StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

How sex, gender, and race are all social constructs - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Concepts of sex, gender and race in English language have undergone uncountable naturalization and universalities, to a point that they are now considered to have always been present. There are numerous arguments that revolve around the three concepts of human diversity. Dr. Warnke for example argues that the three concepts above are social constructs (Warnke 153)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
How sex, gender, and race are all social constructs
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "How sex, gender, and race are all social constructs"

In Debating Sex and Gender and After Identity, Dr. Warnke presents various arguments that demonstrate how sex, gender, and race are all social constructs. Do you agree or disagree with her argument, and why? Concepts of sex, gender and race in English language have undergone uncountable naturalization and universalities, to a point that they are now considered to have always been present. There are numerous arguments that revolve around the three concepts of human diversity. Dr. Warnke for example argues that the three concepts above are social constructs (Warnke 153). This paper is in the light of Dr Warnke’s argument but rather disagrees with her argument about sex, gender and race as social constructs. A critical analysis of her argument is presented in this paper. My stand here is that I agree with Dr. Warnke that race or ethnicity is a social construct, but I totally disagree with her that sex and gender are social constructs. To start with, it is important to put forward the difference between sex and gender. The two terms have different meaning and the meaning of each borrows from different theories characteristic of feminist theories. The term sex refers to male or female based on biological features. On the other hand, the term gender denotes men and women as defined by social factors. However the extent to which the society meets its definition for gender is based on diverse and dynamic considerations, such that gender aspects will vary from one society to another (Warnke 156). Natural or biological treatment characterizes the analysis of these two terms. That is, sex and gender. From gender and sexual studies videos, all persons are categorized to both sex and gender. Also, that is the same case with race or ethnicity. People actually pass as members of a given category. For instance, actors in any given piece of art may take a given character that depicts belonging to a certain race or ethnicity. On the same note, it very hard to come by an actor who will take on the role a different sex or gender different from which he or she is in actual sense. The only time this happens is when such pieces of work are meant to portray transgender motives or situations or in the event that such works need to present a sense of humor. When such an observation is made, it is important to note that the observation is temporary and therefore does not last for long. The motive by which the observation is made is only confirmed or evidenced with such observed scenario. What this shows is that people or the entire human race will identify itself with a given social organized group; that is, a race or ethnic group, but rarely will the same people practice transgender roles. Therefore, sex and gender fails to be integrated as a social construct as presented by Dr. Warnke. However, race or ethnicity as a social construct is in line with her claims (Warnke 178). To a more analysis of the claims of Dr.Warnke, gender as a social construct may hold true only if she provides enough evidence. Although at many instances gender is more tailored towards being a social construct, Warnke fails to integrate her claim into evidence that properly asserts her claims. As a result, this paper seeks to disagree with her opinion and claims. The integral assumptions and argument in that case elicit doubt and skepticism, and therefore her conclusions about race, sex and gender cannot be upheld. People are born and integrated into specific social settings, thereby determining their ethnic and racial backgrounds. These people are born either male or female or hermaphrodites by sex and the gender aspect of it sprouts out of the fact that they are male or female. Dr. Warnke argues that it is the society that builds up the gender side of human race and ethnicity, but fails to provide sufficient evidence to this claim. There are varied believes developed by the society based on male-female and sex-gender roles, but all that is basically based on whether one is male or female. Further to this treatment, the society only provides what should or should not be done by a people of a given gender, but the same society fails to show how it defines gender in the absence of sex. Social organization of people into identifiable groups is more likely than terming sex a social construct. The society’s role of creating sex as Dr. Warnke claims therefore becomes sidelined by this fact. Borrowing evidence from literacy and entertainment works can help establish what or what is not constructed by the society in relation to race, sex and gender. A book by the title “Black Like Me” and the famous story of Billy Tipton depicts that fact. Billy Tipton was a famous musician who was all along thought to be a male (Warnke 162). Upon dying, it was established that this musician was actually female. The interesting bit of it is that Billy Tipton got married twice to women. This secret was discovered only after death. If it was the role of the society to construct sex and gender, then the case of this musician could have been identified earlier and no secrets would be underlying. Since sex and gender are not social constructs as claimed by Dr. Warnke, it follows suit that it would be hard for similar cases as that of Billy Tipton to be identified. However, race or ethnicity as a social construction is evidenced by the fact that this musician actually identified with a given race or ethnic group although the sex and gender aspect of the same person was comprised, and the society made no notice of it. In this regard, ethnic constructions by society are expected. Consequently, the constructed ethnic groups identify themselves with a given race or races as provided for by the society that builds the races up. Physical features in persons across the globe are identified as markers to social diversity (Warnke 191). Complexity characterizes this diversity based on some research aspects, from the gene of sickle cell to shapes of noses in people. Cultural and geographical regions are used to identify specific groups of people to specific regions based on these physical features. Different people from different regions may have remarkable similarities even when these people are not inter-related. The sprouting differences noted in this are evidenced by the American Association of Physical Anthropologists (Warnke 197). This evidence denotes biological racial aspects but the society does not construct it at all. As a result, sex-gender traits may be similar across different societies. The features of these societies (physical or biological) depict no action of social construction since they are based in different environments that rule out possibility of close interaction that could go to such extremes as creating or constructing similar traits among them. Dr. Warnke’s argument that race, sex and gender are social constructs, (Warnke 153) is to some extent ignorant of some specific natural factors that are part and parcel of the society. For instance, in some cultures, more than two categories of gender are said to exist. She does not take this into account. Sex and gender variables actually exist in a continuum. Sex is therefore a physical construct, and while gender has been linked to social construction, no concrete evidence has been provided for that. Sex-gender issues in the society take specific stands (for example in questionnaires), while race or ethnicity is dynamic over time due to the changing nature of the society. New race and ethnic choices are from time to time made available, but the sex-gender aspect remains the same. Many arguments have come up in the light of the interests of this paper. The interest of this paper is diverse, dynamic and concrete to consider. In the light of race, sex and gender, the beliefs of the society are diverse and varied from region to region. The observance of Warnke’s conclusion that race, sex and gender are social constructs across societies varies from one society to another, with some being for and others against the argument. All this depends on the perception held by these societies in regard to the three variables being treated in this paper. There are more likely scenarios that the paper has identified, like the possibility that gender is a social construct. However due to the arguments in Warnke’s book, conceptualizing this point to an evidence fails to materialize. Race and ethnicity takes the argument of the book but the other two variables fails to. This only concludes that only race or ethnicity is a social construction, but sex and gender totally fails to be an integration of social construction. Works Cited Warnke, Georgia. After Identity: rethinking race, sex and gender. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2008. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“How sex, gender, and race are all social constructs Essay”, n.d.)
How sex, gender, and race are all social constructs Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/gender-sexual-studies/1434917-how-sex-gender-and-race-are-all-social-constructs
(How Sex, Gender, and Race Are All Social Constructs Essay)
How Sex, Gender, and Race Are All Social Constructs Essay. https://studentshare.org/gender-sexual-studies/1434917-how-sex-gender-and-race-are-all-social-constructs.
“How Sex, Gender, and Race Are All Social Constructs Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/gender-sexual-studies/1434917-how-sex-gender-and-race-are-all-social-constructs.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF How sex, gender, and race are all social constructs

Gender and Sex as Social Constructions

gender and SEX AS SOCIAL CONSTRUCTIONS Author's name Institutional Affiliation Introduction Social construction refers to something, which does not occur autonomously within the "natural" globe, but is rather a society's invention.... In addition, this adaptation and variation to circumstances, as well as social pressures underpins the notion that gender and sex are social constructions instead of some kind of essence, which begins from biology.... Cultural norms and practices bring about the actuality of social concepts and constructs, and oversee the practices, rules and customs about the manner people view, use and apprehend them....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Womens Voices, Feminist Vision, by Susan Shaw and Janet Lee

The author makes the claim that women live within a birdcage, where each of the individual wires is meaningless but when they are all put together, it is impossible for the bird to escape.... The collection Women's Voices, Feminist Vision, by Susan Shaw and Janet Lee, and the novel The God of Small Things, by Arundhati Roy, both explore the constructs that women face within various societies.... These works show that women are oppressed in a variety of ways in different cultures and that gender constructs are causing this oppression....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Gender, Social Exclusion and Technology

to her own gender and to the other gender.... This paper “Gender, social Exclusion and Technology” postulates that though technology has to a very great extent been aligned to gender bias and social exclusion based on gender, the ICT revolution holds the potential to erase such biases and provide equal opportunity to both sexes.... According to the constructionist perspective the social realm is where gender is located....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Social Constructs of Beauty in America, Europe and Asia

The essay analyzes social constructs of Beauty in America, Europe and Asia.... social constructs of beauty in America, Europe and Asia, in this research work, is analyzed based mainly on the Media, Culture and Society text.... The essay "social constructs of Beauty in America, Europe and Asia" will looks at the international constructions of beauty in various cultural locations all over the world precisely in the USA, Asia and European nations....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Proposal

How True Is It to Say that Femininity and Masculinity Are Social Constructs

"How True Is It to Say that Femininity and Masculinity Are social constructs" paper states that people need to broaden their canvas to get the hang of realistic things and focus less on the social constructs which somehow or the other have passed the test of times, though in an unfortunate way.... nbsp;… The aspects of femininity and masculinity are something that is easily bracketed under the social constructs heading and this has been causing for quite a number of decades now, if not centuries....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Issue of Gender in Relation to Inclusion and Exclusion

hellip; The advent of technology especially in the communication mode spurred further dynamics of social Exclusion/Inclusion.... he dynamics of social inclusion have been active with several respects but as far as gender is concerned social inclusion/ exclusion has been at work quite strongly and technological progress has even widened the divide.... he issue of gender is affecting the level of social decision-making process for its wide involvement to other cross-cutting social parameters....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Effect of Socially Constructed Gender Roles on Marriage

Blau (2011) contends that the different gender roles in relation to reproduction have portended differing pressures on women and men, which constructs gender roles that hold the man as competitive, while the woman is more nurturing.... nbsp;  Gender roles, throughout history, have altered societal and home dynamics, whether created within the home or as a social construct.... While being born as a man or woman is a biological fact, it is one with social implications....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Proposal

Gender and Sex Comparison

The author compares the notions "gender" and "sex" and states that sex is a biological paradigm that captures the genetic, physiological, anatomical variation that presents in species and gender refers to the characteristics which a culture or society delineates as feminine or masculine… gender has been considered to be the performance that is constructed through individual's practices.... gender is exhibited in the manner in which persons style their body and carry on themselves as well as how the move and speak....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us