Yes and No - Life is Absurd - Term Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This paper is focused on the article of Michael Smith by way of an assessment of his arguments which counter Joel Feinberg’s antecedent position that (a) it is incoherent to suppose human life as such is absurd and (b) fulfilment can save human life from being tragic…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
Yes and No - Life is Absurd
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Yes and No - Life is Absurd"

Download file to see previous pages After an assessment, this paper will point out some underlying ideas on which both Smith’s and Feinberg’s differing views are based. A backgrounder Michael Smith is a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Humanities whose interests include the philosophy of the mind. His article Is That All There Is poses a question which embodies the position of the philosophical school of Absurdism that man is incapable of ultimately finding inherent meaning to life. In the article, Smith implicitly avows his absurdist philosophy, nothing short of revealing his growing up experience in an undeveloped suburb of Melbourne, Australia’s capital city. Smith’s schooling was not remarkable, except for the intellectual cream of his school’s teaching staff. Mr. Taffe, one of his respected teachers, came prominently in his recollection as the teacher who introduced him to the French language and culture. The opportunities afforded by Mr. Taffe allowed Smith to attend a Waiting for Godot theatre performance. As an adolescent with a malleable mind, Smith felt strongly influenced by the play’s dramatic portrayal of life’s tragic lack of meaning. The play belongs to the genre of the Theatre of the Absurd which portrays horror and tragedy with characters caught up in situations of hopelessness and absurdity. In Smith’s own words, the play impressed on him the “utter pointlessness and tragedy of human existence” (Smith 77). This sense of hopelessness would linger throughout the life of Smith in spite of such wonderful experiences as having a family. Later in his career, Smith would garner career achievements such his being a Fellow of the Australian Academy of Humanities. But in spite of his success he says he felt the intellectual “dissonance” in his life, and this prompted his study of Joel Feinberg’s paper “Absurd Self-fulfilment.” Feinberg’s essay Feinberg’s essay was a challenge to Smith’s enduring adolescent dissonance. In his critique, Smith found an ally in Thomas Nagel, an American philosopher widely known in the field of the philosophy of the mind. Nagel’s What Is It Like to Be a Bat held a sceptical view of the world, as the mind is obstructed by three barriers to human consciousness-- physical, functional and mental. Smith then expounds his five arguments arguing against Feinberg’s propositions which upheld coherence to human life as such, and the redeeming value of fulfilment to save human life from being tragic: 1. What makes a life absurd? Smiths lays the ground for discussion as he explains Feinberg’s explanation of what is absurd, namely: the irrational/incongruous in things/activities/attitudes of the individual person. For Fienberg, the Absurd can be likened to the mythical Sisyphus who perpetually rolls a rock uphill, the rock rolling down the other side again and again. For Fienberg, there is a spectrum of absurdities from the extreme-intrinsically worthless, to the absurdly trivial, the burdensome-ill-designed, and misfits in terms of pretensions of aspirations. With sweeping insight, Smith viewed Feinberg as positing different levels of absurdity, some more and others lesser the extreme being the thought of life as totally pointless. Smith clarifies that his adolescent dissonance does not redound to absurdity in the extreme case. 2. Can a pointless human life be saved from being tragic by being fulfilled? Smith gave cognizance to Feinberg’s position that human lives can both be pointless to a certain extent and at the same time fulfilled, again to a certain extent. Feinberg’s own definition of fulfilment is “an individual’s having and exercising the capacities that are centrally involved in her being the individual that she is” ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Yes and No - Life is Absurd Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1421975-yes-and-no-life-is-absurd
(Yes and No - Life Is Absurd Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1421975-yes-and-no-life-is-absurd.
“Yes and No - Life Is Absurd Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1421975-yes-and-no-life-is-absurd.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Yes and No - Life is Absurd

The Absurd in Albert Camus The Plague

...of the absurd is not to imply that Camus views the world itself as absurd, but rather humanity’s reaction to it as often being absurd in the literary sense. The concept of absurdism as it applies to literature is that in and of itself, the human condition has no meaning or value. “Cut off from his religious, metaphysical, and transcendental roots, man is lost; all his actions become senseless, absurd, useless.” (Abrams 1). This belief rejects any sense of value, truth purpose, religious beliefs or any meaning whatsoever concerning life and the universe. With this, individuals have no hope of finding happiness or fulfillment and are...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Harold Pinter: An Absurdist-Existentialist Writer in His Play The Room

...ordinary life has a sinister strangeness lurking only just below its surface.” In the following conversation between Mr. Kidd and Rose, we can see illogical responses of the characters which is one of the elements of The Theatre of the Absurd. It is clear that here again, language fails as a means of communication, Rose asks Mr. Kidd about his sister but, he answers something irrelevant, therefore; Rose cannot find what she wants: Rose: What about your sister, Mr. Kidd? Mr. Kidd: What about her? Rose: Did she have any babies? Mr. Kidd: Yes, she had a resemblance to my old mum, I think. Taller, of course. Rose: When did she die then, your sister? Mr. Kidd: Yes, that’s...
20 Pages(5000 words)Term Paper

Camus life is absurd

...?Philosophy: Hare vs Camus Introduction Camus has d his novel “Nothing Matters”. While this is an interesting it can be misleading for some readers who do not understand the real essence, meaning, or significance of the title. Hare has discussed how his Swiss friend drew negative inferences from this title thus changing his behavior for the worse. Hare is right in asserting that the claim that nothing matters is itself absurd and false because if nothing matters to an individual, there is no concept of or reason for survival anymore whereas Camus is wrong in his argument that life can ever be meaningless and that so one may think of committing suicide. Even the non-living things have their own concerns and things matter for them... tendency...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Theatre of the Absurd

...Theatre of the Absurd Antonin Artaud is considered to be a foundator of so-called Theatre of Absurd, which flourished in 50-60s years of 20th century. He was a person who changed the whole view of theatre, having created a unique concept followed nowadays by many play directors. In order to understand his worldview let’s look briefly through his biography, underlining the moments which influenced Artaud in his literary life. Antoine Marie Joseph Artaud was born in Marseille on September 4th, 1896. It was his mother who called him ‘Antonin’, since it was a diminutive form of ‘Antoine’ (or ‘Anthony’). Even though his mother gave birth to many children, only Antonin, his brother...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

The Theatre of the Absurd

...of strangeness within ordinary things so that we begin to develop the feeling that all ordinary life has a sinister strangeness lurking only just below its surface.” In the following conversation between Mr. Kidd and Rose, we can see illogical responses of the characters which is one of the elements of The Theatre of the Absurd. It is clear that here again, language fails as a means of communication, Rose asks Mr. Kidd about his sister but, he answers something irrelevant, therefore; Rose cannot find what she wants: Rose: What about your sister, Mr. Kidd? Mr. Kidd: What about her? Rose: Did she have any babies? Mr. Kidd: Yes, she had a resemblance to my old mum, I think. Taller, of...
20 Pages(5000 words)Essay

Nagel, The Absurd

...The Absurd Thomas Nagel (1971), in his unique article, “The Absurd”, talks about the absurdity of life. He has described how people feel when they confront the absurdity of life. He, at first, mentions the reasons people give why they feel that life is absurd, and then evaluates those arguments proving that there have to be much stronger arguments than what people generally give. Hence, he has put forward two perspectives that actually support the absurdity of life: (1) unavoidability of seriousness, and (2) inescapability of doubt. This paper explains these two points of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The absurd

...The Absurd Thomas Nagel is a well known philosopher and extremely popular for this exceptional evaluation on the reductionist description of the mind. In his one of the most famous essay named as ‘’ The Absurd’’ argues the fact that earnestness and genuineness which people usually adopt in their lives is willingly distinguished with a specific viewpoint accessible to individuals (Feinberg, 299). Nagel attempts to compare the existential suspicion to the epistemological skepticism. In addition, he says that the seriousness of people towards their life is very indispensable to the human nature. But there always exists a complete doubt that there is a summit. This doubt is an ultimate...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Issue 15 yes 2510

...Cost-Effectiveness of HIV/AIDS Interventions in Africa HIV/AIDS is responsible for twenty percent of the deaths that occur in Africa in the recent years. It has reduced the life expectancy in the continent. European Commission is advocating for preventive methods, care and support to solve this problem in Africa. To maximize on these effects, cost-effectiveness is crucial. However, cost-effectiveness has been successful in industrialized countries, leaving behind the low income countries. This is the report for assessed studies of the cost-effectiveness of HIV/AIDS interventions in Africa (Haacker 25). The assessment covered studies that had information on Africa, calculated cost and effectiveness, transmission rates...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Negotiations - Getting to Yes

... Negotiations - Getting to Yes The effectiveness and success of negotiation depends on one’s knowledge in different phasesof negotiation processes. The core of a healthy negotiation lies with the mutual understanding between the parties involved. Hence, people who think that aggressive approach and temperament would win the bargain usually flaw. In order to achieve the negotiation goal, individuals who undertake the task must evaluate the strength and weakness of their positions. In this context, the theme "be hard on the problem; soft on the people" seems relevant for discussion. Negotiation planning involves self-evaluation which is also the most important phase of every compromise. This paper tends to explain the significance... through...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Our Absurd fear of fat

...Rhetorical Analysis on “Our Absurd Fear of Fat” Paul Campos is the of the article Our Absurd Fear of Fat. The is a legal expert and author. The very fact that he is an expert in a field, gives the author some credibility in as much as he does not directly state his expertise within the article. Although he may not have formal training in health matters, he presents himself as someone who has wide knowledge about health matters, more specifically, obesity. Campos writes his article at a time when the American society is obsessed with fighting against obesity and overweight. The American society has been made to believe that being thin is good not only for the sake of health but also for the reason that...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Term Paper on topic Yes and No - Life is Absurd for FREE!

Contact Us