Brief a Case - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
When Miranda was arrested for kidnap and rape allegations, he was interrogated by the police in the State of Arizona without having been made aware of his rights as Fifth Amendment of the U.S constitution requires. Although Miranda gave a confession voluntarily and signed that…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.8% of users find it useful
Brief a Case
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Brief a Case"

Brief a Case When Miranda was arrested for kidnap and rape allegations, he was interrogated by the police in the ofArizona without having been made aware of his rights as Fifth Amendment of the U.S constitution requires. Although Miranda gave a confession voluntarily and signed that he had not been threatened into making the confession, he had not been notified that he had a right to have a lawyer present at the time of the interrogation as well as to remain silent (Clarkson et al. 209). This is why the dispute was between Miranda and the State of Arizona. Background information on Miranda indicates that he had a history of mental instability, which may have contributed to the crimes that he committed. He was a Phoenix resident.
Miranda was sentenced to serve between 20 to 30 years in prison. However, he appealed to the Supreme Court of Arizona stating that the police had acquired his confession through unconstitutional means. This court ruled against him and upheld his conviction. However, the U.S Supreme Court decided to review Miranda’s case three years after his original conviction as he decided to appeal for the second time. The legal question that the U.S Supreme Court had to ponder about was whether a suspect ought to be made aware of their rights prior to any form of interrogation.
To answer this question, the Supreme Court had to analyze the American judicial system and provide new restraints that the society must follow when prosecuting individuals of any crime. The Supreme Court determined that if an individual is to be subjected towards any form of interrogation, they must first be made aware of their rights such as the right to an attorney that can be provided by the state if the suspect is indigent and even to remain silent (Clarkson et al. 210). Remaining silent was an option that the suspect could take but it had to come with an explanation that anything that the suspect would say could be used against them during a court hearing. This implies that if the suspect decides to withhold certain information and then produce it during the session, it could strengthen the case against them.
The right to be provided an attorney during the interrogation was to ensure that the interrogation is undertaken on constitutional grounds. This was to ensure that the constitution is as fair as possible since the individual remains innocent until proven otherwise. This implies that the suspect not only has privileges such as remaining silent due to the protection of the constitution but also a consequence that could come if new information was brought up by the suspect during a court hearing. The Supreme Court was attempting to ensure that the constitution is as fair as possible to a suspect through legal presentation and limited legal privileges. Following this ruling, police in U.S are required to make the suspect aware of their legal rights so that they can make informed decisions. The court also made the ruling basing the argument on the idea that most interrogations are not physical but psychological.
Works Cited
Clarkson, Kenneth W., Miller, Roger L. and Cross, Frank B. Business Law: Text and Cases. Stamford: Cengage Learning, 2015. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Brief a Case Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 1”, n.d.)
Brief a Case Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 1. Retrieved from
(Brief a Case Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 1)
Brief a Case Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 1.
“Brief a Case Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 1”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document


Brief a case

...Melvin Washington vs. of Indiana Facts of the Case  Police Officer Danny Reynolds, who works for the Indianapolis Metropolitan upon seeing a vehicle with a damaged headlight, approached the car to speak to the driver, Washington. Upon reaching the vehicle the officer inquired whether there were any weapons present onboard. Washington admitted to having a handgun, which was located under the driver’s seat. He also informed Officer Reynolds that he had a valid license for the weapon. Washington was handcuffed and upon discovering the weapon under the seat the Officer also found a bag of marijuana that was next to the handgun. Despite the presence of a valid handgun permit the officer issued Washington a summons to show in...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

Love brief a case

... v. Sands Supreme Court of Ohio, 2008 Legal History: The appellant appealed against his conviction and sentence in the Lake County Court of Common Pleas for engaging in corrupt activities, attempted murder and aggravated arson targeting public officers. Facts: In April 2006, Jason Green, a friend of the appellant reported to a police detective that the appellant and his girlfriend were planning to kill four public officers. On the facts, Green and the appellant had suffered several encounters with local police and the Mayor and were of the opinion that they were deliberately targeting and harassed by the police. The duo purchased recording equipment and recorded conversations with officials with a view to proving harassment... v. Sands...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Brief a case

.... Therefore the victim’s statement in response to the photograph is sufficient to constitute the spontaneous exclamation exception to the rule against hearsay. Although spontaneous exclamations usually apply to accidents, assaults and such events, it is not restricted to these types of incidents. The court will look at the specific facts and circumstance of the case. Since the victim had not previously discussed the assault with her family, her response to the appellant’s photograph would amount to a spontaneous exclamation. She was “unexpectedly” shown a picture of the man who assaulted her and thus her response was spontaneous and not one that could be said to have been contrived.... v Court of Appeal of Florida, Third District, 2003...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Brief a case

.... Many of these experts are never caught. However, in this case, the defendant was caught and the court would take the opportunity to set a precedent and by doing so would “send a message” to like-minded computer experts (Werner, v Lewis, 1992). Thus the court ruled that this was an appropriate case for awarding punitive damages as the defendant’s behaviour was morally culpable. Thus punitive damages of US$18,000 was awarded together with compensatory damages of US$7,000. Bibliography Fittipaldi v Legassie 18 A.D. 2d 331, 337 (4th Dept. 1963). Halpin v Prudential Ins. Co. 48 N.Y. 2d 906. Penal Law, Section 156.20. Tommey v Farley, 2 N.Y. 2d 71. Werner, et al. v. Lewis 588 N.Y.S.2d 960 (NYC Civ Ct 1992).... Werner, et al. v. Lewis...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Brief a case

..., if the court errs in determining the expertise of a specific expert witness pursuant to the definition provided in Rule 702, the conviction will not be overturned if the error was harmless (United States v Carrazana, 921 F.2d 1557 (11th Cir. 1991). The expert witness testified to drug language and schemes characteristic of the illegal drug trade. The appellate court ruled that courts have allowed Drug Enforcement Officers to testify as experts relative to drug trades language and schemes. In this case the appellate court was satisfied that the expert witness, as a Drug Enforcement Officer had the necessary training, experience and skill to testify as an expert to such matters. It has already been ruled that an...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Brief a Case

...Brief Case Review The case number 248 NY 339, Helen Palsgraf, the Plaintiff-Appellee, vs. Long Island Railroad Company, the Defendant-Appellant, was argued from February 24, 1928 and decided on May 29, 1928. In this case, the defendant moved to court and filed an appeal to reverse the decision of Supreme Court in the second Judicial Department of New York by asserting that the plaintiff, Palsgraf, failed to prove that her injury was foreseeable (Cardozo 1). In the previous history of the case, the plaintiff, Palsgraf, lodged a complaint against Long Island Railway Company, the defendant, asserting that the defendant was liable for her injuries that...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Brief a case

...Brief a case Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories Sindell’s mother took a drug manufactured and marketed by approximately 200 companies that led to Sindell developing cancer during her adulthood. Since she could not identify the company that manufactured the drug that she ingested before she was born, she decided to sue the five main companies that were involved with the manufacturing and the marketing of the drug. According to her claim, these companies were negligent in the manufacturing and marketing of the drug since adequate tests had not been done prior to its distribution. The court dismissed the plaintiff’s claims simply because she could not identify the company that distributed the drug. She appealed...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Brief a case

...the executor of Willian E. Story (the uncle) estate, Franklin Sidway (D). During the judgment, the case was ruled in favor of P but later on appeal reversed in favor of D. P appealed (1967). Issue Is mere abstention in regards to legal behavior sufficient consideration to come up with a contract that is valid and enforceable? Rule Yes. Mere abstention from a legal conduct that is permissible is sufficient consideration to seal a promise that is based on forbearance of a valid contract. Consideration is not taken as a benefit to the person who promises. When a someone’s offer is ambiguous regarding whether accepting it shall be in form of exchange of promises or performance, determining if the person who offered was...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Brief a case

...Case: Rosenzweig vs. givens Facts: Background between the parties Rosenzweig and Givens had been in a romantic relationship for some time. However, the relationship ended, and there arose a dispute over the purchase of a condominium apartment. Why is there a dispute? Rosenzweig started an action to close on two mortgages that he claimed to have issued to Givens in 2002. He said that he had loaned her $285000 to purchase the property. At the time the mortgage was issued to Givens, the two were in a romantic relationship (Larkson, Miller, and Cross 294). Rosenzweig paid the down payment of the property that he now claims it was a mortgage. He also claimed to have incurred many household expenses with regard to the...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Brief a case

...Brief a case: Hadley vs Baxendale The case number 9 Exch. 341, 156 Eng. Rep. 145, Hadley, the plaintiff, v. Baxendale, the defendant, was argued and decided in 1854. In this case, the defendant moved to court and lodged a complaint and claim against the plaintiff for damages for breach of contract. The plaintiff sued for 300 pounds for loss of profits and salaries (Crompton 1). In the facts of the case, the plaintiff had contracted the defendant to take a component of his mill’s steam engine to Joyce & Co after it broke down. The breakdown caused the plaintiff to close down the mill waiting for a new one. The defendant had stipulated that if the...
1 Pages(250 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Brief a Case for FREE!

Contact Us