Nobody downloaded yet

Bakunin: A great thinker or a man of action How did Bakunin shaped anarchism in the 19th century - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
Bakunin: A great thinker or a man of action? How did Bakunin shaped anarchism in the 19th century?
Mikhail Alexandrovich Bakunin 30 May (1814 – 1876) may have been more known as a revolutionary and an activist but that is not to say that he is not a great thinker. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
Bakunin: A great thinker or a man of action How did Bakunin shaped anarchism in the 19th century
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Bakunin: A great thinker or a man of action How did Bakunin shaped anarchism in the 19th century"

Download file to see previous pages Undeniably, Mikhail Bakunin was also a great thinker given the insights of the books (God and the State), journals (Appeal to the Slavs), pamphlets and extensive correspondents he wrote but he was more known to be a man of action. Bakunin may have the intellectual acumen to write and assert great concepts such as anarchism of which he was credited to be the father of the nihilistic variety, but he did not wrote for the intellectuals but rather for the workers and peasants (Dolgoff 1971). He sacrificed theory in favour of empirical practice that he thought to be more expedient in the pursuit and realization of the practical goals of emancipating the masses from the slavery of institutions. Despite of Bakunin’s capacity as an intellectual, he was known to be contemptuous of the theoretical revolution of Marx and prefers the direct action of the “evil instincts” of the mass that is impatient with the abstraction of ideas (Dolgoff 1971). He view intellectuals as the auxiliary arm of the bureaucracy as a privileged class in its own right and was contemptuous of scientist despite his respect for science” (Hodges 1960:269). Rather than indulging in theoretical abstractions, Bakunin puts his faith more on the revolutionary instinct of the oppressed. He himself prides himself to be unsophisticated and claims none of the mystification of the system builders, philosophers of history and social scientists which he believes are part of the structural oppression as purported by the system of the government, religion and intellectuals and therefore should be abolished for the true liberty and freedom to be realized as prescribed by the masses. To validate further that Bakunin is more of a man of action than a thinker, Karl Marx himself, Bakunin’s staunch opponent in the First International who had him expelled, had a low regard for Bakunin’s theoretical abilities (Smith 2012). Marx dismissed Bakunin’s theoretical assertion of anarcho-nihilism to be nothing but a mere derivative of Proudhon’s ideas and Utopian socialist St. Simon (Smith 2012). This is of course a partial assessment of a political rival because Bakunin himself was an intellectual who wrote several treatises about anarchy although they were not as towering as Marx’s Communist Manifesto or as extensive as Das Capital. Despite of this, Marx and Bakunin shared the same goal of emancipating the masses from the throes of oppression and injustice although they have different methods to achieve the same and were a rabid critic of each other to the point of Marx’s expulsion of Bakunin in the First International after outvoting him. Marx believes in the seizure of the political power of the state so that his proletariat would assume power to become a real government of the masses while Bakunin sees this as a reactionary means of establishing another set of oppressors. Bakunin argues that any form of government that exercises authority will invariably become oppressors and therefore will eventually become as an enemy of the people and revolution. He believes that for the “real and direct revolution” to happen, all institutions and instruments of oppression must be destroyed for real liberty and freedom to be achieved (McClellan 1979). One of the most glaring evidence of Bakunin as a man of action is his preference for Propaganda in Deed to push for his political agenda. This was evident in Bakunin’s Letters to A Frenchman (Bakunin 1870) during the Franco Prussian War where he called on for the propaganda of the deed where Bakunin mentioned “we must spread our principles, not with words but with deeds, for this is the most popular, the most potent, ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Bakunin: A great thinker or a man of action How did Bakunin shaped Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1396672-a-great-thinker-or-a-man-of-action-how-did-bakunin
(Bakunin: A Great Thinker or a Man of Action How Did Bakunin Shaped Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1396672-a-great-thinker-or-a-man-of-action-how-did-bakunin.
“Bakunin: A Great Thinker or a Man of Action How Did Bakunin Shaped Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1396672-a-great-thinker-or-a-man-of-action-how-did-bakunin.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
wa
walton38 added comment 8 months ago
Student rated this paper as
The topic of "Bakunin: A great thinker or a man of action? How did Bakunin shaped anarchism in the 19th century?" was impossible to find. I spent countless hours to find it. Here at StudentShare, I got the finest example. Many thanks!

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Bakunin: A great thinker or a man of action How did Bakunin shaped anarchism in the 19th century

The great man theory

...involves the making of decisions for the people or a group of people under the leader. Effective management portrays the ability of leaders after their tenure or their death. The argument of leadership skills is still with no solution, are great leaders born or raised? The great man theory puts it clear that a great leader is God given not man-made. It only provides two options; either one is born as leader or one is not born a leader. The history of the great man theory dates back to the 19th century, when great leaders seen at that time were in born heroes, for...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

From the book

...and in Nozick’s version of utopia, “is equivalent to the minimal state” (333) and is way better than the any political system because “the minimal state treats us as inviolate individuals, who may not used in certain ways by others as means or tools” (333). Unlike Bakunin’s version of Anarchy where anarchy follows after the abrogation of the state and all institutions, Nozick’s version of minimal anarchism argues that the minimalist state will naturally follow after anarchy. II. Political theories of political thinkers a. Emma Goldman Just like Bakunin, Emma Goldman was also an anarchist who was known for her political activism, fiery speeches and writings and played a...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Anarchism

.... He attended the local school but was primarily self-educated at the town's public library. Proudhon, was among the inventors of socialism, along wih Marx, Bakunin, Blanqui, Blanc, Herzen, Lassalle and Engles. Of these, Proudhon had the profoundest effect upon the workers' movement in the 19th century and his ideas influenced some of the most notable later anarchists, including both Tolstoy and Bakunin, both of whom knew Proudhon personally. Indeed, throughout his life Proudhon acquired and kept a remarkable collection of friends, and as his notoriety spread, acquaintances. Before Proudhon, the word 'anarchist' had been exclusively used as a derogatory epithet to be...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

19th century medievalist poetic comparison

...Order 124133 May 4, 2006 19th Century Medievalist Poetic Comparison In the nineteenth century, a romanticizing of the Middle Ages became a popular part of England's culture known as Medievalism. Medievalism is a term used to describe that which holds characteristics of the Middle Ages. Knights performing acts of chivalry, damsels in distress, magical beings, and internal struggles between loyalty and passion are prominent identifying aspects of medieval literature. Tennyson's The Lady of Shalott and Morris's The Defense of Guinevere are both great examples of nineteenth century medievalism. A better understanding of medievalism is gained by comparing and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

19th century Romanticism in France

...of the 1790’s was the place of murder, mayhem, and inhumanity. The ideals of “liberty, fraternity, equality” were a mockery. And when Napoleon brought order he did so only after crowning himself emperor and thus demonstrated that order in France was only possible if there was a strong monarch. Stendhal was a believer in the French Revolution and himself fought under Napoleon. But the irony of France beheading one ruler so as to embrace another was not lost to him. As well, like so many Romantic thinkers, the cold and almost inhuman character of science was made a theme by Stendhal. “…Romanticism is, perhaps predominantly, a desperate rearguard action against the spirit and the...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

American Literature 17th-19th Century

...Thomas Paine was one of the most prominent individuals who was a catalyst for Americans to fight for liberty against the British Rule. In this philosophical argument, Paine elaborates on the fallacies of the King’s cruel regime. In this particular work of his, Paine is very keen to compare the liberation movement of France from the colonies. In this particular work, he refutes Edmond Burke’s idea, who supported American independence movement but not the French revolution. Hence, Paine’s aim was to elaborate upon the concepts and components of grievances that induced individuals to rebel against their leaders. Tom Paine’s in his literary work the “Rights of Man” described King George as a “royal brute.” In the first part...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

19th Century

...The Biology of Psychology al Affiliation The Biology of Psychology Pierre Cabanis, a French psychologist, pioneered biological psychology in the nineteenth century (Leahey, 2004). Cabanis proposed a number of theories and ideas on how the human brain functions. A significant theory that came into being during the 19th century is the theory of unconscious among other theories (Leahey, 2004). The unconscious refers to the processes that occur spontaneously in the human mind, including motivation, memory, and thought processes. This is an interesting concept because human beings may need to understand why individuals do various actions while asleep or in coma (Leahey, 2004). This discussion will consider the explanation of the theory... of...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Book Review 2: 19th Century

...in defining the housework done by women in the pre-industrial America. With evident examples borrowed from letters and diaries she covers the labor of women from sewing, cooking, and cleaning to tending animals and gardens and making beer, cider, butter, and cheese. Women provided or were involved in the production of goods for local barter or direct family consumption (Boydston, 105). Inasmuch as crucial individuals in the economy (and entire) family, Boydston further argues that their role in driving the economy did reflect to social or political power. Overall, the society or communities remained entirely patriarchal. Boydston’s depiction of women’s housework during the antebellum days is more annoying. Women of the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Book Report/Review

Simon Sinek: How great leaders inspire action

...How Great Leaders Inspire Action Introduction Sinek Simon illustrates a simple yet powerful model in which leaders draw inspiration. This involves the use of the Golden circle concept which asks the question “why?” through the talk, Sinek clearly explains why a group of people can manage to attain their goals whiles other fail. Separation of great companies and great leaders from the rest forms the main them in this talk. The theme is evident in the golden circle concept in which it s attributed that even though most people know what they do, very few understand why they do it. The golden circle proves that great leaders communicate from...
1 Pages(250 words)Movie Review

19TH Century Industrial Tycoons

...The 19th Century Tycoons How should industrial tycoons of the 19Th century such as Rockfeller and Carnegie be remembered? As Captains of industry or as Robber Barons? The times in the 19th century are remembered as the foundations of the immense growth of the American economy being enjoyed currently. This growth is contributed to the inventions and productivity of various industrial tycoons who contributed to the most productive and the rich America we see today. Among the great tycoons attributed to the success are the John D. Rockfeller and Andrew Carnegie (Josephson, 2010). However, the way they rose...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Bakunin: A great thinker or a man of action How did Bakunin shaped anarchism in the 19th century for FREE!

Contact Us