Free

5 & 6 - Coursework Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Q#1: Unlike what is depicted in many lawyers themed television shows, (Chapter 5) depicts the courthouse as a place dispensing “assembly line justice”. Through its use, many victims and defendants are given closure with a timely disposition of their court cases. However,…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
5 & 6
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "5 & 6"

Chapter 5 & 6 Q Unlike what is depicted in many lawyers themed television shows, (Chapter 5) depicts the courthouse as a place dispensing “assembly line justice”. Through its use, many victims and defendants are given closure with a timely disposition of their court cases. However, “assembly line justice” may prevent a smaller number of cases from getting individualized attention. Do you support the use of “assembly line justice” or do you feel it is unjust? Explain you position.
I strongly dispute the use of “assembly line justice” and feel that it is in some way unjust. Despite the debatable assertion that it is important to apply the “assembly line justice” concept because of the large caseloads compared to the resources and personnel needed to handle them, there are a myriad of considerations that are overlooked. Using assembly line justice means that cases do not get individual attention and there are not questions of fact or law that are raised and as such, dispositions in such cases are just routine.
This concept is particularly unjust because, important aspects of a case may be overlooked and as such the dispositions made may be unjust or cruel, despite the fact timely closure for both victim and perpetrator is given. This is because defendants and appellants rights to trial are denied; most cases end with a plea bargain, usually of guilty simply because the court considers the cases routine (Neubauer and Fradella 123). Additionally, this concept of assembly line justice has shifted the focus of courts from the traditional due process procedures, whereby, the courts’ actors, specifically defense attorneys and prosecutors, were required to prove their cases beyond any reasonable doubt before any resolutions can be achieved or reached to courts trying to reach resolutions without any adjudication (Neubauer and Fradella 124). Therefore, using the assembly line justice concept on the mere argument that it helps deal with the issue of excessive caseloads is neither here or there, since it clearly overlooks other fundamental aspects of the court system including the rule of law, local legal systems and the relationship with organization. Therefore, the use of assembly line justice is not just and should not be used.
Q #2: The Supreme Court has decided that prosecutors (Chapter 6) are to be immune from civil lawsuits arising from them acting in their official capacity. Without this type of legal protection, it was feared prosecutors would hesitate to do their jobs because they would be scared of being harassed by future civil lawsuits. Critics believe this blanket protection will encourage the violation of defendant rights. Do you support or oppose this immunity? Explain your position.
According to Neubauer and Fradella (139), prosecutors are expected to prosecute with vigor and earnest, strike hard blows, but he/she is not allowed to present false evidence, strike hard foul blows. They are required to refrain from using methods that are improper and calculated to get a conviction at all costs, even if they are wrongful, Berger v. United States 1935, 88. In my opinion the decision by the highest tribunal to grant prosecutors absolute immunity from civil law suits is proper, and, therefore, I support. This is because prosecutors are very important players or actors in the criminal justice system as argued by Justice Robert Jackson that, “…they have more control over liberty, reputation and life…”, their duties bridge all the duties of other actors in the criminal justice system (Neubauer and Fradella 138). In order for them to perform their duties well-earnestly and vigorously prosecute-, it is important for them not to be in fear of any civil suits. This immunity does not imply that prosecutors are at liberty to use unfair, unjust, unlawful means to push through a conviction or violate the rights of the defendants; it is meant to ensure that they do not hesitate in doing their jobs because of fear of harassment by future civil lawsuits. It is worth noting that, there are certain circumstances in which prosecutors may be sued civilly, and some of the court decisions are overturned in the event that prosecutorial misconduct is determined. Therefore, the fear that this immunity will encourage the violation of the law and defendants’ rights is unfounded and incorrect.
Works Cited
Neubauer, David W., and Henry F. Fradella. America’s Courts and the Criminal Justice System. 10th ed. Belmont, CA: Cengage Learning, 2010. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“5 & 6 Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
5 & 6 Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1613212-5-6
(5 & 6 Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
5 & 6 Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1613212-5-6.
“5 & 6 Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1613212-5-6.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF 5 & 6

Business research: MRF Sections 4 - 5- 6 -7

...?Hi! If you don’t mind I’ll just be writing on this sheet for clarity. (BTW, the font, color and boldface are just for ease of locating my responses.?) 4.2 You did not answer this one. “These participants are the population….” Well, I used this information to modify the comment in 4.1 (see the highlight: “the middle and top level managers of the oil and gas companies.” The comment in 4.2 was connected to the comment in 4.1 which asked about the population. So, I just took what the prof identified as the population, and put it in 4.1 because I think that was his/her intention. On its own, the comment in 4.2 does not require an answer, it didn’t ask for anything. 5.3 Comment 3 In this item, for each data collection method (you’ll... If you...
16 Pages(4000 words)Research Paper

If you would provide a 5-6 page paper on Groupon, applying the principles of marketing

...in the minds of the consumers. If all these steps are followed correctly and effectively then it ensures the success of the product or service. (Kotler and Armstrong 4-5) Groupon primarily focuses on major geographical locations where people have easy access to the internet; are literate, and there are successful companies operating in those areas who can offer the products and services and then, it approaches those companies with its offers and from there on, their marketing process proceeds accordingly. The company is following the marketing process very well. It analyses the major geographical locations to gain knowledge about the needs and wants of the customers of that particular location. It then approaches those...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Organizational Climate and Culture Report, 5-6 pages

...? Organizational Climate and Culture Report of the AT & T Organization 0 Organizational Climate and Culture Report of the AT & T Organization 2.0 Introduction The AT & T Organization that is headquartered in Dallas, Texas involves itself in the production of smartphones, sophisticated solutions to be used by multinational enterprises and the provision of Broadband Television services (AT & T., 2012). They have been involved in the provision of these technologies for more than a century and are renowned for the production of products or services that are reliable, innovative and high-tech (Wichinsky, 2008). This paper describes its organizational culture and climate, its mission and values and also describes the interviews... Organizational...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Liyuan Stanford 19970 5-6 days services

...Essay A: What matters most to you, and why? 750 words To identify a higher purpose, a greater cause and a moral value in every stratum of personal and professional life, and working towards it is what matters to me the most. Being true to these values all along the aspects of personal growth, career development, entrepreneurship, and community services would help me discover the truth of life. These values were identified when I had to strive across the challenges and break out of the restrictions to achieve transcendence in personal growth. My passion for dancing was challenged when I had to quit as my physique out-grew other girls in the team and became the odd one. My determination kept inspiring me to get across the challenge...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Assignment 6 Strategic Planning Process - Steps 4, 5, 6, and 7

...In order to respond to the complex competitive environment, it is really critical that the firm and its management must undertake systematic understanding of the external environment. The assessment of the environment in order to identify the opportunities and threats to the business, various strategic management frameworks can be used. One of the most effective one is based on the assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of the business and to identify the opportunities and challenges. The SWOC framework therefore is the key to understanding the market dynamics and how the firm can basically tailor its strategies to take benefit out of the opportunities arising while at the same time successfully meeting the challenges... order to respond...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Ch.5 and 6

...faith in the Constitution is whole…and I am not going to sit here and be an idle spectator to the diminution, subversion, destruction of the Constitution…” Jordan puts herself forth as an example of a good American citizen. Mythos is an appeal founded on cultural values. She stresses the contrast between “a president grown tyrannical” versus the “preservation of the independence of the executive” as one of the time-honored distinctions made by the democratic American. 2. Three types of propositions discussed in Chapter 6: The first is the proposition of fact, which deals with alleged facts which are debatable or inconclusive. An example of this is the allegation that: “The police power of stop and search is used by...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Unit 5 & 6 - POL 2000

...u06d1 - Challenges Between Nations European case: After the nearly universal implementation of E.U as a currency, nations like Turkey and Norway (Johnson, 2002) were the two to stay away from the common currency. This was based on number of factors. With Norway not wanting to lose an edge in its industries of potential advantage by merging with others. Another clause was that of adherence to the Copenhagen criteria fulfillment which some were reluctant and others failed to fulfill therefore resulting in their barring from the same currency entry. American Case: In case of introduction of same concept and common currency the same obstacles might come to forth in case of American continent. With each country enjoying its leverage... -...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

Journal #5 and 6

...Weekly Journal Week 5 Focus on Activities This week, I attended the FCM weekly staff meeting with my preceptor and two other assistant supervisors. The supervisors gave a staff announcement regarding upcoming new events and also how the Nurses could get CEU’s for their RN license renewal. My preceptor informed the staff that she was in the process of hiring two new employees and would be starting interviewing a few selected candidates in the next couple of weeks. She asked the staff members if they had any questions or unique experiences in the field that they wished to share with the group. The meeting lasted for couple hours. Later in the afternoon, my preceptor told me that she had to go for a couple of urgent...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Bus Lw AM Wk 5 6 7

... Business Law WEEK 5 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS Putting a limit on the award of punitive damages is a considerably sensible guideline. While the compensatory damages are for the reimbursement for the loss of the plaintiff, the purpose of punitive damages is to punish the defendant in case of solid and unambiguous evidence of the commitment of crime. The award of huge amount of money in the name of punitive damage, may give rise to certain complications. Additionally, since the award of these damages is in the hands of the jury, there is a risk of corruption of the legal system, and may give rise to an abnormal shift in the balance of power. 2. The Liebeck v. McDonald’s case is a perfect illustration of the modern civil justice system... personnel....
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Module 5, 6 and 7

...Topic: Consultancy Assignment 4: Consulting in a transcultural and transnational world Many businesses are currently trying to expand their businesses through attempting to understand the society and the market in general. To attain this, they are hiring consultants to use their expertise in advising them how best to serve their clients depending on the facts they gather about the market. However, each consultant has their own background, cultural values, ethnicity and nationality all of which determine the perspective from which he or she will perceive things. There are therefore several aspects of consultancy that the consultant should be well conversant with to enable them handle their clients’ needs effectively. The three... Consultancy...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Coursework on topic 5 & 6 for FREE!

Contact Us