Nobody downloaded yet

Informed consent. The possible dangers of too much information conveyed - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Informed consent is an issue that has many facets. While the truism is that informed consent is generally good, there is some research which suggests that there is a limit to how much a patient should be informed…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.2% of users find it useful
Informed consent. The possible dangers of too much information conveyed
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Informed consent. The possible dangers of too much information conveyed"

Download file to see previous pages rug. Moreover, there is an issue with how much comprehension a participant may have of the risks that are dictated in the informed consent protocol. Not surprisingly, the forms must be readable in order for a patient to truly have considered himself “informed,” and the most important part of readability is to put the risks into layman’s terms. Studies have suggested that esoteric forms which are more difficult to read than complicated texts results in considerably less informed consent than forms which are not so. Therefore, it is important to pay attention to the level of language used in the consent forms and keep the audience in mind. If the person drafting these forms keeps in mind this golden rule, then other studies suggest that informed consent is extremely effective. The possible dangers of too much information conveyed Loftus & Fries (2008) theorize that informed consent may do more harm than good, at least when the risks that are presented to the patient consist of all potential risks that might occur, no matter how remote. They argue that the patient might imagine that he or she is experiencing the symptom because of the power of the mind, in that the mind can play tricks on people, and, if the patient knows that a certain risk is possible, then the patient may conjure this risk even though it is only remotely possible that the patient is actually experiencing the symptom. As proof of this, they point to the power of the placebo (Loftus & Fries, 2008, p. 217). To them, a patient is better off just knowing the general level of risk, ie, the symptoms that are likely to occur, and only provide patients the remote risks if the patient specifically asks for it. Therefore, the informed consent carries risks itself, and they “only ask that those whose task it is to formulate informed consent rituals pay some attention to the harm that may be caused by the ritual itself” (Loftus & Fries, 2008, p. 217). Loftus & Fries then cited a study that they performed that was unpublished. It involved patients at the Stanford University Medical School who were diagnosed with scleroderma and were treated with a drug cocktail consisting of propranolol and alpha-methyldopa. The patients were informed about the side effects of the drug cocktail, which included dizziness, headaches, upset stomach and tearfulness. Some patients received a standard informed consent form and some received a standard informed consent form plus a special message which explained the placebo effect, in that the patients who received the special message were informed of the phenomenon of experiencing symptoms simply because the symptoms were mentioned. Loftus & Fries found that all patients experienced “side effects,” even if the patient was given a placebo. They also found that those patients who received the special message experienced fewer side effects than those who did not (Loftus & Fries, 2008, p. 218). Therefore, their point about a patient knowing “too much” was validated. While Loftus & Fries concentrated on the placebo effect as a drawback for informed consent, at least informed consent that lists every possible side-effect, no matter how remote, Audrey et al. (2008) concentrated on the effect informed consent had on patients who want to undergo palliative chemotherapy. The issue that Audrey et al. focuses upon is ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Informed consent. The possible dangers of too much information Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1427450-what-research-exists-to-support-the-efficacy-of
(Informed Consent. The Possible Dangers of Too Much Information Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/education/1427450-what-research-exists-to-support-the-efficacy-of.
“Informed Consent. The Possible Dangers of Too Much Information Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1427450-what-research-exists-to-support-the-efficacy-of.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Informed consent. The possible dangers of too much information conveyed

The Omnivore's delimma: Too much choice too little information

...? THE OMNIVORE'S DILEMMA: TOO MUCH CHOICE TOO LITTLE INFORMATION. Michael Pollan's The Omnivore's Dilemma (2005) goes far into researching every facet of the food industry. He argues that the rise of industrial farming has meant a decline in the quality of food, and in turn, the emergence and growth of a variety of health problems facing Americans, such as obesity, diabetes and heart disease. Humans are omnivore's which mean that they are given much choice, however, with greater choice comes the greater need for information. It will be argued in the following that consumers need to know more about the health quality of foods and in turn,...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Informed Consent and Client Rights

...? Informed Consent and Client Rights Informed Consent and Client Rights Informed consent is one of the critical elements of the counseling relationship. The counseling code of ethics guarantees clients freedom to choose whether to engage or continue with an existing counseling relationship. Clients, therefore, need adequate information about the counselor and the counseling process before engagement in the treatment process. Counselors have an obligation to review the rights and responsibilities in both writing and verbally with their clients. Counselors must document all the discussions throughout the counseling process...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Informed Consent

...The Pros and Cons of Informed Consent and Parents Rights to Access a Child's Medical Record Date Table of Contents I. Introduction ''''''''''''''''''''''''.. 3 II. Pros and Cons of Informed Consent '''''''''''''.. 3 III. General Information about the Parents Rights to Access a Child's Medical Record ''''''''''''''''''''''' 5 IV. Pros and Cons of Parents Rights to Access a Child's Medical Record ''''''''''''''''''''''' 6 V. A Teaching Plan for Parents '''''''''''''''''. 7 VI. Conclusion ''''''''''''''''''''''''' 7 References '''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 9 Introduction In general, a consenting adult regardless of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Case Study

Informed Consent for Participation in Health Services Research

...Cassell and Young point out that “Ethics committees now require that individuals give informed consent to health services research.” However, they argue that this is “misguided” because “existing ethical guidelines do not help us decide how to seek consent and have allowed managerial experimentation to remain unchecked.” (2002) The main argument that they have for this is that the terms of the Helsinki Declaration do not apply properly to Health Services Research due to the ways in which it differs from Clinical Research. This is the reason that they think an alternative method of community consent should be put into place, and I agree. It is clear from the examples...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Informed Consent in Medical Malpractice

...nature of the patient. Exceptions The objections to the need for informed consent are two-fold. First in cases where prompt treatment is needed to salvage a life or avert serious danger and it is not possible to obtain the consent either from the sick person or from a designated individual who can provide it on behalf of the patient. The law assumes that the consent could have been accorded. This exception is effected based on two important criteria. First, the urgent situation must be severe and secondly, the sick person’s condition rather than the environmental aspect dictates the urgency of the situation (Department of Health, 2006,...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

Patient Rights and Informed Consent

..., and finally, that the patient is mentally competent to give said consent (Hopper, TenHave, and Hartzel 493-496). However, consent forms have become tasked with not only listing every possible risk, but adding in the jargon of hospital lawyers concerned about liability (Hopper et. al. 493-496). The biggest stumbling block to understanding that most patients face is that the forms given to them are simply written at a level above their understanding. A truly informed consent, or educated consent, requires not only disclosure but also a fundamental understanding of the disclosed information (Arnold et. al. 21-28). In a...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Informed Consent

...28 November Informed consent Psychological healing of a sexually abused adolescent Purpose We are asking you to participate in a counseling program. This counseling program will psychologically heal a traumatized individual, especially when one has been sexually abused. People who participate in the counseling program will expose their feelings, experiences, and identify the abusers. More than 1000 people have benefitted from similar counseling program in the United States. In this counseling program, only one client is attended at a time during counseling. The counselor will use the information and identify the reasons to why the trauma keeps disturbing you now and then. You will need...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Allied Health, Information and Informed Consent

..., the treatment, and the supportive care. The consent should be recorded in the patients medical record. The multidisciplinary team should give their recommendations based on the evidence and the acceptable best practice. The recommendations should be recorded in the patients medical record and should be signed by the treating technician. The private patients in multidisciplinary meeting should have their recommendations recorded and signed by the treating technician in the patient notes. The designated team member or the treating technician should convey the recommendations to the multidisciplinary team of the patient by providing appropriate information, which will enable the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Systematic review for informed consent

...from the possibility of making unintentional errors, researchers conducting systemic reviews may make mistakes which are largely influenced by the publication aspirations. This is referred to as publication bias, and often involves the alteration or misguided opinion on results by researchers as they attempt to attain positive results for their work to be published (Petticrew & Roberts, 2006). Researchers also have the professional obligation to constantly update their knowledge as there are constantly new developments in science and certain information may be out of date. Therefore, recommendation by the Cochrane Collaboration state that reviews should be updated every two years and if an update is not...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

SYLVIA LAVIN too much information

...SYLVIA LAVIN Too Much Information Lavin’s “Too Much Information” discusses the fourteenth Architecture Biennale that took place in Venice. Some of the notable concepts covered in the article include elements of architecture, modernity, and Monditalia (Lavin 1). The article mentions the fact that exhibitions threaten the existence of artists in the world of arts. In most cases, authors may never propose the inclusion of artists in art exhibitions. However, Lavin notes that sometimes the authors manage to control exhibitions and in the end promote art and architecture. According to the article, most of the organizers of art exhibitions...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Informed consent. The possible dangers of too much information conveyed for FREE!

Contact Us