StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Insource And Outsource - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
An essay "The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Insource And Outsource" evaluate which of these two strategies would be better for a small insurance company. The arguments will be specifically restricted to either strategy effects on costs, employee impacts and customer impacts…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Insource And Outsource
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Insource And Outsource"

The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Insource And Outsource The debate on which is better, to insource or to outsource has generated so much debate over the past decade. There are a lot of good and bad reasons that can be raised with regards to both but at the end of the day what one needs to realize is that it really boils down to the specific characteristics of a business and the needs that the business seeks to be met. Insourcing is the assigning of a project to an entity within the same company rather than hiring an outside entity whereas outsourcing is the delegation of non-core functions by one company to an external company that is specialized in providing that particular service or function. In this paper we shall evaluate which of these two strategies would be better for a small insurance company. The arguments will be specifically restricted to either strategy’s effects on costs, employee impacts and customer impacts. Effects on costs As a small insurance company there are pertinent functions that the business needs which are not core to either its growth or for gaining competitive advantage. These functions include human resource, payroll, IT and partly finance. Outsourcing here would offer a better choice than insourcing because the company would be able to save on employee compensation, office expenses and other associated costs. Outsourcing essentially converts fixed costs into variable costs, which will enable the small business to use these resources for investment elsewhere in the business (AllBusiness.com 3). On the flip side, small companies must be very careful when negotiating the terms of service with an outsourcing firm. Knowing the challenge that small businesses face with regards to weighing their cost options, an outsourcing company could trap the small company with terms of service that have numerous hidden charges. However, unless the outsourced services provider has numerous ridiculous charges, when it comes to managing costs for a small insurance company, outsourcing offers a better solution than insourcing. On the outset, insourcing does seem like a cost-effective strategy for a company to use because it will simply rely on resources that it already has. This may be true for large organizations that have numerous departments and employees. Small companies are already constrained in terms of staffing, and to manage costs they tend to have employees with flexible role profiles. Adding an additional project to a small company’s present resources would therefore only make their efforts to control cost more difficult. Employee impacts Herzberg’s theory states that there are two sets of factors, hygiene and motivating factors, which affect motivation and job satisfaction. Motivation is largely affected by the factors known as motivators that are related to the job content (Mullins 280). Insourcing in a small company would offer staff increased responsibilities and opportunities for skill variety which increase motivation and job performance according to Hackman & Oldham’s Job Characteristics Model. The disadvantage of insourcing in a small company, however, is that it could lead to the few employees in such firms to be overworked as they take on multiple roles. On the other hand, outsourcing would benefit the staff through skills transfer, skill specialization and flexibility. On-site outsourcing implies that people with different sets of skills will come and work in the company alongside the small company’s employees. This provides one’s company staff with a platform to acquire new skills from the outsourced staff. Also, when a company outsources it remains with skeleton staff that are charged with executing its core activities. Due to the single function these staff members perform everyday they grow to become highly specialized. Finally, outsourcing allows operations that have seasonal demand to bring in additional resources when needed and released when demand goes down. The knowledge that additional personnel will be availed during peak seasons has a motivating effect on the staff that may not look with dread at the oncoming peak seasons. Customer impacts Outsourcing could lead to positive customer impacts in three ways. Firstly, outsourcing enables organizations to focus on their core activities. These lean organizations due to their focus are able to provide their customers with better value propositions. This implies that outsourcing could increase the strength of a brand which would lead to more satisfied customers. Secondly, the reduced overheads and increased cost savings that result from outsourcing could be transferred to the customers in form of price reduction which would improve the competitiveness of a product in the eyes of its customers. Thirdly, outsourcing can help small firms level the playing field by giving them access to the same expertise, efficiency and economies of scale that large competitors enjoy (AllBusiness.com 8). Small firms can therefore exploit outsourcing to reshape Porter’s five industry forces in their favor. This would lead the small firms to be able to improve their customer value proposition. On the other hand, outsourcing could also have great negative customer impacts. For starters, the word itself conveys different meanings to different people. For example in communities where people lost their jobs due to outsourcing, customers would not be too keen to patronize that given brand. Secondly, outsourcing raises the question of sustained quality. There have been reported cases of several outsourcing companies cutting corners so as to increase their margins. Quality problems may lead to the loss of part of one’s market share. Thirdly there is the problem of security, privacy and confidentiality. There is always the risk of data getting compromised when they are moved from one company’s database to the outsourcing company’s. Insourcing is more favorable in terms of customer impacts. With insourcing the organization is assured of the quality of service or goods produced, confidentiality and managerial control. Managerial control is important because it determines the strategies to be followed to improve customer value proposition. My position As the president of a small insurance company I would opt to outsource rather than insource. From our discussion above it is clear that for this kind of business in the service industry outsourcing offers a greater variety of benefits in the value chain than insourcing namely: (1) it will enable the small firm access expertise, efficiency and economies of scale: (2) it reduces labor and capital costs; (3) increases efficiency; and (4) it develops internal staff who learn from on-site outsourcing experts. Works Cited AllBusiness.com. “The Benefits of Outsourcing for Small Businesses.” New York Times 1 Jan 2008. Web. 8 Aug 2011. Mullins, Laurie J. “Chapter 7: Work Motivation and Job Satisfaction.” Management and Organizational Behaviour. 9th ed. Harlow: FT Prentice Hall, 2010. Print.  Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Insource And Outsource Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1578735-outsource-or-insource-the-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-both
(The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Insource And Outsource Essay)
https://studentshare.org/business/1578735-outsource-or-insource-the-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-both.
“The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Insource And Outsource Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1578735-outsource-or-insource-the-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-both.
  • Cited: 2 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Insource And Outsource

Should a company hire new workers or outsource an HRM function due to an increase demand of the companys product

The primary goal of a firm to outsource is to conduct cost-cutting measures while at the same time perform an organizational function.... Should a company hire new workers or outsource an HRM function due to an increase demand of the company's product?... It is economically beneficial to outsource an organizational function instead of hiring new employees.... Almost any kind of organizational activity can be outsourced but it is not advisable to outsource what is called core activity....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

The Potential Hazards and Costs of Manager's Decision of Choosing to Outsource a Function

Commencing from an introduction and historical overview of outsourcing and reasons why managers outsource, the main body of the paper comprises major risks and potential hazards encountered in effective management of outsourcing decisions.... Globalization has placed immense responsibility and need on the part of organization to devise competitive means of operations....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Outsourcing

A number of organizations make the decisions outsource mainly since they want to try and focus on their key competencies, and check minimal value in creating in house processes out of these main competencies.... Outsourcing has turned out to be a key business aspect, providing many firms with the chance of hiring an outside firm, to help in the completion of their production processes, and a well reduced cost but high productivity rate....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Indian Call Centers Create New International Trade Sector

This report desires to shed light on the current state of business process outsourcing.... Specifically, it looks at the data processing and contact centers in the Indian economy, which provides services to European firms.... The highlights of the report are as follow: … Service is "any activity which or benefit that one party can offer to another which is essentially intangible and does not result in ownership of anything" (Kotler 2002)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Outsourcing for IT and Software Development Industry

The trend of… And companies are gaining competitive advantages and saving their resources by outsourcing their needs.... A lot of huge corporations at the present time outsource employments like that e-mail services, call center servicesas well as payroll.... There are a lot of causes that businesses outsource an assortment of employments; on the other hand the majority famous benefit appears to be the information that it frequently accumulates money....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Spread of Outsourcing

There are number of reasons which explain why organizations outsource their functions and business processes, one of the basic and major reasons is that it saves money and allows the organization to pool that money in more productive activity There are many things which companies consider while looking to outsource as the success of outsourcing such as, Companies' capability to manage in mobile locations; Companies' capacities to expand and to build outsource partnerships, and companies' skills and abilities to what to produce and not to produce while being competitive in the market (Boudreaux, 2008)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Advantages of Outsourcing against Insourcing

Loss of managerial control, hidden costs, a threat to security and confidentiality, quality problems, loss of flexibility in reacting to changing business conditions, lack of internal and external customer focus and sharing cost savings etc are some of the disadvantages of outsourcing.... (disadvantages of Outsourcing, 2009)Outsourcing helps an organization to focus on its core activities.... Focus On Core Activities, Cost And Efficiency Savings, Reduced Overhead, operational Control, Staffing Flexibility, Continuity & Risk Management, Develop Internal Staff etc are some of the advantages of outsourcing over insourcing....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Major Risks and Potential Hazards Encountered in Effective Management of Outsourcing Decisions

Commencing from the historical overview of outsourcing and reasons why managers outsource, the main body of the paper comprises major risks and potential hazards encountered in the management of outsourcing decisions.... This paper seeks to address the emerging situation with a critical knack....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us