Constructualism and Deontology Frameworks in Business Ethics - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Name: Name of instructor: Date: Contractualism and Deontology Frameworks in Business Ethics Many issues in business ethics focus on the meaning and scope of the notion; duty of care. The recent claims of Contractarianism in the Academy of Management Review are analyzed critically and found wanting to a high degree…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Constructualism and Deontology Frameworks in Business Ethics
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Constructualism and Deontology Frameworks in Business Ethics"

Download file to see previous pages The care theory has recently depicted to have begun to gain universalist credentials it previously lacked and not to be subject to the limitations of other two paradigms in some key aspects; but that it still carries a conceptual development to do in order to become a practical framework for global business ethics. Weber (1926) argued that most people’s moral decisions are guided by one of two quite different personal frameworks; the ethnics of conviction or responsibility. Conviction covers what one believes to be right, but is normally trumped by responsibility which is what one actually does, on the rationalization of needing to keep the family fed. Conviction resonates with justice, responsibility resonates with care. This doesn’t mean that ethics of conviction indicates lack of responsibility, or ethics of responsibility a lack of conviction. This shows the divide between private and public life, between our office and family, Kohlberg’s framework resolves this in favour of the public and private. Contractarianism has the conviction ethic that honouring agreements is generally good, but also bears the responsibility ethic that moral commitments arise only from contractual privities between specific individuals including those signing marriage contracts. Contractarian theories are usually placed at only stage five of Kohlberg’s six stage paradigm; at stage six are deontic ethical frameworks illustrated by Kant’s unconditional imperative. Deontic rules are universal and general. Contractarian rules are specific and apply to people who have accepted them previously. The common perspective is that the positions they occupy are as a result of reasoned deliberation, without necessarily sourcing in emotion. Both frameworks attributed to hypothetical states of nature in which people coolly reason among them, which sets of rules will be minimally essential for the life or projects that they are about to board. Kohlberg stage three origins is more soberly viewed as compromising and it’s core of integrated social contract theory to that dominance wholly depends much on a very problematic strength of inner morality of contracts. Van Oosterhout et al (2006) attempts to advance their ambition to stigmatize other contract theoreticians as distress from “contractual follies”. He further clarifies that the four “contractual follies” all displays deception, defeasance, mellifluous alliteration and defection. This is unusual happy linguistic fluke. Writers give the occasional baseless assertion amongst an otherwise heavily argued and stranded citation text. Discourse manipulation is beyond more vocal cosmetics and very critical to the writers’ thesis. Contractualism and contractarianism, entails prior commitments to individualism, freedom, private property rights and possibility of free market exchange. The approach involves dedication to reasonableness and basic institutions, acknowledging foundational and privileged role of reasoned and voluntary human responsibility. Before Van Oosterhout, contractualism was originally explained by Dunfee & Donaldson (1994) as lying in the middle of ethical relativism and ethical absolutism in a manner that combines private contracts with deeper societal contracts. It recognizes the power of such key trans-cultural truths as the idea that all humans be worthy of respect. It resides in a ‘moral free space’ where fiscal communities and nations have their own ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Constructualism and Deontology Frameworks in Business Ethics Essay”, n.d.)
Constructualism and Deontology Frameworks in Business Ethics Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1444305-business-ethics
(Constructualism and Deontology Frameworks in Business Ethics Essay)
Constructualism and Deontology Frameworks in Business Ethics Essay. https://studentshare.org/business/1444305-business-ethics.
“Constructualism and Deontology Frameworks in Business Ethics Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1444305-business-ethics.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Constructualism and Deontology Frameworks in Business Ethics

Business Ethics and Deontology

...Business Ethics and Deontology Introduction With the increasing pace of globalization, the transformational changes within the business operations are often observed in order to meet the ultimate expectations of the consumers. Consequently, business ethical concerns have emerged as an increasingly significant threat for business organizations. In order to maintain business ethics and professional working environment, it is necessary to incorporate feasible principles and moral values to maintain an effective balance in between the expectations and the interests of the stakeholders....
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Business Ethics and Deontology

...? Introduction Ethics refers to behavior that characterizes an individual or an organization in its daily running of activities. Business ethics is diverse in nature in that apart from it dealing with the world, it interacts with consumers on a one on one basis. Over the years, we have seen business organizations gaining a bad reputation. (Barry, 2000) Deontology on the other hand, refers to moral obligation and undertaking of duties with the right motives (Darwall, 2003). A business problem refers to a gap that exists between desired results from the normal results. Most businesses deal with problems and constraints...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Business ethics and deontology

...? Business ethics and deontology of the of the Table of Contents Adelphia communications scandal: A brief summary 3 Key ethical problems 3 Deontological ethics 4 General theory 4 Immanuel Kant's Categorical Imperative 5 Deontological framework of business ethics: Adelphia Communications scandal 5 Kant's Categorical Imperative 6 References 8 Adelphia communications scandal: A brief summary Trust is a key element in capital markets that affects its functioning and performance. Confidence of the market agents is developed from the level of trust that is experienced by the market actors, when they make business transactions with one another. The Adelphia Communications scandal that occurred in 2002 is an example of breach of trust... private as...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Business Analysis & Requirements Frameworks

...? Business Analysis & Requirements Frameworks Executive Summary Ambridge Software Ltd (ASL) has been declared as asoftware development organization whose specialization is to develop and tailor customized software in order to make them meet the needs of small and medium enterprises (SMEs). The managing director heads the top leadership, who has senior managers who report to reporting to her. The senior managers include the manager in charge of Software Development, manager in charge of Sales and that of Accounts (Thayer & Dorfman, 1997). At present, the Software Development Manager is the head of the software development. He is in charge of operation in the development together with the different Project...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Deontology and Utilitarianism

...productivity adheres to Deontological Ethics. Conversely, the VP who values privacy over productivity is a follower of Utilitarian Ethics. Although the respect for privacy is given more weight and is applicable for the majority, it does not necessarily mean that this choice is correct. These are the two frameworks which compose the possible options which can be taken. Each differs from the other in that in the first one the actions (improper use of computers during office hours) are given more weight, and in the other, the common good (privacy) is given greater preference over employee performance. As discussed in the introductory paragraphs of this piece, the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Business Ethics and Deontology SLP

...Introduction A business problem refers to a gap that exists between desired results from the normal results. Most businesses deal with problems and constraints instead of prime movers of ethical business. In this study, we will analyze a business problem using deontological ethics (Barry, 2000). An ethical problem which I have confronted in a business situation I work in an organization where suppliers have to buy tenders so that they may be able to supply our company with goods and services. As a company, we do have laws that govern the tender awards and in most cases it is the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Utilitarianism and Deontology

...and deontological perspective that offer two interesting comparative views. Human cloning has dominated science fiction for decades with scenarios revealing how the practice could go terribly wrong. Ethical debates have proposed many other unique issues with cloning; everything from the development of unforeseen genetic flaws, to the devaluation of life, to whether, or not, a cloned being will have rights and even a soul. (McGee) However, it is the incredible potential of medical “miracles” that cloning might allow, in all its forms, which includes, ending infertility, eradicating genetic diseases, curing illnesses, replacing damaged organs, and last but not least, the ability to create life as they see...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Normative Ethics: Utilitarianism and Deontology

...Normative Ethics Affiliation: The search engine market continues to experience enormous growth and development, with new and improved technologies driving this key realization. Although there are numerous players and participants in this market, Google, Inc. has secured a significant share of the market. The company dominates the search engine business globally. Just like any other business enterprise, Google has had its ups and downs as far as its business operations are concerned. Amid this, the company has successfully formulated and implemented business strategies that have enabled it to take advantage of newly developed technologies. However,...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Analytical frameworks

...Analytical Frameworks and of the ment of problemA number of firms in various industries have been unable to realize adequate profitability. A good number of businesses report a profit which is below or equivalent to that of an industry average. This factor is attributed to the presence of various forces on a market that influences the ability of a firm to serve consumers effectively. These forces, subsequently, affect the success of a firm as far as profit making is concerned. Analyzing the Porters Industry Framework and Business Competitive Edge In an attempt to solve various problems as regards earning a competitive edge and eventual profits, Porter formulated a business analysis framework. The Porter’s theory is known... . A case...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Deontology, Utilitarianism, and Virtue Ethics

...Deontology, Utilitarianism, and Virtue EthicsEthics defines a set of acceptable values in a society and is a subjective force to behavior and interactions. There are, however, different ethical theories that explain behavior and this paper discusses utilitarianism, deontology, and virtue ethics, and the theories similarities and differences. Deontology, Utilitarianism, and Virtue Ethics: Description, Similarities, and Differences Deontology is one of the commonly applied ethical theories and is based on Immanuel Kant’s philosophy. According to the theory, morality of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Constructualism and Deontology Frameworks in Business Ethics for FREE!

Contact Us