StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

To What Extent Do Toledoth Yeshu and Graetz Agree the Historical Jesus is Not the Jesus of Christology - Literature review Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The essay "To What Extent Do Toledoth Yeshu and Graetz Agree the Historical Jesus is Not the Jesus of Christology?" observes none of the historians give historically reliable data regarding the historical figure of Christ, referring to religious sources - the Bible, Torah or the Qur'an, which are not considered trustworthy by the experts…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
To What Extent Do Toledoth Yeshu and Graetz Agree the Historical Jesus is Not the Jesus of Christology
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "To What Extent Do Toledoth Yeshu and Graetz Agree the Historical Jesus is Not the Jesus of Christology"

Download file to see previous pages This view of Jesus must be relatively recent in Jewish literature since the author of the Toledoth Yeshu (TY) has a very different take on Jesus and Christianity.  Jesus is identified as a historical personage but he is not shown as having an interest in developing Christianity – rather he is more concerned with developing a cult of worship around himself: “Yeshu proclaimed, "I am the Messiah; and concerning me, Isaiah prophesied and said, 'Behold, a virgin shall conceive, and bear a son, and shall call his name Immanuel.'" He quoted other messianic texts, insisting, "David my ancestor prophesied concerning me: 'The Lord said to me, thou art my son, this day have I begotten thee.'" Graetz holds a more modern view of the relationship between the historical Jesus and Christianity.  He says: “High-minded earnestness and spotless moral purity were his undeniable attributes; they stand out in all the authentic accounts of his life that have reached us and appear even in those garbled teachings which his followers placed in his mouth….” (149) Graetz believes that Jesus initially thought of himself as a preacher following in the footsteps of John the Baptist by reaching out to the abrianim and am ha-arez.  Graetz reminds us that Jesus said, ”I am not come to destroy but to fulfill….” This leaves open the question of how the TY could be so different in conclusion from Graetz and other writers in this field.  The answer may lie in the respective audiences for which the authors were writing: the TY’s medieval audience (c14th century) wished to hear a derogatory account of Jesus and Christianity, whereas Graetz was writing a scholarly history of the Jewish people for the erudite.

What evidence is there that Jesus was divine?
Both the TY and Graetz are certain that Jesus was not the son of God, and Graetz refers to him as a ‘mortal’.  One would have expected the TY to deny that Jesus had divine powers.  ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(To What Extent Do Toledoth Yeshu and Graetz Agree the Historical Jesus Literature review, n.d.)
To What Extent Do Toledoth Yeshu and Graetz Agree the Historical Jesus Literature review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1535231-compare-the-toldot-yeshu-with-heinrich-graetzs-views-on-jesus
(To What Extent Do Toledoth Yeshu and Graetz Agree the Historical Jesus Literature Review)
To What Extent Do Toledoth Yeshu and Graetz Agree the Historical Jesus Literature Review. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1535231-compare-the-toldot-yeshu-with-heinrich-graetzs-views-on-jesus.
“To What Extent Do Toledoth Yeshu and Graetz Agree the Historical Jesus Literature Review”. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1535231-compare-the-toldot-yeshu-with-heinrich-graetzs-views-on-jesus.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF To What Extent Do Toledoth Yeshu and Graetz Agree the Historical Jesus is Not the Jesus of Christology

Jesus & Mohammed Paper

... people to praise and worship him, there are numerous examples of them so doing. Magi, the leper, the blind man, apostles, disciples, the man with unclean spirits, and even angels worshiped him (The Bible). In fact, there are instances when Jesus told others not to worship him, as it was when he rebuked Satan saying “thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve” (Matthew 4:10). Mohammed did not agree that Jesus was the son of God and referred to him as to the one of many messengers and prophets that were before and will be after him (The Quran, Sura 5:75). Unlike Christians, Muslims only worship God Almighty, and Mohammed has a place of the messenger and the servant of God and is revered and honored as such. Both Jesus...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Jesus & Mohammed Paper

... today. Through the teachings of Jesus, Christians have continued to show mercy on other people across the world. Jesus taught his disciples how to pray and therefore, this has been adopted in the Christians worship (Hafez.et.al, 2000). He taught his followers to do wonderful and greater things than what He did. As a result, Christians have continued to pray for the sick, visiting the needy and recruiting new followers to expand the gospel of Christ to the rest of the world. Christians also sing songs of praise to their master as a sign of worship. They also read scriptures about Jesus Christ regarding his birth, death and resurrection. This has become an integral part in Christian lives because it has strengthened their faith in the gospel...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Lessons from Jesus

... Lessons from Jesus The gospel books of the Bible provide intriguing insights into the life of Jesus Christ, who is the central figure in the Christian faith. Some of the accounts elaborate his ministry and the demonstration of high power in addressing the needs of the people. Despite his good deeds, the Jews organized a plot of getting him crucified. This paper will consider these events and analyze how they are applicable in different contexts. Summary Miracles in Mark 5 and John 11 In the fifth chapter of the gospel book of Mark, the author relates powerful signs that Jesus performed. The first twenty verses of Chapter five of Mark describe how Jesus freed a man from the demons that had possessed him. Background information...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Jesus

The Sower and The Seed: Luke 8: 4-15 The parable of the Sower and the Seed was taught by Jesus and was likewise clearly explained in the Gospel. According to the parable, the sower was on the way to plant some seeds. On the way to the place where he was to specifically plant, some of the seeds fell in different places: in the way side, on a rock, and even on thorns. As expected, these seeds eventually withered and died. Only the seed which were planted in good ground became productive and bore fruits. Jesus likewise explained here that the seeds were the word of God and the different types of ground are people who listen to the word. The lesson that Jesus tried to impart was that people who are honest, who have a good heart, and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Religion (Jesus)

... Jesus portrayed himself in which his personal attractiveness with his distinctive way of speaking glitters with its full enlightenment. The kingdom of God was presented in most impressive manner. Kingdom of God was explained in the words of Jesus. The parable of prodigal son interpreted more than theological truth, where we become inwardly involved in a process of transformation. The younger the older son confronts us with the situation where one questions, "Where do I stand Am I more the younger or the older son Or am I both" The motif of the two brothers indicates the inner polarity of souls. The parables are always aimed at reversal and transformation of audience perception and introducing a new concept of God and fellow...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Jesus

... of the of the Concerned 22 May 2009 Jesus Jesus was definitely a luminary and an exceptional personality, not only in his own times, but the relevance and importance that his message commands for the times to come. However, a concerted effort was made by the vested interests to bifurcate the legacy of Jesus' message from His undeniable Jewish identity and ancestry. It became imperative for the Church, for some reasons to establish that that Jews happened to be a narrow, selfish, opportunist and xenophobic lot, and their social and spiritual credentials were and are purely earthy as compared to the celestial personality of Jesus and His universal message. Paul certainly made a concerted effort to distance the persona of Jesus...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Jesus Language

...The Parabolic Method of Teaching by Jesus Christ The Parabolic Method of Teaching by Jesus Christ By A significant portion of the teachings of Jesus Christ in the New Testament made use of parables. Parables, as used in the New Testament refer to stories in which the teachings and messages of Jesus Christ were incorporated and conveyed to the audience. When asked by his disciples why He teaches using parables, Jesus responded in a statement that is today subject to so much debate. Jesus however did not invent the parabolic method of teaching as parables were a common teaching tool before and during his time. However, Jesus perfected its use through perfect execution of the method and it was during his use of them that parables were...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Lead like Jesus

... and having love. Leaders motivated with self-interest tend to place their agendas, status, safety and gratification above those people they influence. In such cases, the leaders become self-serving and not serving leaders. Self-serving leaders view feedback as criticism and a threat to their leadership style (Blanchard and Hodges 41). They do not offer a chance for the members to contribute to the development of organization or team The heart of a servant leader involves being meek, humble and loving. The depiction of love in all issues undertaken including the disciplinary action will ensure harmony in the group. A servant leader must focus on the well-being of others and not him. Jesus in his servant leadership model employed the use...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Jesus Film

Jesus film Questions: Module 2- Part Jesus Film Worksheet How themes such as "sin," "sacrifice", and "relationship with God" apply to the story of Jesus and their significance to a Christian worldview.
"Sin" is a major theme in the film. It is the reason Jesus came to the world, to liberate human beings from sin. The act of liberation had to come at a price. This is a "sacrifice" aspect of the film, where Jesus, being the son of God, left the glory in heaven in order to come down to save human kind. Due to sin, mans "relationship with God" had been strained, and it had to take an act of sacrifice by Jesus to restore the relationship.
What do the events of Jesus’ birth reveal about who Jesus is?
Jesus’ birth in the humbles...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Muslim jesus

In Islam, however, while Jesus is not divine, he certainly existed and was regarded a great teacher of his day. Upon examining various accounts of Jesus and his time spent on earth, it is prudent to conclude that the Muslim account of Jesus is more similar to the true account of the historical Jesus as compared to the Jesus of the Christian faith. This report will, therefore, reflect the reality that the historical Jesus can be seen as more of a zealot or criminal as opposed to a divine being, as recounted in the varied accounts of the Christian gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.
While Islamic teaching does regard Jesus as having been a human being who was a messenger of God, the Muslim faith rejects the idea that he...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Concept Mapping of Social Communication and it's HIstorical Contexts

Communication being a complex social phenomenon relies on a number of related phenomena and processes, particularly history and traditions in communities or human groups, cultural determinants in a certain society, the political context in which a community or group exists, yet, gender and ethnical variables that also play significant role in the processes of information exchange.
There is no doubt that a researcher attempting not only to define the nets of informational exchange in a social group (whether it is a community of organizational environment) but also to provide a solid analysis of communication, needs to evaluate all of the above-outlined variables. Knowledge and past experience, for example, determine both the q...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

To What Extent Was the Bombing of Dresden Justified

An analysis of whether the bombing of Dresden was “justified” needs to start with an examination of whether the whole concept of “area bombing” was justified. Area bombing was first suggested by Charles Portal, of the British Air Staff, in 1941. The destruction of whole cities was thought to be an effective manner of quickly breaking civilian morale. Among cities that had been attacked since 1942 included Bremen, Frankfurt, and Cologne. One method to effectively destroy large cities was the dropping of bombs filled with highly flammable materials such as magnesium, phosphorus and petroleum jelly – the so-called incendiary bomb. The area would catch fire, hot air rose rapidly and colder air from outsid...
9 Pages(2250 words)Term Paper

To What Extent Is It Still True to Say That Legal Justice in England and Wales Rests on Adversarialism

The fact that England and Wales are historically under the common law systems; it would not be surprising if there is still a great extent of adversarialism in said country.  

To understand more about the concept and the possibility of assessing to which the system still exists, let us try to go back in history. Wikipedia said, “Some writers trace the process to the medieval mode of trial by combat, in which some litigants, notably women, were allowed a champion to represent them. Certainly, the use of the jury in the common law system seems to have fostered the adversarial system, and there are many today who believe that it remains the best way of providing for the determination of a disputed issue. On the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

To What Extent Does Advertising Romanticize Cultural Consumption

As a society, we are embedded in a culture of consumption. Neil Postman (cited in Kenway & Fitzclarence, 1999, p. 300) notes that by the age of forty the average American will have seen well over one million commercials and have "close to another million to go before his first social security check". “In order to comprehend the impact of all this advertising, on the society we must learn how to see through advertisements, for they are not just messages about goods and services but social and cultural texts about ourselves”. Root (1997) has pointed out:

As long as you are unable to decode the significance of ordinary things, and as long as you take the signs of your culture at face can free yourself from...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

To What Extent Did the Constitutional Treaty Meet the Objectives Set for It by the Laeken Declaration

Peter Hain, Secretary of State for Wales speaking at Westminster Hall on the Convention on the Future of Europe noted that ‘the protocols envisage a formal role for national parliaments.

A treaty establishing a constitution for Europe was signed on 29 October 2004 in Rome and is required to be ratified by all Member States by November 1, 2006.3 Articles 1-2 of the Constitutional Treaty are consistent with the main goals expressed by the Laeken Declaration. The opening Articles declare that the European Union is founded upon mutual respect for basic human dignity, democracy, equality, human rights and the rule of law in general. The Articles go on to maintain that these goals and values are the mutual concern of al...
12 Pages(3000 words)Term Paper

To What Extent Does the Concept of Emotional Intelligence Point Towards a New Means of Controlling Workers

Weber believed that ‘the specialized experts organized into smoothly functioning units by the bureaucratic managers would provide these elite managers with a decision-making ability foreign to the parliaments and the courts’ (Glassman et al., 1984, 5). However, in order for the role of managers within bureaucratic environments to be understood, it is necessary to proceed to a thorough examination to the structure and the characteristics of such an environment under normal social and political conditions.

Moreover, the acceptance of Weber’s views on bureaucracy has led to the assumption that bureaucracy (Fry, 1989, 41) ‘is not necessarily rational, it may not be efficient, that other forms of orga...
11 Pages(2750 words)Assignment

The Extent and Importance of Secular Musical Influence

Barring Islam, all religions preach love, peace and universal brotherhood.
Islam, with the exception of Sufi order, promulgates Prophet Mohammad or Allah, as the most reverent one and adhering to the diktats of the Quran, as the most important duty of all the Moslems. The fanatic and often dogmatic approach to the religious preaching of Quran and Shariat, have led to increasing dissent among the various moderate and the extremist factions of Islam, throughout the world. Sufism, on the other hand, is the mystical and esoteric dimension of Islam, probably evolved after the death of Prophet Mohammad, which teaches universal brotherhood and believes in self-realization as the only path to knowing God or Allah. Islam spread from A...
11 Pages(2750 words)Assignment

To What Extent Can HRM Add Value to an Organization

The human resource management supports the companies in devising a comprehensive strategic plan by setting specific goals and focusing on their resources, strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. It is on the basis of these plans the management recruits, hires, trains and motivates the members of the staff in order to work on the same lines as described by the management. Management is, scholars opine, far more imperative in comparison with marketing, finance, advertising, and sales, because it has a direct connection with the personnel responsible for the good name and fame of an organization. The Human Resources Management function includes a variety of activities, and key among them is deciding what staffing needs you...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

Historical Analysis Long-Term Care

In accordance with a survey published by the U.S. General Services Administration in 2004 ‘the number of elderly people residing alone without living children or siblings is expected to reach 1.2 million in 2020 — up from about 600,000 just a decade ago’ (U.S. General Services Administration, 2004, online article). Apart from the elderly, people with disabilities – as well as those with severe problems of health - also require continuous assistance in all their activities. The care of people belonging in the above categories is likely to last for quite a long (in most cases for the rest of their lives); for this reason, appropriate changes in existing legislation are made periodically in order to meet the n...
7 Pages(1750 words)Report

The Extent to Which Unemployment Is a Microeconomic As Opposed To a Macroeconomic Problem

...Explain the extent to which unemployment is a microeconomic as opposed to a macroeconomic problem, and discuss the relevance of this analysis for government policy to reduce the rate of unemployment. Name: Roll No: Class: Subject: Teacher: Date: 26th April 2009 University Explain the extent to which unemployment is a microeconomic as opposed to a macroeconomic problem, and discuss the relevance of this analysis for government policy to reduce the rate of unemployment. Introduction One important goal of microeconomics is to analyse market mechanisms, which establishes relative prices of goods and services and allocation of resources limited by nature among the alternative uses of these goods and services. Microeconomics steps in when...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Literature review on topic To What Extent Do Toledoth Yeshu and Graetz Agree the Historical Jesus is Not the Jesus of Christology for FREE!

Contact Us