StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Strategic Inconsistencies and America's Democratic Process - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The remainder of this discussion will consider each of these questions in turn with a concluding section offering general observations. The US has sacrificed the democratic process in times of war in order to pursue a strategy that was deemed necessary and effective at the time…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
Strategic Inconsistencies and Americas Democratic Process
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Strategic Inconsistencies and America's Democratic Process"

Strategic Inconsistencies and America's Democratic Process The question providing the focus for this essay is really best posed as two separate questions. 1. Did the US have to sacrifice portions of its democratic process in the name of consistency and effectiveness in times of war? 2. Was America's democratic process able to overcome the strategic inconsistencies that arose during times of war intact and prevail? The answer to that first question is definitely yes. The answer to the second question is probably not. Moreover, there is also a third question that current events compel us to ask: 3. Has the US sacrificed portions of its democratic process in the name of consistency and effectiveness in the ongoing war on terror? Unfortunately, the answer to that final question is most definitely yes. The remainder of this discussion will consider each of these questions in turn with a concluding section offering general observations and thoughts for the future. 1. Did the US have to sacrifice portions of its democratic process in the name of consistency and effectiveness in times of war? The US has sacrificed the democratic process in times of war in order to pursue a strategy that was deemed necessary and effective at the time. The executive branch and the military expanding the war into Cambodia with neither the knowledge nor the support of Congress, was a clear violation of the democratic process.i Earlier, and in a similar fashion the entire program to develop the atomic bomb and the decision to use them on two Japanese cities in August, 1945 was undertaken in strict secrecy. The secrecy of the program was essential to national security and the decision to use it certainly shortened the war and probably saved the lives of thousands of US combat troops. However, undertaking the development and use of atomic weapons in strict secrecy can hardly be seen as a model of democracy in action. The removal of the Japanese from the Pacific coast during World War Two and their concentration in internment camps was a clear violation of both their human and civil rights. It may well have been necessary, although that is certainly debatable, but, again, it is hardly a model of democracy in action.ii During wartime the United States has clearly abandoned democratic principles in favor of military strategy and efficacy. That said, it would be fair to say that virtually every democracy has made the decision when confronted with the question of military strategy versus democratic ideals in time of war. 2. Was America's democratic process able to overcome the strategic inconsistencies that arose during times of war intact and prevail? Since at least the Civil War there has been a hangover from wartime strategy that has infected the democratic process in the aftermath of war. During Reconstruction Federal troops were placed on the streets in southern cities to enforce law and order. This egregious violation of the Constitution, once recognized, was deemed so offensive that it led to posse comitatus legislation in 1878. The law states, “Whoever, except in cases and under circumstances expressly authorized by the Constitution or Act of Congress, willfully uses any part of the Army or Air Force as a posse comitatus or otherwise to execute the laws shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than two years, or both.”iii Arguably the use of troops can be deemed to have been legal before this act was passed and cannot be applied retroactively however, this incident demonstrates the 'hangover' effect of warfare. Noteworthy also are the 'Red Scares' that followed both World War One and World War Two. Extraordinary, and arguably extra-legal, means were used in the wake of both World Wars to arrest and convict suspected anarchists, socialists, communists and other subversives.iv This again illustrates the 'hangover' effect of the extraordinary measures (such as the removal of the Japanese from the Pacific coast during World War Two) that were employed in wartime. In fact, the entire Cold War can be seen as justification for wartime measures in peacetime. Long after the McCarthy era. These 'hangovers' Highlight Betts' conclusion that, “strategy can be salvaged more often if peacetime planning gives as much consideration to limiting the range of ends as to expanding the menu of means.”v In wartime and its immediate wake the US has frequently focused on 'expanding the menu of means' rather than 'limiting the range of ends' and this has subsequently carried on into the immediate postwar period. 3. Has the US sacrificed portions of its democratic process in the name of consistency and effectiveness in the ongoing war on terror? During the Bush regime the democratic process was sacrificed repeatedly and significantly in favor of strategic considerations. In terms of the Obama government it is too early to offer a conclusive verdict. With reference to the Bush regime the democratic process was subverted when alternate intelligence agencies and processes were established to justify war against Iraq. The most glaring example of this was sending then Secretary of State, and sacrificial lamb, Colin Powell with false proof or Iraqi weapons of mass destruction (WMD).vi The rule of law, and by implication the democratic process, was also subverted when then Attorney-General Alberto Gonzalez produced legal opinions permitting torture. “For the first time [the Attorney-General] provided explicit authorization to barrage terror suspects with a combination of painful physical and psychological tactics, including head-slapping, simulated drowning and frigid temperatures.vii It was also subverted with the establishment of the extra-legal Guantanamo Bay prison complex. In 2002, the Bush administration made a sweeping declaration that many of the combatants captured in Iraq and Afghanistan, particularly those suspected of Al Qaeda links, were 'unlawful combatants.' Further the administration asserted that since they were not members of a legitimate national armed force they did not have to be accorded the rights and protections of the Geneva Convention.viii That unilateral decision has been widely criticized and has a very questionable basis in international law. Their limitless detention in US custody but not on US soil is also legally indefensible in the opinion of this writer. The Obama administration, despite a campaign pledge to immediately close the Guantanamo Bay prison complex, has found it impossible to swiftly and cleanly extricate itself from the morass that was created by the previous administration. Conclusions Returning to the questions posed in the introduction it is plain that the democratic process is sacrificed during wartime in the United States as it is regularly in many democracies. There is also a hangover effect from this that carries over into peacetime. Most disturbing, however, is the impact of the war on terror on democratic principles. The war on terror is in-determinant and indefinite. It has also repeatedly led the government to sacrifice democratic principles to strategic expediency. References Betts, Richard K. 2000. “Is Strategy an Illusion.” International Security 25(2): 5-50. Karnow, Stanley. (1983). Vietnam: A History. New York: Penguin Books. Levin, Murray B. (1971). Political Hysteria in America: The Democratic Capacity for Repression. New York: Basic Books. “Remember that Mushroom Cloud?” (November 2, 2005). The New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2005/11/02/opinion/02weds1.html?_r=1&scp=2&sq=colin%20powell%20WMD&st=cse. Robinson, Greg. (2001). By Order of the President: FDR and the Internment of Japanese Americans. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. “Times Topics: Detainees”. (May 11, 2010). The New York Times. http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/subjects/d/detainees/index.html?scp=6&sq=%22guantanamo%20bay%27%20prisoner&st=cse. “Times Topics: Torture”. (September 9, 2010). The New York Times. http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/subjects/t/torture/index.html?scp=4&sq=gonzalez%20waterboarding&st=cse. United States Northern Command. “About US NorthCom: The Posse Comitatus Act”. Retrieved from http://www.northcom.mil/about/history_education/posse.html. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Strategic Inconsistencies and America's Democratic Process Essay”, n.d.)
Strategic Inconsistencies and America's Democratic Process Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1574059-did-the-us-have-to-sacrifice-portions-of-its-democratic-process-in-the-name-of-consistency-and-effectiveness-in-times-of-war-or-was-americas-democratic-process-able-to-overcome-the-strategic-inconsistencies-that-arose-during-times-of-war-in-tact-and-p
(Strategic Inconsistencies and America'S Democratic Process Essay)
Strategic Inconsistencies and America'S Democratic Process Essay. https://studentshare.org/politics/1574059-did-the-us-have-to-sacrifice-portions-of-its-democratic-process-in-the-name-of-consistency-and-effectiveness-in-times-of-war-or-was-americas-democratic-process-able-to-overcome-the-strategic-inconsistencies-that-arose-during-times-of-war-in-tact-and-p.
“Strategic Inconsistencies and America'S Democratic Process Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1574059-did-the-us-have-to-sacrifice-portions-of-its-democratic-process-in-the-name-of-consistency-and-effectiveness-in-times-of-war-or-was-americas-democratic-process-able-to-overcome-the-strategic-inconsistencies-that-arose-during-times-of-war-in-tact-and-p.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Strategic Inconsistencies and America's Democratic Process

Democrats of the Twentieth Century

Throughout the campaign process of the 2009 Presidential Election, several critics and supporters had labeled Hillary Rodham Clinton as the second coming of John F.... Similarly, one of Clinton's most notable and memorable quotes throughout her political career echoes this same sentiment: "Voting is the most precious right of every citizen, and we have a moral obligation to ensure the integrity of our voting process.... Although both are affiliated with the democratic Party, Kennedy and Clinton were not of the same mold....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Democratic or Undemocratic

The Bill of Rights was instrumental in making a more democratic process in delivering the rights of man, until proven guilty of a crime.... When the Bill of Rights were included in the Constitution, its first ten commandments gained considerable support and adoption, namely: “freedom of speech and religion; freedom to assemble peaceably and to petition for redress of grievances; the right to keep arms; freedom from unreasonable searches and seizures; freedom from self-incrimination, double-jeopardy, cruel and unusual punishment, and excessive bail and fines; the right to a fair and impartial trial; and other forms of due process” (p....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Role of Political Parties in the American Democratic

hellip; The democratic theory asserts that it is only through a free and fair voting process that Americans can primarily control the government.... The Role of Political Parties in the American Democratic ProcessThe democratic theory asserts that it is only through a free and fair voting process that Americans can primarily control the government.... Given the competitiveness of the electoral process, the party goes for those candidates whose manifestos are consistent with the party's (Maisel 45)....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Historical Era for the United States Natives

The era… also sums up Richard Nixon's controversial rule in the United States following a close general election win against Hubert Humphrey of the democratic Party.... democratic National Convention nominates Hubert Humphrey as its candidate for presidency (Provisions of the Constitution and United States Code Relating to Presidential Elections, par 5)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Globalizations Major Inconsistencies

Charges have been labeled against WTO that it can compel sovereign states to change laws on grounds of violating the free trade rules, it does not give equal weightage to the developing countries, it does not allow democratic accountability and finally, it remains indifferent to the impact of free trade on issues like child labor, worker safety, the right to form a union and environmental and animal welfare protection.... This paper “Globalization's Major inconsistencies” will discuss the core issues facing international trade as a result of the criticism lashed against the WTO....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

The Political Causes and Background of the Tiananmen Square Protests

The focus of this analysis will be toward understanding the economic and political causes that led to the student protests of 1989.... The political instabilities that followed Mao's death in 1976, caused a sequence of political order that was inconsistent at the level of policy and governance.... hellip; This paper examined the long-term changes which created the revolt of Tiananmen square....
17 Pages (4250 words) Term Paper

America and Democratic Rule

This essay "America and democratic Rule" focuses on the importance of the democratic rule in America, especially liberal democracy, and how it is important to the citizens of new democracies, how it serves US interests, and how it promotes international peace.... nbsp;… This essay also looks at the benefits of the democratic rule of other countries to America.... The paper gives a line of thought of why America should continue to press for the democratic rule on other countries and how this impacts not only America, but also the citizens of the democracies and how they will benefit, and the impact on the larger international system....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The End of the Cold War

The author of the paper titled "The End of the Cold War" focuses on quite a number of aspects that led to the end of the cold war.... The main aspect for its end is the Soviet Union, but there are explaining factors that led to the downfall, of the USSR.... hellip; Concisely, from the above discussion, it is evident that the collapse of the USSR marked the end of the cold war....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us