Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Application of State and Federal Law within the Reservation - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Most research shows that it is according to what law you are talking about. There does not seem to be an even application of all Federal or all State laws across Reservational jurisdictions. There are many laws that are considered the exception and under some circumstances are beneficial to the reservation and under others are beneficial to the State or Federal Government…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
Application of State and Federal Law within the Reservation
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Application of State and Federal Law within the Reservation"

Download file to see previous pages These constitutions at one time gave the tribes quite a bit of power in making decisions and enforcing legal contracts with the people. However, over the last few years tribal power has been diminished with the most dramatic decrease happening with the Indian Civil Rights Act in 1968. Under this act, tribal courts are denied the power to impose sentences in criminal cases in excess of $5,000. and/or one year in jail (Robertson, 2001, pg 9). This has become a very big issue in taking care of criminal problems on the reservations. To add to the problem, if a tribal member feels their rights have been violated, they cannot take that to Federal Court, it has to go to Tribal Court. Congress has also made the tribes responsible for Environmental Laws as determined by the Federal Government as well as Federal Tax laws.
The United States government maintains that it is the guardian for the tribes or trustee. This role came from the Cherokee Nation v Georgia ( Robertson, 2001, pg 3) This allows the Federal Government to hold the underlying fee title for reservation lands. That is why they are called trust lands. This guardianship capacity like all guardianship laws allows the Federal government to impose legislation affecting Indians that are the best for them. They are supposedly held to a very high standard for this. Tribal status under all of these laws is considered a political classification.
Prohibitory State law applies to reservation land, regulatory does not always. This allows the State and Federal justice system to enforce environmental laws. The reason they can do this is because most environmental laws are prohibitory in nature. On the one hand the Federal government sees that they probably do not have the right to enforce such laws on Indian land but they are also responsible for the welfare of the people under their guardianship clause. It appears from many reviewed cases that the Federal government chooses to enforce when it is convenient to them (www.senat.leg). It is not done the same way every time. This is one of those places where the Reservation Court would not have jurisdiction to enforce because it is Federal law and because the charge is greater than $5,000. It places the tribal enforcement in a poor place because they cannot enforce but are obliged to report. In this case, the advantage seems to be on the side of the State and Federal governments.
Another legal situation that has recently come to light based on the reservations and Federal law is the case the IRS and the auction of Indian lands to pay Internal Revenue taxes. This is one of the poorest Indian Reservations in the nation. The lands belong to the Crow Creek Sioux Tribe. The Federal government says they own Federal income taxes. The tribe has been trying to develop wind energy and this is the land that is set for that development. The land to be auctioned is 7100 acres (Martin, 2009). The law says that Indian tribes are not usually susceptible to tax laws. They are when there is business entities associated with the tribe. The IRS says the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Application of State and Federal Law within the Reservation Research Paper”, n.d.)
Application of State and Federal Law within the Reservation Research Paper. Retrieved from
(Application of State and Federal Law Within the Reservation Research Paper)
Application of State and Federal Law Within the Reservation Research Paper.
“Application of State and Federal Law Within the Reservation Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Application of State and Federal Law within the Reservation

State-Federal Controversies

...?Federalism Checks the Power of the Central Government The article discusses the issue on the advantages of adopting a federal form of government. Federalism is considered by the author as a way of checking the power of the national government (Bodenhamer). To note, in a federal government, the power of the government is shared between the local and national government (Bodenhamer). This goes to say that both of them have the authority to exercise the rights accorded by the U.S. constitution. America’s colonial history has affected the decision to adopt federalism. The American people do not want to be governed by a single authority just like the past...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

U.S Government : Federal vs. State

...?Federal vs. The debate of the power of the federal versus the government has been occurring since the Revolutionary War. It was formed out of the idea that the former British colonies had just won independence from a monarchy, therefore why would they want to put themselves back under one rule. In addition, the colonies were way more autonomous than the states that are composed today in modern day. The debate began with the Federalist and the Anti-federalists. When the first legislature was formed, it was designed so that while the Federal government had power, the states’ still retained some individual autonomy and had representation in the federal government. Even today, that power struggle still continues. The United States... is...
1 Pages(250 words)Dissertation

Secession of a Federal State

...? SECESSION OF A FEDERAL SECESSION OFA FEDERAL United s, in the past, had suffered greatly on matters concerning the civil war before Abraham Lincoln was elected as the president. Moreover, some of the decision made by the president continued the civil war and led to the division of the federal states. This paper is an experiment analysis debate of the issues that were brought up by Abraham Lincoln, and their effect to the country. Part I Fellow citizens, we have fairy backpacked, on our duty, to elect Abraham Lincoln as the head of 1860th government. President Lincoln for long has been featured as black republican, revolutionist and a like to John Brown character. One...
4 Pages(1000 words)Term Paper

Oklahoma Employment Laws

...states in the country and has tasked the Oklahoma Human Rights Commission as an agency of Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) to have the elective capacity to administer its civil rights enforcement. The Genetic Non-Discrimination Act (36 OS 3614.2) of Oklahoma "cannot discriminate in employment based in results of genetic testing (DNA, RNA, chromosome testing). Except for determining coverage or benefits employer may not even ask for such testing." Federal law provided the Health Insurance and Portability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) to provide some protection against discrimination however this act does not ensure: "the limit of collection by insurers and prohibit them from requiring...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Federal and State Governance implement in general incarceration as a punitive measure. An analysis of the nature of the crimes in both states provides may provide insights to the differences in policies. The incidence of violent crimes as well as recidivism in California is higher while Texas shows lesser recidivism and significant higher prison population. According to Kaplan and associates (2002), Texas' law shows greater inflexibility in the use of incarceration as a penal measure citing that the nature of crime in the state historical justifies the application of such measures. Given that the United States follows a federal system of government, each...
30 Pages(7500 words)Essay

International Law, the Vienna convention on the law of treaties 1969

...) that are not formally parties to the Vienna Convention.  It defines a reservation to a treaty as "a unilateral statement, however phrased or named, made by a State, when signing, ratifying, accepting, approving or acceding to a treaty, whereby it purports to exclude or to modify the legal effect of certain provisions of the treaty in their application to that State." A reservation is permitted unless the treaty itself prohibits it, or permits only specific reservations not including the one in question, or if the reservation is incompatible with the purpose of the treaty. Under customary international...
20 Pages(5000 words)Essay

Federal versus State Courts: Florida

...Prof’s Federal versus Courts: Florida The United s has courts divided between the Federal and the State level. States in my home state, Florida, differ significantly in details from the operations, source of laws, and so forth from Federal court. It is important to make a distinction between true Florida courts, and United States Federal Circuit Courts that merely reside in Florida. Source of Laws is the most obvious. The Florida court was established by the constitution of the state of Florida, while Federal Courts were established...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Federal required security within federal buildings

... Federal Security within Federal Buildings Federal government facilities and buildings’ security is of utmost importance as it not only affects the daily activities of the federal government, but it also affects the safety, health, and well-being of federal employees as well as the public at large. The government of the United States has a very important obligation of assuring the peace of mind as well as the physical safety of the numerous Federal employees and members of the public who go to the Federal government facilities and buildings. Unfortunately, over the years, federal government leased/owned property has been susceptible to terrorism acts as well as other kinds of violence (Smith, 2). This paper delves into this topic... of...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Federal vs State Law

...of some of the state laws were eventually put to light as seen in the case of Adams. Thus, the need to revise such laws that predetermined a suspect’s innocence or guilt was raised. Van Orden v. Perry Thomas Van Orden took Texas to the federal district court on the grounds that the Ten Commandments monument at the state capitol building an unconstitutional in that it violated the First Amendment's establishment clause (Unger 34). According to Orden, the law prohibited the government from passing laws that respected religious establishment. The district court and the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals all ruled against Orden....
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Federal vs. State Immigration Laws

...government claims that laws on immigration passed at the state level are a "patchwork" of the already existing immigration laws and would consequently not solve the country's immigration problem Conclusively, per chance a federal and state law contradict, then if one is within a state he/she can follow the state law; however, federal police have the jurisdiction to stop such. Whenever there is a conflict between a federal and state law, the former prevails. Thus, immigration policy setting and...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Application of State and Federal Law within the Reservation for FREE!

Contact Us