StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Narratives of Difference and Belonging - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the research paper “Narratives of Difference and Belonging” the author analyses the article by Weedon. The main concept presented in the article speaks of the various influencing factors that shape the adolescents or the youth of a particular age…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.9% of users find it useful
Narratives of Difference and Belonging
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Narratives of Difference and Belonging"

Narratives of Difference and BelongingKey arguments/concepts presented in the article: The main concept presented in the article speaks of the various influencing factors that shape the adolescents, or the youth of a particular age. It speaks of the various traditional approaches in understanding the developmental processes of this age group (the teen group, till 24 yrs) and focuses on the post modern age of globalization, and the need to change our style of education. Here a very interesting concept is presented, known as emergence of a ‘hybridized’ class of youth, owing to the present wave of globalization, and resultant social structure, which is more open in all aspects, and consists of something of a goulash of various diverse economies, cultures, and traditions.

Interesting fact, illuminating statement, personal connection: An interesting fact mentioned in the article is that of the presence of the same set of things, starting from consumer products, to eateries, groceries, and shopping malls, which are seen everywhere in today’s globalised world. So there is a definite loss of individualism, or uniqueness of a certain place, and one always ends up getting the same thing anywhere they go. This is something we are evidencing today in all parts of the world.

There is always a McDonalds, a Café Coffee Day or a Barista, and somehow the local flavor is slowly disappearing under the burgeoning pressure from these huge multinationals. I can personally connect to this observation, as wherever I have travelled looking for new things, I have always met these giants standing tall, dishing out the same set of standardized products.Author’s perspective/value position: The author feels that in this changed scenario of globalization and high-tech communication era, the youth needs to be first acknowledged as a source of power.

Accordingly their education should be offered in a different manner, inculcated with new values that would be more fitting in this hybridized world. To make this effective, the educators have to change their mindset or else as the author comments “We need new ways of thinking of and working with kids, otherwise we will become irrelevant as we produce education for categories of kids that no longer exist in the postmodern world” (Besley, 74).Validity/usefulness of the article for thinking about issues of cultural diversity: This article is very important in today’s context, as it speaks of the new age culture that we can see all around us.

It also speaks of new ways of handling the youth, so as to make their education better and more effective in this globalised world. This piece of article is very contemporary and helps us to understand the fallacies that we see in our education system today.Implications for education: The article has great implications for the betterment of youth education. Handling a very contemporary topic, this article outlines the reasons as to why the educators and the educational system as a whole needs a complete overhauling, if they really wish to produce a young generation that would not only be well educated, competent, but also be fit enough to survive in this hybridized and high-tech world.

ReferenceBesley, A. C. Hybridized and Globalized: Youth Cultures in the Postmodern Era, Review of Education, Pedagogy, and Cultural Studies, 25: 2, 2003. Print.NOTES FOR TUTORIAL READING Article: C. WeedonKey arguments/concepts presented in the article: The main concept that the author theorizes here is about the formation of human identities, and how they are manifested by certain typical outward expressions like gender, wealth etc., and identification forms the core subject through which a person becomes a ‘knowing subject’ or a sovereign person.

(Weedon, 7). Identities may form from social, cultural or institutional aspects of life, and once acquired, it becomes an intrinsic part of the person concerned. Here the author stresses on the fact that identity of an individual formed under whatever circumstances, be it from gender, power, or class consciousness, or racial discrimination, or good looks, it becomes the central point or pivot, upon which the individual moves. Another important concept is that how globalization and resulting migrations, have also affected the identities of individuals of a nation.

Interesting fact, illuminating statement, personal connection: An interesting fact mentioned in the article is that how often identity forms even through casual remarks made by another person who in reality, is not meaning any harm. Here the author mentions about his looks, and the frequently heard comment “but you do not have the looks”, and how it slowly became his ‘identity claim”. This is so true in the context of our daily lives, especially in the case of a young girl, where she may be persistently compared to her better looking elder sisters or her mother.

It would create a sort identity crisis in the child’s mind, often leading to other psychological problems. This is also true in cases where one is taunted for his color, his wealth, or even stature.Author’s perspective/value position: The author feels that our identities are created by how we perceive ourselves, and what others as a society perceive and tell us about their observations. As for example America is always identified with capitalism and exploitation, though it may not be true in all cases.

However it is what who don’t stay in America perceive, and say so, with the result that the identity persists. The author is of the view that once an identity is formed, it becomes the centre point for the existence of that person.Validity/usefulness of the article for thinking about issues of cultural diversity: This article is very important as it speaks about and explains the various theories that create an identity of a person. In this globalised world there have taken place large numbers of migrations, leading to change in identity perceptions and creating completely new identities.

Such migrations have very often changed the very face of existent societies, as for example when the white colonials migrated to America, they changed the identity of the local Native Americans who were already staying there.Implications for education: The article has great implications for the betterment of youth education. Handling a very contemporary and relevant topic, this article tells us how the society helps to create the identity of an individual. Bearing this in mind, and the effects that a globalised world and the resultant migrating crowds have caused, we have to shape our educational system in such a manner that we help the young minds form strong positive identities about themselves.

An identity that is confident enough to believe in its own self worth, irrespective of race, color, wealth or class, is the objective all educators should aim for, and strive to achieve, by instilling proper values in the young minds that they prepare for the future. Works CitedWeedon, C. Identity and Culture: Narratives of difference and belonging. Subjectivity and Identity, 6-20. Madenhead: Open University Press, 2004.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Narratives of Difference and Belonging Assignment”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1568936-making-notes-for-3-reading-articles-detal-see-instructions-and-attached-files
(Narratives of Difference and Belonging Assignment)
https://studentshare.org/social-science/1568936-making-notes-for-3-reading-articles-detal-see-instructions-and-attached-files.
“Narratives of Difference and Belonging Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1568936-making-notes-for-3-reading-articles-detal-see-instructions-and-attached-files.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Narratives of Difference and Belonging

Narrative Analysis - Chinese Culture

The plot for business narratives can change according to the customer's response and needs for that particular company.... Analysis of a Business Narrative [Author] [Institution] Narrative analysis is a form of research, which determines the pattern of narration of any event or incident....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ethnography as Memory

However, some focus on the narratives of experiences of people, which constitute one memory of a certain shared experience that can shed some light on how people see a certain phenomenon.... At the same time, there is a critical interrogation of how memories are situated across time and how narratives of it become a valuable source of knowledge.... Following such a condition, one can take into account that memories of the past become stories or narratives that are passed on from generations to generations, which could impart lessons and predicaments for the contemporary society....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Multicultaralism

The author's narratives which take him back to a country of his origin is an attempt to forge a relationship with a land although alien to him secures him a root of his cultural origins thus giving him a sense of belonging and identity which is somehow lost in the multicultural milieu of his migrant country.... The apparent references to the color of these migrants who belong to a host of countries including Jamaica, Nigeria, and Trinidad suggest the discrimination of people belonging alien origins whereby the 'blacks' were often paid lower wages on account of their color – an obvious form of racial discrimination....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Golden Gate by Vikram Seth

Vikram Seth's extraordinary style, where everyday words, happenings including narratives show wit and represent sentiment in refined facet.... A novel in verse is those type literary forms which are at the brink of extermination.... It accepts various distinctive bliss in addition to vague response by some....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Theory used in Social Work Practice

The point in this paper is about 'tragic' news narratives of an Asian Lady suffering from depression due to sudden death of her mother.... Even emotionally charged narratives belonging to specific communities put cultural specific scripts of individuals.... hellip; Consequently, cultural narratives are not individual and cultural narratives about life stories differ in the individuals of different cultures.... In some cases of tragic narratives style can define the culture and the extent of depression of the subject....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Book reflection

Only if somehow the stories belonging to every nation were to teach more tolerance and... In the book, The Truth About Stories: A Native Narrative, Thomas King turns the critical lens on storytelling itself, but by doing this the author is, in fact, still studying his people, the Native Americans, because stories are an important part of the subjective meaning making… King's literature subverts the concept of the ‘imaginary Indian', but Thomas King emphasises the mortality of men and the passing of the traditions of the ancestors to the living generations to shape and to mould those who are the offspring of Perhaps Thomas King is right because after all the stories of the Old Testament still profoundly interest and shape every new generation that is born, even though the actors who had once acted out these stories and even the stage are all gone....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Champion of the World vs Fish Cheeks Comparison

Angelou uses direct quotes to recreate the experience for the reader while Tan describes her idea of the teachings her mother imposed on Angelou's style of narration and description are better and more effective than Tan's methods because Angelou's readers take on a selfless and unbiased perspective of cultural difference in the United States.... This culture clash acts as a barrier for Tan to describe her experience with cultural difference positively....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Gender Roles in the 20th Century: A Trifles Revelation

laspell criticizes, and thereby summons the reader to also criticize, the biased importance of the point of views of men and women, and responds by developing an agitating and thrilling drama that progresses through the unfolding of the separate narratives of men and women.... "Gender Roles in the 20th Century: A Trifles' Revelation" paper argues that Susan Glaspell's Trifles demonstrates the differences in male and female roles in the 20th century through her masterful depiction of two narratives, one female, which is in the point of view, Mrs....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us