Nobody downloaded yet

Madness: A result of individual rights being nullified by societal rights - Research Paper Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
Social Insanity and the General Will Subverted in “The Yellow Wallpaper” and “Seasons of Madness” Insanity is usually understood to be a purely mental phenomenon, in which something is severely wrong with the sufferer…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
Madness: A result of individual rights being nullified by societal rights
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Madness: A result of individual rights being nullified by societal rights"

Download file to see previous pages This definition has to do less with the individual alone than with the individual in relation to the rest of society, and hinges around something similar to what Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Jacob Talmon discuss in their explorations of democracy. Both men are interested in what Rousseau calls the “Social Contract,” which is essentially the individual’s privileging of society’s rights over his or her own. Although this theory do not deal explicitly with insanity, its system of social understanding serves as a good model to explain the way society constructs its ideas of madness. These social constructions, and the submission to the will of the general population, can rob a rational, normal individual of their rights and life. Rousseau’s theorizing—and Talmon’s critical response to it—are less clear than they may be, especially when applying them to something other than politics. However, two short stories which show just the sorts of thing they are talking about are Gilman's “The Yellow Wallpaper” and al Shaykh's “Seasons of Madness,” which both show social constructions of insanity. In Gilman's story, set in 19th century America, the madness of her character is set upon her by society, but becomes debilitating and very real after she has been supposedly cured of her ailment. On the other hand, al Shaykh's story, which is set in a 20th century Middle Eastern society, portrays a madness chosen for more selfish social reasons, and which the character is able to set aside when she wants to. Regardless, both stories do show some of the dangers involved in treating madness as a purely mental phenomenon, and argue somewhat for an understanding of insanity as a social construction in some cases. Taken together, and when viewed through the political and philosophical ideas of Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Jacob Talmon, the stories make a convincing argument that insanity is socially constructed, and that this can be dangerous. In most cases, when someone is labeled insane by society it is because there is something severely wrong with how their brain works, or at least how it relates to reality. However, insanity could also be understood as an individual's refusal to fit himself or herself into the consensus of what reality should be. In “The Yellow Wallpaper,” this happens when the narrator constantly refuses to stop writing and using her imagination. In “Seasons of Madness,” it is apparent in Fatin’s pretended insanity, which she uses to distance herself from what her husband and family expects of her. In these cases, the individual's insanity is not so much a serious mental illness as a rejection of what society deems right and proper. This would suggest that the reason society as a whole puts those suffering from insanity into asylums may be to protect them, as well as society, from their own selfish rejections of the consensus view. On the other hand, as both short stories show, this idea is ripe for abuse: if insanity is not necessarily a mental problem, serious harm could be done to sufferers by treating them as if it is. The unnamed narrator in “The Yellow Wallpaper” ends up insane in truth where before she was just different to other people. Fatin at the end of her story is caught up in others’ perceptions of her as insane even though she has just admitted to being perfectly rational. Rousseau is the older theorist, and his “Social Contract,” written in the late 1700s, is considered by many a classic of political theory. In it, Rousseau famously described man as being “born free, and everywhere … in chains” (14). He argues that the way to help man be free in life is through the use of the “Social Contract,” ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Madness: A result of individual rights being nullified by societal Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1430424-madness-a-result-of-individual-rights-being
(Madness: A Result of Individual Rights Being Nullified by Societal Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/english/1430424-madness-a-result-of-individual-rights-being.
“Madness: A Result of Individual Rights Being Nullified by Societal Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1430424-madness-a-result-of-individual-rights-being.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
da
dameonfritsch added comment 7 months ago
Student rated this paper as
Excellent paper! Used it to finish an assignment for a english course. It was easy as ABC, for the first time in my life.
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Individual Rights and Climate Change
...in the event of disagreement. Some argue that this is the case. Caney (2005) and other researchers like Barry, Beitz, and Pogge made a claim that people have ethical concerns or a moral standing which is worthy of admiration. A few would outline the notion of rights and give emphasis to human rights, “say, not to be killed or imprisoned without trial” (Freeman, 2011, p. 192). As a result, individualsrights should be appreciated as it is quoted from the ‘Universal Declaration of Human Rights’. Others avoid the notion of rights and might accentuate individuals’ moral requirements. In accordance with...
25 Pages(6250 words)Essay
Marx's objectives to individual rights
.... However, it also resulted in all of the better houses in the nicer areas being sold off. As a consequence the houses that were left within the hands of the council were in the worst conditions or areas: the houses that nobody else wanted. Because of this the poorest people in society, the ones who could not even afford to buy, or were unable to buy, the council housing were forced to live in the houses that nobody else who had a choice would live in.12 This is another example of how private property rights benefit the rich but deny freedom to others. So it is seen how the arguments of Marx and Engels in favor of the abolition of private property rights are presented:...
17 Pages(4250 words)Research Paper
List of Individual Rights
...translated this principle to mean that sovereigns should not breach individual’s rights to their property. According to them, people are born when they already have the natural rights with the responsibility of the government being to defend the liberty. The philosophers also thought that giving individuals the rights to their property also made them break the rules (Whitehead, 2008). The philosophers also discovered that men’s weaknesses like hunger for power and opportunism create problems to the government. Due to this, individuals wanted to create ways in which a strong executive would be created without a king while...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper
Statement of Individual Rights
...? ment of Individual rights Task ment of Individual rights Part Introduction The island of tag is experiencing a growth in its population based on the influx of foreigners from other regions. As a result, the island is becoming diverse in terms of its ethnic composition. Oil exploration is luring a number of foreigners into the island; thus, affecting the homogeny of the island. The people entering into the island are after exploiting the discovered oil resources. Consequently, diversity is taking a toll in the island of Tagg by infusing cultures from diverse backgrounds. According to Hatts (2005), the infusion is causing anxiety to the council of elders...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
Individual Rights
...Legally Observing Individual Rights As citizens in the United s, that are certain freedoms for which each individual are guaranteed under the stated laws of the land. One of those freedoms so entitled to is that of being told, when approached by those in law enforcement with the intent of placing into custody, the rights we have to such things as to remain silent or also our right to legal representation. Just one of the definitions of rights according to law.com is as follows, "plural of right, which is the collection of entitlements which a person may have and which are protected by the government and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Individual Rights and the Law
...The Human Rights Actincorporates into English law the Articles of the European Convention of Human Rights. The Government decided to guarantee basic human rights under a broad range of circumstances, which encompasses the management of psychiatric patients, who can now challenge many aspects of their treatment. However, European cases suggest that current clinical practice is largely compatible with the act and that future legislation, policy and procedure would be shaped by patients challenging existing practice using the provisions of this act. The result will be a new mental health act and legislation for the detention of dangerous people, which will maintain a balance between the rights of individual patients and the rights... of the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study
Marx's objectives to individual rights
..., it also resulted in all of the better houses in the nicer areas being sold off. As a consequence the houses that were left within the hands of the council were in the worst conditions or areas: the houses that nobody else wanted. Because of this the poorest people in society, the ones who could not even afford to buy, or were unable to buy, the council housing were forced to live in the houses that nobody else who had a choice would live in.12 This is another example of how private property rights benefit the rich but deny freedom to others. So it is seen how the arguments of Marx and Engels in favor of the abolition of private property rights are presented: "In a...
17 Pages(4250 words)Research Paper
Individual Rights and Social Order
...Individual rights and social order Introduction The criminal justice system of the US continually faces balancing individual rights and the need for social order. While the criminal system of justice must uphold the rights that citizens are granted, it should also protect its people. Two opposing sides, crusaders of individual rights and those advocating social order represent this act of balancing. An observation was made by the Presidents Crime Commission some forty years ago, which a justice system is a mechanism used to impose standards of conduct. This mechanism in whatever society or the environment, it may arise deemed essential to shield individuals. Additionally, it was necessary to safeguard the overall well-being... . Social...
11 Pages(2750 words)Assignment
Sex Predator - Societal Protection vs. Constitutional Rights
...Sex Predator: Societal Protection vs. Constitutional Rights Affiliation Governments are man d to protect people from any acts of violence through measures, which prevent crime. However, the government must consider the right of individuals and avoid any law that can infringe on the human rights. Conviction of individuals for a crime does not deter them from claiming a just treatment in the hands of the government. Sex predator laws are in conflict with the rights and freedoms of individuals, the civil society, and the human right groups are always in controversy with the government. The constitution, which should protect peoples rights contain laws, which interfere with the offenders freedom and rights. Offenders are human beings... , and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
National Security vs. Individual Rights
...National Security vs. Individual Rights al Affiliation Introduction In seeking a scrutiny at individual rights and how they merge with the National Security presents a paradox which claims that avenues are often crafted that propagate terror which broods in the liberty bestowed by democracies. According to Kettl, (2013), American citizens treasure freedom of movement. The key dilemma resonates on the extent the government should intrude, interfere or compromise with its citizens lives in its pursuit to offer national security to the same citizens. The fundamental core objective of this paper is to screen and probe at the tenets of the legal response of the terrorism...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Madness: A result of individual rights being nullified by societal rights for FREE!
Contact Us