StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Tort Reform - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Tort Reform Instructor Institution Impact of Tort Reform on Health Care A tort is defined as a civil wrong which would be substantial as to bring a suit in a court of law. For an offence to be a tort, it has to have resulted into injury or harm upon the injured party…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
Tort Reform
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Tort Reform"

Tort Reform Impact of Tort Reform on Health Care A tort is defined as a civil wrong which would be substantial as to bring a suit in a court of law. For an offence to be a tort, it has to have resulted into injury or harm upon the injured party. Tort proceedings and legislation is intended to mitigate the injured party against damages and to act as a deterrent against such commissions occurring in the future. Health care and medical practitioners have also been subjects of tort proceedings involving their clients. A tort proceeding in health care is usually intended to protect the clients from professional negligence, lack of provision of informed consent, and medical battery (Chepke, 2008). Torts are usually classified according to whether they are intentional or non-intentional, which normally informs he type of remedy and punishment meted out to the plaintiff in such a suit. Recent developments in tort reform have made the issue of tort in health care attain new meaning and importance. Maine and Medical Malpractice Tort Reform The state of Maine has one of the highest rates of medical malpractice premiums in the United States (Williams & Mello, 2006). With the soaring costs of insurance, the state legislature felt that a ceiling on the damages that are to be awarded in instances of medical malpractice of pain and suffering would be appropriate. The proposed cap on pain and suffering damages is supposed to set the ceiling at $ 250,000. The proposed plan has elicited controversy among medical practitioners, insurance providers and victims counsel. The proposal was brought about by the Maine legislature as a result of successful implementation of the same in other states such as Florida and Massachusetts. Issues that Necessitating Reform Tort reform in Maine State is as a result of issues and factors that are not unique to the state. Many other states such as Florida and New York have had the same issues and passed similar legislation to reform their medical malpractice tort laws. The main issues that have led to the proposals for medical malpractice reform is with regard to the increase in the amount of premiums that practitioners have had to pay to insurers against medical malpractice suits (Williams & Mello, 2006). High premiums charged by insurance companies were unfair to practitioners and were hurting health care hence defeating the objective of malpractice legislation. The state legislature believed that non economic damages suffered by patients ought to have a cap imposed on them. Excessive awards by juries have to be settled by the insurers of these practitioners. Since awards are often too high, the insurers have to charge high premiums in order to hedge against losses in medical malpractice claims. Solutions Awards on medical malpractice are usually awarded to the claimants by juries in courts of law. It has become a norm rather than the exception that the amount offered to the claimants is typically higher than what is expected which means that the insurers have to pay higher amounts (Eviatar, 2011). The state of Maine would thus limit the maximum amount that can be awarded to a claimant at $250,000. These will have the effect of making juries make lower awards since only the most deserving cases would be awarded the ceiling amount. Medical malpractice ceilings will however, only be applied in cases of non economic damages such as pain and suffering. These are cases in which no fiscal damage can be quantified against the claimant. Success of Tort Reform The proposed legislation has been controversial since its implementation. There have been varied views on its effectiveness in reducing the costs of insurance to medical practitioners and health care in particular. Since its introduction, costs of insurance with regard to medical malpractice suits have come down to a degree though not to the level that had been projected (Eviatar, 2011). Insurers have been blamed for not bringing down their rates even as their costs have certainly come down with the introduction of the caps. Insurers have on the other hand defended themselves in saying that they the ceiling rate of $ 250,000 was still too high to make premiums come down substantially. Insurers are also of the opinion that setting such a ceiling would increase the tendency of juries awarding amounts that are near to the ceiling. They contend that there was a chance of lower awards if there is no ceiling than when there is a ceiling (Chepke, 2008). The legislation has however been successful in reducing the number of malpractice suits brought before courts since the incentive of huge monetary awards has been clipped. The measures to reduce the cost of healthcare is however not a function of medical malpractice premiums alone and more needs to be done to address the other factors that are driving up costs. References Eviatar, D. (2011). Tort Reform Unlikely to Cut Health Care Costs. The Washington Independent, 7(5), 5-6. Chepke, L. (2008). Medical Malpractice. Boston, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Williams, C., & Mello, M. (2006). Medical Malpractice: Impact of the Crisis and Effect of State Tort Reforms. New York: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Tort Reform Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1435625-tort-reform
(Tort Reform Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1435625-tort-reform.
“Tort Reform Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1435625-tort-reform.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Tort Reform

The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005

...The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005. On February 24, 2004, a bill was introduced in the House of Lords that sought to redefine the role of the judiciary and after amendments, has finally been approved by both Houses as the Constitutional Reform Act of 2005. The purpose of this reform is directed towards strengthening democracy and enhancing the credibility of public institutions1 while also recognizing the value of judicial independence and the need to preserve it.2 The major provisions of the Constitutional Reform Act include: (a) abolishing of the office of Lord Chancellor (b) creating a new, independent Supreme Court to replace the system of Law Lords (c) creating a new Judicial Appointments Commission. (d) Provisions...
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Tax Reform Situation in American

The tax process has been reformed, changed, developed, organized and is now one of the most complicates codes of law in the world. Some of the reforms underway are still being debated and they must be examined to show how the reform process takes place in America.

Overall, American taxation involves payments from individuals to four levels of government depending on where they reside. Taxes are due to the local government i.e. district or country, to the regional bodies like schools and utility providers, to the state government and finally, to the federal government. Other than general income tax on companies and private persons, the American government collects taxes and contributions for Social Security, Medicare and...
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Tort Law of the United Kingdom: 3 Problem Questions

Trespass on land, goods, and person is altogether the most common type of tort, but in all cases, the main concern is the allocation of responsibility for whatever losses are sustained. For anyone party to be held responsible for violation of the tort law, the claimant must establish that there is a duty of care and that there has been a breach of that duty to cause damage or loss to the claimant that needs to be compensated by an award of damages. There is a breach of the duty-of-care principle if the defendant is proven to have failed to do what a reasonable person will do in the situation presented.

Francesca was a chambermaid of good standing at Hulton hotel until a regular hotel guest stormed into the manager&rsquo...
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Act Tortious: Homeowners File a Tort Claim against a Theme Park

In criminal law, the state is portrayed as the bigger offended party than the plaintiff such that if a defendant is proven guilty the state metes out the appropriate punishment.  It is different in tort cases, in which the plaintiff, whose more popular assignation now is “claimant,” is the victim of the alleged wrong.  Once the defendant is found liable he is directed by the court to pay damages to the claimant or else to desist from the wrongful activity through “injunctive relief.” Compensation and deterrence are two of the four main purposes of a tort, the other two being appeasement and justice (Williams, 1951). 

The types of torts in England and Wales are limited to trespass t...
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Company Law Reform Bill

...February 2007 Company Law: Company Law Reform Bill The Companies Bill (earlier popular as the Company Law Reform Bill) is a major steptowards extensive reform of UK company law. The government considers that these principles while long established lack certainty and are not easily accessible. Very often, directors have to take advice in these areas so as to ensure that they do not inadvertently breach any duty enshrined in the case law. The government therefore believes that codification of directors’ duties will make the law in these areas more consistent, certain and accessible. Companies Act 2006 (‘the Act’), which received Royal Assent on the 8th November 2006, codifies directors’ duties including the long-established fiduciary duties...
14 Pages (3500 words) Coursework

The Concept of Security Sector Reform

...Topic: What do you understand by the concept of security sector reform? In what ways could it offer a way forward in weak s? Explain with examples Security Sector Reform (SSR) is a concept that emerged in Eastern Europe in the 1990s. It begins where a malfunction security sector is not capable of providing security to the state and its inhabitants efficiently under secular set up. A spoilt and malfunctioning security sector comes in the way of long term development, democracy and peace. SSR is both operational as well as normative in concept. Security Sector Reform, according to Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (SSR) is “another term used to describe the transformation of the ‘security system’--which includes...
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

A Plan to Reform the US Healthcare System

The regimes need to be proactive in nature which means that the vision of having the related healthcare systems within the US medical departments and hospitals should be an ongoing activity rather a one-step, a reactionary move which usually happens from time to time, usually due to one calamity or a catastrophe that hits the particular region within the United States of America. Thus in this paper, our focus would be set on discussing the healthcare systems that are operational within the US and also pinpoint the gray areas where some particular steps could be taken to ward off the negativities thus attached to them. 

A healthy person is not difficult to define. He or she is a person who does his chores regularly...
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Homicide Law within England and Wales: Is There a Need for a Reform

... expressed himself on the side of the reform saying that England and Wales ‘need a new law of homicide, or a new law of punishment for homicide, or preferably both.2’ As it is not possible for the judges to change the law, all the prominent people who were on the side of an immediate reform urged the government from time to time, to make proper changes in the law. Naturally political parties knew that a reform of that kind will never be popular amongst the people, who would naturally think that too much of lenience has been accorded to the murderers by placing excuses and fresh defences in their favour. Perhaps none of the parties was interested in taking a risk. Still the Home Office press release of 2004, says that a ‘clear, comprehensive...
56 Pages (14000 words) Dissertation

The Distinction Between the Tort of Negligence and the Tort of Nuisance

There are many instances in which establishing a claim in private nuisance does not require proof of negligence and it, therefore, remains necessary to maintain the tort of private nuisance distinct from the tort of negligence. The discussion that follows will demonstrate the necessity by comparing and contrasting both torts.
The tort of negligence is founded on the principles enunciated in the House of Lords decision in Donoghue v Stevenson which essentially defines the duty of care and situations in which a breach of that duty will give rise to a claim in negligence. Lord Atkin explained that we are required to take all necessary precautions to prevent injury to our neighbours. He goes on to fully explain the duty of care i...
17 Pages (4250 words) Case Study

Applied Land Law, Contract Law and Tort Law

There seems to be a lack of consideration to accompany the subsequent agreement between the parties for ABC Ltd. to pay the extra ₤10,000. In essence, ‘consideration’ refers to something of value, in a legal sense, flowing from Grabit to ABC Ltd. so as to enable Grabit to hold ABC Ltd. to its promise to pay that extra amount.
Grabit will obviously argue here that they are indeed doing something of value to ABC Ltd by building the extension of the warehouse. However, the problem is that this building of the extension is exactly what Grabit was already contractually bound to do under the ₤200,000 fixed price contract. As seen from Stilk v Myrick1, the general rule is that the performance of an existing contractual d...
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Tort Reform for FREE!

Contact Us