Critiquing an Argument - Essay Example

hortest course the later on he says that one leaves everything he has including family to take a walk I don’t think an idler who said to be the holy landers can even have a good family or job to leave n take a walk n to add on that if one is successful and has a family and he owns something why should he or she go on a walk the so called holy land which even doesn’t exist in real sense (Murphy 45). It requires a direct dispensation from Heaven to become a walker. You must be born into the family of the Walkers.

This is not true because God can’t let someone become a walker and can’t allow one be born a beggar. Some commitment to religious practices is fantasy. If one is going to saunter through the woods and over the hills and fields how is he or she going to preserve their health, mechanics and shopkeepers spend their afternoons sited with their legs crossed yet they are to use their legs doing something important to earn a living so as not to become holy Landers (Lewin 22). In Thoreau’s mindset and observation, women do not like their place in society.

This is because they are expected to just sit at homes while men do all the work and walking. For men, the indoor activities increase only when they are growing old. This is not such a fair assessment but he strongly believes in how women are bored and this is shown by the use of capital letters that “I have ground to suspect that most of them do not STAND it at all” (Murphy 85). Walking is considered as a catalyst to ungodliness. This Thoreau believes because he states that even great philosophers had to import woods to themselves instead of going out into the woods.

Walking in my opinion does not make one forget about their duties and responsibilities (Lewin 34). Thoreau disagrees and believes one can walk in body without getting into the act in spirit. The author is a believer in walks only that he doubts if the society sees any good in them. He is an avid walker as he has made it almost a