Rose and Lamott Response Paper - Essay Example

For example, on page 391, he mentions Dunker, Miller, Galanter, Pribram, and Polya as some of the students that apply his rules which may are either learned directly or indirectly. Some of the examples include the differences in algorithm and heuristic rules. In my opinion, I find that he has a subjective view since the conclusions provided do not have enough groundings and contain only general observations. Still, I find it to be an interesting article full of views that are believable and worth reading.

Anne Lamott also demonstrates a clear point, that; writing does not occur naturally, even to the most experienced writers in the world. There use of words such as “child’s draft” (which she regards as a primary attempt to express the ideas, whereas secondary polishing still needs to be done) and “shitty first drafts” to make her argument more valid, which makes it easier for readers to understand that writing naturally is a misconception. I always notice that my first draft expresses the main ideas, but word selection and language in general require amendments. We can distinguish 2 steps of writing: expressing ideas and building the proper linguistic structure of the text. An excellent illustration is on page 1 of her book where she asserts that there are no writers that write elegant first drafts. I agree with her view because it reminds me as a student that I should never feel embarrassed for writing my first drafts with so many mistakes. Completing the final draft requires analysis of all components which form one’s assignment: checking the smooth transition between ideas, and the logical structure of the writer’s thoughts and language, which includes grammar, punctuation, and stylistic analysis of the text. What helps is when the writer starts looking at a topic from different angles to get to the right ideas, hence the final draft. By making a conclusion I would like to say that creativity requires balancing between one’s inner thoughts and ideas and the way those ideas are expressed via language. Writers' inner voice should embody in the text by transferring precise ideas using stylistically rich and grammatically correct language.