StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th century - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Title of the course May 20, 2011 Interpretation of Copernicus in the 16th Century The drastic changes in arts and sciences that occurred in the Renaissance period had outstanding consequences for the further development of Western civilization…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th century
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th century"

Download file to see previous pages This essay will deal with the interpretations of Copernican cosmology among his contemporaries, with special attention being paid to views on Copernican theory exhibited by leading theologians of the epoch, both Catholic and Protestant. In addition, an account of interpretations of Copernicus in non-European historical environment will be presented, with Ottoman Empire serving as a case study. It will be argued that the dominant interpretations of Copernican astronomy in the 16th century were far from overwhelmingly hostile, as might be inferred from the treatment of Giordano Bruno and later Galileo Galilei, and that established ecclesiastical authorities in most cases lacked a coherent policy towards Copernicans until the 17th century. THE EARLY LUTHERAN RESPONSE TO THE COPERNICAN THEORY. MELANCHTHON, RHETICUS AND THE WITTENBERG INTERPRETATION Although the notion of existential hostility of Lutheran thinkers towards Copernican astronomy, presented by White in his famous account of Luther’s alleged derisory remark on Copernicus (White 1:126-7), is widespread, it seems that such a conclusion would be premature. While Kuhn asserts that Luther and Melanchthon viewed Copernican theory as contravening the Scripture and constituting near blasphemy (Kuhn 191), Barker and Westman strongly oppose such a view, instead suggesting that the attitude of Lutherans to Copernicanism was more nuanced (Barker; Westman, “The Copernicans and the Churches”). First of all, it is significant that the presentation of Copernican heliocentric theory itself was conducted not by Copernicus himself, but by Georg Joachim Rheticus (1514-1574), a young mathematician from the University of Wittenberg, which was the spiritual centre of Lutheran current in the Reformation (Westman, “The Copernicans and the Churches” 81). In fact, Rheticus was entrusted by Copernicus with publishing Narratio Prima, the draft version of the Copernican master work, De Revolutionibus, in 1540. Together with another Lutheran scholar, Andreas Osiander (1498-1552), Rheticus published De Revolutionibus itself in 1543, with a special notice that the latter was an astronomical and mathematical, rather than philosophical, work. It is assumed that this notice was added in order to prevent possible backlash by conservative theologians and scholastics against Copernican theory (Westman, “The Copernicans and the Churches” 81). Such interpretation of Copernicus’s work, i.e. not as a work aimed at uncovering physical truth, but as a mathematical treatise that was merely to provide mathematically consistent observations was to become a basis for the so-called Wittenberg Interpretation of Copernicus. It is interesting to note that Melanchthon seems to have been initially critical of Copernicus’s ideas, but later acknowledged their validity, especially with regard to Copernican planetary parameters and theory of moon movements (Westman, “The Melanchthon Circle”). Although Melanchthon never recognized the claims of Copernican heliocentrists with respect to cosmological issues, he obviously regarded Copernicus’s mathematical calculations on celestial body movements as superior to the Ptolemean ones. Melanchthon dismissed Copernican observation on the earth’s motion, finding it to be incompatible with the Scripture and the Aristotelian idea of simple motion, according to which each simple body has only one type of motion inherent in it (Westman, “ ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th century Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1421976-interpretation-of-compernicus-in-the
(Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th Century Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1421976-interpretation-of-compernicus-in-the.
“Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th Century Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1421976-interpretation-of-compernicus-in-the.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th century

Catholic Church in Sixteenth-Century Europe

he mournful words of the Pontiff at that time, as he lay on his deathbed in 1559, clearly spell out the darkest moments of the Catholic Church. "From the time of St. Peter there has not been a pontificate so unfortunate as mine. How I regret the past! Pray for me." (Pope Paul IV). The erosion of its bastion in Europe necessitated action from the Catholic Church to stabilize and maintain its presence in Europe. (1
The age of the Reformation gave rise to the possibility of several national churches springing up in place of the Catholic Church. The prior attempts of reform, termed as heresy, and schism by the Catholic Church had failed, but the Reformist movement was not only proving a divisive force to Christendom in Europe but...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

The Proper Role of Universities in the 21st Century

 This modification in the rationale of universities has been motivated by the knowledge of economic theory which postulates that ideas, and the ability to influence them, are of more importance than the traditional factors of production. In this type of economy, a world-class university is of increasingly useful benefit.

Universities in England are currently undergoing vast changes unseen since the creation of the vocational-based polytechnics programs of the 1970s (Deem, 2002). “Universities are the research engines of our society. They create new knowledge. The number of breakthroughs and innovations that come from universities is endless. In fact, it is almost impossible to think of one that hasn’t b...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Globalization and Protectionism in Our Century

...Globalization and Protectionism in the 21st Century Globalization is an international phenomenon with far-reaching consequences in the social, political and economic realms. Economic globalization, namely the spread of neoliberalism and capitalist-inspired consumerism as the dominant engine of economic growth, has both supporters and detractors. The world is becoming more and more interdependent and whether you think globalization is a good or bad thing, it is here to stay. Many people in developed countries argue in favor of protectionism because foreign wages are much lower and domestic producers cannot compete. The result is that jobs are lost as employment trends shift overseas. Seeking to explore the present international...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

In What Ways Did 20th Century Conflicts Change the Nature of Western Introspection

The 20th century period was marked by several conflicts: World War I, the Holocaust, World War II, the exploitation of Latin American countries, Racial Segregation and the Negro Revolution which spawned the Civil Rights Movement in America and the Feminist Movement.

The Holocaust is admittedly one of the most horrific events in the history of mankind and the impact of the horrors it brought changed the way Ellie Wiesel sees his faith. While Jews are known for their orthodox and unquestioning faith in God, Wiesel’s experiences in the concentration camps of Auschwitz compelled her to question God’s existence. In Night, Wiesel tells of the unspeakable hanging of a young boy who was left dangling for thirty min...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

The 20th Century: Conflict and Learning

...The 20th century: Conflict and Learning Table of contents Introduction 3 National Pride and World Wars 3 Communism and the USSR 5 Race and Equality 5 Feminism 7 Conclusion 8 Introduction The 20th century was marked by remarkable achievements in many human endeavors. This was the age of where many technological wonders began to take shape in telecommunications, transportation, power generation and computer systems. Society, in general, made great strides in education, ideology, health and politics. Not only did we see the introduction of mass-produced mobiles, we also saw man go into outer space. The 19th century was full of visions of romance and dreams of a better world. So much was the faith...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Interpretation of Financial Statements: Next Plc and Ted Baker Plc

...Interpretation of Financial ments Table of Contents Interpretation of Financial ments Table of Contents 2 Introduction 3 Financial analysis of Next Plc (NXT) & Ted Baker Plc (TED) 5 Recommendation 9 Reference 10 Bibliography 12 Introduction The financial statements of a company provide important financial information about the business operations. With the help of this information one can compute financial ratios relating to liquidity, profitability, gearing and efficiency that help in assessing the financial performance of the company.   Next Plc   Ted Baker Plc   2010 (£m) 2009(£m)   2010 (£’000) 2009 (£’000) PROFITABILITY  (£m)       Gross Profit 996.9 908.5   99927 89366 Revenue 3,406.50 3,271.50... of...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Diversity for the 21st Century

...Diversity for the 21st Century Diversity has become the watchword in the 21st Century. The world is fast growing into a more diverse place. The reason why this is the case is not because diversity did not exist before. It was bottled up. Globalization seems to have let the genie out the bottle. We now have to contend with issues of diversity. The world is becoming a village. New means of transport and communication have ensured that people are moving closer together. Competition also ensures that people from different backgrounds are competing for the same resources and opportunities. This has highlighted the differences that exist between people even more. There seem to be differences with regards to gender, physical ability, race and so...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

20th Century Theatre History: Augusto Boal

... Task: 20th Century Theatre History The integration of spectators and audience is critical in the success of any theatre performance in communicating the theme by the actor. In addition, spectator alienation has rendered theatre performance an exercise void of political expression and openness to spectators and the audience. The adoption of techniques that engage the audience and the public in theatre performance is vital in full communication of the theme in the performance. Such techniques aimed at assuring the spectators that that their contributions towards the success of any theatre performance are invaluable are traceable from the contribution of great artists as Augusto Boal. The contributions of Boal in creating reforms in theatre...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

The Changing Landscape of Working in the 21st Century

Today, emerging jobs require a variety of knowledge, attitudes, and skills while coping with such changes calls for ongoing education and development of imagination and the human mind.
Technology today is responsible for most changes in the work environment in the first century and includes changes in organizational structures, job definitions, and nature of work, job qualifications, workplace redesign, and changes in higher education.
Momentous changes in the workplace are attributed to novel and advanced technology. According to Karoly and Panis (74), the technology revolution initiated in the last decade of the 20th century has influenced the way of life of the 21st century, from home to work. In the workplace, techno...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

The 21st Century Workplace

Managers have had to take on the role of investors. This is because they are tasked with distributing resources with the sole aim of getting good returns just like investors (Cheverton, 2004). To achieve this role a manager needs to let employees have a say in what they are to do. Thus a discussion if not negotiations need to be employed to achieve the organization’s goal and objectives.

Managers play the role of customers in any organization operating in a global workplace. This is because as nature of workforce changes as they become more involved in their work. They cease to be just hired employees but self-employed persons offering their services to customers within the organization who in this case are the m...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Interpretation of Compernicus in the 16th century for FREE!

Contact Us