StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles - Article Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
'Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles" paper compares and contrasts these two articles to determine which one is a more persuasive and effective discussion on the issue of single-sex classrooms. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles"

Download file to see previous pages Learning institutions today are faced with the issue of whether there is indeed an advantage in creating single-sex classrooms.  Two articles were written to present both sides of the issue.  The first article “Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum” by Barnett and Rivers debunks the idea that girls and boys who attend single-sex classrooms perform better than their counterparts in a coed environment (Barnett and Rivers 539). The authors claim that research shows that the difference in the cognitive abilities of girls and boys is trivial; thus, there is no gain in opting for single-sex classrooms in public schools. Aside from the high cost of setting up these classrooms, it also goes against the federal law which requires that schools should make available their resources to both sexes. The authors conclude their article by stating that single-sex classrooms do not make any sense. On the other hand, Reed’s essay, “Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms” takes the opposite side by arguing that “single-sex education is a valid and compelling option” (Reed 542). The article mentions that the learning styles of girls and boys differ; therefore, there is a need to promote single-sex classrooms. 

In the fourth paragraph, Reed cites a study of secondary schools and colleges which showed that single-sex schools for females provide better educational opportunities and occupational achievements (Reed 542). On the other hand, Barnett’s and Rivers’ style is less direct. They do not present their position in the first part of the essay; rather, they mention about a school’s superintendent plan to create two single-sex public schools. Unlike Reed, the readers are not made aware of their stand until the middle part of the essay. The style of Barnett and Rivers is to show examples of single-sex classrooms and how it affects the performance of the students. The mention of statistics is not predominant in the article unlike that of Reed’s. Barnett and Rivers’ article lacks the support of statistical data. They mention that the theory that there are major gender differences in the processing of information between boys and girls has been debunked but they fail to present evidence of such, unlike Reed who supports her theories by citing statistics. The use of statistics makes Reed’s article more convincing and believable. A notable style of Barnett and Rivers is shown in paragraph 8. Contrary to Reed’s style, they include a statement in their article that single-sex classrooms are good provided the resources are there (Barnett and Rivers 540). They agreed to the opposing position but immediately contradict it by saying that there is a catch to it. Reed on the other hand, never mentions that coed classrooms are good. Instead, she strengthens her position by presenting the drawbacks of her argument but refutes it by discussing the results of the research made among more than 450 schools (Reed 542).   ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Article, n.d.)
Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Article. https://studentshare.org/education/1460582-compare-and-contrast-two-articles-with-opposite
(Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Article)
Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Article. https://studentshare.org/education/1460582-compare-and-contrast-two-articles-with-opposite.
“Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Article”. https://studentshare.org/education/1460582-compare-and-contrast-two-articles-with-opposite.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles

Articles Comparison

...Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... two essays ‘Its all About us’ written by Steven Johnson and ‘Enough About You’ written by Brian Williams center around webs, videos and all those social networking kind of stuff. Clearly the purpose of both the essays is to show how life has simplified to a great extent in this era of web technology. The first essay also gives a description of people handling complex matters to some extent even without the interference of experts taking help of newly invented instruments. The purpose here is not only to give...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Boys and Girls by Alice Munro

...Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... (Add (Add “Boys and Girls" by Alice Munro Alice Munro’s specific approach to represent the prevalent gender-role influence in the society was visible throughout most of her literary works. The Ontario born Canadian fictional story writer, Munro was a great analyst of real-life situations with characterization of imaginary attributes that could correlate the representative models of the society. The author mainly focused on short stories and novels to express the characteristics of both male and female in the social...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

EDUCATION PERFORMANCE SINCE 1980: GIRLS VS BOYS

...Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Education Performance Since 1980 - Girls Vs Boys Task: Education Performance Since 1980 - Girls Vs Boys ExecutiveSummary This document extensively analyzes the relationship between the male and female gender as per the statistics on their educational achievement at the various levels of the curriculum of the UK. In so doing, the discussion will be made on the choice and preference of both genders on fields of specialization. This difference will be made distinct along the years from 1980 to date. A comparison of the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Psycology articles comparison

...Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Psychology articles comparison: Significant research experiment in the discipline of psychology Grade (8th,May. 2013) Psychology articles comparison: Significant research experiment in the discipline of psychology Introduction Psychology is a discipline that entails the scientific study of mental functionalities and behavior (Harris, 1979). There are several branches of psychology, with each branch dealing with a different aspect of the behavioral study. Experimental psychology is a branch of psychology that entails...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Should Boys and Girls be in a Separate Class

...Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Boys and Girls should be in a Separate es The idea that boys should attend to and be taught separately from girls has been a topic of concern for some time now and is raising an alarm in many societies. The question might never disappear due to the many diverse arguments put across by psychologists and other scholars. Currently, there are schools where learners are taught as per their gender, though it is not a very common phenomenon. This topic is debatable, given the advantages and disadvantages that accrue to this ...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Psychology of Language - The Differences between Boys and Girls in Language Development

...Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Differences in Language Development Introduction A great deal of attention and study has been given to the development of language in children. Language skills may begin before birth. Children are exposed and learn to recognize speech patterns, tunes and the tones of languages during fetal development. After birth, a child’s language develops as a result of the presence of older children around who interact with them, the presence of sensitive adults who listen to them, and numerous influences that children use to ...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

Raising Boys and Girls: Which is Easier

...Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Raising Boys and Girls Parenting plays an important role in raising good citizens and well rounded human beings (Yeatman, 2004, Pg. 404). However, parents may find that raising one particular gender is easier than the other. In fact, it seems that it is the individual child and the parenting method which will truly define whether a child is easy to raise or difficult to raise but on the whole it appears that girls are easier to raise than boys. There are three compelling reasons for this and the first is expert...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Adapting Curriculum for Multicultural Classrooms

...Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... a Curriculum for Multicultural rooms affiliation: Introduction A multi-culture curriculum is vital in exposing students to culture diversity, prejudices, biases and prejudice, help students understand and advocate for diversity awareness. This paper will focus on developing a multicultural curriculum to facilitate better learning for students. The curriculum will focus on incorporating many cultural concepts of different students in the school. According to Boutte (2002) a multi-cultural curriculum clarifies issues o...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

Analysis, Comparison of Two Articles

...Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... of Contents Introduction 3 Discussion 4 1Works Cited 10 Introduction This paper undertakes an analysis and comparison of two articles, one on the difficulties and issues surrounding the sex divide when it comes to conversations, and the other relating to the rise in use of an undershirt whose name, wife-beater, has connotations that the writer asserts are negative, that reinforce the dominance of males in society, and which imply the acceptance of violence on women as fashionable, non-serious, an...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Differences in Boys and Girls' Achievements in the Classroom

...Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles... Gaps and Social Class: Differences in Boys and Girls Achievements in the Classroom Introduction Several studies have shown and analyzed the difference between boys and girls when learning new materials within an educational system. The studies have shown that boys tend to score lower than girls on most topics. There are noted differences where boys score higher, such as science, technology and math. However, the generalized scores that have been analyzed provide detail into the difference between genders when takin...
13 Pages(3250 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Article on topic Comparison of Differences Should Not Drive a Curriculum and Girls and Boys Thrive in Separate Classrooms Articles for FREE!

Contact Us