Nobody downloaded yet

The Mentally Disturbed: To Jail or Not to Jail - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Insert name Name of institution Name of professor Date The Mentally Disturbed: To Jail or Not to Jail Mental Illness and violence seem to go hand in hand and as witnessed in the recent Aurora and Sandy Hook shootings. This problem can be traced back to the Columbine shootings and further beyond…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
The Mentally Disturbed: To Jail or Not to Jail
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Mentally Disturbed: To Jail or Not to Jail"

Download file to see previous pages NAMI (National Alliance on Mental Illness) defines mental illnesses as medical conditions that disrupt a person's thinking, feeling, mood, ability to relate to others and daily functioning. Mental illnesses are medical conditions that often result in a diminished capacity for coping with the ordinary demands of life. An article by Columbia University tries to examine the relationship between different types of mental disorders and related crimes resulting from these. The article concludes by affirming that diminished accountability had the strongest relationship with psychotic disorders. By analyzing the murders committed at Columbine, VA Tech and Sandy Hook I will prove that those suffering from severe psychotic disorders are the main culprits in mental ill crimes. Also according to this article I will prove my findings that more often than not, patients suffering from mental disorders are more often convicted for crimes than the general population (Wallace et al.; Arseneault et al.; Brennan et al.; Walsh et al.). Other mental disorders such as bipolar are not in themselves psychotic but can be rated as cases of severe mania. The most fundamental questions that everyone should ask himself or herself is, why the mentally disturbed such a concern for the jail population? Whether the mentally ill are even safe in jail or not? Why are jails actually used as mental hospitals? By analyzing the Columbine, VA Tech and Sandy Hook shootings and the mental illnesses from which the killers suffered in relation to the jail system in general, (American Psychiatric Association) conclude that that mentally ill/disturbed people who commit crimes should not be put in jail but in facilities that can help them better function in the society. Sexual and drug related offenses are the most common crimes that are committed by the psychotics (Bonner). As Cohen notes, the serious crimes committed by this lot are facilitated by the need to get money for drugs or forced sex either with the opposite gender or with the same gender while under the influence of drugs (Cohen). This is because the psychotic condition is often characterized by a limited ability to make cognitive decisions on various important issues relating to life and proper behavioral characteristics (Barr). There is always an absence of accountability for the various criminal offenses committed by the psychotics while under the influence of a mental disorder. The Dutch’s court classifies the level of responsibility in mental disorder offenders based on three meter levels as complete responsibility, slightly diminished, diminished, severely diminished or absence of responsibility (Grob). Complete responsibility according to this indicator is defined to refer to an occasion where the commission of the offense is not in any way related to the mental disorder the person could be suffering from or the offender has been found to have committed the offense while in his or her right mind. Absence of accountability on the other hand is far much related to the influence of drugs under which the offender committed the crimes indicated. Most studies carried out in relation to this matter often drive to an almost unanimous agreement linking the various offenses committed by psychotics to be associated with a total lack of accountability on their parts while others try to fake the absence of respon ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Mentally Disturbed: To Jail or Not to Jail Research Paper”, n.d.)
The Mentally Disturbed: To Jail or Not to Jail Research Paper. Retrieved from
(The Mentally Disturbed: To Jail or Not to Jail Research Paper)
The Mentally Disturbed: To Jail or Not to Jail Research Paper.
“The Mentally Disturbed: To Jail or Not to Jail Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Mentally Disturbed: To Jail or Not to Jail

Walnut Street Jail

...?Running head: WALNUT STREET JAIL Walnut Street Jail School Affiliation Walnut Street Jail The penitentiary or prison system in US is responsible for handling convicts who are undergoing long?term confinement. To be specific, the penitentiary system acts the role of a blockade between the mainstream society and criminals. So, one can easily identify that inculcating innovation to the traditional prison system is helpful to reduce crime rate and social insecurity. Within this context, Walnut Street Jail is to be considered as the forerunner in the development of US penitentiary system. Thesis statement: The Walnut Street Jail, especially the concept of penitentiary house, deeply influences the current prison system in US and proves... to be...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

St. Clair County Jail

...? St. Clair County Jail St. Clair County Jail located in Ashville, AL The first county jail in Ashville was established in 1827, by St. Clair resident, whose name is James Fulton (Jenks, 1997). The jail in Ashville has 74 beds that adult inmates as well as a juvenile detention facility. The County jail in Ashville does not house any women inmates, having them housed in the facility that was established in the Pell city. The Jail facility in Ashville employs 8 full time jailers, 6 part time jailers and 4 casual jailers. The medical needs of inmates are addressed by a nurse contracted on a daily basis and a physician contracted on a weekly...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Letter From a Birmingham Jail

...Argumentative Essay: Letter From a Birmingham Jail In the Letter From a Birmingham Jail written by Martin Luther King, Jr. while incarcerated in 1963, as a civil rights advocate, he was promulgating a supposed nonviolent direct action to fight injustices sustained by the African Americans during his time. The author actually directed the letter to the members of the clergy and since it was deemed published in totality, the target audience for this particular discourse is the white moderate population, who were deemed indifferent. The white moderate segment of society was noted to have preferred the status quo or retaining order and keeping their stance as observers rather than stir the social condition...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Mental illness in jail

...? Mental Illness in Jails Mental Illness In Jails A systematic review of 62 surveys of the incarcerated population from 12 Western countries showed that, among the men, 3.7 percent had psychotic illness, 10 percent major depression, and 65 percent a personality disorder, including 47 percent with antisocial personality disorder. Among the women, 4 percent had psychosis, 12 percent major depression, and 42 percent a personality disorder (Daniel, 2007, p.4, p.406) Heredity and environment are believed to be the major contributors for mental illness. It is quite possible that those who develop or brought up in unhealthy environments may develop...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Letter from Birmingham Jail

...? “Letter from Birmingham Jail” The Martin Luther King itself recalls a remarkable era of reformation in the religion of Christianity. His contributions deserve high appraisal since he served the society as an American Clergyman, an activist, reformer and a leader in the African-American Civil Rights Movement. Moreover, being a clergyman he undertook many activities to safeguard the rights of the blacks. The “Letter from Birmingham” is the clear evidence reflecting the active involvement of Luther in protecting the rights of the blacks residing in America. The universal truth of cause and effect is vivid in the context of writing this letter, for he writes this letter with a particular intension. During the period of...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Letter from birminghan jail

...24 October 2007 Letter from Birmingham Jail Luther King Letter from Birmingham Jail was written in 1963. In his Letter to black people and racial minorities, King explains his ideas and vision of a free man, importance of human rights and racial equality. Letter from Birmingham Jail stands as one of the notable documents in the struggle for black civil rights. King moved cautiously, ever worried about the possibility of violence that could do irreparable harm to political struggle and social order. Thesis King appeals to the audience using rhetoric devices (logos, ethos and emotional appeal) to create dramatic and vivid descriptions of hardship and casualties of life caused by racism and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Getting booked into jail

... The process of getting booked into a jail The booking procedure into a jail is actually fairly a simple procedure. There are various myths; most incited by movies about the actual process and rights the subjects is given. The procedures at most jailing facilities are essentially similar, with some minor differences. Every State has their own Corrections Department, or something similar, which dictates the gathering of particular data. Additionally, the FBI provides some input, and receives much of the collected information when inmates are booked into the facility. When individuals get arrested, they are normally taken to a police station / Sheriff’s Office, to be interviewed, and if necessary, forms and reports are prepared... . If the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Letter from Birmingham Jail

...Letter from Birmingham Jail Martin Luther King, Jr. is a prominent person in American history due to his achievements in campaigns for justice and equality among races. He was born in 1929 to a Baptist minister at Atlanta, Georgia and was ordained at the age of eighteen. He studied at Morehouse College, went to Boston university and Chicago. He rose to prominence in 1955 when he led the people to boycott the segregation bus system in Alabama. King campaigned against racial segregation with non-violent means. He is the chief campaigner who advocated civil rights in his time. In one of his campaigns, king led his team to protest against the segregation from the Birmingham local government. The protest led to his arrest and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Letter From Birmingham Jail

...Analysis of Letter from Birmingham Jail Martin Luther King Jr. does integrate variety of choice of words and language techniques in relaying his information. His work Letter to Birmingham remains an artistic masterpiece. He is very careful in the choice of words that he does select. Essentially, he utilized the art of pathos, logos and ethos deeply to persuade the readers, making theme emotional and inducing the act of understanding the message in an easier manner. Moreover, his choice of words does match and combats the oppression being faced by humanity at that time. His letter was a response to the clergymen on a call to remain united (Leff and Utley, pg. 38). Kind does utilize rhetorical questions to persuade the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Letter from Birmingham Jail

...Letter from Birmingham Jail A just person has a moral obligation to disobey an unjust law. Martin Luther King Jr indicates thatthe unjust laws are the primary causes of segregation and oppression of the minorities in the society. Fundamentally, unjust laws tend to infringe upon the shared moral standards. It is noteworthy recognizing that laws codify the moral repulsion for cases such as rape, murder, and any form of oppression. Hence, the just laws have the moral duty and legal obligation to protect all the citizens, regardless of the status they hold in the society. King (1963) argues that laws are just when they depict consistency with morality. In contrast, the unjust laws disrespect people’s moral autonomy, as well...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic The Mentally Disturbed: To Jail or Not to Jail for FREE!

Contact Us