Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Health Sciences - Research Critique - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Research Critique Introduction In order to ensure the quality of health practice, research evidence which can be used to support the practice must be reviewed and critiqued. This paper shall critique two journal articles on client responses to psychotherapy, comparing their results based on standard measures for research critique…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
Health Sciences - Research Critique
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Health Sciences - Research Critique"

Download file to see previous pages The Levitt study provides a qualitative and a more specific and in-depth evaluation of psychotherapy outcomes for mental health patients. As is common in qualitative studies, they cover a smaller population and results are presented in terms of common themes expressed by respondents (Marshall, 1996). The smaller number of respondents covered for qualitative studies make their results less reliable and less generalizable to a larger population (Daymon and Holloway, 2010). The issue of generalizability is less apparent in quantitative studies, as in the Cottone study which covers a larger number of respondents. The specificity of the results for quantitative studies is however less practical in the actual research, as they provide general figures and numerical equivalents for the results (Scherer-Rath, 2004). The data collection methods for both studies were also different. The Levitt study applied a semi-structured questionnaire in order to gather data from respondents. This method of gathering data is typical of qualitative methods which allow for a more intimate contact between researchers and respondents (Wengraf, 2001). The data was gathered via a one-on-one interview method where the researcher posed the essential questions, and the respondent was not restricted in his answers by a set of choices. This made the data gathering process more detailed and more patient-focused (Flick, von Kardorff, and Steinke, 2004). Due to the smaller population covered, carrying out a more intimate and focused data gathering process was possible. This type of data gathering was however difficult to carry out in the Cottone study and usually in most qualitative studies (Cottrell and McKenzie, 2011). The population is too large to specifically cover within the time allocated for research. Moreover, results had to be translated to numerical figures and using the prescribed scales to measure client progress was the more effective tool for the quantitative study (Thomas, 2009). Using these scales allowed the data gathered to be collated into numerical representations which could be generalized over a bigger population (Horn, 2008). The themes chosen by the researchers in the Levitt study had a good fit to the data gathered. The researchers were able to illustrate how the themes were drawn from the answers. The themes covered specific answers which ultimately helped answer the question being raised by the study. In the Cottone study, the depression and mood disorders scales were used to evaluate the patient outcomes and response to therapy. The scale allowed a measure of patient progress in terms of their specific disorder. It also concentrated on gender differences between respondents in relation to the outcomes from their therapy. Gender measures were however difficult to apply in the empirical sense because the numbers of respondents were lopsided with more females than males in the sample population. Admittedly, with a larger recruited population, a more objective result would have been possible (Evans, 2007). The researchers were also reflexive during the entire process of research in both the quantitative and qualitative studies (Morrow, Boaz, and Brearley, 2012). They identified the ethical considerations they needed to safeguard; they also considered the limitations of the methods they were applying and the results they unveiled after the research. Levitt identified how the number of respondents ...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Health Sciences - Research Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Health Sciences - Research Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from
(Health Sciences - Research Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Health Sciences - Research Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words.
“Health Sciences - Research Critique Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Health Sciences - Research Critique

The Speciality of Colonial Heights Health Care

Colonial Heights Health care and rehabilitation center provides interdisciplinary support for the medical and physical needs of the patient with sickness and injury. They include neurological events, orthopedic surgery, oncology care, and general surgery. Other medical services comprise IV Infusion Therapy, specialised Alzheimer’s care, tracheotomy care, wound care management, rehabilitative nursing, occupational and speech therapy, etc. Respite care of the hospital provides clinical, psychological and emotional assistance through caregivers for patients who require additional support. Social Services of the health care center include volunteer programs, café dining, special outing, family gatherings, social service c...
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

National Health Service Human Resource Planning

There are about 1500 primary care dentists who are working on a salaried basis with the NHS, in most cases employed by primary care trusts. This group of individuals was a part of the local government earlier but in 1974, they were transferred into the NHS. (Personnel Today, 2007). Starting from the year 1997 onwards, the U.K. Department for Education and Employment had allowed for additional funding of $7.2 million to ensure that medical schools are able to pay clinical academia staff the awards that have been recommended for doctors and dentists in the NHS, by the Doctors and Dentists Review Body (Beecham, 1996). This move was initiated to introduce pay parity because university employers found it difficult to pay the 3.8% incre...
14 Pages (3500 words) Term Paper

Research Methods in Linguistics

 The writer of content tries to preserve his/her culture and also wants his/her culture to get attached to his/her recent living due to which, he/she makes use of the bilingual aspect to write a narrative.

Because of this writing, the English reader faces some problem in decoding the meaning but he/she realizes the presence of another culture by means of this writing. Many writers provide a glossary at the end so that the readers face no problem in decoding the words given in another language such as Soueif has done but many take it for granted that readers know the other language as well.

The article contains a detailed evaluation of the novel by Soueif which can be categorized as the strength of the re...
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Developing a Research Base for Intravenous Peripheral Cannula Resites

... for this study. This was very much appropriate for this type of study. According to Pildal, et al (2005), Randomized Controlled Trial or RCT is best for medical or health related studies. It ensures efficiency and accuracy as long as the number of subjects are enough to represent the population. In addition, confounding may be prevented by using this type of research method. The control group followed the protocol of transferring the peripheral venous catheter to a different site every 3 days, or as clinically indicated. On the other hand, the intervention group only transferred the peripheral catheter when clinically indicated. The independent variable for this research is relocation of the peripheral venous catheter. Treatment...
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Decision Making in Health and Social Care

Consumer sovereignty principle illustrates the fact that in a free market economy the consumer is free to consume what he wants. However, the consumer’s sovereignty does not have meaning if he/she is unable to buy what he/she wants. This paradox is solved through government intervention in the provision of those merit goods such as health care and education. On the other hand, agency theory indicates that conflicts between principals (e.g. shareholders or owners) and agents (e.g. managers) occur as a result of the latter misrepresenting facts and misinterpreting information so that resources can be diverted to uses which they regard as more lucrative. Since principals cannot themselves carry out the task of managing the busi...
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

The Relationship Between Security, Risk and Health in a Large Organisation

Managers in modern organizations tend to use appropriately customized policies – in accordance with their firms’ needs and resources (employees, funds, technology) available. The current paper focuses on the examination of the various aspects of security, risk, health and safety within large organizations; Particular emphasis is paid on the fact that the demands of each one of these factors may be differentiated under the pressure of the market conditions and the organizational priorities. The case of Shell in Nigeria has been used as an example in order to show the potential co-existence and interaction of these factors within a specific organizational environment. The measures required and the role of the security ma...
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Indigenous Community Health in Central Queensland-Australia

Though present in many regions of Australia, New South Wales, and Queensland make up for the largest concentrations of the indigenous population. A larger percentage of this population inhabit rural and remote areas. The median age of this indigenous population is 21 years, which is much lower than the non-indigenous population at 37 years. High fertility rates and low life spans in the indigenous community are believed to be the cause of this disparity in median age. Unemployment and low earnings are characteristic differences in the indigenous population and the non-indigenous population. The unemployment rate of the indigenous population is threefold that of the non-indigenous population. The average weekly income of the indige...
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Forensic Mental Health

In contemporary society, we do have a moral obligation to treat everyone who enters the criminal justice system fairly. However, there are two aspects of this argument that seem to be developing. On the other hand, someone who does not have control of themselves because of mental illness may need to be seen differently than what has been set for "normal" criminals. The literature points in both directions and this can be a difficult call when people are actually entering the system.

In the current literature, the current criminal justice system has specific ideas of what should be done when an individual commits a crime. As an example, Carvan (1999) poses a question in a case study that is pertinent to the shit study. I...
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

The Interprofessional Practice and the Health Care System

This is also the position Stone (2007) takes in the quote under discussion.
Furthermore, Stone goes on to declare that Australia has been very slow to implement this practice as compared with other countries and government agencies. One of the primary reasons is that the public policy system in Australia is quite complex and the decision-makers have not come into agreement on where to place it in the policy matrix. This leaves Interprofessional Practice and Education in the dark (or the cold) as far as strategic planning for implementation as well as placing itself within the funding cycles of the government disbursements. (Stone, 2007)
Policies are created in order to put in place how politicians and government official...
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Lack of Health Insurance for the Mentally Ill

Worse, because the family sometimes cannot afford to cover their medical expenses, these mentally ill patients end up with no medical care at all; they are forced to suffer the debilitating symptoms of their mental illness and to be subjected to worsening mental and general health conditions.
This paper shall discuss the lack of insurance among mentally ill patients. It shall first describe the mental health issue and the student’s position on such an issue. This paper shall also explain why this position is important and the relevance of the position to nursing practice, the mentally ill, and society. The rationale of this position shall be clearly explained and two factors that contribute to this issue shall be identi...
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Health Sciences - Research Critique for FREE!

Contact Us