Country Report Critique - Book Report/Review Example

Task: EXTRA CREDIT COUNTRY CASE GRADING EXERCISE ____________________________________________ Country: ___________________________________________________CRITERIAPoints ReceivedMaximum PointsGrading CommentsWhether the philosophy/foreign policy of (Your Selected Country) facilitate cooperation or conflict? Whether the patterns of globalization in the country support the hyperglobalist, sceptics, or transformationalist view? Whether the country’s winners and losers from the process of globalization are represented through the NIE, the SPG, the Outliers, or Feminist Economics perspective?

And whether the phenomenon of globalization in the country has called for government intervention? 18 points22 pointsThere is a good interpretation of Pakistan’s philosophy.Ideal identification of conflicting issues in the selected country.There was also observance of relevant choice of examples of conflicts in Pakistan.Lack of clarity in highlighting the different patterns of globalization in Pakistan, which support either hyperactive globalist, skeptics or transformationalist views.Mention of representation of special groups (winners and losers) in required perspectives was not adequate.

More examples are required in order to make the explanations offered clear.Intervention of government in globalization phenomenon not mentioned in the paper. CRITICAL THINKING CRITERIA: Presents, interprets, and analyzes relevant information, data, or evidence; Develops and presents argument, position or hypothesis, with implications2 points3=exemplary; 2=acceptable; 1=unacceptableRelevant interpretation of the data, which has been mentioned in the paper.How developed is _______ in regard to the concept of competitive advantage of nations?

How has _______ adjusted to the age of nonpolarity (numerous centers with meaningful power)? And whether the relations between the state and corporations in ________ can be described as state capitalism or market capitalism?19 points22 pointsIt is not true that Pakistan has sufficiently embraced the concept of competitive advantage.There was no description of the relation between corporations and the state in Pakistan.CRITICAL THINKING CRITERIA: Presents, interprets, and analyzes relevant information, data, or evidence; Develops and presents argument, position or hypothesis, with implications2 points3=exemplary; 2=acceptable; 1=unacceptableThere were acceptable developments and implications from the essay.

Whether or has ______ managed or has been altered because of the new geopolitics of energy or other scarce natural resources (i.e., water, etc)? How do the country’s identity politics and diasporas affect the country’s economic development? And whether _______ has solved or has been impeded by the puzzle of economic development?17 points22 pointsThere was provision of sketchy examples of natural resources.The mention of whether the economic development puzzle was solved in Pakistan is unclear.

CRITICAL THINKING CRITERIA: Presents, interprets, and analyzes relevant information, data, or evidence; Develops and presents argument, position or hypothesis, with implications2 points3=exemplary; 2=acceptable; 1=unacceptableVery good examples used. Minimum 5 scholarly resources (3 points each)9 points12 pointsMost work cited is from magazines. Include more citations that are scholarly.CRITICAL THINKING CRITERIA: Considers context, assumptions, and other perspectives2 points3=exemplary; 2=acceptable; 1=unacceptableThere was citation of articles, which were relevant to the topic.

Minimum page requirement (5 – 8 pages)4 points5 pointsSatisfaction of number of pages required was observed.Organization1 point2 pointsSome paragraphs are very long. CRITICAL THINKING CRITERIA: Identifies problem, question, or issue; Draws meaningful or justified conclusions; Communicates with regard to complex problems3 points3=exemplary; 2=acceptable; 1=unacceptableThere was proper identification of problems affecting Pakistan.

Additionally, a meaningful conclusion was reached at.Total Points79 points100 pointsA paper that is well written but could be better if there was inclusion of more relevant examples central to Pakistan. Further, there should be correction of all grammar mistakes that are observed in the paper. Works CitedSpeck, Bruce. Grading Student Writing: An Annotated Bibliography. New York, NY: Information Age Publ, 2005. Print.