Question 3&4 - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Therefore, he focuses on the requirements of the fourth amendment. Taft believes there is no analogy that fits wiretapping in the Fourth Amendment…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
Question 3&4
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Question 3&4"

Describe the reasoning that led Taft to not consider wiretapping a search in Olmstead and why Stewart did in Katz. Justice Taft argues that there is no need for the application of the fourth amendment because the Fifth Amendment was not violated. Therefore, he focuses on the requirements of the fourth amendment. Taft believes there is no analogy that fits wiretapping in the Fourth Amendment. It makes sense to apply the fourth amendment in matters pertaining mail and other material things. It is because the Congress has developed laws to protect the privacy of the mail. However, it is difficult to fit wiretapping because the law does not treat it as an intrusion of privacy. The Fourth Amendment does not apply in wiretapping there was no seizure and search. The evidence was obtained solely by hearing. Nobody entered the house of the defendant by force. Taft asserts that the words contained in the Fourth Amendment cannot be expanded to include a phone and the wires that leave the defender’s home to different parts of the world.
Justice Stewart reasons that private conversations can be made in public. An individual pays for phone services with the expectation that his conversation will not be public. He expects privacy. The intrusion of this privacy via wiretapping is a violation of the Fourth Amendment. Stewart states that listening to phone conversations is equivalent to a search, which has been mentioned in the Fourth Amendment.
Explain the significance of Weeks vs. U.S. concerning gathering and considering evidence in trials involving the fourth Amendment.
The Weeks vs. U.S. case presented the courts with the real definition of privacy intrusion. The trial did not accept the violation of the rights of the defendants found in the Fourth Amendment. The ruling of the case stated that the trial court erred by allowing the evidence collected by forceful entry, search and seizure as part of the evidence. The defendant’s home is a personal space that should not be intruded by any government agency. The Weeks vs. U.S. case helped in defining the implication of the Fourth Amendment. The Fourth Amendment did not affect the evidence that was forcefully seized during the arrest of the defendant. In respect to the court’s conclusion, the Fourth Amendment does not expand to the acts of individuals acting without the push of the federal government. The law is present to control the power of the federal government.
The significance of the case is related to the definition of fourth amendment right implications and the extent of the violations found in it.
The question central to this course is how law written in the 18th century should be interpreted by courts to deal with the technology of the 21st century. Contrast the minority (dissenting) opinions of Brandeis in Olmstead vs. U.S. and Black in Katz vs. U.S.
The interpretation of the law is not constant. The law evolves as time and people change. The development of new technology and new methods help in changing the definition of the words contained in the law. The law has an underlying factor that is constant. For example, the right to privacy is a factor that remains valid. Justice Brandeis dissents by pointing out the need to understand that it is necessary to expound the constitution. The law must be adapt to ensure the rights protected can never be lost. On the other hand, Justice Black dissents (Katz vs. United States) by pointing out that the wiretapping is not covered in the fourth amendment. He believes wiretapping is equivalent to eavesdropping, which was around for long. The law must have included eavesdropping if it wanted to include it. Black and Brandeis differ in the real meaning of wiretapping. In conclusion, the law must change to accommodate the changes in the society. They should protect the rights at all costs.
Question 4 (A and C)
A. Justice Scalia characterizes the thermal imaging devices as a search because it reveals the content in the privacy of the home. The imaging devices detected the heat coming out of the house. Scalia mentions the concept of surveillance and asserts the thermal imaging was a search because of what it did to the petitioner’s home. According to Justice Steven, the ‘bright line developed by Justice Scalia does not handle the matter of the thermal imaging device. Instead, it makes it broad by claiming the thermal imaging device constitutes a search. It is too broad because it implies even sniffing dogs are covered under the fourth amendment, which is not the case. The line created by Scalia would disintegrate when a technology that can see through the wall is in the hands of the public. The line is too narrow because something that protects people from sense-enhancing equipment should not be restricted to homes.
B. Justice Scalia interprets the use of beeper as a search. However, Scalia points out the search was an unconstitutional invasion of privacy. The beeper performed the same thing that agents would have done by following and observing the petition. Justice Alito agrees the use of the GPS tracking devices was a search. The search does not fall under the fourth amendment, which protects the privacy of the home. Officers can survey and watch people in public places when conducing investigation. The search in open fields or public roads does not constitute the meaning of a search depicted in the fourth amendment.
Works Cited
Fine, Toni M. “How the U.S. Court System Works.” n.d. Document
Katz vs. Unites States. Supreme Court of the United States. 1967. Print.
Kyllo vs. United States. Supreme Court of the United States. 2001. Document.
Olmstead et al. v. United States. Green et al. v. Same. Mcinnis v. Same. Supreme Court of the United States. 4 June 1928. Print.
United States, Petitioner v. Antoine Jones. Supreme Court of the United States. 23 Jan. 2012. Print.
Warren and Brandeis. “The Right to Privacy.” Harvard Law Review (1890). PDF Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Question 3&4 Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Question 3&4 Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“Question 3&4 Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document


The contribution of the construction industry to economic development in Libya

...?The Contribution of the Construction Industry to Economic Development in Libya Table of Contents Question 3 Question 2 3 Question 3 4 Question In 1986, GDP of Libyan construction industry was 492.6 Million L.D., whereas the country’s national GDP was 6960.7 Million L.D. Hence, the construction industry contributes almost 7% (7.07%) to the national GDP. Over the next five years this contribution was reduced to almost 3.88%. During the period of 1986-1991 the contributions of construction industry to the GDP of Lydia were 6.84, 6.20, 6.28, 5.55 and 3.88 respectively. Over the next ten years i.e. 1991-2001...
2 Pages(500 words)Dissertation

Question 3

...?Damage Claims for Damaged Reputation Alice, driven by the desire to share her wealth and good fortune with her fellowmen, founded the world-renowned‘University of the One-World Religion’. Given her financial and social stature, Alice has an honorable reputation to keep. When the London Reporter ran a story headlined: ‘Amorous Alice and her Religion of Love,’ depicting her as a cult leader disguised as a philanthropist, Alice has every right to demand for reparation and vindication against all persons who imputed a vice or defect against her good name and character. Alice has valid and stable grounds to support a legal action for defamation which, as defined in Black’s Law Dictionary, is “an intentional false communication, either...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

The topic for your paper will be Baze v Rees, a Supreme Court hearing on lethal injection. The question for your 3-4 page paper

...?A United s Supreme Court case called Baze v. Rees, 553 U.S. 35 (2008) is a unique case when the petitioners in the person of Ralph Baze and Thomas Bowling sentenced to death in Kentucky highlighted that lethal injection violates the 8th Amendment to the US Constitution (Supreme Court, 2008). The main claims by the petitioners were that the three components used in the injection may be injected in an improper way causing Baze and Bowling a severe pain. This is why the case was granted by certiorari. Nevertheless, all points concerning the 8th Amendment are to be reconsidered so as to find out the truth through the analysis of both sides in the case. First and foremost, the main argument on the part of the Baze’s lawyers... United s Supreme...
3 Pages(750 words)Term Paper

American Memory of the Second World War Versus American's Experience of the Second World War

3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Integrated Project Management Tools

3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper


...history (3rd ed.). Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Pearson Prentice Hall. Question #3 Explain the impact of humanism on Christian beliefs in the fifteenth century In the fifteenth century, Christianity had already become an extremely powerful religion with extraordinary influence. Within the same time period, however, the Renaissance was just beginning to take shape. The Renaissance provided a unique contrast in that it focused on education, culture, and philosophy. One such concept that became popular during this time and influenced Christianity greatly was humanism. According to Howard Spodek, author of the book entitled The World’s History, humanism was a philosophy centered on the idea that “the proper...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Question 3

...; further market research is necessary to establish whether additional packaging units must be made for 7, 60 and 90 packets. Additional research is also necessary with respect to advertising and distribution. The product has been pretested for purity as well as potency; further market tests will be conducted using stratified samples for possible side effects. The product will be available nationwide using a market penetration strategy, along with a strong advertising effort. 3. Product Life Cycle and Product Positioning Oxylent will be launched by the second quarter of this fiscal year and is expected to achieve strong market growth soon. The marketing strategies for the product have been designed to snare a ten to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

I want you to read my decument ( IEP Study notes) and answer my question 2- 3- 4

... Individualized Education Program It is true to say that the program can be financially accomplished. For this success to be experienced, there are some conditions that are put in place by the Texas committee to ensure that these students have the same experience as normal students. The environment provided for these students is not restrictive. They ensure that there is full support from the parents, members of the community and ensure that all special children get what they need without getting discriminated from the other students who do not have any disability. The member of the ARD does not necessarily need to attend the meeting, but before this is done it must be put in writing. There must be a consensus between the parents... Individual...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Discussion Week 3 Question 1 Retirement Planning Chapter 4

...Retirement planning Retirement planning It is important to plan for ones retirement. This is because, when retiring, onesage makes it difficult for them to generate income. This is one of the major reasons why planning for ones retirement is very important. According to Jasper (2004), there various ways of planning for ones retirement, but setting up a pension scheme is the best way. A pension is amount of money in which one pays or is deducted in order for them to have an income after reaching the age of retirement where they do not have to work. There various ways of calculating the amount of money one needs to save in order for them to meet a certain amount in which they will be receiving as their retirement income, (Marx 2004... planning...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Question 3

...Exercises for Each Plane of Movement Exercises for Each Plane of Movement The sagittal plane divides the body into right and left halves. It is involved in exercises that utilize forward and backward movement, including flexion and extension. The exercises that involve the sagittal plane are common in most gyms. They include bicep curls, chest presses and squats, cycling and running. Cardiovascular exercises that involve the heart and blood systems also use the sagittal plane. The sagittal plane exercises concentrate on building up strength in the upper body. It is also important to include sagittal plane exercises for the lower body and the core. The frontal plane divides the human body into two halves, the front and the back... for Each...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Question 3&4 for FREE!

Contact Us