Nobody downloaded yet

The Methodology of Three International University Ranking Systems - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
University rankings can be defined as tables of specific groups of institutions relatively ranked according to a mutual set of pointers in descending order (Usher & Savino, 2007). …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.2% of users find it useful
The Methodology of Three International University Ranking Systems
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Methodology of Three International University Ranking Systems"

Download file to see previous pages The three major international ranking systems that are used for this purpose are The Times Higher Education World University Rankings, Shanghai Jiao Tong University Rankings of World Universities as well as The CHE ExcellenceRanking 2010 (Gallagher, 2011). The essay will start off with a definition of the university league tables and how they work, reasons for their popularity and the substantial growth in their use over the past years. Next, it will explore various areas in relation with the league tables such as critical analysis of the three ranking systems to gauge their strengths and weaknesses, debate on the evidentiary basis of league tables to explain the criteria upon which the universities are ranked and criticism as well as the limitations to the validity of university ranking systems. Lastly, it will single out the methodology that stands out. The need for and growth of ranking systems: The world is in the process of getting preoccupied with rankings more and more every day. Just like scarcity, having access to the ‘finest’ as well as prestige more or less mark the purchase of almost every commodity in our daily lives, so are the customers of the tertiary sector continuously looking out for pointers that improve their capability to know and access the best in the tertiary sector (Salmi & Saroyan, 2007). Criteria for measuring the rankings: In most of the university ranking tables, the criteria used to measure the rankings is: To be distinct about what the ranking will measure. To use a variety of indicators and multiple procedures rather than a single, weighted ranking. To associate comparable programs or institutions. At the institutional level, use rankings for planned preparation and quality enhancement purposes. At the government level, use rankings to kindle a philosophy of quality. Use rankings as one of the tools available to notify and update students, families and employers and encourage public debate (Salmi & Saroyan, 2007) Analysis of the ranking systems: Shanghai Jiao Tong University (SJTU) rankings were formulated in 1998 and were more formally known as ‘The Academic Rankings of the World Universities’ (ARWU). Universities that have field medallists; highly cited researchers as well as Nobel laureates are included in the ranking. According to this criterion, ARWU is not trying to compare all the universities throughout the world; instead it is targeting the world’s top research universities only. ARWU initially picks out around 1000 universities from throughout the world, of which only 500 are later on ranked in the league tables. For all ARWU indicators, data is usually collected from third parties that include the official site of the Nobel Prize as well as numerous Thomson Reuters websites in order to access citation and publications (Rauhvargers, 2011). Moving on to ‘The Times higher Education World University Rankings’, it is apparent that, published in 2004, it was an ‘answer’ to the Shanghai ARWU rankings. The indicated drive of ‘The World University Rankings’ is “to recognise universities as the multi-faceted organisations that they are, to provide a global comparison of their success against the notional mission of remaining or becoming world-class” (Salmi & Saroyan, 2007). This ranking separates 300 in each of the five faculty areas as well as about 600 universities and uses sources such as incorporate surveys from individual academics and researchers, employer organisations, third-party data as well as university information (Salmi & Saroyan, 2007). Lastly, The CHE Centre for Higher Education Development that designed an ‘ ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Methodology of Three International University Ranking Systems Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1430802-compare-and-contrast-the-methodology-of-three
(The Methodology of Three International University Ranking Systems Essay)
https://studentshare.org/education/1430802-compare-and-contrast-the-methodology-of-three.
“The Methodology of Three International University Ranking Systems Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1430802-compare-and-contrast-the-methodology-of-three.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Methodology of Three International University Ranking Systems

Methodology

...that research design finds and collect information regarding these different areas. The international students educational and socio cultural experiences in a different country (UK), their opinions and way of life, and their perception of UK before and after their stay. It also looks at the way the international students in the United Kingdom cope with the life and their attitudes toward the British educational system, also their decision to study in UK rather than any other country for their education. 1.3.1 Sampling Sampling is a method in which, a subset of individuals is selected and this selection is based on some specific concern related to the selected subset (Ader, Mellenbergh...
11 Pages(2750 words)Dissertation

Methodology

...). 4. The institutional levels basically emphasizes over the exogenous traits of organizations and their representatives influencing the process of gatekeeping such as political alliances and market forces (Donohue, Olien, & Tichenor, 1989). 5. The social system level determines the influence of culture and ideology over gatekeeping (Gramsci, 1971). During the end of 19 70's, various other disciplines commenced to use the gatekeeper term and also embedded it in to their own domain. The field of Management considers the gatekeepers primarliy as intermediaries (Schultze & Boland, 2000) or as "key individuals who are both strongly connected to internal colleagues and strongly linked to external domains,"...
10 Pages(2500 words)Dissertation

The Systems Development Life Cycle Methodology

...?THE SYSTEMS DEVELOPMENT LIFE CYCLE METHODOLOGY The Systems Development Life Cycle methodology Affiliation The traditional software development cycle is based on a rigid set of steps with a documented sign-off at the completion of each one. In this scenario, a comprehensive and in-depth requirement analysis is performed in an attempt to determine the system needs and requirements to form a Software Requirements Specification (SRS) document. In addition, clients are forced to "sign-off" on the requirement specification document before system development proceeds to the next step. Moreover, the other steps of system...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Pros and Cons of University Ranking

...of the institution’s performance, capacity, and success rate in offering the desired course. This serves to enhance transparency in information disbursement among the ranked institutions (Rauhvargers 20). Consequently, university ranking systems have been illustrated to encourage student enrolment by highlighting preferences in accordance to their target. This is evidenced by the establishment of rankings based on faculty performance, which is easier to interpret when choosing an institution. The system serves as an efficient tool where students can evaluate their aspirations and decide on the institution that will best serve them....
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Three Information Technology Systems

...? Criminal Justice Three Information Technology Systems (100-150) Understanding how to successfully use technological systems is essential for the success of any police department in combating crime in their city. The utilization of mapping systems which show at a glance where certain types of crime may be occurring is important when deciding where to put certain amounts of patrol units so that the presence will discourage and prevent further crimes and to also solve them at the same time. When investigations are conducted into crimes and fingerprints are recovered, it is very helpful to have access to the database systems which retain fingerprints and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Soft Systems Methodology

...the framework of ideas that are internal to us. c. Methodology: There are many of these of which SSM is one.. Formal Systems Model : Formal Systems Thinking is applied to the development of the conceptual model. It serves as a guideline for checking the conceptual model we draw. If S represent a human activity system, then S is a formal system (Macauly, 1996). if it meets certain requirements such as : It must have some mission, a measure of performance, must have a decision making process, must have components which interact with each other such that the effects and actions are transmitted through the system, must...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Soft Systems Methodology (SSM)

...system development and analysis. The SSM is now mostly used technique for the information system analysis and development. This technique is really effective for the problem design within information systems development. Work Cited 1. Christopher Bond and Sandi Kirkham. Contrasting the Application of Soft Systems Methodology and Reflective Practice to the Development of Organizational Knowledge and Learning - A Review of Two Cases in the UK National Health Service, New Orleans LA USA, Page 1-11. 1999. 2. Laudon, Kenneth C. Management Information System. (Sixth Edition), New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 1998. 3. Yinghong, Z. Soft...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Methodology

...Table of Contents Table of Contents 0 Chapter 3 Research Methodology 3 Achievability of Objectives 3.2 Selected Research Methodology: 2 3.3 Researcher’s Philosophy 5 3.4 Framework for Action Research 5 3.5 Implementation of PBIS and Action Research 8 3.6 Data Collection Methods 9 3.6.1 Theoretical Framework: 9 3.6.2 Comparative Study of Qualitative and Quantitative Methods: 10 3.6.3 Collection Method Used 14 3.7 Sampling Strategies 17 3.8 Reliability, Validity and Research Triangulation: 20 Bibliography 22 Chapter 3 Research Methodology 3.0 Introduction: The previous chapter has dealt with the literature specifically related to the Positive Behavior Intervention System. This chapter aims at detailing the research methodology used... ...
30 Pages(7500 words)Research Paper

The pros and cons of university ranking

...by the institutions. This evaluation is relative; however, as quality will be perceived differently and as such, there cannot be fixed criteria (Almegren 14). Recently, there has been mounting attentiveness to ranking systems and great criticism of existing rankings. The problem with the existing rankings is that they do not include universities and higher learning institutions from various parts of the world. This has become necessary, as governments of many countries have reiterated the significance of quality in research and higher education, and linking economic growth, innovation and research. Moreover, higher education and research institutions...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Ranking method

...faced by users during their interaction with different websites. They possess a common theme which seems to revolve around the optimization of informational search. The same has been successfully conducted in tweeter by use of a tweet ranking system [2]. The successful optimization of informational search can however be achieved by improving the online items ranking. 2. Discordant themes The algorithms used in the three research papers were different and different criteria were used for ranking. In research paper [2] the authors propose a general graph model to analyze re-tweet behavior. The sources of information are converted to the feature vectors of...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Methodology of Three International University Ranking Systems for FREE!

Contact Us