Informative - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The Bill of Rights, or the first ten Amendments to the United States Constitution, guarantees statutory freedoms to all citizens. Among these freedoms are particular rights of protection from certain aggressions, either from others or from the state. For instance, the Bill of Rights protects citizens from cruel and unusual punishment in the Eight Amendment, which also affords protections against excessively high bail, which would otherwise severely affect the lives of individuals accused of crimes…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
Informative research paper
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Informative"

The Bill of Rights, or the first ten Amendments to the United s Constitution, guarantees sta y freedoms to all citizens. Among these freedoms are particular rights of protection from certain aggressions, either from others or from the state. For instance, the Bill of Rights protects citizens from cruel and unusual punishment in the Eight Amendment, which also affords protections against excessively high bail, which would otherwise severely affect the lives of individuals accused of crimes. Together, these basic elements define the Eighth Amendment as a measure to protect individuals from punishment before being convicted of a crime. Without protection against excessive bails, one could argue that an accused party could be punished even before conviction of the actual crime. Likewise, Eighth Amendment protection ensures that individuals do not serve sentences that do not reflect the nature or severity of the crime, which is a basic element of retributive justice. According to the reasoning behind the Amendment, these limitations on the court’s power to interpret and apply the law are necessary in a system of checks and balances; that is, the Eighth Amendment was created in an atmosphere of a strategic decentralization of power into the separate branches of government. The Eighth Amendment, like most of the Bill of Rights, was inspired by instances in English case law. In particular, the case of Titus Oates demonstrated the need for such protections (Patterson 35). Oates was tried for perjury after wrongly accusing many people who eventually hanged for their offenses. He was sentenced to annual pillory, whipping, and imprisonment. For many, this constituted a cruel and unusual punishment, which led to a 1689 law that banned such punishments in Britain. Like the subsequent American law, this put a limitation on the imagination of judges, who were responsible for constructing punishments for those convicted of crimes. Americans George Mason and Patrick Henry extended this limitation to the powers of Congress in order to prevent laws upholding usual and cruel punishments (Patterson 84). Given that Eighth Amendment protections can be divided between excessive bail stipulations and cruel and usual punishment stipulations, it is obvious that much has changed since the Amendment’s original ratification. For this reason, the role of the Courts is to adjust what exactly defines an "excessive” bail or a “cruel and usual” punishment” (Stinneford 18-22). As Earl Warren reported in the opinion of the Supreme Court case Trop v. Dulles, “The Amendment must draw its meaning from the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society” (Trop v. Dulles, 356 U.S. 86). In other words, as society changes, so much the standards of decency with respect to what punishments reflect the values of society. Of course, the dimensionality of cruelty in a punishment not only reflects what is abhorrent to the general social values and culture, but also in proportion to the offense committed (Finkel 138). For instance, not only might our contemporary society find drawing and quartering a murderer objectionable; contemporary society might also find putting a shoplifter to death a “cruel and unusual punishment” as well. An example of the Supreme Court’s interaction with the Eighth Amendment with respect to the disproportionality of the punishment to the crime came in 1977 with the case of Coker v. Georgia. In this case, the Court prohibited the death penalty in cases of rape committed against a woman. Erlich Anthony Coker, a prison escapee, was kidnapped of rape while serving a sentence for rape, kidnapping, murder, and assault. He was sentenced again on the charge of rape, but this time sentenced to death. After the Supreme Court of Georgia upheld the sentence, the United States Supreme Court repealed the sentence and declared that the proportionality of the punishment must reflect the nature and dimension of the crime. Unlike murder, the crime of rape does not deprive another of life; therefore, it does not involve as “serious” of an injury as does murder, and so does not deserve as serious a punishment (Coker v. Georgia 433 U.S. 584). While outlawing capital punishments in the case of rape is strongly intuitive in terms of disproportionality of punishment to crime, the 2003 Supreme Court case of Lockyer v. Andrade upheld the 50-years-to-life sentence imposed on violators of the Californian 3 strikes law. In the case, the defendant’s third conviction was for shoplifting videotapes that, in sum, were worth about $150. The misdemeanor or felony severity of this shoplifting crime was left up to the discretion of the California court, who inevitably judged it a felony. On top of his prior convictions, Andrade was sentences to 25 years to life in prison. Under this Californian three strikes law, three felony convictions opens an individual up to the possibility of a prison sentence that far outweighs the costs of their crimes. The presumed purpose of this law is to deter individuals who have been convicted of felonies to continue to commit such crimes. However, the United States Supreme Court upheld the legitimacy of this law in Lockyer v. Andrade by ruling that this punishment was not in fact cruel or unusual. The Eighth Amendment was drafted as part of the Bill of Rights in order to protect American citizens from unjust punishments. An excessive bail, like a cruel and unusual punishment, does not reflect the values of the criminal justice system to the extent that individuals are innocent until proven guilty and that those convicted of crimes must be punished proportionately to their crime. As such, the Amendment places a limitation on the discretion (and ultimate power) of the Courts to assign whatever sentence or punishment to the accused that they wish. This limitation prevents the abuse of power that could inevitably damage the legitimacy of the criminal justice system. As mentioned previously, as society’s notions of what constitutes cruel and unusual or an “excessive bail” changes, so must the Courts set new precedents on what is justified and what is not in terms of the punishments handed down to criminals. The Supreme Court will play a vital role in this changing sense of decency. Works Cited Coker v. Georgia 433 U.S. 584. No. 75. United States Supreme Court. 28 March 1977. Finkel, Norman. Commonsense Justice: Jurors' Notions of the Law. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2001. Patterson, John. The Bill of Rights: Politics, Religion, and the Quest for Justice. New York: iUniverse, Inc., 2004. Stinneford, John. "The Original Meaning of "Unusual": The Eighth Amendment as a Bar to Cruel Innovation." Northwestern University Law Review, 102(4) (2008): 1-89. Trop v. Dulles, 356 U.S. 86. No. 70. United States Supreme Court. 31 March 1958. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Informative research paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Informative Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
“Informative Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Informative research paper

Informative Paper on Islam People

...? Religion and theology RELIGION AND THEOLOGY INFORMATIVE PAPER ON ISLAM People who follow the religion Islam are called Muslims. The word “Islam” literally means “submission” which is a word derived which means “peace”. Islam is a monotheistic religion that is articulated by the Holy Quran. Islam is based on the concept of submission to Allah and accepting his supremacy over all and believing in the Holy Prophet and the Holy Quran. One becomes a Muslim by reciting the Shahadah declaring his submission to Allah and accepting the Muhammad is the prophet. Islam is not just a religion; in fact, it is a complete way of life which teaches Muslims peace, mercy and forgiveness (Mawdudi 1975). Islam is a...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Informative Research Paper

...Informative Research Paper Thesis The study is on the eighth amendment of the constitution of USA by considering its history, the people who led to the amendment, the reasons for the amendment and the steps that the Supreme Court has made to implement the amendment. Background Before the amendment came to rule, the federal government had been imposing excessive bail giving excessive fines, and it had been giving cruel and unusual punishment for minor crimes. This is as seen in the case of Robinson v. California, where the plaintiff got unusual and unfair punishment from the California authorities. (Darby 50). The amendment came as part of the bill of rights of 1791. There amendment...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Informative paper

...? Legal Aspects of Internet Governance Legal Aspects of Internet Governance Introduction Hacking and other forms of illegal activities related to computer and internet through which mankind experience huge amount of issues have spread over the past few years of time period. Various forms of internet related issues have been figured out such as cyber terrorism, war, defense and insecurity of information. Policy makers and researchers have tried to counter this problem, but while countering this problem they have to keep in mind various challenges such as right to privacy, autonomy, freedom of expression and communication, access to information and data. The aim of this...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Informative Research Paper

...? Informative Research Paper: Solar Energy Introduction Conventional non-renewable energy sources such as coal, oil, and natural gas are disappearing very fast due to the growing consumption of these natural resources. In addition, the fast emerging economies such as China, India, and Brazil negatively affect the future scope of non-renewable energy sources. Every research to find an effective solution to this growing energy crisis points towards developing potential alternative renewable energy sources. It seems that solar energy is more potential as compared to other renewable energy sources, because it is easily and freely available and causes less harm to the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Writing Consultation Assignment

...? Writing Consultation Learning has never been this fascinating, especially when you consult a professional. On Monday, November 24, I got the opportunity to book an appointment with Jonny Carter, a writing tutor. I wanted assistance on my informative research paper on all the types of baseball bats and how best to put in writing a well-informed paper on bats. Because there are many ways to approach this topic, I had not completed an outline, and Jonny functioned as a sounding board off, of which to bounce my ideas for the paper as well as pointing me in the right direction to get more research about my topic (Bjork,...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


...FAQs Why sell web space in pixels? 2. Is the site credit worthy and our space would be maintained in future also? 3. Are you desperate for fast buck? 4. Who are you and can you give proof of your genuineness? 5. Why have you named your website as gazilliondollarhomepage? 6. Does the mascot in your homepage has special significance? 7. What are the minimum pixels that I can buy? 8. What is the differential element of your website as against the 9. I want to become famous; can you make me a celebrity? 10. Can I introduce chatting option in my space? 11. Will you be hosting my webpage? 12. Will I be able to update my web content, whenever I want? 13. How soon will I become a millionaire if I buy pixels... Why sell...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Informative memo

...Informative Memo Task MEMO Supervisor [INSERT] 23 February Issues and Trends in Communication There are various subjects addressed on the bulletin board about thinking critically within the context of communication. They include psychology, marketing, nutrition, stress, human resource and Information Technology. Wingert, M summarizes an article on IT by highlighting that the article’s audience is business professionals. She acknowledges the positive tone of the article that encourages the sales people to observe confidence with the intention of making their ideas sell. However, she is of the opinion that the article should include more recommendations on juror behavior. Shott, S analyzes ways in which...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review

Informative publication

... Supporting Live Jazz MEMO Christmas Holiday To all Deldo Club Jump for Jazz Friends 14-12- Jump forJazz Jump for Jazz December 14th 2014, will be a day of workshops, live performances and demonstrations. Jump for Jazz is an annual music education event that is planned to be on Sunday 14th 2014 at the Delva Performance Hall, Colorado. Day time will entail free concurrent education sessions followed by a ticketed night concert. This event mainly intends to educate the public, youth in particular, on different types of jazz and how each of them is created and performed. Deldo Club will publicize the event locally targeting mainly the youth population with all our efforts. The Deldo Club organizing committee plans to use all... Supporting...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Informative report

...INFORMATIVE REPORT MEMORANDUM FOR THE NATIONAL MARKETING COUNCIL As requested, information regarding the purchasing patterns of the consumers across the nation was gathered. The information contains the general expenditures by age of primary provider (family of four). The information included consumption of food, tobacco and liquor, housing, clothing, personal care, medical care, recreation, reading, education, transportation and other expenditures. The following table summarizes the consumption: Percentage distribution of expenditures of consumption Under 25 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65-74 75 and Over Food 21.6 23.2 24.8 24 24.9 25.7 26.7 Tobacco and...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Informative Paper open chance to involve notable guest experts or fellow students from other institutions in an online environment as well as permit students get information and resources from across the globe. Here, an instructor can pull together a resource section in the online environment and link it to institutions, scholarly articles and other study materials related to the course topic. These resources are made available for students who undertake research, extension and comprehensive study of the course materials in the global learning environment. Adult education literature allows the use of interactive learning environment, a factor those points to the benefit of creative teaching. This advantage contributes...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Informative research paper for FREE!

Contact Us