The Secret Ibis by James Hurst and Film Simon Birch - Essay Example

Talking about The Secret Ibis, it comes to understanding that Doodle (the lead character who is physically unstable) was a disappointment to his family. Among all, his brother was more disappointed because he could not play with him the way he expected to run. In the second setting, Simon Birch, one can note that Simon was not able to be one of those kids who were normal. It should also be noted that he was a short-sighted person who was not accepted by anyone not even the society he lived in (Hurst).

It will not be incorrect to state that if Doodle or Simon were treated well by his brother and Joe then it could have been expected that there were betterment in their lives. The support from family or friends would have helped them to be accepted by society in general. As a contradiction to this statement, it was marked in the short story that Doodle was not at all accepted by his brother as he was tortured by showing the coffin that was bought by Doodle (Johnson). Ultimately, Doodle’s brother left him alone when the storm occurred. Doodle lost his life in the storm as he was dependent upon his brother for reaching school. Similarly, Simon was put to the test by his friend who was rather supposed to provide support to him. Just because of the misunderstanding, he wronged Simon (Hurst).

The community has seemingly failed to understand the need of dealing with people who are abnormal but can be gifted in many ways. For instance, Doodle was a mighty heart because he was able to survive when everyone thought he will not. In the same way, Simon was considered a person who was shot and a misfit in society. However, in real terms, he was extremely talented and wise. Nevertheless, despite their gifted personalities, they were not provided with the support and acceptance that they deserved to have (Johnson).

Through the above analysis, it comes to the understanding that the two written pieces entitled, The Secret Ibis and Simon Birch have conveyed the difficulties that were faced by abnormal characters. Both stories have marked the significance of family and society to provide support to such people. Thus, it can be well stated that people like Doodle and Simon were not able to live in the societies because they were made deprived of the basic necessity of life which was support from family.