Nobody downloaded yet

Exception to the Right to Refuse Treatment - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Running head: EXCEPTION TO THE RIGHT TO REFUSE TREATMENT Exception to the right to refuse treatment (name) (school) Exception to the Right to Refuse Treatment Introduction Every person has an inherent moral right to refuse treatment. These are moral rights which help ensure that a patient’s right to self-determination and autonomy are respected by the health care givers and the medical professionals…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
Exception to the Right to Refuse Treatment
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Exception to the Right to Refuse Treatment"

Download file to see previous pages This paper shall consider the exception to this right, more particularly in instances of emergencies when the patient poses a danger to himself or to others. It shall demonstrate how a health practitioner might justify a violation of the moral rule to treat a patient. It shall explain how such justification is determined and what the ethical implications are of such actions taken by the health professional. This paper is being undertaken with the hope of establishing a comprehensive and scholarly understanding of the subject matter, as well as its specific circumstances and applicability to patient situations and circumstances. Discussion The right to refuse treatment is not an absolute right. It may be restricted in emergency cases when the patient poses a danger to himself and others. This may often be seen among psychiatric or mentally ill patients and among suicidal patients who may enter stages of mental incapacity where they pose a danger to the public and to themselves (Kavaler and Spiegel, 2003). In these instances, the welfare of the public supersedes the right of the patient to refuse treatment. ...
Normally, an incompetent person may not be considered capable of caring for himself and of providing for his needs; however, he may also be competent enough to understand the risks which some forms of treatment may pose on his health. In effect, although he is incompetent in some respects, he is still competent in some other purposes (Jeste and Friedman, 2006). It is therefore important to establish an incompetent person’s capacity to make treatment decisions before he can be allowed to refuse treatment. In most US states, the medical profession has recognized and acknowledged the fact that competent, but involuntarily committed individuals have the right to refuse treatment. The courts have even acknowledged the fact that mentally ill prisoners have the right and freedom to refuse unwanted antipsychotic drugs (Jeste and Friedman, 2006). Many states are still however very much divided on the issue of imposing procedural processes to protect such right. Some states have utilized the decision-maker model which basically allows the medical professional to make the informal assessments of the patient’s competence (Jeste and Friedman, 2006). Others however, require the conduct of a formal hearing before a judge or other decision-makers. In these states, mental disorder and involuntary commitment are not sufficient elements to a determination of incompetence in making medical decisions (Jeste and Friedman, 2006). In which case, before a medical treatment is to be imposed on the patient, the judge must establish that the patient is not mentally capable of making treatment decisions, in other words, he cannot weigh the risks, ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Exception to the Right to Refuse Treatment Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Exception to the Right to Refuse Treatment Essay)
“Exception to the Right to Refuse Treatment Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Exception to the Right to Refuse Treatment

Womens Right (Equal Right Amendment)

...the obvious and utter neglect of women in the laws of the land (Whitney 57). In 1872 during the presidential election, Anthony cast her ballot in one of the poll precincts in New York invoking her right as a citizen as provided in the 14th Amendment. Her somehow rebellious act prompted her arrest, conviction and a penalty of $100, which she refused to pay. On the other hand, the Supreme Court decision in Minor versus Happersett (1875), pronounced that while women may be citizens, not all citizens are necessarily allowed to vote. Stanton, Mott, Anthony, Truth and the rest of the women abolitionists and suffragettes during the time passed their lifetime without experiencing the joys of participating in the...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

Right to Refuse Treatment

...treatment includes the right to refuse involuntary hospitalization. (Godard, Bloom, Williams, and Faulkner, 1998) More often than not, Nurses find themselves in the front line when the situation arises to deal with patients that refuse medication or treatment. Evidently, a voluntary patient has the right to refuse treatment and must not be treated against his or her consent, with the exception being in situations in which the patient becomes actively to others or to himself. The right to refuse treatment is closely related to the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Patient's Right

...before going ahead to administer it. A consideration was important in this context because patients have a right to refuse treatment (Council of Ethical and Judicial Affairs, 1995). The nurse may have disregarded the patient’s protests on the basis that he was depressed and uncooperative. However, if the nurse made her decision based on this factor, her decision would not be binding until a third party is involved. A close family member to Mr. X would have been involved in the decision of whether to administer the enema or not. Therefore, the patient has a legal case against the nurse. The nurse fails to listen to the patient, and therefore goes ahead and does what she thinks is best for...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Voting Right

...?Insert The Path to 270: analysis The remaining time to presidential elections in the United s is less than a year. In view of this, there has been a remarkable increase in the competitiveness of the ideologies, with the current economic challenges and a substantially strengthening of the Republican electoral machine potentially reducing the influence of Democratic candidate, President Obama, who is already ahead of the race courtesy of his incumbency. Apparently, the equation could change ahead of the election but from the time the wooing of voters began in earnest, it is apparent that there have always been two significant factors which will eventually influence the victory of either side. These include the ever changing... The Path to 270: ...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay


...?PSYCHOLOGY TREATMENT PLAN This paper reviews a treatment plan for a thirty five year old patient exhibiting symptoms of hopelessness, reduced energy, hypersomnia and feelings of worthlessness. Moreover, the patient runs the risk of committing suicides. These symptoms indicate that the patient is suffering from depression. Suicide attempts are at a high rate in relation to the general world populace. With the behaviors becoming complex issues, there are a number of preventive measures that can be utilized. There has been minimum research in the field to offer effective preventive measures, and thus it remains a problem in determining the best approach relevant to these scenarios. Consequently, there are a...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

A Right-Versus-Right Problem

...A Right-Versus-Right Problem In APA Style Your School's My Own Experience As a normal human being, I experience simple right-versus-right problems in ordinary days. Some of these I usually brush off, except for some with serious repercussions. Sometimes, I also experience value conflict, in which I find hard to decide between two right alternatives. One particular experience of a right-versus-right decision was when I was still working in the hospital. One of the AIDS patients died so I myself contacted a funeral home to pick up the body. When I asked them if they have known that the patient had HIV/AIDS,...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Right Thumb Pain Child Treatment

...Five Cases Studies with Minor Injuries Patient A. 4 years old male Patient comes accompanied by the motherand an older brother 7. The mother gives consent for examination and treatment (Greaves and Johnson 2002, p.74). Patient scheduled for examination and planning of care. The patient is alert and oriented, he however appears to be in pain. He has no problem walking and eating. P/C: Pain on the right thumb with an open wound (Talan et al. 1999, p. 88). HPC: The patient was well until few hours ago when he was bitten by a stray dog while playing with other children in the neighbourhood. Has been having consistent thumping pain on the bite site with swelling of the entire hand. Weight: 19.6kg PMH:...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Texas Decision to Refuse to Expand Medicaid

...Texas Decision to Refuse to Expand Medicaid Number Faculty Texas Decision to Refuse to Expand Medicaid Introduction Texas is facing a very critical moment of making a decision on whether or not to accept federal dollars to provide health insurance to many uninsured state residents through Medicaid, which is expanded under affordable care act. This decision will have serious implications for millions of Texans who stand to gain health coverage if the state participates in the Affordable Care Act’s Medicaid expansion. The decision on whether or not to accept the Medicaid will affect the entire state. With the expansion, new federal funds regarding billions of dollars will become available. These funds would stimulate Texas’s economy... and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Right of a Patient to Choose over the Obligation of the Medical Practitioner to Respect Their Wishes

...Medical Law Introduction The most sacrosanct right conferred to man is the freedom of choice. However, much controversy is generated when the autonomy of choice is exercised over right to life or in its negative form, the right to terminate life. Man, when faced with mortality, reacts differently but nonetheless when an option is made refusing medical treatment or procedure, the wisdom or motivation of such preference is put to test not to mention the mental state of the person making it is similarly questioned. It would appear that the capacity to think rationally or make an intelligent choice is diminished when it involves a medical decision to prolong...
11 Pages(2750 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Exception to the Right to Refuse Treatment for FREE!

Contact Us