Free

Hills like White Elephants is a story where the dialogue is prominent, but still many of the details are vague and shadowy. How would you describe the man in this story from his dialogue What about the woman What can you tell about their relationship - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
How would you describe the man in this story from his dialogue? What about the woman? What can you tell about their relationship?
The man is domineering,…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
Hills like White Elephants is a story where the dialogue is prominent, but still many of the details are vague and shadowy. How would you describe the man in this story from his dialogue What about the woman What can you tell about their relationship
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Hills like White Elephants is a story where the dialogue is prominent, but still many of the details are vague and shadowy. How would you describe the man in this story from his dialogue What about the woman What can you tell about their relationship"

May 29, Hills like White Elephants is a story where the dialogue is prominent, but still many of the details are vague andshadowy. How would you describe the man in this story from his dialogue? What about the woman? What can you tell about their relationship?
The man is domineering, yet he is also insecure and immature because he undercuts Jig’s ability to make decisions for herself and he focuses too much on having fun in life. He wants to dominate the relationship by manipulating Jig into seeing the abortion as something easy and good for their relationship. He insists that abortion is “perfectly simple” (Hemingway 403). He even makes grand promises that afterwards, they can be happy again and “have the whole world” (Hemingway 403). He wants to manipulate Jig into thinking that abortion is best for them, when, in reality, he does not want to commit to Jig any more than he has to because he is not willing to have kids with her.
Ironically, though the man is domineering, he is insecure because he always has the need to feel superior over Jig. For instance, when Jig says that he has not seen any white elephants, he responds: “…just because you say I wouldnt have doesnt prove anything” (Hemingway 401). He has a defensive tone in his language that shows that he does not want to be in any way inferior to Jig. In addition, the man dominates Jig through his patronizing attitude. Jig is going to undergo a physically-intrusive and potentially emotionally-damaging abortion operation and yet he calls it an “awfully simple operation” that is “perfectly natural” (Hemingway 401). He also asserts that abortion will make everything return to normal because it is “the only thing” that made them “unhappy” (Hemingway 401). He just wants a carefree relationship with no strings attached. In addition, their relationship is unequal because the man wants to monopolize the power in making decisions for their welfare through emphasizing the girl’s lack of knowledge on abortion and relationships. The words “perfectly simple” (Hemingway 403) are redundant already, which means that he is saying that Jig knows nothing about abortions. He even pretends to care for her by saying that she can choose to not abort it, but he also reminds her that the operation is “perfectly simple” (Hemingway 403). His true intention is to control their relationship according to his needs and wants alone.
Jig is young, so she tends to be passive and emotionally dependent on the man, at least initially, but as she reflects on the importance of having a baby, she develops courage and independence. She is young because the story refers to her as “the girl” to emphasize her age. In addition, Jig is emotionally dependent at first on the man because she always wants his approval. When she thinks about the abortion, she values the thoughts and feelings of the man. She says that if she does it, the man will be “happy and things will be like they were and [he]ll love [her]” (Hemingway 402). She cannot make decisions without prioritizing his feelings. Later on, Jig becomes more dominating as she asks the man to “stop talking” (Hemingway 403). She resists his manipulations regarding the abortion and their relationship. Finally, when she says that she is fine and there is “nothing wrong” with her (Hemingway 403), it can be argued as a courageous act that she is ready to have a baby because she can be fine as she is without the man. Jig gains her autonomy by showing that she can make decisions about her emotions and her future.
Work Cited
Hemingway, Ernest. “Hills like White Elephants.” Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Hills like White Elephants is a story where the dialogue is prominent, Essay”, n.d.)
Hills like White Elephants is a story where the dialogue is prominent, Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1647457-hills-like-white-elephants-is-a-story-where-the-dialogue-is-prominent-but-still-many-of-the-details-are-vague-and-shadowy-how-would-you-describe-the-man-in-this-story-from-his-dialogue-what-about-the-woman-what-can-you-tell-about-their-relationship
(Hills Like White Elephants Is a Story Where the Dialogue Is Prominent, Essay)
Hills Like White Elephants Is a Story Where the Dialogue Is Prominent, Essay. https://studentshare.org/english/1647457-hills-like-white-elephants-is-a-story-where-the-dialogue-is-prominent-but-still-many-of-the-details-are-vague-and-shadowy-how-would-you-describe-the-man-in-this-story-from-his-dialogue-what-about-the-woman-what-can-you-tell-about-their-relationship.
“Hills Like White Elephants Is a Story Where the Dialogue Is Prominent, Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1647457-hills-like-white-elephants-is-a-story-where-the-dialogue-is-prominent-but-still-many-of-the-details-are-vague-and-shadowy-how-would-you-describe-the-man-in-this-story-from-his-dialogue-what-about-the-woman-what-can-you-tell-about-their-relationship.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Hills like White Elephants is a story where the dialogue is prominent, but still many of the details are vague and shadowy. How would you describe the man in this story from his dialogue What about the woman What can you tell about their relationship

Ernest Hemingway Hills Like White Elephants

...?Geoffrey Gomez English 101/ Hall 04/22 Opposite Sides of the Tracks The short story Hills Like White Elephants by Ernest Hemingway has two unique characters caught in the difference of views and emotional substance. The American is a flat character who refuses to grow up and exists with a purely self centered and self interested motive while Jig is well-rounded character who initially is caught between her love and responsibility ultimately grows up to know that she is absolutely uncared of. The American likes wilderness, frolic and fun while the only reason Jig too like to do the same is because the American is...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Hills like White Elephants

...the characters, the story could not have grabbed this much attention of the readers. The innocence is consummate which can be observed at the time when girl starts gazing that the hills are looking like white elephants. “I won’t worry about that because it’s perfectly simple” (Hemingway, 618) this vague sentence expresses the several dimensions which could be derived from the answer. This is simply incredible and complex piece of fiction where dialogues are attention grabbing and indulging multiple means in one sentence to aid the strength in the plot (Benson, 70)....
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Hills Like White Elephants

...it depicts that the man does not really care about his beloved. The girl says: "That's all we do, isn't it - look at things and try new drinks" (Hemingway). It is illogical, but Hemingway underlines that human life depends upon decisions and actions of other people much more than we think. The main difference is inner psychological state of the characters who try to find the "rights" solution. Hemingway depicts fresh and vivid images of "white elephants" which intensify, clarify, and enrich emotional response of both characters. A symbol of "white elephant" means the unborn child. For the girl, hills...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The Search for Better Health

12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Short story analiysis- Hills Like White Elephants,by Ernest Hemingway

...said”(Hemingway). The hills come to symbolize the ultimate issue that lies between the man and woman within the story. It is inferred that the woman is pregnant and that the man is taking her to get an abortion. The hills are a symbol of this conflict. The female character brings up the hills and how they look like white elephants; however, later on in the story, she changes her tune about them: ‘They’re lovely hills,’ she said. ‘They don’t really look like...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Hills Like White Elephants

...Hills like White Elephants al Affiliation Hills like White Elephants First published in 1927, Hills like White Elephants has become one of America’s most famous short stories today. The story opens at a train terminus in Spain, where two American couples only described as “the man” and “the girl” engages in a conversation as they wait for a train to take them to Madrid. Even though the story is difficult to understand based on the way...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review

Hills like White Elephants by Ernest Hemingway

... “Hills like White Elephants Communication. Ernest Hemingway’s short story, “Hills like White Elephants,” is a very concise and intense narrative. An American man, whose name is not even known, and a girl, Jig, are at a railway station waiting for a train. There is no detailed narrative voice or plot. The author conveys the entire meaning of the story through the dialogue between the two protagonists. Even this dialogue is minimal, leaving many things unsaid, and the reader is left to draw his own conclusions. Communication is the central theme of the story. Hemingway uses communication to portray the man’s selfishness, reveal the characters’ animosity towards each other, and suggest the complete breakdown of the relationship... a mutually...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Hemingway's Personal Life and its Influence on his Short Story, Hills Like White Elephants

...is little short of emotional blackmail of a sensitive woman who cares a great deal about him. The American’s comments of "I dont want anyone but you"(p.215) and "I dont want anyone else"(p.215) are business-like and devoid of genuine sentiments. His heart is dry and affection-less. He almost expresses hatred for the child that is yet to emerge in this world and in place of the heart he must be having a stone and thus he is a clever psychological manipulator. Conclusion: To talk about abortion ninety years ago could not be as easy as it is in the present times. Yet the American in the storyHills...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

The Hills like White Elephants

...The Hills like White Elephants Introduction In the story The Hills like White Elephants a man and a woman are waiting for the train at the railway station. Intensity is felt in their relationships. Is she going to make an abortion? Actually, the story is only about that, but Hemingway manages to provide his work with the complexity typical for a modernist poem. The story is full of the hidden meanings, and due to the opacity Hemingways stories are so strongly stamped in memory. Here it is important to note that intended darkness is suitable for the story: in a big novel such a manner of narration would look extremely tiresome. The given paper will prove that “The Hills like White Elephants” is a puzzle, the solution... says:...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Relationship between Attractive People getting Hired and Success in the Job Application Process

10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Hills like White Elephants is a story where the dialogue is prominent, but still many of the details are vague and shadowy. How would you describe the man in this story from his dialogue What about the woman What can you tell about their relationship for FREE!

Contact Us