StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Frameworks and Decisions - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The main theme of the article is the discussion of the current system of the study of ethics and how it has evolved into an indispensable part of school’s curriculum. Almost everyone and just as many people have become self-proclaimed experts in ethics…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Frameworks and Decisions
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Frameworks and Decisions"

 The main theme of the article is the discussion of the current system of the study of ethics and how it has evolved into an indispensable part of school’s curriculum. Almost everyone and just as many people have become self-proclaimed experts of ethics without truly understanding what this entails. Gordon Marino aptly puts it “take any given profession and there is another profession called the ethics of that profession.” The author substantially tackles that this overlooks other equally, or more important aspects, such as the ability to have a valuable self-reflection that would inevitably render a more righteous individual in relation to more practical scenarios. Is he accurate in what he says? Yes, to a great extent Marino calls it intuitively to point out the reality of the teaching of ethics. It is quite true that ethics is being taught in almost all fields and discipline but this does not in any way guarantee that those who partake of it would automatically make the right choices in the future. It is true that there is bioethics, legal ethics, medical ethics and all others of the genus but this in no way has it proven that arbitrarily mandating the students and other individuals would mean that there would be less of any malpractice in the future. The old Greek viewpoint of Socratic origin does make one wonder whether or not virtue could be taught. What is the moral challenge? The greatest moral challenge is to first get to know one’s self in a contemplative and accurate way before being able to definitively claim that ethics may be imparted. This in its entirety gives out a deeper understanding of the almost ludicrous title that Marino has given his article. “Before Teaching Ethics, Stop Kidding Yourself” challenges each person, especially those who teach it, to have a deeper psychological understanding of who we are so that we may be able to envisage our line of reasoning when faced with a moral dilemma. This makes for a tangible approach to teaching ethics. The outcome of “we will look at this tomorrow” according to Marino is that we distance ourself from our moral knowledge, is this true? I deeply understand this sentiment because the lapse of time between now and that concept of “we will look at this tomorrow” is ample time to give any person for him to be able to reconcile his moral knowledge with justifications that he would have easily made without it. “Until finally we come to our senses and convince ourselves that the convenient course is the righteous course” (Marino 2004). But this could also go the other way wherein the extent of time provided may be enough to persuade one’s self to do the right thing and not to walk away from a virtuous judgment that he must make. This would in fact depend on the state of morality that each individual possesses. Task 2 What legislation is important for service provision in your discipline? Please write your discipline and the full title of the legislation and how it relates to the community’s moral standards. Legislation in Biomedical Science Perhaps the most controversial legislation that pertains to Biomedical Science recently is the Stem Cell Laws. The most pressing issue regarding this is the public funding for stem cell research that has been denied by both the Bush administration and the Obama administration. The most debated in this topic is Embryonic stem cell research is not totally banned in the country where states such as California has Proposition 71 and New Jersey has a law that also allow human adult stem cells and germ cells to be used. California is the more liberal with the approval of a law that allows the use of cloned embryos. In perspective, the possibility of human cloning is still against all United States laws. Task 3 Did this man act morally? Why /why not? Yes, because in his own moral knowledge he acted for the greater good rather than to be able to rescue his own family. In his own hierarchy of what could be considered morally good and what is not. He was convinced that by saving the town leader and his family over his own, he acted according to the dictate of his moral conscience and by this he acted morally. We may have different perspectives on what is morally virtuous and not but it is in acting on what you know and believe to be right which makes it moral. This man acted on good utilitarian grounds. But was it the right thing? Is the cultural context a factor in your deliberations? What other response could be made and what would be the ethical justification for it? It may be easy to categorize that the deed was purely on utilitarian grounds but this may also be inferred in terms of a rational choice theory. Certainly it is not a natural choice to allow the death of one’s own family for the survival of another but we cannot conclusively argue that the man’s act is immoral though it is unacceptable for the majority of people. The rational thinking of the man led him to the belief and knowledge that by saving the town leader he will be able to help more people despite the grief of having to lose his own family. In addition, the facts are not entirely complete as it did not provide the actual state of the people under the rubble. Perhaps there was a greater chance for the other family to survive over his wife and children. This brings to mind the notion that it is not choosing right from wrong which is the greatest of all moral dilemmas that one can face, rather, it is choosing between two rights which will determine the degree of character that makes for a righteous individual. The man was faced with this predicament under catastrophic circumstances. This makes it difficult to render judgment purely on a subjective basis because choosing one over the other does not make either choice inherently wrong. Bibliography Garfinkel, M. (2004). Genome News Network [online]. [Accessed 15 November 2011]. Available from: . Marino, G. (2004). Before Teaching Ethics, Stop Kidding Yourself. Chronicle of Higher Education [online]. 50, [Accessed 15 November 2011], p.B5-B5. Available from: . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Frameworks and Decisions Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Frameworks and Decisions Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1761288-ethicsframeworks-and-decisions
(Frameworks and Decisions Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Frameworks and Decisions Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1761288-ethicsframeworks-and-decisions.
“Frameworks and Decisions Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1761288-ethicsframeworks-and-decisions.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Frameworks and Decisions

Ethics:Frameworks and Decisions

Autonomy ensures the ability to make quick uninfluenced decisions that often helps achieve my desires.... A value is a belief or philosophy that defines what an individual considers meaningful, and which he makes efforts to subscribe to (Posner, N.... ).... Most… Individual aspects like commitment to social justice, respect/service/concern for others, integrity, accountability, passion for unity, and wisdom are some of the common personal values The personal values have some relations with various ethical/moral theories and principles....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Britvic Plc 2011 Annual Return

He made a comparison of the year's performance with the previous years in the company.... In his statement, he said that 2011 was a challenging year to the soft… According to his statement, the chairman quotes profit that the company has been making since its floatation as a public company six years ago....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Individuals Factors That Impacted on Learning

The participants were seasoned professionals, hence creating a facilitating environment where learning can occur made my job easier although my inexperience and ability to relate their decision making examples to theoretical frameworks is a weakness that I need to work on.... The paper “Individuals Factors That Impacted on Learning” on a framework for decision making was complimented by the learning activities and the author's personal attention to each participant....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Teleological and Deontological Frameworks

eontological frameworks1) Existentialism this is where only one person who is making decisions can determine right and wrong.... ) Kant's ethics the free will to make decisions needed to be converted into a universal will.... Sedgwick's dualism attempts to bridge the gap between the frameworks of ethical egoism and utilitarianism.... Sedgwick's dualism attempts to bridge the gap between the frameworks of ethical egoism and utilitarianism....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Ethical Framework Analysis:

Ethical decision making refers to following a certain acceptable code of ethics in making decisions, especially those that affect a wide or a vast group of people.... There are various frameworks for decision making and a variety of codes followed in making decisions.... This will be achieved through comparing and contrasting Edward Veith's spiritual framework and the management ETHICAL FRAMEWORK ANALYSIS Introduction Ethical decision making refers to following a certain acceptable of ethicsin making decisions, especially those that affect a wide or a vast group of people....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Watching movie then writing

If the agents and brokerage firms would have taken decisions based on this theory they would not have advised their clients to invest in CDOs as they knew that their investors would face a loss for investing in CDOs.... They would have refrained from indulging in such unethical acts if they would have made their decisions on the basis of ethical frameworks of Utilitarianism and Kant's Categorical Imperative....
2 Pages (500 words) Admission/Application Essay

DECISION MAKING AND INFORMATION POLITICS

Governance structures and decision-making processes echo responsibility for both decisions and contributions made exclusively to those decisions (Haes & Van Grembergen, 2014).... The objective of governance specific to the information technology function and services is bringing value against the commercial and governance requisites (Hughes,… Information technology has to underwrite this precise objective of organizational governance because value creation is only achievable by acknowledging benefits and resources while minimizing risks....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Importance of Ethical, Legally Sound Decisions and Effective Communication in Business

As the paper "The Importance of Ethical, Legally Sound decisions and Effective Communication in Business" outlines, effective communication is a powerful tool that is key to encouraging sound decision-making.... Therefore, it is important for the management of an organization to make ethical, legal, and fair decisions that are stakeholder-centered.... Understanding what is required in regards to ethics and legality helps the employees to make decisions that are fair to all....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us