StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Police: Streetcorner Politicians by William K. Muir Jr - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
One of the attractive features of the book observed in the paper "Police: Streetcorner Politicians by William K. Muir Jr. "  is how it combines armchair analysis with on-field documentation. With regard to the latter, the author seems to adopt a hands-on, spontaneous documentary style…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
Police: Streetcorner Politicians by William K. Muir Jr
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Police: Streetcorner Politicians by William K. Muir Jr"

Muir acknowledges the propensities of policemen for stereotyping victims and resorting to easy violence. Yet, he constructs his narrative in a manner empathetic towards them. He highlights how highly stressful the daily duties of police are and how their poise can consequently sometimes snap. A policeman’s professional life is mostly filled with tragic or emergency situations. These situations demand an elevated degree of resourcefulness, alertness, and decisiveness. Needless to say, such great demands on the body and mind take a toll on their health and wellbeing.

It is mostly as a result of such adverse conditioning that a policeman comes across as having an aggressive and rigid personality. It is interesting to note that these same apparently negative qualities turn virtuous in situations demanding valor and fortitude. By highlighting these nuances of the psychodynamics of policemen on duty, Muir has crafted a well-rounded personality profile of a police officer. Muir treats the phenomenon of corruption among policemen without getting judgmental. He illustrates how even honest and forthright police officers face peer pressure to play along with the system.

An isolated well-meaning policeman simply gets ostracized by his peers if he does not conform to the general culture of corruption prevalent in most police departments. In terms of style of scholarship, breaking away from conventions and decorum expected of academic research, Muir builds personal camaraderie with his interviewees. He makes them feel comfortable by projecting that he is one among them. They then give answers in an uninhibited fashion. This atmosphere also allows Muir to elicit answers that are not colored by psychological defense mechanisms or protective rationalizations.

Muir is thus able to get a composite portrait of policemen, with both the professional and personal facets included. He is able to show how many policemen struggle to separate their personal and professional lives. The high volatile environment of police duty incurs a personal cost. Oftentimes, their interpersonal relations with close family members suffer due to this imbalance. Muir attempts to thus portray policemen with humanitarian understanding. All things considered, police personnel play a crucial judicial function (law enforcement) that no democratic civil society can do without.

However, they often get a bad rap as greedy and ruthless – a perception that melts away under Muir’s scrutinizing scholarship. The other underappreciated facet to a police officer is his blind subjugation to existing laws. Even when a policeman personally disagrees with the law and perceives it to be unjust, he is bound to enforce it with an attitude of detached solemnity. Despite overcoming several such moments of conflict in the course of his duty, the policeman yet remains negatively stereotyped.

Muir endeavors to correct this general misunderstanding. Muir also analyzes also a policeman in the context of power. This explains why he parallels a policeman with a politician since both share a platform of power. The author recognizes the power’s tendency to corrupt the soul. In turn, an otherwise good policeman is susceptible to the rot that police work poses. The text strays from the superficial understanding of a policeman’s work to presenting a policeman as a person with intellectual and moral choices to make.

He uses the first-hand account of 28 retired police officers about their work in an American city, in the 1970s. In chapter 10, the author explains why the police use threats to survive through their career1. He uses the analogy of roughneck politics whereby having a nasty reputation helps a person establish an easy working relationship with people in the long run. The easy working relationship, however, develops out of fear rather than respect. A policeman, therefore, may employ intimidation and a rough personality in order to coerce people towards respecting one’s demands.

The book delves into the subject of irrationality and how such an aspect commonly confronts a policeman. A policeman deals with irrational characters such as street burglars, who may always possess a one-dimensional perspective on things. This, however, does not accord a policeman the power to act irrationally. In essence, the author characterizes a policeman as a person endowed with significant power. The large capacity to abuse such power can severely affect a policeman and the society that one lives in the same.

A good policeman, therefore, chooses moral and intellectual viewpoints that help better society. In sum, the book is deeply humanistic. Although Muir brings to the table a degree of distanced objectivity fitting a research scholar, one cannot but help feel his sympathies with the police profession. The composite picture of policemen that he paints is one showing them as decent human beings by and large.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(POlice: Streetcorner Politicains Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words, n.d.)
POlice: Streetcorner Politicains Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/2022939-police-streetcorner-politicains
(POlice: Streetcorner Politicains Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
POlice: Streetcorner Politicains Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/2022939-police-streetcorner-politicains.
“POlice: Streetcorner Politicains Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”. https://studentshare.org/social-science/2022939-police-streetcorner-politicains.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Police: Streetcorner Politicians by William K. Muir Jr

Compare or Contrast two politians

Compare and contrast two politicians 2.... Name Professor Class Date Planning Page 1.... President Barack Obama of the United States and President Benigno Aquino of the Philippines 3.... President Barack Obama and and President Benigno Aquino are supreme examples of democratic leaders where they uphold democracy and the rule of law....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Local Politician Event in Ireland

This assignment "Local Politician Event in Ireland" will delve into things and key aspects with regards to realizing the success of an event in this kind of nature and how areas of concern are addressed in order to fulfill the objective of the event.... hellip; Focus and proper management of time and resources are vital in order to realize the project as well as to preempt the possible problems that might occur in the future which can be a failure in realizing the intended outcome....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

The CFT Issues

This paper talks about thе U.... .... Cеntrаl Аmеricа Frее Trаdе Аgrееmеnt (CАFTА) which was sighed with Costа Ricа, Еl Sаlvаdor, Guаtеmаlа, Hondurаs, аnd Nicаrаguа.... CАFTА wаs nеgotiаtеd, in pаrt, аs а rеgionаl аgrееmеnt in which аll pаrtiеs would bе subjеct to thе “thе sаmе sеt of obligаtions аnd commitmеnts… According to the report CАFTА is а comprеhеnsivе аnd rеciprocаl trаdе аgrееmеnt, which distinguishеs it from thе CBI unilаtеrаl prеfеrеntiаl аrrаngеmеnt bеtwееn thе Unitеd Stаtеs аnd thеsе countriеs....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Implementing and Evaluating Public Policy Simulation Summary_303

Seemingly, the only neutral member of the team is william Morrison who is an expert in policy initiatives but his stance on the issue was not made clear.... When policymakers are confined to the dictates of lobbyists without considering the overall effects that represent the other side of the spectrum, then politicians are… The existence of these interests groups that embody a different argument in the debate paints a more holistic picture of the entire issue....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Political influence of different racial politicians

The hypothesis of the paper “Political influence of different racial politicians” is a case study design.... The detailed analysis examination outlines have developed over the recent years as a helpful device for exploring patterns and particular circumstances.... hellip; A research endeavor is an in profundity investigation of a specific circumstance instead of a clearing factual review....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Police Brutality

william Bratton was the commissioner of police in New York and had gained the reputation of building good social community relations between the police and the surrounding community.... The paper "police Brutality" describes that police brutality is well mastered by the Russian police, who are very well trained with angry protesters and disperse them through creating the fear of arrests and criminal charges.... nbsp;The brutality of the Russian police has not only been directed....
5 Pages (1250 words) Annotated Bibliography

Politicians Role Models

The author of the paper "politicians Role Models" will begin with the statement that when people claim that something is impossible, this claim helps to influence an individual to work even harder.... In a world so corrupt in regards to politicians and the actions they make, it is important that these politicians are held responsible for their actions.... This is important since the actions and decisions made by politicians have a large effect on the general public....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Dispossessed by William Deresiewicz

… The paper "The Dispossessed by william Deresiewicz" is a worthy example of a book review on English.... The paper "The Dispossessed by william Deresiewicz" is a worthy example of a book review on English.... The examples are given by william Deresiewicz consist of the whites and black personalities, highlighting the widespread nature of the predicament.... In The Dispossessed, william Deresiewicz talks about working in America and the challenges they face in their setting, especially from the media....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us