Nobody downloaded yet

Insanity and Criminality in Literature - Book Report/Review Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The nineteenth century was a period of socio-political turmoil. Technological advances, rapid cultural changes and the evolution of alternate worldviews all combined to inspire a reconsideration of the human condition and man's status in the world and vis-vis others…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Insanity and Criminality in Literature
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Insanity and Criminality in Literature"

Download file to see previous pages . . are seen as contestable, but those of science as inconvertible" (6). In earlier times the reverse was true: religion was inconvertible and science was contestable. Although the shift that granted science technical status as "the accurate reading of Nature's book with eyes undistorted by social interest or cultural prejudice'" occurred over a long period of time (Wright and Treacher 4), in the narrow context of insanity and culpability the shift from moral conceptions of insanity to physiological conceptions of insanity occurred during the nineteenth century when voluntarist discourse, with its assumptions of free will, individual responsibility, and self-discipline, conflicted with determinist/fatalist discourse, with its assumption of inevitability and the inescapability of predetermined fate.
The conflict between these different worldviews led to confusion regarding normal versus abnormal human behaviour and, indeed, to debate over sanity versus insanity. The question became whether humans freely chose their path and was their path imposed upon them. Needless to say, the implication here was that man's status in the universe and his role in his society/world were all questioned. In his 1874 treatise Responsibility in Mental Disease, Henry Maudsley maintains that this questioning led to confusion and, in turn to a feeling of loss, in the sense that humans were no loner anchored down by specific sets of beliefs and understandings. This sense of being lost and without anchor led to the evolution of "a borderland between crime and insanity, near one boundary of which we meet something of madness but more of sin, and near the other boundary of which something of sin but more of madness" (36). In this borderland, judgments of insanity involve not only medical distinctions between sanity and insanity but also political distinctions between legal and illegal acts, and philosophical distinctions between moral and immoral acts. Physicians, lawyers, politicians, reformers, poets, novelists, and the public participated in the debate over legality versus criminality, fatalism versus determinism and sanity versus insanity. Among the novelists who participated in this debate were Dostoevsky and Poe, both of whom questioned the very nature of criminality and sanity. Within the context of their respective novel and short story, these question were asked through the actions and thoughts of their monomaniacal protagonists.
Both Poe and Dostoevsky create fictional worlds which are supportive and nurturing of their protagonist's monomaniacal tendencies. These worlds are, ultimately, unreal in the sense that they have been coloured by their protagonists' skewed worldviews; worldviews in which the imaginary and the real merge, prompting actions that, while thoroughly criminal, are expressive of mental suffering. Dostoevsky focuses on the connection between irresponsibility and self-created depression and monomaniacal obsessions. His protagonist abdicates his personal and social responsibilities, withdraw from the immediate and concrete reality in order to focus on the real/imagined insults which society and the political system have inflicted upon him. Poe is also interested in the consequences of isolation, but he delves more deeply into the morbid consequences an individual's "insane" behaviour has on others and on his own self.
As may have been deduced from the foregoing overview of insanity versus sanity, the legal versus the illegal, ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Insanity and Criminality in Literature Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
Insanity and Criminality in Literature Book Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532410-insanity-and-criminality-in-literature
(Insanity and Criminality in Literature Book Report/Review)
Insanity and Criminality in Literature Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532410-insanity-and-criminality-in-literature.
“Insanity and Criminality in Literature Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532410-insanity-and-criminality-in-literature.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Insanity and Criminality in Literature

Famous Insanity Defense Cases

...hospitalized. Whilst the hospital staff recommended medication to him, he categorically refused to take it. The Supreme Court granted this case certiorari. c) John Wayne Gacy Gacy is a famous case of unsuccessful insanity defense. He has been found guilty of raping, torturing and killing over 30 young men and boys, in spite of Gacy admitting to having committed those crimes, but pleading insane. 2. The Andrea Yates case The Andrea Yates case is one of the most mediated criminal cases involving insanity defense of the 21st century. Unfortunately, this is due to its dramatic implications. However, in spite of the horrifying implications, the defense attorneys managed to...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Theroies Behind Female Criminality

...? Female Criminality Smart (2009) observes the rare concern of criminological theories in analyzing female criminality. Typically, criminologists would discuss women offenders under general theories with men or unsatisfactorily briefly under special or marginal categories. In the context of a patriarchal society, most researchers would pay less attention to female criminality. This paper gathers statistics from various sources to show the trends in female criminality, particularly in the US, citing the nature of common crimes committed by women. In trying to explain the observed phenomena, the paper analyses critical theory, feminist theory, strain theory and biological...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Insanity plea

... The Insanity Plea Introduction Insanity plea entails criminal law in which the accused alleges that he or she is guilty with regard to mental incompetence at the given time (Anderson and Gardner 120). It is one of the several defense mechanisms that have been used in weighty cases all over the world. It is used by the criminal defendants where the accused must be absolutely impaired by a mental disease or defect at the time when a crime is committed to enable him or her receive such a defense (Torre 97). Actual Defense The insanity defense is one of the numerous misused features of the forensic psychiatry that does not only allow sane persons to impose ‘insanity traits’ in courts but it also allow to criminals or dangerous people... to...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Insanity defense

...?Insanity Defense Introduction The criminal law requires criminal conviction to fully satisfy the presence of both the criminal act ‘actus reus’ and the criminal mind ‘mens rea’, grounded on the belief that the commission of a crime necessitates an evil intent. This requisite of the particular state of mind gives insanity defense room in the criminal justice system. (Reznek, 1997, p. 15) By pleading insanity, a defendant may avoid culpability of a criminal act on the ground that “a defendant cannot be held accountable for a crime if his mental illness made it impossible for him to...
4 Pages(1000 words)Term Paper

Insanity

...? Insanity People do not just become insane without any reason. There are a whole lot of reasons that bring about insanity in someone. At the same time, insanity has multiple effects, although all of them are destructive either of one’s sanity or even of one’s life. Nevertheless, through the various pieces of American literature one learns that insanity is a part of human nature whose cause is a great desire to express something and whose result is always destruction. In the story “The Most Dangerous Game,” one can see that General Zaroff is insane as he is so engrossed at the idea of hunting people as he would animals,...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Hamlets Insanity

...Hamlet’s Insanity Madness is a complex of the brain that is complex to discern. This of the brain is hidden, and it develops over time. In the play Hamlet, Shakespeare has depicted Hamlet as a sane or insane person depending on the situation. However, this turns out tragically for Hamlet. In the play, Hamlet feigns madness so that he can discover the truth behind his father’s death (Shakespeare 29). This plan proceeds well, but he slowly begins to slide down the tunnel to insanity. This causes his mind to go out of control. What started as an act of antic disposition or insanity becomes less of an act and it ends up to Hamlet’s reality and tragedy. In my opinion, Hamlet...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Insanity Defense

...The insanity defence directly speaks to mens rea because its primary focus is the mental capa or intent of the perpetrator upon the commission ofthe offense. In other words, as determination of criminal culpability is inextricably linked to intent and, importantly, awareness, a guilty finding is predicated on the establishment of intent and awareness, on mens rea. Within its legal context, insanity specifically focuses on mens rea or intentional and mental capacity. As regards the stated, there are three approaches to the insanity defence, all of which may be defined as standards. These are the M'Naughten, Durham, and ALI defences/standards/models. Following a brief...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Crime and Criminality

...Quantitative & Qualitative Approaches 2 A look into the Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches to the Study of Crime and Criminality Nations around the world regardless of might and power, form of government, number of populace, territorial regions and resources at hand all have a similar battle - the struggle for peace and order. That one fight against crime and criminality. This one vision for a nation stable against internal and external threats against the citizenry. Albeit pushed in various strategies with varying policies in curbing the problem, battling crime and criminality has unified the world even as world leaders and policy makers struggle to find a common denominator in the process of achieving acceptable peace... and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Insanity defense :

...The insanity defense has been a relatively recent phenomena in court cases having first appeared in 1843 at the trial of Daniel M’Nagten, a woodworker Scotsman who killed the secretary to the British Prime Minister in a mistaken attempt to kill the man he believed was targeting him (Martin, 1998). As a result of this trial, judges determined the insanity defense might be invoked if the defendant was operating “under such defect of reason from disease of the mind” as to not realize that what they were doing was a crime (Martin, 1998). It is this right versus wrong idea that has formed the basis of most of the American laws regarding this defense argument. Yet, the insanity defense has...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Insanity

...The Insanity Defense is used more frequently than necessary, but only a few cases fit the criteria for this defense. It is wrongly presumed that if a defendant has a mental illness that they can use the Insanity Defense. However, the law in most of the fifty states require a defendant to not know right from wrong to be acquitted on the basis of legal insanity. Only three states have a law against using the Insanity Defense. This paper will take a brief look at several cases that have used the Insanity Defense successfully and unsuccessfully. The first case where the Insanity Defense should have been used, but was not, is the case of...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Book Report/Review on topic Insanity and Criminality in Literature for FREE!

Contact Us