StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Failure of Merger of Equals - Dissertation Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Failure of Merger of Equals" looks at the merger proposal made by Xstrata to Anglo American. The proposal was rejected as unacceptable. The article looks at reasons for mergers and causes of failures. It determines if it would have been successful had it been allowed to go through…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.5% of users find it useful
The Failure of Merger of Equals
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Failure of Merger of Equals"

Download file to see previous pages In terms of efficiency, emphasis is placed on economies of scale or other synergies that may result. Horizontal mergers often refer to economies of scale to be gained; however, economies of scale do not continue to infinity. There is always a point to which they apply, unless more advanced technology can extend it further then diminishing returns is likely may set in.

1.1 Background
In the letter proposing the merger of equals between Xstrata (the bidding company) and Anglo-American (the targeted company) Xstrata (2009a June 17) stated that the combination was being considered for some time and such a merger is a compelling, value-adding proposition for both sets of shareholders while combining a management team that would bring to the table ‘fresh and value-creating opportunities that may not be available otherwise. On June 21, 2009, Xstrata sent out a news release indicating that it notes Anglo-American’s response. Xstrata (2009) argued that the merger of ‘two world-class companies would bring about many benefits. This proposed merger of equals which had no premium attached was expected to create a giant in the mining industry with a market valuation of £40 billion (MacNamara 2009).

Xstrata has grown through a number of acquisitions over the previous five years and wanted to generate economies of scale much like that enjoyed by BHP Billiton and Rio Tinto – which at that time were two of the largest companies in the mining industry. However, Anglo’s CEO Cynthia Carroll indicated that Anglo had superior assets to Xstrata and so the deal had no strategic merit and Anglo would be able to achieve its goals in relation to growth on its own.

1.2 Research Aims
The aim of this research is to determine why Anglo-Americans rejected Xstrata’s merger proposal. It looks at other mergers to determine whether they could have been successful if it was allowed to go through.

The research hypothesis: H0: all mergers are beneficial to both parties
The alternative hypothesis: H1: not all mergers are beneficial

2.0 Literature Review
In order to gain knowledge of what work has been done in this area it is important to review what other researchers have done. This section of the article looks at the reasons that have been given for mergers and acquisitions. It looks at whether mergers are beneficial to both parties (the bidder and the target) and the findings in relation to failed mergers in an attempt to determine the reason for such failures.

2.1 Reasons for mergers
Arnold (2008) indicates that the three main motives for mergers are synergy, bargain buying, managerial motives, and third-party motives. Some of these are similar to Andrade (2001) who looks at economies of scale and synergy, market power, market discipline, and diversification.

2.1.1 Synergies
Operating synergies have been given as one of the primary motives for mergers and acquisitions (Andrade 2001; Mukherjee et al 2004). It is defined as an approach that reinforces the competitiveness of a business by increasing the cash flows that would accrue to both companies independently. The number of expenses that are now paid by both companies would be reduced since only a single payment would be necessary once the companies have merged to become one. They would include audit and accounting fees; fees for advisory services; public relations and stock exchange fees. ...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Empirical Finance: The Failure of Merger of Equals Dissertation”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1397699-empirical-finance
(Empirical Finance: The Failure of Merger of Equals Dissertation)
https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1397699-empirical-finance.
“Empirical Finance: The Failure of Merger of Equals Dissertation”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1397699-empirical-finance.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Failure of Merger of Equals

The main dangers of using mergers or acquisitions as a form of market entry

On the other hand, merger occurs when two companies agree to operate as one new company.... On the other hand, merger occurs when two companies agree to operate as one new company.... As suggested by Turner and Johnson (2010), in both cases, that is merger and acquisition the outcome is that one company swallows another and operates as one.... Practically, equal mergers do not often happen, in most cases a company purchases another and allows it claim that it was equal merger, despite the fact of it being technically acquisition....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Why Firms Merge and the Problem They Cause

This paper focuses on the motivating factors toward mergers and the problems caused by these mergers.... The author discusses why firms merge, some of the reasons why firms merge include the effort to gain market power, tax advantages of gaining a loss-making firm, and efficiency.... .... ... ... The firms should be much more careful when merging, there should be proper communication with the employees about the reasons why the company is merging, a firm should select the most appropriate partner and the negotiation process should take the shortest time possible so that it does not affect the productivity of the firms....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Performance Measurement in a Post Merger Integration Process

The second one has categories on profitability while the class takes in many studies which have used other effects of merger success.... The paper "Performance Measurement in a Post merger Integration Process" will begin with the statement that in the recent past there has been an increasing trend toward the formation of mergers as companies strive to position themselves in the changing world.... Faced with the threat of entry of multinationals as previously closed markets become open, most small companies have found out that a merger could be the only way out of possible loss of market....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Merger of HSBC and Oman International Bank

As the paper "merger of HSBC and Oman International Bank" tells, contemporary business models face challenges such as the competitiveness of rivals and the economic landscape.... The motive of this type of merger is to cut down on competition and maximize factors that can improve the economic footing of both companies.... This research aimed at showing how a bank merger can perform or fail under various circumstances and conditions.... Before considering a merger, various options fall under a business's disposal....
21 Pages (5250 words) Essay

Merger of XM and SIRIUS

The essay "merger of XM and SIRIUS" covers that XM Satellite Radio and Sirius Satellite Radio merged into one company with a subscriber base in excess of 17.... The merger of XM Satellite Radio with Sirius Satellite Radio is an accretive merger, because already the acquired company, XM Satellite Radio, has experienced a rise in its share prices since the announcement of the merger.... On March 24, 2008, the Justice Department approved the merger, thus clearing one of the biggest hurdles....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Mergers and Acquisitions

As already seen, since mergers and acquisitions are not easily categorised, it is no easy matter to analyse and explain the many variables underlying success or failure of M&As.... More often than not a merger is where two enterprises of roughly equal size.... The exception to this is when both parties agree, irrespective of the relative strength and size, to present themselves as a merger rather than an acquisition.... An example of a true merger would be the joining of Glaxo Wellcome with SmithKline Beecham in 1999 when both firms together became GlaxoSmithKline....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment

Merger and Acquisition Processes

The following paper under the title 'merger and Acquisition Processes' is a great example of a management term paper.... The following paper under the title 'merger and Acquisition Processes' is a great example of a management term paper.... The following paper under the title 'merger and Acquisition Processes' is a great example of a management term paper.... It will also discuss the possible problems during merger and acquisition processes and the possible means of solving them....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Roles of Cultural Differences in the Mergers and Acquisition Failures

his has in most cases, been cited as the core reason for the failure of most mergers and acquisitions.... However, general research has shown that the predicted efficiency gains, often do not show up in most merger cases (Søderberg and Vaara 2003; Herndon and Galpin 2013)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us