Nobody downloaded yet

Should corporal punishment be permitted in public schools - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Should corporal punishment be permitted in public schools? Caning in schools has long been agreed by the British parliament to outlaw. In 1998, the parliament banned corporal punishment for all within the academic institution (BBC News, 1998). Aside from his strong stand that corporal punishment is wrong in principle and barbaric, Don Foster, Liberal Democrat education spokesman, said in a report, “There is no evidence whatsoever that the use of corporal punishment is an effective deterrent, either for a child who may have been misbehaving nor indeed is it a deterrent for other children” (BBC News, 1998)…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
Should corporal punishment be permitted in public schools
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Should corporal punishment be permitted in public schools"

Download file to see previous pages In psychology, it is a proven observation that a man’s self-awareness changes over time as they are exposed to the environment, which could facilitate their learning. This is evident in cognitive, behavioral and humanistic perspectives in psychology that try to point out that the environment plays a crucial role in the child’s developmental stage particularly in their learning process (Feldman, 2003). This therefore tries to stand in contradiction against Foster’s claim that a punishment may not be an effective deterrent. In psychology, punishment may facilitate learning (Feldman, 2003). In addition, self-awareness develops over time with age (Feldman, 2003). Considering this point, it is therefore important to include the idea that the level of learning may not be equal to all people especially among children of varying ages. There are those children who could not totally relate with punishment and there are those who could manage to understand it. As a result, some children may be able to learn from their experience with punishment and others may not, which may depend on the prevailing age due to the issue of self-awareness and its development. Considering this point, Foster might have been trying to generalise the issue. In fact, a certain study reveals that in general there is reduction of disruptive behaviors with the employment of disciplinary interventions among alomost 80 percent of the subjects (Marzano, Marzano & Pickering, 2003, p.78). Although this evidence requires further validation, but the point is that there are considerable studies needed in order to justify whatever claims concerning punishment and deterrent. There are other methodological concerns and scientific considerations that need to be taken into account the moment there is a relevant push to knowing whether corporal punishment is effective most importantly in public schools. Furthermore, punishment requires reinforcement for it to be effective. This is a remarkable suggestion based on a study employing combined punishment and reinforcement in correcting misbehaviours (Marzano, Marzano & Pickering, 2003, p.78). This means for instance that after a child receives a punishment, there should be somebody who must be skilled enough to explain clearly to the subject concerning why there is a need to inflict punishment. This should suppose to help the child understand the point why he is punished in the first place. As a result, if children clearly understand the reason behind caning in schools, it would condensed within their innermost understanding that they just have to behave in the class. They would learn to realise that not being able to behave is not normal especially if they are in the classroom or inside the school premises where the ultimate reason why they are there is to learn good things. For them to learn, then they have to conduct themselves well. Employing punishment could help establish this mindset in schools. Now here is the ultimate reason why corporal punishment should be permitted in public schools. Students need discipline. It is not inhumane if they are punished for as long as the ultimate reas ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Should corporal punishment be permitted in public schools Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Should Corporal Punishment Be Permitted in Public Schools Essay)
“Should Corporal Punishment Be Permitted in Public Schools Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
School corporal punishment
...Module: School Corporal Punishment Inflicting physical pain has been in use for centuries as a means ofinstilling discipline among people. Schools have used it to maintain good mannerisms among students and Nepal is a good example of countries where it is widely practiced. This practice is termed as corporal punishment and many Nepal people advocate for it based on Hindu teachings that state that children should get tadana which means reprimanding by beating in order to shape their lives. Year after year students across the world have been subjected to corporal punishment. Many nations...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper
Corporal Punishment on School
..., that is it does not need money to train teachers on how to administer punishment in school and so it is cost effective to use such kind of punishment. On contrary, medical society for the adolescents has put into documentation with the most prominent consequences that result from corporal punishment. On the aftermath is the name of the activator and that it includes hemorrhaging and whiplash. More so, corporal punishment did lead to decline on the family life by the forceful removal of pupils at schools by the parents. The Lowdown Hitherto, in the U.S, corporal...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper
Issues of Corporal Punishment
..., but the practice is still continued in non-western societies, and the politicians of the western society keep on trying to making this punishment method a part of their legal system. Corporal punishment has existed in schooling systems and questions have been raised against and support has been given in the favour of corporal punishment in educational institutes. Activities that are categorized as Corporal punishment includes: whipping, gagging, flogging etc. These activities were practiced in US as well as Europeans nations for several years. Graeme Newman, a supporter of Corporal...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper
Corporal Punishment in School
...? 15 July Corporal punishment in school: This essay is primarily based on discussingthe issue of whether corporal punishment should be legalized, introduced, or justified in all schools around the globe or not. This issue raises a huge concern for the wellbeing of the children or young adults which is why discussing it with the help of research facts and valid reasons remains highly important. Corporal punishment is basically about deliberate infliction of pain on the students by the supervisors or teachers in response to any offensive action taken by them as a way of restraining bad...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
State Laws on Corporal Punishment
...massive support from various organizations that aims at protecting human rights. Although United States of America has made noticeable progress in addressing challenges that are associated with corporal punishment in public schools, human rights activists have observed that, a lot of work need to be done in order to effectively protect children against violation of their basic right. Moreover, present corporal policies prohibit use of corporal punishment by teachers and other school administrators. According to the existing policies, any form of corporal punishment...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper
Corporal Punishment
...of the study, not only should the children’s performance at school or obvious change in habit will be gauged but also their way of thinking and all the internal mechanisms that are going on in their minds. This is to acknowledge the possibility that there are some cases of children who would physically appear reformed and renewed but who would actually channel their aggression and violent behavior towards other things like perhaps the killing of small animals or occasional telling of lies. In short, the approach that is required of any developmental study that is to investigate the usefulness of corporal punishment in children must therefore involve a very holistic and...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper
Corporal Punishment
...Running Head Corporal Punishment Corporal Punishment The moral dimension of corporal punishment requires much more than just recognition of the substantive doctrine of law. Since ancient times, corporal punishment was one of the most popular types of punishment and upbringing. Today, corporal punishment is prohibited in schools and at home, but still many parents use this type of punishment to 'educate' their children. Thesis Corporal punishment causes more harm than good, because it...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Corporal punishment
...pain that may cease to exist in a manner of days, than to feel emotional pain that may last for quite some time. III. Corporal Punishment: A Negative Atmosphere in the Home Despite various efforts of pro groups and individuals, corporal punishment should not be enforced due to the fact that it promotes a negative atmosphere in the home (De Rivera, 2003). Such atmosphere is not good for the overall development of the child, particularly in the aspects of emotional and psychological well-being. Children who endure corporal punishment are often equated as products of child abuse and domestic violence. According to De...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Discipline:State Laws On Corporal Punishment In Public Schools
...Discipline: Laws on Corporal Punishment in Public Schools Discipline: Laws on Corporal Punishment in Public Schools Problem Statement Every U.S state has the authority to place a ban on corporal punishment in both public and private schools. Presently, corporal punishment is banned in public schools in about 31 U.S states inclusive of the District of Columbia. In Iowa and New Jersey corporal punishment is illegal in both...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper
Child discipline and corporal punishment
...of catharsis. Parents and school staff can learn how to use this method by trying to institute and impose it at home or at school. However, since this is only purely a personal idea of mine, then care should be taken to ensure that a psychologist has somehow expressed consent over this policy. Parents and school stuff should also try to refrain from imposing power unjustly or from using sarcasm and public humiliation against the child. However, in the case of extremely defiant children, I would rather they be treated differently and they be brought to an institution where they meet equally defiant children or perhaps sent to hospital...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic Should corporal punishment be permitted in public schools for FREE!
Contact Us