StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative evaluation in the instructional design process - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Instructional Design Process Name: Institution: Instructional Design Process Question One The benefit of formative evaluation in the instructional design is that experts in subject matter are a key element to the process (Paas, Renkl & Sweller, 2004). They identify inconsistencies in tasks and performances while providing guidelines on the detection, assessment and looping back of supportive feedback…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative evaluation in the instructional design process
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative evaluation in the instructional design process"

Download file to see previous pages Here, the clarity, impact and feasibility of the message and the instruction are determined. In the small group evaluation, the entire group is handed similar feedback based on grouped outcome of the successes or difficulties. This effectively addresses the instruction rather than the learners. In the field trial evaluation, the instructor uses the design and course materials already modified twice to present a full-scale instructional session. Challenges with formative evaluation are often found in feasibility matters. Students’ capabilities, instructional environment and medium greatly impact the outcome of the stage. The motivation, independence and maturity of individual students will determine the required time to complete the stage (Smaldino, Rusell & Heinrich, 2005). Summative evaluation is beneficial because it is possible to develop consistent, standardized sets of information on each learner. It also creates a justification for wide-scale decision making in education programs. Summative evaluation uses two phases to assess the worth or merit of a program. The inclusion of external evaluators is beneficial because it adds value to the evaluation and design of the learning process and materials. In the expert judgment phase, feasibility, content, design and congruence analysis are examined. In the field trial phase, outcome and management analysis are examined. It further looks at the impact on the students, job and organization. Essentially, the performance of the group in relation to the set objective is analyzed by the instructional designer in various ways (Gagne, Wager & Keller, 2005). Organizational resources and needs are aligned with the program through congruence analysis; goals are identified through content analysis; sufficiency of modules of instructional strategies is evaluated through design analysis; and feasibility analysis is in relation to the materials’ utility. Summative evaluation is challenged when it comes to balancing process and product measures and preventing backwards implication; anticipating the scope of positive and negative consequences of using results of summative assessment; attending to both non-cognitive and affective features of flourishing academic programs; and the information’s timeliness (Gagne, Wager & Keller, 2005). In confirmative evaluation, there is a follow up of the students after they are out of the program. It is beneficial because instructors get to know their competitive levels and how well they are making use of the knowledge and information they gain from their programs. This is a marriage of the other evaluations and programs in continuous improvement. Unlike the other kinds used at the designing and learning levels, confirmative evaluation comes months after implementation of the program (Morrison, Ross & Kemp, 2004). Endurance of outcomes, efficiency and return on investments are tested. However, the challenge is that the evaluators and students are forced to commit themselves to the full scope of evaluation. Identifying and including all the stakeholders, especially decision makers and activity planners, is also a problem. Question Two Formative assessment is an ongoing measurement in educational preparation aiming at the improvement of student learning. It provides information crucial in the monitoring of an individual’ ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative Research Paper”, n.d.)
Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1484652-compares-and-contrasts-formative-summative-and
(Compares and Contrasts Formative, Summative, and Confirmative Research Paper)
Compares and Contrasts Formative, Summative, and Confirmative Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/education/1484652-compares-and-contrasts-formative-summative-and.
“Compares and Contrasts Formative, Summative, and Confirmative Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1484652-compares-and-contrasts-formative-summative-and.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative evaluation in the instructional design process

Evaluating Instructional Design

...?Running Head: INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN Evaluating instructional design Evaluating instructional design Introduction Instructional design comes from the idea that instruction can be programmed with the effect of creating a more efficient system in which the student is attracted to the act of learning. The basis for instructional design is in behavioral psychology, where learning is defined through paradigms in which expected behaviors are part of how the design of the instruction is put into place. In the video “Merrill on Instructional Design”, the topic of instructional design is discussed. The three basic outlines for how to approach instruction are defined and given meaning in relationship with instruction. Fifteen principles are involved...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Instructional Design Outline

The main purpose of education is to nurture critical thought, capacity for independence and creativity in general. Educational institutions need to ensure that young individuals leave formal education armed with the skills, aptitude, and confidence needed to face life outside school (Brown & Green 2011). It has in the past been believed that educational success of a child is dependent upon their background. This is however not the case. Educational success is determined by the willingness of the student to learn, their hard work as well as the effectiveness of the educator in teaching. Educators in the 21st Century have come to understand the importance individual education since the young generation of today is the future of tom...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Formative, Summative and Confirmative Evaluation

While summative evaluation focuses on the outcome or the effectiveness of the program. It is used to measure effectiveness of a performance intervention or evaluates if the interventions during the process have resulted into an effective outcome (Van Tiem et al., 2000, p. 157). Summative evaluation as the name suggests summarizes the result after the whole process was made by assessing whether the object can be said to have caused the outcome; determining the overall impact of the causal factor beyond only the immediate target outcomes; and, estimating the relative costs associated with the object (Trochim, 2006).
On the contrary, confirmative evaluation, unlike the first two focuses on determining the adequacy of competenc...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Description of the Instructional Design Process

...? Final Paper: of the Instructional Design Process Ahmed Alzahrani Naif Alsayyali ACE 625 - Facilitating Adult Learning Indiana of Pennsylvania Table of Contents Final Paper: Description of the Instructional Design Process 3 The Instructional Project 3 The Instructional Design Model 3 Assessing and Developing the Adult Educators’ Skills 4 Developing Content Knowledge 4 Learner Needs and Characteristics 5 Learner Needs Assessment Strategies 6 Understanding the Learning Contexts 7 Developing Goals and Objectives 8 Developing Learning Activities 8 Evaluating Learners 9 Evaluating the Instructional Plan 10 Conclusion 10 References 11 Final Paper: Description of the Instructional Design Process The Instructional Project To comply...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Summative and Formative Program Evaluation

.... It’s also known as the internal evaluation and focuses more on the actual procedures or process of a program. The audience is decided according to the types of formative evaluation in use. They are: on process evaluation, (this needs assessment structured concepts and implementation evaluation). Objectives of formative evaluation: - This kind of evaluation permits the designers, instructors and learners to keep an eye on how its meeting its instructional goals and objectives. It also allows the learners to learn and understand the required knowledge and skills. It’s best when used in evaluating students learning, student’s achievements, and teachers involved in teaching (Evaluation Toolkit, 2013) Summative evaluation This is also known...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Design Thinking summative assignment

... as to inspire, develop business relationships and linkages thereby getting things done (Cross, 2010). Flexibility in design thinking is necessary to ensure open mindedness and the capacity to integrate ideas from external sources in to the business process for greater productivity and there after influence the company’s composite system to launch the new innovation (Badke-Schaub et al. 2010). Effective identification of innovation opportunities is important for successful design thinking. Colas were the leading soft drinks controlling a market share of 60% of the soft beverage market in the US (Lester & Tice, 2012). However, diet drinks also indicated a higher upward trend compared to other beverages. These trends positioned Diet Coke...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Instructional Design and Program Evaluation

...Instructional Design and Program Evaluation 1 Introduction Online/distance learning programs are rapidly gaining international popularity because they provide adult learners with the opportunity to further their education, whether for career or personal purposes, irrespective of time and space. Within the context of an increasingly and intensively competitive labor market, continued education is an essential strategy for the acquisition of a competitive edge but the primary obstacle to the acquisition of this particular competitive advantage is time constraints and geographic distance. Online education has emerged as the solution to the stated and, as such, is gaining ever-increasing popularity. Paradoxically, however, even as more...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Models of Instructional Design

... learners elaborate and extend their individual knowledge bases and cognitive processes (Scandura & Scandura 1980). In contrast to two previous theories, cognitive learning theory explains mental processes and takes into account thinking and perception processes. In contrast to this theory the goals of the behavioral analysis were on identifying small, incremental tasks or subskills that the learner needed to acquire for successful completion of the instruction, designing specific objectives that would lead to the acquisition of those subskills, and sequencing subskill acquisition in the order that would most efficiently lead to successful learner outcomes (Scandura & Scandura 1980). Also important to researchers' investigations...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Instructional planning and design

... Curriculum Mathematics. Retrieved May 15, 2008, from http://www.dodea.edu/curriculum/math.cfm Interactive Chalkboard (CD-ROM). (2004). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Companies. Lowry, D.W., Ockenya, E.G., & Rucker, W.E. (1990). Pre-Algebra. Lexington, MA: D.C. Heath and Company. Instructional Materials Evaluation Checklist Resource: Bailey, R., Day, R., Frey, P., Howard, A. C., Hutchens, D. T., McClain, K., Moore-Harris, B., Ott, J. M., Pelfrey, R., Price, J., Vielhaber, K., & Williard, T. (2004). Glencoe Mathematics. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Companies Inc. Reviewer: Date: May 2008 Area Criteria N/A, +. , or - Comment(s) Design The content is accurate. a The content is logical and well organized. - Even though it is a logical...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Formative and Summative Evaluation in Educatin

In implementation evaluation, the question that will and should be answered includes: who the participants are, to what extent the participant be involved, activities to be taken before and after the evaluation (Lenze, 1995).
On the other hand, progress evaluation focuses on answering questions such as: how will the participant progress in the direction of specifically outlined goals, and what strategies can be of assistance to the participant in order to reach predetermined goals (Lenze, 1995).
The other type of evaluation which is summative is intended to assess the program at its finale. It will attempt to determine whether the project is successful if the goals were met, if the participants were satisfied ad benefi...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Effective and Ineffective Evaluation Tool

It has been an endless matter of debate for decades as to which methods reap effective results and which not.
One of the most effective tools for assessing students’ annual performance has to the one with a more comprehensive approach. The feedback by the teachers is very crucial for the students. It is the assessment plan which is developed by the teachers upon the on-going students’ achievements throughout the course and not merely upon the written traditional examinations1. It is considered to be an effective assessment tool because it reflects directly on the teaching and learning process of the teachers and students respectively. Feedbacks also help the students to engage in reflective, constructive and analy...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Future Digital Design Process

As we shape up the interface between the designer and the virtual environment we are naturally going to produce a greater and far better outcome.
It will enable the end-user to be more creative and experimental and explore possibilities that were previously tedious or impossible. The design possibilities of virtuality will enhance the outlook of environments.
Now we can also term it according to the duration it can last. For any new thing, the duration is 10-30 years. If it lasts for 10 it would be popular as a tool another 10 and it would very well be a theory and if it survives all 30 years it will soon be defined as a revolution.
It was the end of the 20th century and the beginning of the 21st century that saw th...
21 Pages(5250 words)Assignment

A Six Stage Model of the Innovation Process

This paper will focus on the relationship and impact and innovation will have on politics. The backbone of the paper will be the strong opinion of Professor Langdon Winner who teaches at the Department of Science and Technology Studies. He has said that “technical things have political qualities” and this paper will base its study on this. “Langdon Winner is a political theorist who focuses on social and political issues that surround modern technological change.” (Brief Biography). When undertaking a serious study of the topic, so many theories and assumptions also begin to emerge that are related to the topic. They include concepts like SCOT, Actor-Network Theory, determinism, closure, and other related f...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

Marks and Spencer Organizational Development Process

Procurement of resources is made globally from over 2000 suppliers. More than 75000 employees are on the rolls of the company. In the retail clothing sector of the UK market, the company has a growing market share. Online business strategy is also adopted by them. (About us, 2009).

Through customer-focused production and marketing techniques, the company is aiming to attain a world-class position in the retail market field. Along with offering of highest quality products, customer servicing is also ensured by them for attaining loyal customer base. “Our brand values – quality, value, service, innovation and trust – are more important than ever. Our commitment to these values sets us apart from our comp...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

A Hydrograph of River Cynon and Design of an Open Channel

The maximum elevation of the catchment area is 515.6 m., while the minimum elevation is 80.8 m (CEH Wallingford. 2005).

Based on the rainfall and river data for River Cynon given in the assignment brief, a hydrograph was developed using Microsoft Excel (2003). This hydrograph depicts the hourly observations of rainfall and river stage height for a four-day period from October 12 to October 15, 1998. Rainfall height is shown as a vertical bar graph plotted on an hourly time series in millimetre. River discharge is superimposed on the same time series as a line graph in terms of 1 x 10-1 (Bv), where B is the base of the river cross-section in meter and v is the given velocity of flow at 4 m/s.

As reflected in F...
9 Pages(2250 words)Report

Learning and Memory Process

...Profile Report This report compares and contrasts the answers provided by the interviewees X and Jason. Learning and memory process Interviewee X prefers to learn by observation and has the ability to give directions to a place that X has earlier visited. Jason also prefers to learn by observation. Interviewee X prefers to work in silence to avoid distraction whereas Jason prefers distractions as they force him to concentrate. Quietude makes his mind wander. Interviewee X’s preference to work in silence points to the use of committing work to the long term memory. Jason displays a preference to utilize short term memory for his work since it has the capacity to focus on the work at hand despite distractions around. The use of short term...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

An Evaluation of the Role That the Principles of Behaviour Therapy Have to Play in Clinical Hypnosis

Hamburg (2006) first used this combined effort to treat two patients who were scared of dying. He uses his paper to encourage clinicians to refrain from not using their knowledge at the introductory classes of hypnosis but to go into it deeper. Many therapists at that time were taking the bold step of combining behavior therapy with hypnosis (Chaves, 2006). One group used hypnosis for desensitization therapy (Kirsch et al, 1995). However, there was general disagreement about the manner of hypnosis being employed and the methods of mentalist constructs. Chaves who strongly believed in the treatment combination used it as a base for many of his therapeutic interventions (Chaves, 1997a as cited in Chaves, 2006). The hypnotic therapy...
8 Pages(2000 words)Article

Syllabus Design for Learners of English as a Second Language

The translation and transmutation of syllabuses into the teaching procedures are generally recognized by the established conceptions of the second language learning methodologies, predominant amongst them are the Grammar Translation Method and Audiolingual Method. These notions in addition to the emergent concepts aiding to the structuring of the syllabus and curriculum for English as the Second Language are critically discussed in detail in this literary essay.

English being globally considered and established as the ‘lingua franca’ whether in terms of international communications or technological interrelations, hence English as the second language is extensively popularized and most sought after language...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Evaluation of Children with Visual Impairment between Ages 4-12

A visually impaired child may suffer from incomplete sight, reduced vision, total blindness as well as legal sightlessness (Kelley and Gale p 45). It is a condition that may become severe in a child, thereby affecting its growth and development. The impact is usually dependent on the kind of loss, age at which it occurs, as well as the general body functioning of the child. The normal interest that is usually evident amongst children on seeing attractive items in their surroundings lacks in a visually impaired child. This may interfere with the child’s learning capabilities unless he/she is assisted to learn. The development of social behavior in children usually depends on the ability to see parents or those in charge of ca...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

Evaluation of Performance of a Bank Using Published Accounting Data

... be evaluated by a number of ways such as checking the rating agencies and listings, going through customers reviews, independent analysis based on published accounting data, instructional guides and FDIC bank statistics and research.8 The most common method that is used to evaluate the individual performance of the bank is through its financial statements. The published accounting information that is usually given in the form of financial statements include Statement of financial position (Balance sheet), Statement of earnings (Income statement), and Cash flow statement and Statement of activities (Kenneth, 1996). The financial ratios can be determined based on the information collected form these statements. To analyse the profitability...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative evaluation in the instructional design process for FREE!

Contact Us