StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Christian Worldview in the Golden Compass - Movie Review Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This paper tells that movie "The Golden Compass" tries to prompt children to look at all forms of authority (including religion) critically. In the rational-secular world view being celebrated by the creators of the film, the truth will always hold a primacy and superiority over power structures…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.3% of users find it useful
Christian Worldview in the Golden Compass Movie
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Christian Worldview in the Golden Compass"

The Golden Compass is a bold movie in the sense that it tackles a major social malaise – namely religious authority. Although references to Christianity in particular and God, in general, have been removed from the film version, there is no doubt that the sweeping authority of the Magisterium includes these two sources of authority. The clue that religion, especially Christianity is being criticized is evident from the original novel by Philip Pullman that goes on to claims that "'The Christian religion is a very powerful and convincing mistake... Every church is the same: control, destroy, and obliterate every good feeling... For all its history [religion] has tried to suppress and control every natural impulse" (Pullman as quoted in Burke 2007). The worldview espoused or promoted by the movie is very different from the Christian worldview. The former suggests the application of rationality and equitable humanism whereas the latter promotes dogma and exclusion on communal lines. What Weitz has attempted to convey in the film is the corruption that is inherent in institutions of power. Under the pressure of marketers to make the film appealing to all, Weitz had to remove explicit references to religion. In their stead, Weitz erects this abstract Omni-authoritative organization called the Magisterium. Weitz (and by extension Pullman’s) proposition is that any form of authority should be questioned by those who come under its purview. They encourage even children to question the authority of elders, albeit with proper manners. It is through this freedom to question authority that progress is ever possible. It is through this attitude of free-inquiry that truth is established and marked as such. The Christian worldview is very contrasted to the one conceived by Pullman and Weitz. The Christian doctrine is full of commandments, warnings and graphic descriptions of retributions awaiting the unfaithful. Neither does it allow believers to question, verify and modify the set doctrine as demanded by the evidence. The church, the foremost institution that wields Christian religious authority, is a closed and uncompromising institution. It is this rigidity and the attendant abuse of power that The Golden Compass seeks to critique. (Scaliger 2007) Director Chris Weitz had a challenging task of watering down the decisive anti-religious stance of the author. But Weitz manages somehow to use the device of the allegory to imply religion without bringing its name. For example, terms like ‘heresy’, ‘oblation’, etc are common in Christian texts. Their use in a contrived secular context does not remove the obvious allusions to the sources. By showing the tendency towards tyranny in any power structure, Weitz is simultaneously showing the alternative way forward, namely, one based on rational and egalitarian public discourse. This is a progressive world view, although it might appear a tad utopian. Through the numerous twists and turns in the plot as well as the several minor and major intrigues through the narrative the director keeps coming back to the central theme of excesses of authority. It is ironic that just as if to prove what the author-director team was suggesting, Christian organizations took a vociferous approach to censor and ban the film. This reactionary and intolerant behavior merely serves to indicate what the movie seeks to expose. Pullman and Weitz could not have dreamed of better evidence for the voices of religious authority than in the manner in which Christian associations across the United States tried to undermine the commercial success of the film. Perhaps, too, it is an indication of the changing cultural currents that many people flocked to the movie theatres despite protests and threats of a ban. (Wood 2008) It should be remembered that The Golden Compass was targeted at a family audience. Children and teenagers especially would find their fantasy-adventure storyline very engaging. A theme of religious authority would seem an unnatural ally to such a genre. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Golden Compass Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1486548-the-golden-compass
(The Golden Compass Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1486548-the-golden-compass.
“The Golden Compass Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1486548-the-golden-compass.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Christian Worldview in the Golden Compass Movie

Crime in a Christian Worldview

... with suffering humanity, affirms suffering humanity, and heals suffering humanity. “Do you know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit, who is in you, whom you have received from God? You are not your own; you were bought at a price” (1 Corinthians 6:19, 20). God forbid the claims of others against another person’s life and the claims of man on their lives (“A Biblical Perspective,” n.d.). In addition, the Baptist contended that assisted dying violates the sanctity of human life, (“What are Christian,” 2009.) while, Roman Catholic firmly opposed to both suicide and euthanasia (“Euthanasia and Christianity,” 2011). The Laws Regarding Assisted Suicide In the United States of America, since the legalization of abortion was ratified...
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Christian worldview 2

...? Christian Worldview Malisa Anderson (Your school) Christian Worldview The Bible is considered to be the bestselling book of all time. It is also said that it is the most complete book. Some even claim that everything about humanity and its existence is in this holy book. We just have to know where and how to find the information we need in the Bible. Even the aspects of research and program evaluation can be found in different passages of this Book. Amazing, is it not? Genesis tells the wonderful story of creation, chapter 1 starts with the creation of the earth, sky, oceans, and animals of the waters and of land, plants and every living thing on Earth. After the creation of these things God saw that it was good, rested on the 7th day...
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Worldview

... include the physical being of individuals, which makes for the perfect environment for individuals. Such understanding may bring forth a relaxing feeling knowing that the universe will always take care of what it causes, and all that is caused will eventually, take care of the universe. It is through this worldview that humans find themselves perfectly placed in an environment that has or creates natural order, without the presence of any Supernatural phenomenon (Meister & Copan, 2013). In conclusion, in comparison to the Christian worldview, naturalism tries to bring out the physical state of the immediate environment. Christianity, on the other hand, wishes to convince an individual’s mind of something that is not physical in nature...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Worldview

...?Part I am a Baptist Christian by belief. I would consider it to be one of the most diverse religious beliefs; the fact that there are many Baptists churches across the world that do not follow one central authority, or that there are varying beliefs that we hold while holding on to the collective Baptist religion clearly proves the diversity and the acceptance thereof. To be a Baptist, to me, means that a person can be “different” from the others yet still be part of the same collective. This is a beautiful and inclusive message, and that is why I would describe my worldview as diverse and inclusive. The core beliefs of Baptism include that there is only one God, who manifests Himself in three persons: the Father (God in Heaven), the Son...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Christian worldview

... dominion over all the created things, both living and non-living (Genesis 1:26-28) (Version, 2011). According to the Bible, God has chosen humans to be the leaders and rulers of the world. They have the authority to rule over all the living creatures on land and in the sea. Humans have more dignity than all the created animals in the sea and on land. Despite the fact that humans are more rational and have been chosen to be rulers over all other creatures, this does not give them the authority to harm other animals or living creatures. A suitable rationale for all human beings is created by the biblical worldview. One of the common problems in the Christian worldview is suffering. The vast population of the universe assumes that suffering...
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Christian Ethics Moral Compass

...Business: Christian Ethics Moral Compass INTRODUCTION: The decision making compass guides the users in their desire to improve the leadership process. The research delves on the importance of the decision making compass. The research delves on the four modes of the compass. The compass values enhance the leadership process. The decision making compass areas: A) Purpose-Will this action Serve a worthwhile purpose? The end must be worthwhile. The business is correct in pursuing its purpose. The main purpose is to generate revenues, a worthwhile purpose. To generate revenues the business enterprise is correct in implement the means to achieve the purpose. The business of using the competitors’ prices as a basis for setting...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Christian worldview of financial accounting

...Christian worldview of financial accounting Christian worldview of financial accounting Introduction As a Christian, there is a great necessity to look and consider all the world’s aspects. There should be a clear distinction between the secular worldview and the Christian worldview. It has long been assumed that Christians are old school and narrow minded. It is true that Christians are called to follow, as well as pursue the God’s purpose. However, the business field requires the Christian worldview more than anything else. Christianity advocates for honesty and transparency, which are very essential aspects in the business world (Clements, 2012).  The paper analyzes the importance of financial accounting from the Christian world view...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

My Christian Worldview

...Christian worldview of Life, Death, Human History, and External Reality Christian worldview is different from Naturalism, Postmodernism, Existentialism, Nihilism, and Deists on a number of aspects ranging from life to death. Christian Theism bases all its arguments on the Holy Bible while other Theisms may not necessarily refer to a god who controls the universe (Ekstrand, 2008). Christianity takes a completely different approach in regards to the fundamental issues of life in that it takes an Almighty God as the Creator of the Universe and human beings. In addition, Christianity looks at God as the Originator of life and death and that only the righteous ones can gain salvation (Anderson, 2014). Although other belief systems may differ...
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Christian Foundations of a Secular Nation

America is a nation that was founded by Christians even though the present shape is secular. However, a study of the history of the forming of the constitution suggests that the founding fathers wanted to have a Christian nation. Yet at the same time, I do not think that they would be disappointed by the shape of the nation as it stands. On the other hand, they might be disappointed by how the presidency has become little more than a punch line for late-night shows.

From a cursory look at the constitution, a person may be tempted to say that it is entirely secular and makes clear divisions between church and state and has no mention of Christianity or religion whatsoever. However, a deeper analysis of the question shows...
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Connection between Holocaust and Jewish-Christian Relations

A history of anti-Semitism and it is a prevalent belief in Christendom that the Jews, as the murderers of Christ, deserve all possible sufferings is the reason that Hitler's massacre of the Jews was met with silent acceptance from the vast majority of his subjects. The continued anti-Semitic feelings of the Church stem from Christian teachings based on interpretations of the New Testament that have also contributed to the Holocaust and the persecution of Jews in Europe over the centuries.
In 1814, Jews in the Papal States were locked into cramped ghettos at night, were forbidden to practice law or medicine, to hold public office or to hire Christian servants. Meanwhile, elsewhere in Europe, Jews were increasingly free to live...
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

Heresy in Early Christian Church

Conclusion: The attitude toward heresy and the reason for its formation and the church’s opposition to it is stated in general terms.

Heresy was the term used to characterize those groups of religious sects that challenged in some way or another, the ideology that came to be accepted at orthodox Christianity. While many of the heretic groups differed in their beliefs and norms they were united by a common notion that the Church did not represent their particular values and beliefs. They were predisposed to reject and isolate themselves from the Church and its one-dimensional views of Christianity. The Church, in turn, viewed these detractors as heretics and rejected them, isolating them and persecuting them for th...
11 Pages (2750 words) Report

Integrating the Christian Faith into the Science of Counseling

..., if that therapist is properly trained, is no more probable to transgress a client’s value independence than any other therapist. Obviously, compassion and tolerance for the diversity of religious and spiritual practices, in addition to the multicultural domains, are ethical conducts anticipated of every mental health professional. To behave or act otherwise obviously infringe the ethical standards of their profession (ibid). IV. Gray Collin’s View of Counseling The mainstream of Christian counselors in the contemporary period is not satisfied to depend singularly on the Word of God. Numerous Christian counselors have aimed to combine their theories with the Bible in anticipation of ‘integration’. At the midpoint of majority...
13 Pages (3250 words) Assignment

Christian Identity Movement

verted to this religion believe that finally they have found their true identity by discovering that they are the descendants of the tribes of “white” Israel that were lost (Quarles 2004, p.7).
When any group of people say that they are superior to others on the basis of the race they belong to and also inculcate the belief that they are the only chosen people of God and not the people from other ethnic background, then one can very well say that that group or the organization is practicing racial beliefs. People who follow the Christian Identity believe that the people from Caucasian ethnic background are true Israelites and hence they are the only people from the God’s family (Quarles 2004, p.9). The teach...
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

People as Cultural Beings and the Christian Posture

In recent times questions regarding the impact of Christianity over culture have become so prevalent that several of the modern intellectual disciplines consider it an archetype of orthodoxy that is aimed at restraining the newer cultural trends (Niebuhr 1956 p. 1-2).
However, the existing historical shreds of evidence clearly convey that despite Christianity has always been one of the most important factors in the context of determining people’s reciprocation towards a particular cultural trend, but different civilizations at different points of time have denied the impact of the Christian culture as those perceived that it can be a threat against individuality of their respective cultural tends, “Not only Jews b...
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

Biblical Christian Worldview and Secular Humanism Worldview

...Biblical Christian Worldview and Secular Humanism Worldview Introduction “Absolute truth belongs only to one class of humans...the class of absolute fools”1Even though science and technology has developed a lot, the miseries surrounding life before birth and after death is still not unveiled. While atheists or secular human believe in natural evolution theory and the superior power of human over everything in the world, others believe that everything in this universe is controlled by God. Some religions like Hindus believe in multi God theory whereas most of the other religions believe in single God theory. The definition or perception of the God by different religions is different. Christians believe in single God theory...
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Falling Down Movie

...Falling Down Introduction After taking some time and watching Falling down a couple of times, one’s mind seems to keep pulling new information. I first saw this movie as a crazy man roaming around Los Angles, but after the third viewing I could see who this man really was and what he cared about most. At times he still came off crazy, but in his point of view he was the normal one. Joel Schumacher did an excellent job of showing the image and unconscious underbelly of society throughout this film. This essay examines the film through a deep analysis of its narrative and associated elements. The essay also offers a personal perspective on the film, and considers it as compared to Paul Haggis’ Crash and Mathieu Kassovitz La Haine. Analysis...
13 Pages (3250 words) Movie Review

Christian Worldview in Comparsion with a Naturalist Worldview

...Comparison between Christian Worldview and Natural Worldview The basic dichotomy between the Christian Worldview and the natural worldview is that when the first one is based on a self-existent god, the second considers that nature is self existent. A worldview is generally considered as the conceptual and theoretical foundation depending on which man interacts with his or her surroundings, more generally speaking with the world in which he or she lives, as James W. Sire says, “A world view is a set of presuppositions…which we hold about the basic makeup of our world"1. It comprises of a man’s interpretations of the world and his ways of organizing his belief, assumptions and, theoretical and empirical findings about the world. Obviously...
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

The Golden Era of Soccer

... s Soccer, "The Golden Era" 1921-1933 “The Golden Era” in American soccer was between 1920- 1933 (United States 37). The initial America league was in 1921. The league attracted enough prestige which necessitated concrete competition among European players into the American league. During the 1920/1921 season, the two American leagues (National Association Football League and South New England Football League) faced exceptionally severe financial crises. This led to the split of the teams participating in both leagues. The separation was on wealth bases where richer teams joined together and formed a new league (ASL). The ASL was the most complex professional league in United States of America at that time (United States 37). ASL emerged...
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review

Contained Technologies in Iron Man Movie

...Term Paper IRON MAN 3 Iron man 3 is a science fiction blockbuster movie based on Marvel comic. The movie features asmart, wealthy businessman cum scientist and an inventor who gets kidnapped by Afghan terrorists. The terrorists kidnap the billionaire for his scientific invention capabilities. During his time in capture he develops a super-weapon suit in which he uses to escape and to bring justice as the movie progresses. Key stars in the movie include; Robert Downey who is the main actor, Jr Gwyneth Paltrow, and Jeff Bridges among many others (Burr, Ty 50). This movie basically is a showcase of technology already in use or being developed with additions of fantasy technology. The main notable technology that makes up the movie is the use...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

References from the Bible in Boxing the Compass

... of the of the of the References from the Bible in Boxing the Compass The book Boxing the Compass provides the reader with a third person narrator who follows a woman into her house. The woman is the main character in the novella that walks reluctantly, waking into the anniversary of her mother’s death. After rising from her bed, she dresses, leaves the apartment, goes to buy bread in a nearby bakery, and then returns into the apartment. She makes tea, takes a bath,and leaves the house again. She boards an urban commuter train and moves towards her mother’s graveyard.She has memories about her mother, father, and brother where she meditates about time and space. Her meditations relates with an ocean undergoing climate change...
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Movie Review on topic Christian Worldview in the Golden Compass Movie for FREE!

Contact Us