Nobody downloaded yet

Compare and contrast traditional Marxist approaches to international relations with EITHER Neo-Gramscian OR Frankfurt School vie - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
ORTHODOX MARXISM AND NEO-GRAMSCIAN THEORY: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS by Presented to [Name of the Professor, Name of the Class] [Name of University] [Name of the City and State] May 3, 2011 Introduction This essay will deal with common and distinct features of orthodox Marxism and neo-Gramscian school as approaches to research of the IR…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
Compare and contrast traditional Marxist approaches to international relations with EITHER Neo-Gramscian OR Frankfurt School vie
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Compare and contrast traditional Marxist approaches to international relations with EITHER Neo-Gramscian OR Frankfurt School vie"

Download file to see previous pages The essay will be structured as follows. In the first section, the basic assumption and specific views of orthodox Marxist theorists of the IR will be examined. It will be argued that orthodox Marxism proceeds from the notion of primacy of international economic relations over political processes in the world system of states, neglecting ideological dimensions of international system. The second section will be devoted to analysis of neo-Gramscian approach to the IR. The questions of neo-Gramscian view on interrelation between economic and social factors of the IR will be given due attention. Finally, in the third section which will represent a conclusion to the essay, the direct comparison between orthodox Marxism and neo-Gramscianism will be presented, with a view to proving the difference between these two schools of international political thought. 1. Orthodox Marxism as a Theory of International Relations Basic Assumptions of Orthodox Marxism The crux of orthodox Marxist approach to the study of the IR lies in its assumption of primacy of economic and technological development over purely political processes, and of predominance of the struggle between different social classes over conflicts between political states (Linklater, 2005, p. 110). Unlike idealist and realist perspectives that centre on assumption of basically unchanging process of competition between self-interested individuals/political entities, a Marxian political analysis rests on the idea of historical specificity of social processes and of organic nature of social relations (Rupert, 2007b, p. 150). The Marxist theory implies the interconnection between productive forces as material bases for social production, and relations of production, which refer to the social relations between individuals, usually organized into classes, over the issues of production and distribution of social product. A Marxist perspective on the social processes proceeds from the idea of dialectic of “relations in process” (Rupert, 2007b, p. 151), where the social subjects, or agents, are both dependent on social structures that set the framework for their actions and effect their maintenance and further development. In that way, social structures simultaneously determine the actions of social agents and are continuously altered by them (Rupert, 2007a, p. 36). In class society the nature of social agents is determined by their class nature, with capitalist social relations being preconditioned by the struggle between two socio-economic classes: the bourgeoisie (capitalist entrepreneurs) and the proletariat (propertyless wage workers). The View of International Relations in Orthodox Marxism Just as Marx and Engels viewed economic structure of specific societies as the factor defining the whole variety of its political, juridical and ideological forms (the former was regarded as “basis” of society, the latter as its “superstructure”), so they regarded the problems of the IR as the result of interactions of different economies controlled by national dominant classes, whose interests are represented politically by their state. According to Marx and Engels, as the existence of bourgeoisie as a class in capitalist society was predicated on ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compare and contrast traditional Marxist approaches to international Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419537-compare-and-contrast-traditional-marxist
(Compare and Contrast Traditional Marxist Approaches to International Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419537-compare-and-contrast-traditional-marxist.
“Compare and Contrast Traditional Marxist Approaches to International Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419537-compare-and-contrast-traditional-marxist.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Compare and contrast traditional Marxist approaches to international relations with EITHER Neo-Gramscian OR Frankfurt School vie

International Relations. Approaches To Poverty, Environmental Issues

... which a comprehensive analysis of International Relations can be conducted. On the other hand, the classical approach seems to be very simplistic in nature. It seems to have very limited scope and does not answer the main elements of the International Relations question. However, I think that it offers a very practical and simplified approach to International Relations analysis on a theoretical level since it is much more easier to analyse just one variable, the State rather than all the new variables that the constructivists bring on board. Question 2 Compare and contrast the mainstream and critical approaches to poverty and development. Which account is more convincing? The main theoretical framework for International Relations... . In...
22 Pages(5500 words)Essay

Compare, Contrast and Evaluate Three Psychological Approaches

...? Compare, Contrast & Evaluate three psychological approaches December 10, Compare, Contrast & Evaluatethree psychological approaches Psychology is considered to be one of the most practical & interesting fields of study. It is basically the study of human behavior regarding different situations, i.e., how a person or a group of person react while facing a particular kind of situation. By studying the behaviorism, human psychology can be well understood effectively. Hence by studying a variety of cases, psychologists become able to drive a generality about human behavior & find the ways of treatment of different psychological problems....
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Realist and Neo-Realist International Relations

...Introduction The dominant approach in international relations theory for virtually the past two millennia, from Thucydides to Machiavelli to Morgenthau, has been Realism, also known as Political Realism. Realists come in many stripes. Most notably, they divide between Classical Realists and Contemporary Structural Realists or Non-realists. Realism is the type of IR theory that interprets all aspect of international politics as reducible to a struggle for power, with the state seen as a unitary entity in control (more or less) of its destiny, the main actor but conditioned in its behaviour by the "international anarchy", the absence of government in...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Frankfurt School

...that a group of people came out with new ideas that were co-related with Social Research. This Public Institution began in 1923, where Marxism was the main theory as part of the Institute's proceedings. It was the first Institute of Research that followed Marxism. This change took place so as to do away with the Christian Religion and ideologies that involved the lives of the European people and other relevant matters. The members of the FrankfurtSchool developed a theory that was meant to change the entire system by which people of that century were living. Their main aim was to ...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Beo-Gramscian Approaches and Marxist Thinking on International Relations

...In what ways do neo-Gramscian approaches differ from other Marxist thinking about international relations Besides realism and liberalism, radicalism is considered as "the third overarching theoretical perspective to international relation" (Mingst, 2005, p.71). However, radicalism is not a homogeneous perspective, it is an umbrella term to denote a number of perspectives which have significantly different world views while sharing some central tenets of Marxism. "Radicals are concerned most with explaining the relationship between production, social relations and power"...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

International Relations High School Essay

...The ethnic and racial stereotypes through which Americans see and understand the other,' are rooted in the nation's history of immigration and conquest. The first arrivals, the white Anglo-Saxon Protestants, dominate and are regarded as the superior race, followed by those who came after, the Catholics and Jews. The conquered, the natives of the land, the American Indians are, within the scheme of things, at the bottom of the tier; they are the inferior race. Upon a consideration of the logic which informs this particular racial structure and its associate ethnic/racial stereotypes, one discovers that it is ultimately informed by the historical dynamics of the interaction between the races and, importantly, interaction... ethnic and racial ...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Compare and contrast the positions of one or more neo-Marxist or post-Marxist theorists of ideology with those of the classical Marxist tradition

...of the social relations of production, whereas Weber conceptualizes classes as common positions within the market.” (Burris, 1987, p.1) In conclusion, the neo-Marxists discussed in this essay have all made their own unique contributions to the analysis, interpretation and expansion of traditional Marxist ideology. While Karl Marx will be remembered as the most influential political scientist of the modern era, neo-Marxists Max Weber, Antonio Gramsci and others will be remembered for adding new dimensions and interpretations to traditional Marxist ideology. References Bieler,...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Compare/Contrast the Representation of gender relations

...Compare/Contrast the Representation of Gender Relations The short stories, “Hills like White Elephants,” by Ernest Hemingway and “The Story of an Hour” by Kate Chopin present with the lives of two married couples and these stories portray the relationship between the husband and the wife. The two stories explain the similarities that exist in married relationships. They indicate the complexity of a married life where despite of the presence of love, relationships become strained on the basis of personal choice and freedom. The gender relations between a husband and a wife are portrayed in a similar manner in the two stories as the wives are aware of the fact that their...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

United States and the neo-Gramscian perspectives

...the position that hegemony must relate to leading factions within the economy.10 On the other hand, there are several schools that are aligned and even support the neo-Gramscian perspective. For example, there is the case of the world system theorists, who also view hegemonies as a crucial component of international relations. Frank and Gills (1996) found the neo-Gramscian schools aligned with their approach to hegemonic transitions. There are even theorists who were able to combine neo-Gramscian perspectives and world systems theory...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Four traditional approaches

...Approaches to Job Design Introduction The four approaches to job design were introduced in the 20th century in America. These are scientific management, job enlargement/job rotation, job enrichment, and the job characteristics theory. In this paper, the four approaches will be described and compared. The first approach is the scientific management which focuses on the specialization and simplification on work. This approach is used mainly for jobs that are scientifically-specific such as engineers. In this design, the workers do not need to analyze or think about the tasks as they are permanent and instructed already mostly with a...
2 Pages(500 words)Admission/Application Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Compare and contrast traditional Marxist approaches to international relations with EITHER Neo-Gramscian OR Frankfurt School vie for FREE!

Contact Us