Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This paper "Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria?" investigates the case between the teachers’ union, Newbury Education Association and employer, Newbury Ohio Local School District Board of Education that primarily deals with the teachers with the extra duty of supervising cafeteria during the lunchtime. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria"

Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria?
The case is between the teachers’ union, Newbury Education Association and employer, Newbury Ohio Local School District Board of Education that primarily deals with the teachers with the extra duty of supervising cafeteria during the lunch time. During 2001-2002 the principals of the school observed increased behavioral problems amongst the students in the cafeteria and the playground. Thereafter, 20 minutes lunch period was introduced, every three days, for teachers to supervise the cafeteria, resulting in two teachers being present in cafeteria during the lunch breaks. The teachers filed the grievances for these new assignments.
According to the employers, there was standard management rights’ clause in the parties’ collective bargaining agreement which they had invoked in the present case to contain rowdy behavior of the students, during the lunch break. The union, on the other hand, asserted that cafeteria supervision was mentioned in the agreement for the secondary teachers only and due to lack of any past practice, assigning these duties to the elementary teachers was against the contract.
Case Answer 1
Yes, Union’s claim is right. There is a contractual basis, expressed in language because the contract mentions the supervision duties for the secondary teachers and not the elementary school teachers.
Case Answer 2
No, there is no past evidence of elementary school teachers burdened with the added responsibilities of supervising cafeteria during the lunch break. There was also no inclusion of such in their job description as against the fact that cafeteria supervision was included in the agreement for secondary teachers. The union also claimed that the lunch time was used by the teachers for various other educational activities like meeting parents, remediation, preparing and planning students’ performance enhancing activities etc. that were designed for the overall development of the students. Cafeteria supervision would restrict these extra activities that are essential part of teaching aids and measures. Hence, extra duties are legally and ethically wrong.
Case Answer 3
As an arbitrator, I would ensure that the elementary teachers were not burdened with the extra duty of cafeteria supervision because children in the elementary school require more educational aids and teachers-parental interaction for improved results. The roles and responsibilities of a teacher are multidimensional. The teachers often serve as role models for their students so they need to be very meticulous and at the same time, he/she should be extremely knowledgeable so as to command respect from their students.
In the contemporary times, lunch breaks are critical time for teachers as they use the time for improving and improvising the teaching methodologies. The time is also used for interacting with the parents to evolve easy for improving students’ performance.
What do you think the outcome should be?
The elementary school teachers should not be assigned the duty of cafeteria supervision. Though the management may have discretionary rights but the fact that there has been no evidence of past practice of binding elementary school teachers for cafeteria supervision and the contractual agreement is silent on the issue for elementary school teachers gives legitimacy to the grievances of the elementary school teachers.
Case Study: Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria? Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria Essay - 7”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria Essay - 7)
“Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria Essay - 7”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria

Teachers Collaborating to Help Students with Epilepsy

... epilepsy syndromes, such as infantile spasms, Lennox-Gastuat syndrome and Rasmussen’s encephalitic begin in childhood. Children spend most of their times at school and under the supervision of teachers. That is why the importance of teachers cannot be stressed upon enough when understanding the solution to epilepsy. Teachers and students can collaborate to work establish environments that inhibit neurotransmitter movements that are known to lead to seizures. One way of doing this is to change the physical environment into a relaxing and comfortable one, whereby the brain functions normally and patients are not exposed to increased pressure or physical stress. Psychological mentoring is also extremely important in helping patients deal...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Business Proposal - Gym Cafeteria

...?Business Proposal - Gym Cafeteria Business idea My business idea is a GYM with cafeteria facility in London to provide GYM members with suitable food pattern. The suggested business idea is unique in this area because many of the GYM centres do not have cafeteria facilities or they do not pay attention to their members’ diet. Even though such GYMs provide their clients with modern exercise equipments, they are unable to promote sustainable health. As a result, their clients are forced to depend on external sources to maintain diet. In most cases, people do not give much attention to their dietary habits even though they are willing to spend long hours in GYM centres. GYM instructors opine that regular exercises alone will not make...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Students-Teachers Friendship on Facebook

... Introduction Technology is a basis of good social networking. It is one of the mainly used social networks. Face bookhas improved means of communication as well. Face book as a social site aids in finding long time lost friends for instance old school mates, long lost cousins, friends or neighbors across the streets. It is worth noting that nowadays teens are making friends with everyone whom they find in face book or whoever requests them to be friends without being cautious of the possible harmful implications of such friendship. Teachers are adults charged with the responsibility of guiding young minds towards success in life. They act as role models to their students and whenever they decide to send them a friend request they are most...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Healthy College Cafeteria

... 16 November 2008 Proposal for a Healthy College Cafeteria We are what we eat! Or so the saying goes, so why is it that in colleges across the country the food that is served is often mass produced, low quality and of poor nutritional value There is a real and urgent need for people, and in particular students to wake up to their diets. A recent study by the University of West Hampshire showed that eight hundred undergraduates between the ages of 18-24 were on course for development of chronic health diseases, including being overweight, obese, having high blood pressure and mineral deficiencies as a consequence of their diets1. Eating healthy is made more difficult by the lack of available healthier foods in college canteens yet due...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

A Teachers Role in the Lives of Students

...A Teachers Role in the Lives of Students Aside from the parents, teachers play a major role in the shaping of the behavior, learning process and the total personality of a child. The impact of the teacher on the lives of students is immeasurable. Foremost among the roles of a teacher is that of being a model, provider of experiences and interactor. Since teachers are looked upon by students as role models, they must exemplify the highest standards of positive attitudes and behaviors. Aside from being well-educated, teachers must possess characteristics that are worthy of emulation by the students. These qualities include being honest, patient, humble, understanding, affectionate and exhibiting an unquenchable thirst for knowledge...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


...Teacher-Learner Interaction The shift of the role of the teacher from being the “sage on the stage” to being the “guide on the side” means that both the teacher and the learner have realized that engagement in the process of learning make learners process information as well as reconstruct it in their own meaningful ways, and as a result increase the chances of remembering and applying the information in new situations. In connection with this, one can claim that learners use their existing knowledge and prior experience in discussing ideas while deriving meaning from learning materials whereas the teacher on the other hand, “facilitates learning in less directive ways” (King, 1993, p.30). The main principles underlying cognitive theory...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Online learning for students and/or teachers

Ethical Issues in Online Learning Affiliation Ethical Issues in Online Learning Technology has a vital role in the education system by providing modern communication to the teachers and students in their classrooms. The most necessary thing is to prepare the future teachers in the application of technology as one of the teaching methods. The National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) report showed that by the end of year 2000, 98% of students in public schools were applying the use of the internet in learning. Many ethical issues arise from the incorporation of the online learning to both the teachers and the learners. There are teachers without some experience in the social, legal, and ethical issues concerning the digital t...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Notice of cafeteria construction

...Notice of cafeteria construction RE: Notice of cafeteria construction Dear ColdStone Employees, Following your efforts and hard work towards the development of the organization, we have decided to renovate our current gourmet cafeteria. Therefore, the cafeteria will be closed from next Wednesday, May 15, 6am to Friday, May 17, 9pm. Among the employee benefit programs, the cafeteria where employees can get acquainted with other colleagues was found to be the most important contributor to the productivity improvement. Therefore, the purpose of the expansion is to make the cafeteria more comfortable place so that employees can get along with each other more actively during the meal breaks. After the renovation, the changes will be made...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

Project Management Plan: Cheap Calls for International Students and Tourist

...Executive Summary The purpose of this project addresses the immediate need and tourists in Brisbane to be provided with an alternatives means of communication. Basically, the initial concept, developed by Queensland University of Technology (QUT) offers cheap international calls for tourists and foreign students. Despite the competition in information and communication technology (ICT) overseas telephone calls remain expensive. Service providers are citing the increased cost in overhead as the primary reason for the costs of international costs to remain high. Initially, QUT will start the project and will subsequently be turned over to a private firm after income targets have been satisfied. The project will require 100,000 AUD...
11 Pages(2750 words)Term Paper

Education Law Involving Parents In English Language Learning Of Immigrant Students in America

Ethnic and racial minority children are the most at-risk group in social institutions, with the most significant academic underachievement, high poverty rates, high teen pregnancy rates, low skill levels, and low-paying employment opportunities. The projection is that by 2015 over 50 percent of all students in K-12 public schools across the US will be ELL students, boosting the number of this school population that has the highest dropout rate and the lowest ranking in academic achievement and expectations. The phenomenon necessarily speaks ill of the American public school system.
The No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 was enacted precisely to address the problems being encountered by ELL students across the US so that the ed...
8 Pages(2000 words)Literature review

Impact of Feedback on Students Behaviour

One group of students verbalized aloud while solving problems during all sessions, the second group verbalized aloud during the first half of the training program (first three sessions) but not during the second half, and the third group did not verbalize. It was expected that overt verbalization during the first half of training would help students learn how to work subtraction problems in a strategic (algorithmic) fashion. To the extent that students could then shift this means of regulating their task performance to a covert level, we felt that continued verbalization would offer no benefits. Researchers have shown that once strategic task behaviors are instilled, overt verbalization may be discontinued with no performance decr...
23 Pages(5750 words)Case Study

Outlining Explicit Learning Objectives and Outcomes for Teachers and Students

Explicit learning is presented by teaching the specific concepts individually and mastery occurs then after. The main key in such a mode of teaching is being highly structured in every activity that is undertaken inside the classroom can be considered as part of the organization of the technique. One of the defining features of the technique is the fact that the teacher commonly points out the part of the lesson where they are in, thus, the term used is explicit teaching (Boyles, 2002).
The explicit form of teaching can be considered to fit lessons that are considered to introduce certain concepts, ideas or skills that are needed to be learned and that the students have low familiarity or experience with. For that matter, the...
10 Pages(2500 words)Report

Activism: Teachers, Therapists and Self-Esteem

Many activists present their ideas, attitudes or thoughts in the form of art, in some creative endeavor. Art shows the "story" in a visual way that the individual is attempting to speak out about, in such a way as to get others involved with helping the cause.

When many people think of activists, they may not think about therapists or teachers as being in this mix of ideas. Often, they are the ones who are quiet when it comes to activism because they can feel they are removed from what is happening in society on an everyday basis. However, they are in the middle of controversy all of the time whether they understand this or not.

As I was thinking about a project to do, I thought it would be interesting to get...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Supporting Exceptional Students in an Inclusive Class

Being a teacher is truly a challenge.  To help a young learner reach his potentials and make something out of it is the fulfillment one derives from such hard work.  Such a challenge and feeling of fulfillment are felt more when a teacher is tasked with helping students in an inclusive classroom.

It also touches on specific legislation that supports children with special needs as well as support from the family, the school, and special devices that can help exceptional children cope better in an inclusive environment.

It would be fitting to begin the discussion with a definition of terms that may be confusing to a reader who is not familiar with special education concepts since some terms may be eas...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

The Attitude of York University Students With Regard To Medical Transplant and Organ Donation

Chapter one of the study included the background of the study, statement of the problem, the purpose of the study, study objectives, research questions, significance of the study, limitations of the study, scope of the study, assumption of study and definition of terms. Chapter two of the study offers an outline of medical transplants and organ donations. These ideas are going to introduce key concepts and understandings that link to the purpose and field of research. Chapter three describes the research design that provides information regarding the population of the study, sample size and sampling procedure, instrumentation, data collection, and data analysis techniques. Chapter four deals with data presentation and analysis; af...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

Observation of Teaching Methods and Students Interaction

...Observation Log Location: reading room (level 2) October 3, Time: 10.00 AM Purpose: To observe teacher’s teaching method, teacher and students’ interactions, and the important things. Setting Comments The teacher arrived in the class 15 minutes before the class start time. He sat at his chair talking to the ten students present in the class. There were supposed to be 18 students, the rest were just wandering out as there was still time in the commencement of class. The teacher gave a bundle of papers to the girl sitting in the front row and gestured with hands to distribute them in the class. Out of the 18 students, 13 were male students and 5 female students. There were 10 Spanish students, three were French and five were Chinese...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

How Teachers Can Identify Talented Students

...How Teachers can Identify Talented Students Introduction a. Hook: All children have a right to learn in an environment that enables them to reflect their enthusiasm, distinctive characteristics and fascinations. b. Background: Children all require adequate opportunities to grow, learn, and be inspired to endeavor for brilliance. This is especially the case for students that wield exceptional learning potential and talent, since they require specific attention. c. Thesis statement: This paper seeks to explore ways through which teachers can identify talented students. Careful observation of children’s behavior and habits, coupled with listening to them will provide insights into their interests and learning potential, hence identification...
5 Pages(1250 words)Term Paper

Roles of Teachers in Relation to Working with Young People

Further, like any other education professional, a PE specialist is required to ensure that the curriculum and laws governing the exercise are adhered to in administering physical education. The main trainer is either a coach or a teacher. Despite both the teacher and coach having the same structure in terms of occupation, the two practitioners differ not only on the professional training but also in the manner, in which they deliver their services to children.

The two terms-coach and teacher can be used interchangeably because both involve imparting knowledge to trainees. However, the two differ in the same measure; a teacher imparts his or her skills to trainees whereas a coach may not necessarily transfer his/her ski...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Should Students Have to Wear Uniforms

The negative conducts that are related to students' dress that include absenteeism, teasing, school violence, and activities that are gang-related (The Ethical School, pg 23). On the other side, the opponent’s main argument is that uniforms deny students their individual rights including the right to choose their dressing. While many public schools today maintain strong policies on dress code, the weight of this subject matter begs the question as to whether students should be required to wear uniforms. In the United States, public schools have increasingly embraced the idea of school uniforms even as parents and other stakeholders in education device new ways to make school a safe place. Based on reports gathered from admin...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Are Teachers Obliged to Supervise Students in the Cafeteria for FREE!

Contact Us