StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Hobbes and Lockes Legitimate Political Authority - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Hobbes’ and Locke’s Legitimate Political Authority" explains that Hobbes and Locke reiterate that the people have the power to grant authority to govern and that authority belongs with the people.However, it is Locke who has a greater influence on the modern political science…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Hobbes and Lockes Legitimate Political Authority
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Hobbes and Lockes Legitimate Political Authority"

Hobbes’s and Locke’s legitimate political ity based on the consent Introduction Hobbes and Locke have contributed significantly to the field of political science. Both theorists tend to have similar views with regard to where power emanates in the society. They both support the constitution or popular contract as an avenue where the people give the power to rule. Hobbes and Locke reiterate that the people have the power to grant authority to govern and that authority belongs with the people.

However, between the two theorists, it is Locke who is recognized to have a greater influence on the modern political science. Conversely, Hobbes’s influence is evident on what the people can do to change their government (Sigmuid, 1971) Similarities and differences between Hobbes and Locke Both Hobbes and Locke agree that the government is a necessity. As reiterated by Hobbes, people form government for purposes of self-preservation. In any society, the creation of government is often perpetuated by fear.

However, Hobbes is against limited government and supports absolute sovereignty since limited government is not sufficient in terms of safeguarding citizen’s right to self-preservation. In essence, absolute power as addressed by Hobbes arises when citizens give power to an individual or group of individuals. Consequently, the sovereign has the mandate to, for instance, wage war, impose taxes or declare peace. Hobbes further believes that establishing a government is necessary resorting to the state of nature.

Hobbes also maintains that a government plays a role in preserving citizen’s lives (Hobbes, 1994). Locke believes in a government that is established by the people and works for the people. However, such a government does not create absolute sovereignty as posited by Hobbes. Locke also asserts that the people have a right to change a government that does not respect natural laws and human rights. On the other hand, while Hobbes and Locke recognize the importance of having a government, they differ on the amount of government and ruling respectively (Dunn, 1969).

With regards to rights and equality, Hobbes believes in the right of self-preservation. He also reiterates that men are equal in terms of their physical and mental capabilities. As such, the weak in the society can establish confederacies to defeat the strongest. Similarly, Hobbes also suggests that each man is in a position to agree to be governed and make their choice based on survival instincts. Conversely, Locke believes in inalienable right that include, for instance, right to life, property ownership and liberty that allows man to pursue happiness.

On another note, while Hobbes considers humanity in individualistic terms, Locke views humanity to be more communal. The inalienable rights as posited by Locke ensure that governments respect the natural laws (Dunn, 1969). Conclusion While Locke’s views tend to be similar with Hobbes, he appears not to accept man’s nature (pessimistic and egoistical) as described by Hobbes. In essence, the governments described by both theorists appear to be similar, but in actual sense, they are different.

Further, Hobbes and Locke also differ with regard to their view of sovereign power. While Hobbes is against mixing of the power, Locke allows for mixes between different forms of government, for instance, tyranny, anarchy and oligarchy. References Dunn, J. (1969). The Political Thought of John Locke: An Historical Account of the Argument of the Two Treatises of Government.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Hobbes, T. (1994).Leviathan. Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company Sigmuid, P. E. (1971).

Natural Law in Political Thought. Washington,D.C.: Winthrop Publishers, Inc.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Hobbes and Lockes Legitimate Political Authority Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1700205-hobbes-and-lockes-legitimate-political-authority
(Hobbes and Lockes Legitimate Political Authority Essay)
https://studentshare.org/social-science/1700205-hobbes-and-lockes-legitimate-political-authority.
“Hobbes and Lockes Legitimate Political Authority Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1700205-hobbes-and-lockes-legitimate-political-authority.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Hobbes and Lockes Legitimate Political Authority

Achieving Justice

Question 2 A hobbes and Locke are both well-known political theorists whose works have been momentously influential into the modern-political thought development....   hobbes and Locke's ‘state of nature' differ from one another.... Furthermore, there is a moral responsibility to abide by civil authority as long as the authority is genuine.... For example, if the authority is built upon a just and fair agreement amid society's members (Rousseau par 6)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

What does Hobbes mean by sovereignty Is his understanding of this concept still relevant today

Leviathan can, consequently, be seen as a political person that can exhibit noble, republican, monarchical or autonomous features (Sim and Walker, 2003) Thomas hobbes and his renunciation of the principle of right reason.... In every social society where a system of law is present, there is also most likely to be found underneath the assortment of political forms, a latent democracy as much as in an absolute monarchy.... This is because the relation of the sovereign to the subjects constitutes part of the very connotation of those expressionsThomas Hobbes' philosophy of government Hobbes stated a clear personal sureness in his point as the 'author or inventor of a reliable political science'....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

A Justified Rebellion

While Hobbes comes across as a believer in the force of authority.... he social contract theory is a common concept used in many different fields such as political science, economics, and sociology.... nbsp;… John Locke's main concern was how governments should be considered legitimate, and how society should function for all its members.... Additionally, comparisons can be made in terms of how other philosophers such as hobbes have seen the legitimacy of government as opposed to Locke to fully understand the position Locke takes on what a government should do to keep the social contract....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Culture and ethical values

Each individual gives up his own power to the supreme sovereign, the ‘Leviathan', whose authority is indivisible and unchallengeable.... Hobbes' fascination with authority and the unbridled faith he reposes in the sovereign are products, however, of how he feels a just society and a commodious existence can be best preserved.... Thomas hobbes remains one of the most important figures in the history of modern philosophy, and is best remembered for the employment of the theory of the social contract to explain the nature and origin of government as emanating from a ‘state of nature'....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Evolution of the Civil Society

For Hobbes, the people authorized the government to have the authority in directing civil society.... The essay "The Evolution of the “Civil Society” focuses on Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679) and his book Leviathan greatly influenced political thought in the seventeenth century.... Besides, John Locke (1632-1704) and his work Two Treatises on Government (1690) is also a seminal work on political thought.... hellip; Locke and hobbes have diverging views on the relationship between the government and civil society....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

The Social Theorists

In conclusion, hobbes and Locke's approach to decision making can be justified only based on consent.... hellip; The social theorists are justified if the authority, in their sense is effective, or if it gets individuals to decide to base on the reasons it generates.... The distinction between legitimate and effective authority is that an effective one simply supports to change the decisions.... The legitimate authority has the ability to alter these decisions....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Social Contract Theory Of Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau

Rousseau states that civil society has not done anything in order to enforce the equality and individual liberty that was promised to mankind thereby suggesting that the only legitimate political authority is the one consented to by all people, who have agreed to the government by entering into the contract for the sake of their mutual preservation.... olitical and Social Power in terms of authority and legitimacyAuthority is the power invested government or body of government officials in order to enforce laws, command, determine, judge or even exact obedience....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

John Locke and His Philosophical Beliefs

This is quite in contrast to hobbes's view, who first proposed his philosophy on the laws of nature, which was based on prudence and rational thinking and believed that humans derive their moral behavior from society.... hobbes believed that all our moral behavior is acquired from the society that each of us lives....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us