StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Max Weber on Capitalism and Its Foundations - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Max Weber on Capitalism and Its Foundations", Weber’s views on capitalism are expressed through the “protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism” and his other writings, which cover the relationship between the ethical values of ascetic Protestantism and the rise of capitalism…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
Max Weber on Capitalism and Its Foundations
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Max Weber on Capitalism and Its Foundations"

? Max Weber on Capitalism and its foundations Part Max Weber’s views on capitalism are expressed through the “protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism” and his other writings, which cover the relationship between the ethical values of ascetic Protestantism and the rise of capitalism. Weber presents the idea that the ideas of different religious groups, particularly the Calvinists, contributed to the emergence of the capitalistic spirit (Kennedy, 2004). He postulated that there was a relationship between being a protestant and engaging in business, therefore reached the conclusion that religion was a potential cause for the development of the capitalistic society. Max argued that the capitalist saw profit as an end on its own, and that the pursuit of profit was virtuous. In tracing the relationship between Protestantism and capitalism, he pointed out the concept of “calling” whose emphasis was that capitalistic activities were inclined to religious values (Grossman, 2006). Marx pointed out that Calvinism, in particular, was a major influence – noting that they associated salvation to success in business; material success and profit-making were viewed as a sign of God’s favor. He noted that other religious groups like the Methodists, pietists and the Baptists identified with the same idea, but to a lesser degree (Grossman, 2006). The idea that profits and material success was an indicator of God’s favor solidified into the basic structures, on which modern capitalism was developed. However, he noted that after modern capitalism matured, the protestant values behind it were disregarded and business ethics took center stage (Kennedy, 2004). It is important to note that Max insists that Protestantism was not the only factor that led to the development of capitalism, but that it was among the factors leading to its development; he added that the emergence of capitalism influenced religious ideas. Part 2: a). Max Weber’s position about capitalism is greatly motivated by the works of Marx’s theory, which emphasized materialism and economic reductionism; materialism and economic reductionism formed the fundamentals of Weber’s idealism. This shows that Weber’s theories and arguments are largely shaped by the frameworks and the foundations developed by Marx. The inheritance of Marxian thoughts is evident from the emphasis that Weber offers to the part played by the materialist outlook of different groups in the consequential development of capitalism (Grossman, 2006). However, Weber’s ideas and arguments are motivated by his tendency to characterize Marx as a deterministic economist; that could be partly attributed to the facts that Weber did not have access to the early writings of Marx. The divergence could also be attributed to Weber’s preoccupation about Marxian views about Germany and Russia during the start of the 20th century (Kennedy, 2004). The positions projected by Marxist thinkers in exploring Russia and Germany played a major role in propelling Weber to take the route he took, in formulating his theories and adopting his points of view on the origins and the development of capitalism (Grossman, 2006). This shows that the political climates of the last half of the 19th century as well as the first half of the 20th century were major contributors and influence to the theories and the positions adopted by Weber, about the origins of capitalism and the factors leading to its emergence. Irrespective of the major differences in the studies and the theories developed by Weber and Marx, Weber preserved many of the thoughts and the thinking developed by Marx. The fact that Weber preserved many of the theories and the models formulated by Marx shows that Weber was greatly influenced by the teachings of the Marxian school, irrespective of the fact that he was fully congruent with their thinking. This could also show that the thoughts and the theories developed by Marx were used by Weber as the basis of his theories; Weber used Marx’s ideas to develop his theoretical models about the emergency and the factors influencing capitalism. The most distinctive revision of Marx’s theories and thinking is that Weber offers more emphasis to cultural and subjective factors, but rejects the historical evolutionary models that could have played a role in the development of capitalism (Grossman, 2006). The emphasis channeled towards the importance of subjective and cultural factors like religious values, the equation of material success with God’s favor and the religious attribution of profit as a valuable contribution to God’s course also shows a different picture. This emphasis on subjective and cultural factors demonstrates that Weber was more explorative of the society of his time; the changes within the society offered a possible answer regarding the emergence of capitalism. For example, he attributes materialism to the religious values of the Calvinists, and more importantly, expanded their materialist outlook to the non-religious society, where the values of religion were considered irrelevant. Weber’s epistemological position, despite the fact that it borrows largely from the models developed by Marx, was informed by the social formation of religion of the time. This is evident from his thoughts that the Calvinists held the belief that profit making was virtuous before God, and that material success was an indicator of God’s favor – this compelled the Calvinists to pursue capitalism as a way of identifying with the religious connotation of materialism and the search for a virtuous life (Grossman, 2006). Further, he notes that other religious groups, including the Methodists, pietists and the Baptists were also inclined to the same belief – despite that they identified with it to a lesser extent. Weber’s insistence on the values of different religious groups and its influence on the emergence of capitalism demonstrate that Weber picked religion as the emphasis of his theories; he emphasized that the religious-based capitalistic views of the Calvinists and other groups offered the foundation for the development of a capitalistic society (Kennedy, 2004). b). Max Weber emphasized the role of social constructions like religion and law in influencing the adoption of different behavioral patterns, and the approaches employed in the economic sphere of the society (Swedberg, 2006). However, he introduces the thinking that while taking the different influencing factors, a sociological outlook should be employed towards the exploration of the motives of social actors, which determine the course of all spheres of social life. Weber’s contribution is evident from his insistence on the role of the motives (social inclinations) of groups and individuals in shaping the society, which complements all other influencing factors like law and religion. Socially constructed systems like law and religion play a major role in the other spheres of society, including the economic (Kennedy, 2004). Through his theories and school of thought, sociologists have developed models of shaping the motives of members of society, which help in ensuring that the other systems established within the society are operational and successful. For example, through appealing to the ethical appeal of individuals, the doctrines of law are more likely to work, than in a case where they were working against the motives and the values of the society. The ethical implications of Weber’s arguments include that the social aspect of the individual plays a major role in the shaping of the society, economic life, legal structures and also their success levels (Swedberg, 2006). This leads to the conclusion that nations and societies should maintain a balance between the different frameworks of society and social life, so that the intended outcomes are attained. References Grossman, H. (2006). The Beginnings of Capitalism and the New Mass Morality. Journal of Classical Sociology, 6(2), 201-213. Kennedy, D. (2004). The Disenchantment of Logically Formal Legal Rationality or Max Weber’s Sociology in the Genealogy of the Contemporary Mode of Western Legal Thought. Hastings Law Journal, 1031-1076. Swedberg, R. (2006). Max Weber's Contribution to the Economic Sociology of Law. Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 2, 61-81. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Max Weber Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1495270-max-weber
(Max Weber Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1495270-max-weber.
“Max Weber Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1495270-max-weber.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Max Weber on Capitalism and Its Foundations

Marx and Weber- rise of capitalism

The essay compares the differences in the approaches of Marx and Weber towards the emergence of capitalism and the crucial factors behind its origin and growth.... The essay compares the differences in the approaches of Marx and Weber towards the emergence of capitalism and the crucial factors behind its origin and growth.... Karl Marx and max weber are two eminent sociologists whose theories have been regarded as milestones in the development of two distinct schools of thought in sociology....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Karl Marx, Max Weber, and Capitalism

The paper "Karl Marx, max weber, and Capitalism" pinpoints that near the turn of the 20th century, leading socialist theorists Karl Marx and max weber assembled many complex approaches to how capitalism affects the perceptions and realities of social class.... The study of capitalism by both Marx and Weber related directly to its effect on society.... Marxism theorizes that as capitalism persists, it exacerbates the misery level for working-class individuals....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Key characteristics of bureaucracy

In his influential essays such as The City and capitalism and Rural Society in Germany, Weber acknowledges the “disappearance of the sociological relevance of the urban-rural distinction.... capitalism and Modernity: An Excursus on Marx and Weber.... Sociologist and philosopher max weber has contributed significantly toward our understanding of social and political institutions role in everyday situations.... What was it about bureaucracy that max weber saw as positive?...
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Difference between Karl Marx and Max Weber's Perception of Social Classes

The paper "Difference between Karl Marx and max weber's Perception of Social Classes" illustrates a need to view the differences between Karl Marx and max weber's theories of class to integrate socialism into the western democratic political system without worker's revolution.... Fifty years after Karl Marx published the Communist Manifesto in 1848, max weber was beginning his teaching career as a professor at the University of Heidelberg.... It is in these ideological reforms of Marxism that were introduced by the SDP in Germany historically, creating a more mainstream Socialism that could be integrated into the western democratic political system without worker's revolution, that it is necessary to view the differences between Karl Marx and max weber's theories of class....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Max Weber Biography

His intellectual concerns were rationalism, disenchantment, and secularization in the hope of understanding capitalism and modernity.... This thesis dealt with ascetic Protestantism as one of the main 'elective affinities' which relate to the rise of the Western market which was driven by capitalism and rational-legal national-state.... The most important of Weber's work is the 'Protestant Ethic thesis' which was about a non-Marxist genealogy of present capitalism and the 'Rationalization thesis' which talked about the analysis of the dominance of the west in the present times....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Karl Marx and Max Weber as an Influential Theorist in the Social Sciences

They delved into other matters that had a direct effect on the society and its development such as class conflict, the role of leadership as well as the significance of history and historical events in shaping the society (Turchetto, 2000).... The paper "Karl Marx and max weber as an Influential Theorist in the Social Sciences" state that while Marx believed that social change could only be achieved through revolution, Weber, who lived during calmer times, was of the opposite opinion, believing that change should be gradual....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

In What Ways did Durkheim and Weber Regard Totemism and Ascetic Protestanism

discusses how religion factors into a society that increasingly is built on the foundations of rationalism.... The paper "In What Ways did Durkheim and weber Regard Totemism and Ascetic Protestanism, Respectively, as Important Influences on the Behaviour of People?...
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

The Origins of Modern Capitalism According to Marx and Weber

The paper "The Origins of Modern capitalism According to Marx and Weber" highlights that Marx held that all aspects of the society, including law and religion were the expressions of the causal economic forces, thus only the major ones to be considered systematically noteworthy.... weber is in agreement with the developments proposed by Marx as leading to capitalist development, though he views that Marx was too deterministic on the basis of economical aspects....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us