Nobody downloaded yet

Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th century - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Title of the course May 20, 2011 Interpretation of Copernicus in the 16th Century The drastic changes in arts and sciences that occurred in the Renaissance period had outstanding consequences for the further development of Western civilization…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful
Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th century
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th century"

Download file to see previous pages This essay will deal with the interpretations of Copernican cosmology among his contemporaries, with special attention being paid to views on Copernican theory exhibited by leading theologians of the epoch, both Catholic and Protestant. In addition, an account of interpretations of Copernicus in non-European historical environment will be presented, with Ottoman Empire serving as a case study. It will be argued that the dominant interpretations of Copernican astronomy in the 16th century were far from overwhelmingly hostile, as might be inferred from the treatment of Giordano Bruno and later Galileo Galilei, and that established ecclesiastical authorities in most cases lacked a coherent policy towards Copernicans until the 17th century. THE EARLY LUTHERAN RESPONSE TO THE COPERNICAN THEORY. MELANCHTHON, RHETICUS AND THE WITTENBERG INTERPRETATION Although the notion of existential hostility of Lutheran thinkers towards Copernican astronomy, presented by White in his famous account of Luther’s alleged derisory remark on Copernicus (White 1:126-7), is widespread, it seems that such a conclusion would be premature. While Kuhn asserts that Luther and Melanchthon viewed Copernican theory as contravening the Scripture and constituting near blasphemy (Kuhn 191), Barker and Westman strongly oppose such a view, instead suggesting that the attitude of Lutherans to Copernicanism was more nuanced (Barker; Westman, “The Copernicans and the Churches”). First of all, it is significant that the presentation of Copernican heliocentric theory itself was conducted not by Copernicus himself, but by Georg Joachim Rheticus (1514-1574), a young mathematician from the University of Wittenberg, which was the spiritual centre of Lutheran current in the Reformation (Westman, “The Copernicans and the Churches” 81). In fact, Rheticus was entrusted by Copernicus with publishing Narratio Prima, the draft version of the Copernican master work, De Revolutionibus, in 1540. Together with another Lutheran scholar, Andreas Osiander (1498-1552), Rheticus published De Revolutionibus itself in 1543, with a special notice that the latter was an astronomical and mathematical, rather than philosophical, work. It is assumed that this notice was added in order to prevent possible backlash by conservative theologians and scholastics against Copernican theory (Westman, “The Copernicans and the Churches” 81). Such interpretation of Copernicus’s work, i.e. not as a work aimed at uncovering physical truth, but as a mathematical treatise that was merely to provide mathematically consistent observations was to become a basis for the so-called Wittenberg Interpretation of Copernicus. It is interesting to note that Melanchthon seems to have been initially critical of Copernicus’s ideas, but later acknowledged their validity, especially with regard to Copernican planetary parameters and theory of moon movements (Westman, “The Melanchthon Circle”). Although Melanchthon never recognized the claims of Copernican heliocentrists with respect to cosmological issues, he obviously regarded Copernicus’s mathematical calculations on celestial body movements as superior to the Ptolemean ones. Melanchthon dismissed Copernican observation on the earth’s motion, finding it to be incompatible with the Scripture and the Aristotelian idea of simple motion, according to which each simple body has only one type of motion inherent in it (Westman, “ ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th century Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th Century Research Paper)
“Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th Century Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
Religious Conflicts: 2nd-4th century and 16th-17th century
...?RELIGIOUS CONFLICTS Comparisons between new religious groups during the 2nd and 3rd centuries under Roman rule as well as the 16th and 17th centuries in great Europe show that the environment of the times saw many similarities and differences. In both instances, the status quo was challenged by a novel religious movement, and the balance of power was at risk of changing. Despite being centuries apart, both were examples of groundbreaking changes not only in religion but in politics and culture. The groups in power treated the new religious groups somewhat differently in each case. During the time of the Roman Empire, Christianity was generally seen as dangerous and...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Church Reformation in the 16th and 17th century
...? CHURCH REFORMATION IN THE 16TH AND 17TH CENTURY Church Reformation in the 16th and 17th century The 16th and 17th century is the period when church reformation for catholic and Protestants churches took place. It is a period for the catholic and protestant reformation, which was a powerful influence of western Christians. Calvin John, King Luther and other earlier Christians initiated the Protestant reformation. The second wave of the reformation, which became more popular, is the Anabaptists, who are the protestant Christians. Although some scholars consider Anabaptists as a distinctive movement from Protestantism, it created radical...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper
Church Reformation in the 16th and 17th century
...Church Reformation in the 16th and 17th Century Background information In 1054, a great schism occurred between the eastern and western Christian churches. The schism resulted from regional, theological, linguistic, and political differences that had emerged. The western side of the split formed the modern church while the eastern side formed the Orthodox Church. The western side was to undergo further schisms in the following years. In 1375, the Catholic Church experienced a great schism that saw the rise of different competing popes1. This compromised the respect accorded to papacy2. Since the schism tarnished the reputation of the papacy authority, it needed a resolution that would re-unite the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
16th Century U.K. Epidemics and its Impact on the British
...16th Century U.K. Epidemics and its Impact on the British This paper discusses the impact of epidemics upon the British people in the 16th century (1500-1600) with reference to three common diseases. The first part is a brief introduction on what an epidemic is and its causes. The second part is on England before and during the 16th century to show why it became prone to epidemics. The third part is on epidemics of malaria, influenza, and the plague in 16th century England and its effects on the English people and their history. Epidemics: Nature and Causes An epidemic is an outbreak of a contagious...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay
The Use Of Mirrors In 16th Century Paintings
...The Use Of Mirrors In 16th Century Paintings. Art is a manifestation of life, the one that we live and the one that surrounds us. The undeniable relationship of art with life has always ensured that art become a respectable and an honest source for documenting the age in which it is being made. If studied closely, the painting and the symbolism strewn on its canvas, can give a true account of the driving force of the age. It can show us the thoughts and ideas that occupied a prominent position in the era in which that particular piece of art had been created. Due to this reason, it is vital to analyze closely the objects depicted in the work. These objects, though at first sight might appear random, yet...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay
16th Century Travel
...16th Century Transportation Before the Industrial Revolution, there were a few changes in the modes of traveling from the period the wheel was invented. The 16th century was a time of conquests, expansion of land and authority and a period of more discoveries and inventions. Throughout all of these, people in the 16th century walked, sailed, rode horses or traveled in carriages. Moving from one place to another on foot was the first ever means of traveling and remained a common way of transport in the 16th century. Where it was the primary way of getting around, walking was eventually reserved to...
1 Pages(250 words)PowerPoint Presentation
16th century Empires
...16th Century Empires Although the Europeans, Andeans, and Mesoamericans had all established dominant empires by the year 1500 AD, each utilized different means and resources to fuel their imperial expansion. All three were able to accomplish their imperial expansion successfully but while the Europeans growth depended on the people they ruled, the other two empires expanded their domains. The "Spanish" empire did obviously take advantage of the foreign territories it conquered, the two empires in the Western hemisphere had a more sympathetic relationship with its peoples save for Mesoamericans who make their captives as human sacrifice to their god. To put the comparison in perspective, it has to be...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Artworks in painting from the 16th century
...Artworks in painting from the 16th century The artwork and painting in the 16th century provide crucial artwork admirable in the current era of art studies. The 16th century artwork provides an inter-link of the historical past and allows the current to understand the intrinsic nature of the essence of artwork. Paints and artwork are a format of conveyance of information that has been very important in the past and is still very valuable. Picture is worth thousands words. In the past; 16th century photographs and cameras were not present hence new only paintings and artwork facilitated the ...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
The European Colonialism in 16th century to mid 20th
...Introduction Colonialism entails the establishing, exploiting, maintaining, acquiring and expansion of a colony by a political power in one territory to another territory. A relationship that is not equal between the colonial power and the colony and even between the indigenous population and the colonial power was evident. The European colonialism was from the 16th century to mid 20th century, an era when authorities from different European countries established their colonies in Africa, Asia and within America (Margaret, 2006). Initially, countries followed mercantilist policies meant to strengthen the home economy. By the mid-19th century, the powerful British...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper
Apitalism in the ourse of the 16th Century
...Сapitalism in the Сourse of the 16th Century Introduction Capitalism could be described as the ownership of a means of production and accumulation of personal wealth and profits through investment of capital and employment of labour. Capitalism is based on the concept of a free economy and business enterprise with limited or little government intervention. Thus the term ‘free market’ is significant in capitalism as it refers to an economic system that is free of external intervention and is guided by a rule of law that is focused on establishing and protecting private property, including, private ownership of the means of production (Levi-Faur et al, 2005). Protection of private property was never...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th century for FREE!
Contact Us