( Thompson 154). The Court...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Womens Involvement in British Imperialism

9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Canadian Politics. Topic below

...Canadian Politics: The Principle of Parliamentary Supremacy Within the Canadian Constitutional System The Constitution of Canada is the supreme lawin Canada, and it is an amalgam of codified acts and uncodified traditions and conventions. The Constitution of Canada is what truly outlines Canada’s system of government as a whole, as well as the civil rights of all Canadian citizens. There is a lengthy and complex history behind the constitutional system of Canada, and in fact, the colony of Canada received its first full constitution in the Constitutional Act of 1791, of which was what established much of the actual composition of the government in general. Of course, with...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Canadian politics- Position paper

...Canadian Politics- Position Paper-Environment Introduction Climate change and its increasing impact on our environment is a growing concern worldwide. In Canada the environment has become a national issue since the turn of the new millennium. In the late twentieth century environment was not taken seriously, but over the last few years concern on climate has climbed rapidly, such that it ranks immediately after health care on the minds of the Canadian people. This climb in concern for the to make it an important national issue has resulted from the greater awareness of the consequences of not addressing the issue of rising temperatures, which is the result of irresponsible human activity...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Canadian Politics - Senate Reform in Canada

...in the Senate. Senate reforms are also looked at from a positive outlook based on the comprehension of their connection with democracy and the legitimate establishment of representative institutions that are linked with democratic processes such as electing Senators rather than relying on an appointment procedure upon the discretion of the prime minister. The essay also aims to shed light upon the effectiveness of Senate reforms by analyzing whether a direct electorate process is applicable in the Canadian political structure and what alternatives can be explored to enhance the legitimacy of the Canadian Senate by using the reforms applied by the Australian Senate as a primary model, so...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Why did George Grant describe Canada in 1965 as collapsed, disappeared unable to be sovereign and impossible, and Canadian nationalism as having been defeated Does the study of Canadian politics, society, and political cult

...Canadian Nationalism The United s and Canada have had a very friendly relationship for a very long time. The two countries share a common border, and language. These countries operate a free market between them. The extent of this relationship has spread to politics and aspects of governance. The two countries also share the same ideologies and culture. Though there are several differences between the two countries, some political analysts believe that the Canadian political culture is slowly being Americanized. George grant described Canada as lacking nationalism. In his analysis, he felt that the country was unable to be sovereign and will always depend on the United States. This essay will study the Canadian society, politics... and the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Canadian law and politics

...Canadian Law and Politics POLS 3463 Dr. E. Newstadt Peter Misheal 100118704 The parliament and legislatures of the provinces apply sections of the constitution to control the possession and use of non-medical use of drugs (Russell & Leuprecht, 2011). Initially, the powers of criminal law were considered to be the principal source of federal power to regulate the use of drugs. However, in the case of R. v. Hauser, [1979] 1 S.C.R. 984 the supreme court of Canada maintained the constitutionality of the federal Narcotic Control Act under the peace, order, and good governance (P.O.G.G.). P.O.G.G. outlines the doctrines under which the Canadian parliament should execute criminal laws. The...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Canadian Politics for FREE!

Contact Us