StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Tax & Ethics Issues in the UK - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Tax & Ethics Issues in the UK" focuses on the role of companies, their professionals, and HM Revenue and Customs and will discuss whether ethical principles should be applied to the payment of tax. The morality of corporate tax avoidance is a bone of contention in the UK…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Tax & Ethics Issues in the UK
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Tax & Ethics Issues in the UK"

?Tax & Ethics The morality of corporate tax avoidance has been a bone of contention in UK for the last few months. The UK government is planning to take a firm stance against corporate tax evasion. The British Prime Minister David Cameron denounced corporate tax avoidance as the act is “morally wrong”. However, many people, including business executives and some economists, argue that tax avoidance is ethically right. Recently, there has been much controversy over the amount of corporate tax international companies such as Starbucks, Google, and Amazon have paid on their UK operations. This paper will evaluate the role of companies, their professionals, and HM Revenue and Customs and will discuss whether ethical principles should be applied to the payment of tax. The four major sources used for drafting this paper are BBC, The Guardian, KPMG, and HMRC, because these sources were found potential for providing analytical information about the topic under consideration. However, only facts and figures have been mainly taken from such sources, for news reports tend to be biased depending on the reporters’ personal outlook. A BBC report dated on 21st November 2012 reflects that UK lost billions in lost revenues as a result of corporate tax avoidance by multinational corporations. The report points out that new tax avoidance schemes are emerging each year and the situation makes it difficult for HM Revenues and Customs (HMRC) to curb this issue. According to National Audit Office, taxation authorities identified nearly 2,300 avoidance schemes between 2004 and 2011 (ibid). Since the actual figures of tax avoidance are not available, the UK government cannot estimate the accurate amount of loss. It has been identified that specialist tax advisers suggest best tax avoidance schemes for their clients; and this practice significantly contributes to the issue. Recently, Margaret Hodge walloped the big four accounting firm for helping companies avoid corporate taxes (as cited in Toynbee 2011). According to another BBC report dated on 3rd December 2012, some leading multinational companies including Starbucks, Amazon, and Google were severely criticised by UK government authorities for paying little or no tax. The UK government officials point that it is unfair for these companies to practice different schemes to avoid corporate taxes despite the fact that their UK operations account for hundreds of millions of pounds (BBC 2012). UK Prime Minister David Cameron states that international co-operation is necessary to tackle this issue because some forms of tax avoidance are very difficult to address (David Cameron). In order to publicly express UK’ stance on tax avoidance, the HM Revenue & Customs publicly named top tax dodgers for the first time (as cited in King). Reportedly, Starbucks, Google, and Amazon are the three major multinational corporations that have practiced schemes to avoid corporate taxes. In addition, small businesses including Cheshire wine merchant, Menemis, and Brian Clifford Tattersall were also criticised for tax avoidance. Yet another BBC report says that Starbucks sold goods worth ?400m in UK in 2001 but paid nothing in corporate taxes (BBC news Business 2012). Starbucks managed to avoid corporate taxes by transferring some of its funds to a sister company in the form of royalty payments, buying coffee beans from Switzerland, and paying high interests rates other parts of the business in the account of borrowing (ibid). Similarly, on the strength of some well structured schemes, Google also notably reduced the amount paid in corporate taxes. As per reports, Google could trim down its tax bill by approximately $1bn a year by transferring profits to subsidiaries having low tax rates (O’Carroll 2011). A subsidiary located in Bermuda assisted Google to save nearly $3.1bn over a period of three years because corporate tax rate is zero in Bermuda (ibid). In response to this criticism, a Google spokesperson said: “we have an obligation to our shareholders to set up a tax-efficient structure, and our present structure is compliant with the tax rules in all the countries where we operate” (Ibid). These words give an explicit view that Google emphasises more on contributing to shareholder values. These words represent the view of all other companies that have attempted corporate tax avoidance. Arguably, the prime role of every company is to increase their shareholder values and to enhance long term sustainability. As discussed already, the UK government argued that professional tax advisers like the big four accounting firms are unfairly helping companies to avoid taxes. However, tax advisers like to call its ‘tax planning’ or ‘tax efficiency’. Evidently, tax professionals have an obligation to their clients to help them improve their tax efficiency. Therefore, it is the duty of the tax advisers to assist their clients to cut down tax amounts maximum as possible. At the same time HMRC has the responsibility to persuade companies to pay corporate taxes fairly because it is a governmental authority obliged to do so. HMRC has introduced a Patent Box regime to provide companies with an opportunity to reduce their UK tax burden significantly (KPMG). In addition, HMRC is developing better strategies to address the issue of tax avoidance (HM Revenues and Customs 2012). While analyzing the ethical concerns over corporate tax avoidance, it seems that this practice is not ethically wrong. It is clear that the government allows all companies to practice lawful money management. Undoubtedly, the so called corporate tax avoidance is nothing more than lawful money management. More precisely, a company has the right to transfer profits to its subsidiaries or to borrow money relatively at higher interest rates. Evidently, corporate taxation is a practice of forcing rich companies to pay more taxes. However, the government does not consider the huge and risky efforts taken by those organisations to achieve their current prosperity. From the view point of The Telegraph reporter Young (2011), corporate tax avoidance is not ethically wrong but it is just a perfectly sensible behaviour. In order to justify this view, it is better to cite an example suggested by the Conservative thinker Andrew Lillico who speaks in favour of tax avoidance. According to him, “if you buy freshly squeezed orange juice, the price includes VAT. If you buy standard concentrated orange juice, there is no VAT. So if a key reason you buy concentrated orange juice is that it is cheaper, you are avoiding paying VAT. Is that wrong?” (as cited in Young 2011). Sensibly, the answer for the question is ‘no’. In short, corporate tax avoidance is not morally wrong and hence ethical principles should not be applied to this practice. References BBC news. (2012) ‘UK Politics: Tax avoidance schemes costs UK billions in lost revenue’ [online] available at [accessed 4 March 2013] . BBC news Business. (2012) ‘Tax paid by some global firms in UK ‘an insult’ [online] available at [accessed 4 March 2013]. BBC news Business: Cameron, D. ‘Tax avoidance must be tackled’. Jan 24 [online] available at [accessed 4 March 2013]. HM Revenues and Customs. (2012) Annual Report and Accounts 2011-12 [online] available at [accessed 4 March 2013]. King, M. (2013) ‘Tax dodgers publicly named in HMRC crackdown’ The Guardian, Feb 21 [online] available at [accessed 4 March 2013]. KPMG.(2011) Patent Box [online] available at [accessed 4 March 2013]. O’Carroll, L. (2011) ‘US investigates Google tax strategies’. The Guardian [online] available at [accessed 4 March 2013]. Toynbee, P. (2013) ‘Accountancy's Big Four are laughing all the way to the tax office’. The Guardian [online] available at [accessed 4 March 2013]. Young, T. (2011) The Telegraph: ‘Tax avoidance isn't morally wrong. It's perfectly sensible behaviour’ [online] available at [accessed 4 March 2013]. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Tax & Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Tax & Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1469557-tax-ethics
(Tax & Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Tax & Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/business/1469557-tax-ethics.
“Tax & Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1469557-tax-ethics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Tax & Ethics Issues in the UK

Organisational and Stakeholder Ethical Considerations - Xstratas Case

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) and stakeholder theories Approach Examining the CSR issues in Xstrata's case is another way of analysing the case.... 17) state that the concept of ethical culture in an organisation means the values and norms that an organisation puts forward as appropriate conduct to guide its employees in decision making process in determining whether their response to ethical issues is right or wrong.... Instead, the management strives to shun ethics hence the rest of the firm follows suit (158)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

An Exceptionally Competitive Tax System in the United Kingdom

Several players make sure the completeness of the tax system in the uk such as companies, company's professional advisers, Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs or the Government.... the uk tax system is competitive in the G7 and the G20 since their standard corporation tax is 26% and applies to both resident and non-resident companies.... tax ethics The United Kingdom has exceptionally competitive tax system in the world that seems attractive to investors globally....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Art of Aggressive Tax Planning

00 million in the uk last year, but paid no corporation tax.... Amazon, which had sales in the uk of ?... million And Google's uk unit paid just ?... million to the Treasury in 2011 on uk turnover of ?... The issue of aggressive tax planning raises the question of ethics.... tax DEBATE In the wake of global capitalism, multinational companies have mastered the art of aggressive tax planning....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Nursing Shortage and Outsourcing Boom

The Information Technology sector comes second, with about 85% of a total of 22,000 expatriate IT staff hired in the uk hailing from India alone.... The report also showed that this phenomenal shortage was not limited to the US, but as estimated by the International Council of Nurses (ICN), several other countries, including the uk, Canada, Netherlands, and Zambia were in no better position.... nn Swain, CEO of the Association of Technical Staffing Companies (ATSCo) made an interesting remark: "The irony is that while low-skilled IT jobs continue to be shipped to India, highly skilled Indian professionals are coming to the uk to take up managerial roles....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Research Paper on Ethical Dilemma

in the uk, they join a different institute, namely the Institute of Chartered Accountants UK.... This level of responsibility binds them to follow a certain code of ethics in their line of work, as professionals.... The aforementioned associations, to which these accountants belong, provide this code of ethics.... In England and Wales, for instance, accountants follow the code of ethics implemented by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of England and Wales (ICAEW)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Ethical Business in the UK

The present essay under the title "Ethical Business in the uk" is focused on the ethics issues of business running.... In many cases, people preferred to be involved with the ethical companies that are operational in the uk.... The financial crisis that took place in the uk made the ethical companies skate the financial downturn (Flynn, 2008, 121).... eople in the uk have grown frustrated by the existing tax loopholes that make the international companies avoid paying taxes or pays very little taxes as compared to the other companies....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Tax Avoidance of Starbucks in the UK

The author of the "The Tax Avoidance of Starbucks in the uk" paper argues that ethics and morality in business are key to the essential establishment of a brand name, and Starbucks Corporation never realized the essence of such until the case emerged.... The corporation has functioned in the uk for over 14 years since entering the markets in 1998.... The Starbucks Corporation, since entering the uk market has established over 750 stores and employs about 8500 employees in the country (Gilbert, 2009, p 65)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

ICAEW Code of Ethics vs CISI Code of Conduct

The essay "ICAEW Code of ethics vs CISI Code of Conduct" focuses on the critical analysis of the comparison between the ICAEW Code of ethics and CISI Code of Conduct.... Every professional organization, company, nongovernmental organization, or any institution has codes of ethics and conduct.... The primary aim of the codes of ethics is to articulate the highest behavioral standards in the organizations.... Therefore, a code of ethics can be clearly understood as established principles of an organization that influences how staff and members carry and conduct themselves (Fisher and Lovell, 2006)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us