Assessment on the The Singer Solution to World Poverty The average American family spends one-third of the household income in unnecessary things such as a new television, new clothes, and vacations. With this on hand, Peter Singer believes that if only every American family donates then poverty and hunger will be deterred, and children will be given the chance to live a normal life…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
Download file to see previous pages
For this reason, the paper will dwell on the possible and unreasonable solutions stated by Peter Singer as a solution for world poverty. In brief, Singer believes that a person’s action will be judged by its result. As a utilitarian philosopher, he believes that Dora did the right thing in deciding to get the child back. In this manner, the moral issue here is that Dora was haunted by the fact the she was able to see the child, which caused her to feel guilty of her actions. Personal interaction was the most dominant difference between Dora and an American who will be donating. However, Singer cited that if an American chose to donate $200 to charity rather than spending it on unnecessary things, he or she will be able to save five children from dying. In a personal level, the argument of Singer in act donating is agreeable because the expected result would be saving at most five lives of children in poverty. In an average, $200 is a little amount of money to spare in order to help other people, especially a child, to live. It is inevitable to be persuaded by Singer in this part of his argument especially in knowing that this amount will be sufficient for four years to help a sickly child be healthy when he or she comes to the age of six. As a person, Singer’s argument holds much more than the consequences of a person’s action. It exemplifies a person’s capacity to help others, which is more profound rather than buying a new shirt with $200. On the other hand, in the later part of the text, Singer’s argument shifted from $200 to donating almost all of what is left after a family had spent for their necessities. He cited that an American household’s annual income is $50,000, and the annual expenses would be $30,000. Therefore, the average $20,000 left must be donated to charity. Singer’s persuasion in donating had lost its point when he asked for every individual to donate all their extra wealth. In a personal level, when Singer’s argument headed on this direction, it became less persuasive because first, it became unfair. For one, donating the money of what is left after spending for necessities is unfair for the person who had worked hard to earn that money. It is by far saying that a person must work hard in order to save the lives of other people and not think of themselves. Yes, the notion is realistic especially in seeing the statistics of death due to poverty. However, it is also necessary to note that an earning person must reward herself or himself every once in awhile. This reward can be as luxurious as having a cruise or as easy as getting massage. Aside from this, it is also beneficial for people to save for themselves. These savings will be essential especially in unavoidable and unexpected circumstances. This is not to say that a person must only think of the lives of the people they love, but this is saying that a person must be realistic enough to prepare for certain circumstances. The persuasiveness of Singer’s article was shaken when he injected the argument on giving all that is left to others. The text lost its point and eventually, in a personal level, became illogical to follow. For an average person to donate $200 is acceptable. Donating all the excess money and wealth is already questionable. It is a fact that poverty must be combated with the help of people who are capable of helping. A child living in poverty must be
...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
(“The singer solution to world poverty Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1464615-the-singer-solution-to-world-poverty
(The Singer Solution to World Poverty Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
“The Singer Solution to World Poverty Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1464615-the-singer-solution-to-world-poverty.
Mr. Singer argues that, in no uncertain terms, the world is not doing enough to help those that need it, and in fact those that can help have a moral obligation to do so. Mr. Hardin argues that while help is certainly possible for those that need it, the likelihood of being able to help everyone is a reality that will never be attained due to the limited amount of space and shrinking resources.
Singer is a moral philosopher who has served as the chair at Monash University and Princeton University and has lectured at the Oxford University on ethics and moral philosophy. He has published many texts on moral dilemma and ethics. In his article in the New York Times, he questions the charitable burden and false sense of ethics that normally respectable claim that they have.
The author states that the society around us is divided into a number of sections in regards to religion and culture. There, lives within our society, a variety of religions including Jews, Hindus, Christians, Muslims, etc. All of these religious present a different picture of an ideal person but there is one similarity among all religions.
ends in this article that the affluent people should spend their money only on what is necessary, and give their surplus resources to the poor people dying of hunger (Singer, 558). A critical analysis of this argument shows that Peter Singer is wrong on this issue. The solution
The results of this have been an increase in poverty levels across the globe, leading to suffering among the poor. Secondly, I also view the article pointing towards the lack of success of the Americas
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
GOT A TRICKY QUESTION? RECEIVE AN ANSWER FROM STUDENTS LIKE YOU!
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"The singer solution to world poverty"
with a personal 20% discount.