Iranian System of Organ Transplantation - PowerPoint Presentation Example

• Transplantation is more permanent, safer, surer, and cheaper than dialysis (Mackay 1). Both poor and the rich will benefit from kidney transplants, which are currently the most needed organ. Iran has authorized the procurement of kidneys in a market situation. It has ensured that there is a properly regulated market with only modest room agreements. The country is now boasting of a reduction in the number of people on the waiting list for organ transplantation. Countries should learn from Iran. Legalization of the trade will thus help in regulating its practices. It will ensure proper intermediary, balanced demand and supply, proper pricing, and safe transplantation (Gregory). 

Mark explores why the well-intentioned legislation and perceptions create roadblocks that prevent the restoration of the health of many people. He suggests that these barriers should be eliminated. He uses statistics and examples to demonstrate that human organs should be given to those in need of them as donations rather than commodities for sale. He points out that a majority of people concurs with the notion that the most efficient, legitimate and humane place to distribute resources in the market. Hence, body parts should be one of the resources being traded in that place. Instead of dwelling on purported irrational “moral repugnance” and human exploitation, Cherry claims that people should focus their attention on saving a life. Therefore, his arguments were valuable for supporting my thesis since it has examples and statistics that strongly support the importance of legalizing the sale of human organs in order to save lives.

“Why Legalizing Organ Sales Would Help to Save Lives, End Violence” by Gregory A. Gregory describes why he thinks that making the organ trade legal will end violence and save lives. He thus says the idea of selling organs should not sound gruesome to people. He refutes claims that organ sales will give the rich an advantage over the poor by saying that this is the characteristic of today’s black market trade.  Hence, legalizing organ sales will reduce these markets and create fair trade.  He uses facts, examples and statistics to back up his claims.  The source was significant for my thesis because it explicitly concludes that legalizing organ sales are inevitable since the trade is going on anyway, although through black markets.  Berman argues that although legalizing organ sales is callous and abhorrent, the well-meaning attempts to bar organ sales have created something worse – an illegal market in body parts. He says that the practices of black markets hurt the poor and are a cause of many deaths. He says that organ transplant does not pose more risks than many daily operations for which no person raises ethical questions. He uses facts to show the high demand for organ transplants.

• He also uses examples of how proper regulations can be carried out. Additionally, Berman uses facts to show that organ sales are happening regardless of the law. The article was useful for my thesis as it points out that legalizing organ sales will make the poor smile and reduce the number of deaths. What if people start killing each other to sell their organs, how will that be addressed? In this society, some people lack morals and are inhuman. It is true that this group of people may take advantage of the situation and start killing in order to sell other people’s organs for personal gain. However, such greed cannot be tolerated; thus, the law legalizing organ sales should come with strict measures for dealing with such cases.

For example, the perpetrators can be given harsh punishment such as life imprisonment in order to discourage such behaviour in the community. The organ market will be regulated by appointing a government agency to handle all issues dealing with the sale. This will also involve enacting policies and imposing ethical standards to govern the conduct of those involved. What is the expected success rate of legalizing organ sales?  Legalizing organ sales is expected to avert 90% of deaths due to kidney and another organ failure. Read More