StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper 'Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom' tells that The situation that Cynthia Cooper, the Vice President of Internal Audit in WorldCom, finds herself in gives many employees a dilemma. In this regard, employees find themselves in such situations, especially those that are concerned about fraud…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom"

Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom The situation that Cynthia Cooper, the Vice President of Internal Audit in WorldCom, finds herself in gives many employees a dilemma. In this regard, employees find themselves in such situations, especially those that concern fraud, like the case of Cynthia Cooper whose further investigation unearthed evidence to prove the fraud. On one hand, there is the option of taking the right action and whistle blowing these findings while risking retaliation from fellow employees. On the other hand, Cynthia has a choice of taking no action and risking her career while protecting the career of fellow workmates. This expose elucidates on the appropriate decision that Cynthia should take to deal with this issue. From the onset, it is crucial to point out that the right decision for Cynthia would be reporting these fraudulent acts to her superiors without making the information public. In order to make her case strong, Cynthia should use the findings from the additional investigations she carried out in order to ensure that the exposure has enough merit. However, it is crucial for her to seek another job before taking any action since the decision taken might leave her jobless. Any decision that one might take in such a situation has various implications. One such implication would be on the families affected by the whistle blowing in case of termination of careers and effectively the source of livelihood. Cynthia Hooper is no exceptional and has to consider her career and family and the careers of other employees, something I would do in her shoes. According to Sissela Bok, “Would-be whistleblowers confront the conflict inherent in all dissent: between conforming and sticking their necks out. The more repressive the authority they challenge, the greater the personal risk they take in speaking out” (as cited in Donaldson & Werhane, 2007). In this regard, there is a big risk of one’s livelihood and that of the family and the career of the whistleblower in case the superiors view such acts as dissent. Donaldson and Werhane (2007) further support this idea by stating that, “When audiences are not free to receive or to act on the information-when censorship or fear of retribution stifles response-then the message rebounds to injure the whistleblower.” The most important reason for reporting the extra findings indicate that Cynthia is showing responsibility by indicating the extra steps taken towards unearthing the truth. When making this decision however, it is crucial for her to remember that she may face accusations related to dissent and a breach of loyalty. Donaldson and Werhane (2007) further support this by arguing that the audience who receive this information may “impose certain requirements of accuracy and judgment in dissent; of exploring alternative ways to cope with improprieties that minimize the breach of loyalty; and of fairness in accusation. “ In effect, this argument may make an individual in Cynthia’s situation conform and fail to blow the whistle since she had engaged in her personal auditing, a position I would also consider if I were in her shoes. Therefore, the act of conducting a personal audit is an indication that she is on the journey of taking responsibility of her findings on fraudulent activities at WorldCom. Nevertheless, it is crucial to ensure that the results were 100 percent correct by carrying out an audit of the results. A breach of loyalty puts Cynthia’s livelihood and career at a risk. In addition, the careers and livelihoods of other employees are also at risk, which is also a violation of loyalty to some extent. However, reporting the additional findings without going public minimizes the breach of loyalty. Though contradictory to the decision that I would take if I were Cynthia should take, it is important to consider the element of public interest before disclosing this information. As a public limited company, WorldCom’s stakeholders deserve to know of any fraudulent activities. Nevertheless, Cynthia needs to consider what would be the action to take if she was amongst the shareholders at WorldCom. Aristotle supports this idea by pointing out that, “What is best in us-our virtues-are in turn defined by that larger community, and there is therefore no ultimate split of antagonism between individual self-interest and the greater public good” (cited in Donaldson & Werhane, 2007). However, this Aristotelian approach ultimately disagrees with my initial decision and would instead argue for Cynthia Cooper to be a whistleblower and to look our for the larger community instead of her own self-interests. Although the Aristotelian approach would advice Cynthia to be a whistleblower, the consequences and retaliation from different sources may hinder this decision. While the act of forwarding the additional findings is an indication of honesty and extolling virtues in the auditor that is Cynthia, this might be an antagonistic move according to the proposal by Aristotle regardless of the fact that Aristotle spoke in a time that corporations were inexistent. Nevertheless, Donaldson and Werhane (2007) noted that this approach by Aristotle “begins with the idea that it is individual virtue and integrity that counts: good corporate and social policy will follow; good corporate and social policies are both the preconditions and the result of careful cultivation and encouragement.” This idea of business ethics by Aristotle does not apply in Cynthia’s case since a number of people with integrity within the corporation had already come forward enquiring WorldCom’s questionable behavior and were effectively threatened or fired without any improvement or stoppage of the fraudulent business practices. On the other hand, Kant believed that the highest good was the good will, and that it is the intention behind an action rather than its consequences that made that particular action good (Donaldson & Werhane, 2007). In this regard, Cynthia Cooper’s intent is to bring to light the fraudulent behavior at WorldCom. In effect, Kant would agree that reporting the additional findings would be in good will. On the other hand, whistle blowing will not be necessary because Cynthia Cooper’s intent is to bring light this fraudulent behavior without causing too much disruption in both her and her co-workers lives. Therefore, All three of Kant’s formulations are applicable to Cynthia Cooper’s decision in report her findings and the additional findings to her superiors. According to the first formulation by Kant, an individual should “act only on maxims which you can will to be universal law” (cited in Donaldson & Werhane, 2002). In this regard, every individual in the universe would possibly act based on the principle of reporting this questionable fraudulent behavior to superiors within their company since it should be the most ethical thing. On the other hand, the second formulation by Kant says that every individual should “always treat the humanity in a person as an end, and never as a means merely” (cited in Donaldson & Werhane, 2002). In the case of Cynthia Cooper, she is not using humanity as a means to achieve anything. In effect, Cynthia Cooper’s concern might be her co-workers reputation, retirement accounts and the implications that whistle blowing could have on their future. Similarly, Cynthia Cooper is not using WorldCom to her benefit by reporting her findings. Finally, the third formulation by Kant states that, “So act as if you were a member of an ideal kingdom of ends in which you were both subject and sovereign at the same time” (cited in Donaldson & Werhane, 2007). In this case, Cynthia Cooper wants the company to stop the fraudulent behavior. Therefore, she is acting in a way that she would want somebody else to act if they were the one came across similar findings. It is my strong opinion that, if Cynthia owned the company, she would therefore want someone to report possible fraudulent financial findings. On the other hand, utilitarianism is an ethical theory by Mill that strives to bring the most amount of pleasure to most people. However, this theory does not correspond with my decision for Cynthia Cooper in reporting her additional findings without whistleblowing. In this regard, without whistle blowing, Cynthia Cooper would only make her co-workers happy since the findings are not public. On the other hand, whistle blowing effectively means that Cynthia Cooper’s co-workers risk losing their careers and source of livelihood once WorldCom carries out its investigations. On the other hand, millions of WorldCom’s shareholders would suffer from my decision of not blowing the whistle on these fraudulent activities. In this regard, they will be in the dark and ultimately this action may cost them in future once the truth surfaces years after Cynthia Cooper’s initial findings. I find it impossible to apply John Stuart Mill’s ethical belief that “actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness” (cited in Donaldson & Werhane, 2007). In this regard, any decision taken by Cynthia Cooper, whether going ahead and whistle blowing or not, will result in profound unhappiness by millions of people. On the other hand, I do think that making the decision to report her additional findings will satisfy Cynthia Cooper’s higher pleasure capacities of intellect, noble feelings, imagination, and moral sentiments. Although reporting her findings will not bring happiness to a number of people, Cynthia Cooper’s choice will display emotional intelligence, heroism, humility, moral imagination, and moral sentiments of justice, honesty and fairness. In conclusion and based on the foregoing, different theorists inform the type of decision I would take if I were in Cynthia Cooper’s shoes. Although any decision I would take would have adverse effects either to me, my co-workers, and shareholders in WorldCom, the best decision to take would be to report these findings to my superiors and await further action while preparing for any adverse effect this action might have on me as an individual. It is crucial to point out that my decision is a result of following Aristotle’s approach that individual virtue and honesty counts in the corporate world. In addition, Kant also informs my decision since I would be acting according to maxims on what I would like to be a universal law of reporting such fraudulent activities. These two approaches will play the most fundamental role in informing my decision. Reference Donaldson, T., & Werhane, P. (2007). Ethical Issues in Business: A philosophical approach (8th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ:  Prentice Hall. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1590189-cynthia-cooper-and-worldcom
(Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1590189-cynthia-cooper-and-worldcom.
“Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1590189-cynthia-cooper-and-worldcom.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Cynthia Cooper and WorldCom

Whistleblowers. The Process and Risks

cynthia cooper – Whistleblower of WorldCom cynthia cooper was working as vice president of internal audit at WorldCom.... Some of the recent examples of whistleblowers are Sherron Watkins of Enron, and Cyntha Cooper of worldcom.... Forgeries, scams and scandals are ever increasing in the corporate and non-corporate world....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Responsibilities that Impacts WorldCom

When the company merged with Advantage Companies, Inc, the company's name became LDDS worldcom in 1995.... In April 14, 2003, the name of the company was… 1 A lot of companies were bought by worldcom in the past.... The companies that were merged with worldcom were Advanced Communications Corp.... worldcom also acquired the mother company of Digex – the Intermedia Communications and sold all of its intermedia's non-Digex assets to Allegiance Telecom....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

External Auditing and Corporate Governance

More specifically, the paper focuses on the practice of corporate governance in the United Kingdom and the countries such as South Africa, Australia, US,… Since the rules and the laws of every country and region differ from one another, there are differences in the practice of corporate governance and external auditing too. With regards to corporate governance, a huge debate is raging the world of governance these days as to how the level of trust can be improved in our communities in regards to the governance bodies of companies, aboriginal communities and charitable corporation....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Extraordinary Circumstances - the Journey of a Corporate Whistleblower

This book talks about the longest served WorldCom chief audit executive, cynthia cooper who led her team to expose the largest fraud in corporate history.... In addition, the author discusses the struggles she had in overcoming challenges she MEMO (Insert the audience (Insert 19 March Book Assignment Introduction This book talks about thelongest served WorldCom chief audit executive, cynthia cooper who led her team to expose the largest fraud in corporate history....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Effective Corporate Whistle-Blower Hotline

Concerning with case provided, cynthia cooper was the whistle-blower who unveiled the fraudulent practices carried in the WorldCom.... Subsequently, after completing her graduation… It was observed that she joined worldcom during the year 1990 that was established as small and closely held company in the year 1980.... cynthia in the year 2002 discovered that the company used illegal practices to manipulate its accounts.... cynthia thus decided to carry out a secretive investigation on the fraud practices exercised by the company which then resulted to the termination of the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) Scott Sullivan....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Fraud in the AIS

hellip; The research paper showed that the accounting maneuver was exposed by the internal auditor in worldcom.... The risks and threats are clearly seen in the case of worldcom (Beltran, 2002).... nvestigations showed that the accounting maneuver was exposed by the internal auditor in worldcom.... Arthur Anderson had acted in collusion with top management at worldcom to falsify the company's profits with the aim of increasing its stocks....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Business Ethics of WorldCom

Some individuals who were permanently affected by the fraud were cynthia cooper.... The essay "Business Ethics of worldcom" analyzes the facts that relate to business ethics challenge in worldcom.... The issue that is also to be discussed is the important events in the industry that worldcom operated and the effects that the company brought to its competitors and to the labor market.... hellip; worldcom was acquired by Verizon communication, which had been in business since the 19th century....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Ethical Issues in Whistle Blowing by Internal Auditors

This paper "Ethical Issues in Whistle Blowing by Internal Auditors" focuses on the fact that in Brown and Williamson Company, Jeffrey Wigand was the senior vice-president of research wing.... He attempted to blow the whistle how the top management of his company lied before Congress.... hellip; Cigarette smoking is injurious to health and is linked to lung cancer, heart attack and other life-threatening medical issues....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us