Chauncy and Gay Male Culture, 1890-1940 (responses) - Assignment Example

Responses The first response is exhaustive in its explanation of the questions raised about gay male culture from Chauncey’s book. The first response correctly identifies the three myths about gay history that Chauncey attempts to breakdown in his introduction as; isolation, invisibility and internalization. The author of the first response also provides good reasons for why gays remained closeted in early history as due to religion, family, and cultural reasons (Chauncey 2). The author fully addresses his surprise as to why he or she is surprised as to why she thinks gay men have always been forced into a closet.

I feel the response is correct in its assessment of gay male culture through the questions answered.The second response correctly identifies the three myths that Chauncey aims at dismantling. The response is however not very well detailed when it comes to assessing the questions raised. The author identifies the reasons for gay closure on a narrower perspective. The author should provide a wider perspective of the reasons gays remained closeted at certain points in history. The author provides his answers to the question as to why gay men got forced underground by simply quoting Chauncey.

The author should elaborate on Chauncey’s reason a bit further. The response also has a few grammar mistakes in regards to the use of tenses and sentence structure which require ironing out. I feel the author in the second response has valid answers to the questions posed but needs to structure his sentences for his or her answers to come out more clearlyWorks CitedChauncey, George. Gay New York: Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of the Gay Male World, 1890-1940. New York: Basic Books, 2005.