StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Justice and Civil Disobedience - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Justice and Civil Disobedience" discusses that people may feel that injustice is just a part of having the government take control of society. They do what they want even if it is not right or proper just because it makes things easier for them…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
Justice and Civil Disobedience
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Justice and Civil Disobedience"

?Justice and Civil Disobedience By definition, justice can either mean the quality of being fair or reasonable, or the administrating or maintaining the law. However, every person has a different view of what justice is based on their own experience, referring to the workings of the government as the main example. From most points of view, justice is considered to be the same thing as unfairness. It all comes down to how people view the government when the government tries to enforce justice, with the claim that the government does what it wants despite what the people need. Even though many people do not agree with how the government upholds justice, the government is still there to make sure that justice is kept. In his Civil Disobedience essay, Henry David Thoreau points out how pointless the government is. It is useless and the only reason that it has power is because it is treated strong, and not because they have the most legal point of view. Thoreau goes on to say that the government likes to do what is easiest instead of what is right; as such, Thoreau believes that if what the government is unjust, the people that should be doing the right thing should not follow the whims of the government. “A person is not obligated to devote his life to eliminating evils from the world, but he is obligated not to participate in such evils (Thoreau).” The purpose of this essay was to make it known that the government gets its power from us and that it does with that power whatever it decides to, even if it may not always be right. Thoreau made a few good points, but his actions in regard to how he felt about the government and its keeping of justice only showed why the government existed in the first place. In response to the approval of slavery, Thoreau protested by not paying his taxes and ended up spending a night in jail. While protesting may have seemed like a good idea at the time, all he proved was that the government was keeping justice as it should by punishing criminals refusing to obey the law. The government may not always be fair, and they may have their own agenda, but they still try to make sure that people are punished properly. On the other hand, Martin Luther King, Jr., in his Letter from Birmingham Jail, wrote about the purpose of his own protest against the government. Upset by the racial segregation in the United States, King led a nonviolent protest. However, he was arrested, being told that protesting against racial segregation should be saved for the courtroom and not for the streets. King states that “one has a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws (King).” In this way, the government did act in an unjust way, punishing somebody that was not doing anything bad or against the law. Legally, King was allowed to have a peaceful protest and the police did not have the right to arrest him. They wanted to put an end to something that was making them look bad, even if it was true. All the same, the government was acting in a way that they thought was proper to avoid causing more problems between King and his enemies. John Rawls took a different view on justice and civil disobedience. He believed that everybody should be allowed to “have an equal right to the most extensive scheme of equal basic liberties compatible with a similar scheme of liberties for others (Rawls).” Rawls felt that if everyone had the same liberties, there would be no need for injustice or civil disobedience. This could make things easier for the government, but it would not give people the chance to exercise their right to protest. Rawls’ views continued to state that everything should be distributed equally unless an unequal distribution would be the best for those least favored. These ideas would allow the government to completely avoid any trouble that might make them look bad by not letting people have all of their freedom. At the same time, the government is doing what it can to make sure that people do not act in ways that they should not. On the other side of the argument, Cicero, in The Defense of Injustice, points how out important injustice actually is. He believes that by arguing for injustice, justice will be better understood (Cicero). It would also make it much easier to find real justice. Likewise, people are left with three choices: perform and not suffer from injustice, perform and suffer from injustice, or neither perform or suffer injustice. What this means is that a world without injustice will never really know what justice is. There need to be mistakes made before people can figure out the proper way to do things. Also found in this text is that a world cannot really exist without some form of injustice. Cicero wrote about how important it is to understand both concepts of injustice and justice since they are things that will never be absent. This can benefit both people and the government. If people are treated with injustice, it will be a good learning experience for when they are treated with justice. Then, they would know what justice really is, just as the government would. People may feel that injustice is just a part of having the government take control of a society. They do what they want even if it is not right or proper just because it makes things easier for them. There is very little to prove this. Yet, when people go out of their way to break the law in protest, just like Thoreau, they deserve the punishments that government has for them. The government will continue to do its job whether or not everybody always agrees with them. Even if people do not agree with the justice of the government, the government still tries to do what they feel is the best thing. In a world full of opinion, not everyone is going to see eye to eye with the decisions made by others. Works Cited Cicero, Marcus Tullius. On Government. London: Penguin Books, 1993. Print. King, Martin Luther. I Have a Dream/Letter from Birmingham Jail. Logan, Iowa: Tale Blazers Perfection Learning Corp., 1990. Print. Rawls, John. A Theory of Justice. Original ed. Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press, 2005. Print. Thoreau, Henry David. Civil Disobedience and Other Essays. New York: Dover Publications, 1993. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1410826-justice
(Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1410826-justice.
“Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1410826-justice.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Justice and Civil Disobedience

The Impact Of Civil Disobedience And The Use Of Morality And Justice

In this essay "The Impact Of civil disobedience And The Use Of Morality And Justice" the main focus will be on the views held about the effect of civil disobedience and the use of morality justice to support civil rights and occupy movements.... Some of the implications of the view that there is a right to civil disobedience will be central to the discussion in this paper.... According to Gandhi, the right to civil disobedience is essentially diverse from the way that contemporary liberals like John Rawls, Ronald Dworkin, and Joseph Raz comprehend the term....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

David Thoreau and the Doctrine of Disobedience

Published in 1849, 'civil disobedience' is Thoreau's reaction to an America that he believed had failed to live up to the constitutional promise of equality and justice.... The doctrine that Thoreau espoused, which Mohandas Gandhi said 'contained the essence of his political philosophy,' is today famously known as 'civil disobedience' The paper tells that the questions that emerged from Thoreau's famous night in jail resulted in an essay originally entitled 'Resistance to Civil Government,' which probably more accurately describes his position and the course of action he adopted in response to what he considered the depredations of the U....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Civil disobedience is justified when citizens experience injustice from the government

Many government policies are flawed and civil disobedience is only effective method of ending injustice in the society.... civil disobedience is justified when citizens experience substantial injustice from the government.... civil disobedience is deliberate disregard for the rule of law by citizens in advancing moral principles are protesting against government policies.... civil disobedience is justified when citizens experience injustice from the government....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Rawlsian Civil Disobedience

As it is, acts of injustice in a democratic social order signify an infringement of individual rights and civil disobedience provides a good opportunity to defy injustice but still observing the law.... It is the kind of resistance to injustice employing non-violent means, the kind of struggle wherein civil disobedience takes center stage.... Ladies and gentlemen, civil disobedience, I believe, is one form of resistance available to the public instituted on the basis of majority rule....
2 Pages (500 words) Speech or Presentation

Civil Disobedience

The paper "civil disobedience" highlights that Thoreau's mood is assertive.... He speaks out his thoughts on justice and openly hits out at the audience.... The decision of the majority is not justice since the majority may not be right.... Conscience should be used to determine justice for all.... uestion #7Thoreau's concepts of justice revolve around individuals other than the state.... He believes that it is up to the people to deliver justice through their actions, although they are ignorant of the motives....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

The Case against Civil Disobedience

civil disobedience involves nonviolent resistance to the ‘unjust' governing laws by certain members of the community to which.... civil disobedience as a method of seeking political justice is ually ‘irrelevant' to the real world today given the fact that it involves defying the governing laws and being ready to face the penalty that are set by these same laws.... his paper will argue on the facts against using civil disobedience in achieving either effective revolution or a conventional political action....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Supporting Civil Disobedience in the Society

The essay "Supporting civil disobedience in the Society" provides the reasons why civil disobedience should be more acceptable than it is, is that without a voice, the people of any state, country or nation will go unheard and therefore fall will under the tyranny of the said state, country or nation.... civil disobedience never occurred, women would not have the right to vote, the emancipation of the slaves would not have occurred and segregation would still be firmly in place....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Law: Civil Disobedience

This work called "Law: civil disobedience'" describes an analysis of the limits of citizens' obligation to obey the law, the rule of law.... The author outlines that civil disobedience is unjustifiable in any democratic regime.... This causes civil disobedience.... Diverse authors, philosophers, and leaders have varied opinions on civil disobedience.... Proponents of civil disobedience highlight its effectiveness in correcting unjust laws....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us