StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Aquinas Thinking of Ethics: Promoting Equality and Goodwill in Society - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper will highlight and analyze the similarities and differences between Kant and Aquinas’ concepts of ethics and the moral value of actions. The positive and negative aspects of both concepts will then be analyzed for their application to a culturally diverse society…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
The Aquinas Thinking of Ethics: Promoting Equality and Goodwill in Society
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Aquinas Thinking of Ethics: Promoting Equality and Goodwill in Society"

Introduction Thomas Aquinas and Immanuel Kant did a significant amount of work on moral philosophy. Kant was a believer that moral requirements are based on the standard of rationality which was referred to as the “Categorical Imperative” (Johnson, 2008). His arguments concerning ethics and moral value were deontological and his work on ethics is referred to as Kantian Ethics. Aquinas shared many views with Aristotle. His thought regarding ethics is based on the Cardinal values of prudence, temperance, justice and fortitude. His work gave rise to the philosophical school of thought referred to as Thomism. This paper will highlight and analyze the similarities and differences between Kant and Aquinas’ concepts of ethics and the moral value of actions. The positive and negative aspects of both concepts will then be analyzed for their application to a culturally diverse society. Agreement in Thoughts Both Kant and Aquinas attach a great significance to the role of practical reason in ethical life. Among other similarities in thinking, both philosophers emphasize on the importance of law in ethics and both make claims that certain kinds of actions are good and evil in them selves (Hinton, 2002). Practical reason refers to the general human capacity for resolving through reflection, the question of what to do. It considers a set of alternatives to determine what ought to be done (Wallace, 2003). Kant and Aquinas agreed that ethics are derived from practical reasoning and suggested that this concept allows one to distinguish good actions from bad ones. Emphasizing the importance of law in ethics, Aquinas establishes the concept of Natural Law which refers to ones compliance to the order of reason which directs the will. Kant focuses on the concept of Universal law emphasizing that one is obliged to conform to duty by laws that be relevant to us. Despite the many similarities in thought both Aquinas and Kant differ significantly in many concepts. Differences of Thought The dissimilarity among the concepts of right the thinking of Aquinas and Kant emerge the very basic level of the fundamentals of ethics. Aquinas held that what is good should always hold superiority over what is right. Kant on the other hand discarded this dogma with his own core concept of ethics. He believed that what is right should always hold priority over what is good. His concepts of ethics were based on the thought that moral obligation should be consequential of nothing other than duty. Kant believed the notion of duty to be supreme. For him an action held no moral importance if it was not backed by the motive of duty. Aquinas and Kant’s principles of ethics also differed in terms of the principle of moral laws. Kant felt that moral law is a standard of rational and cannot be supported on reliant essentials about what will result in happiness. Aquinas held that an act can only be considered good if it executes the will of God. He believed that good and moral activities pursued the purpose of happiness, which cannot completely be found in this temporary world. Another difference in thought is that Kant believed that actions being right or wrong are not determined by the outcome of the act. In fact they are judged by the motivation of the one who carries out the deed. For Aquinas, the perception of virtue and ethics in order to establish the moral value of an act is that, it is essential to consider both the intent and the circumstance surrounding the action. Analyzing the Concepts I feel the positive elements in Kant’s deontological system can be applied to everyone everywhere under all situations. If something is considered moral a person is required to do it without giving consideration to what they want to do without submitting to their own desires, it would be executed as a mere duty. Every individual under particular circumstance would be expected to act morally on the basis of duty to do the right thing. This concept treats everyone equally and lays down rules of duty which every individual is to follow. The negative aspect of Kant’s thoughts regarding ethics is that it does not assume the consequences of the actions. According to Kant’s view of morality a person is obliged to do whatever is right without giving consideration to the consequences which the action might result in. This concept cannot be applied fully to life since life is far more complicated and the outcome of situations is every essential to consider since no two situations are alike and they call for different actions to be taken. This may even cause issues when an individual is faced with the dilemma of two clashing duties. Kant’s philosophy on ethics can is difficult to accept for a free culturally diverse human community since it does not actually take the diversity of culture into account. It does not recognize cultural obstructions and the fact that the same moral principles are not applicable across every culture. Conclusion Kant and Aquinas both have their own versions of the moral doctrine. There are some basic similarities in terms of the significance of practical reason and law to ethics, but the fundamental principles for both are quite distinguished. Both have different ideas regarding how to determine what is morally right and the actual moral value of an action. Kant believes that obligation is derives solely from duty, and that one should do what is right without considering the consequences. Principles of categorical imperative are obligatory regardless of ones desire to do otherwise. Aquinas on the other hand believes the concept of doing good as coming before that of doing what is correct. According to this principle when one sees good, he must desire to go towards it. In comparison the Aquinas thinking of ethics, Kant’s thinking has some positive points such as promoting equality and good will in society. However Kant’s universalisability aspect the approach makes it difficult to apply to the culturally diverse society, by not recognizing the diversity of culture and moral values for each. Reference Jay Wallace. Practical Reason. 2003. November 30, 2009 Robert Johnson. Kants Moral Philosophy. 2008. November 30, 2009 < http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/practical-reason/ > Timothy Hinton. Kant and Aquinas on the Prioirty of the Good. Philosophy Education Society Inc. 2002. Immanuel Kant & Lara Denis. Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals. Mississauga Canada. Broadview Press. 2005. Thomas Aquinas & Richard Regan. The Cardinal Virtues: Prudence, Justice, Fortitude and Temperance. Indianapolis, Indiana. Hackett Publishing. 2005. Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Aquinas Thinking of Ethics: Promoting Equality and Goodwill in Research Paper”, n.d.)
The Aquinas Thinking of Ethics: Promoting Equality and Goodwill in Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1560535-essay-midterm
(The Aquinas Thinking of Ethics: Promoting Equality and Goodwill in Research Paper)
The Aquinas Thinking of Ethics: Promoting Equality and Goodwill in Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1560535-essay-midterm.
“The Aquinas Thinking of Ethics: Promoting Equality and Goodwill in Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1560535-essay-midterm.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Aquinas Thinking of Ethics: Promoting Equality and Goodwill in Society

Saint Thomas Aquinas and his influence on Western thought

Name Instructor Course Date Saint Thomas aquinas and his influence on Western thought St.... Thomas aquinas is also referred to as Aquino, lived between 1225- 1274.... He was an Italian theologian as well as philosopher during the medieval era (Gilby and aquinas 5).... One could only conclude that Aquino's existence was needed at this time when Catholic politics and the events in the world needed great intervention (aquinas and Regan 73)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

The Life and Effect of St Thomas Aquinas

Thomas aquinas 1.... hellip; Thomas aquinas otherwise referred to as a biography.... Thomas aquinas Introduction A great philosopher and theologist, Saint Thomas aquinas was born in Aquino a small town in south Italy in January 1225.... Some claim that the family acquired the name aquinas from the small Italian town they lived in.... Thomas aquinas otherwise referred to as a biography.... Early life His father was Landulph aquinas the count of Aquino and his mother Theodore the countess of teano....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Thomas Aquinas - Law, Morality and Politics

In this regard, Thomas aquinas (1225-1274), one of the prominent Italian thinkers of the Middle Ages during which the ground was laid for the upcoming early modern period with its upsurge in political philosophy, presents a very indicative example when an issue that constitutes one of the most hotly debated political problems nowadays was equally important for this medieval philosopher.... However, despite influences on aquinas from the political climate of that time, we can perhaps find out the essence of his view on the mentioned problem that still would be relevant for our todays situation....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Critical Thinking and Ethics

However, personal ethics can change with a period of time and changing experiences though the morals and values forming the foundation of ethics may continue to be the same.... Social responsibility is concerned with the behavior considering the society as well as variables surrounding the individual e.... ("Personal Ethics and Life") Since, man is a social animal and cannot be divided from the society, it would be correct to say that the personal ethics need an evaluation as well as a serious thought for linking them with social responsibility....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

GoodWill: Offering People a Chance Not Charity

goodwill Industries International, the seventh largest nonprofit organization and one of the worlds largest providers of workforce development and employment services, served a record 448,563 individuals in 2000 and reports a new high of $1.... 5 (b) billion in revenues for the… The figures represent an increase of 20 percent in people served since 1999 and a steady annual revenue rise of 12 percent. goodwill Industries provides a broad range of training courses for in-demand jobs in fields such as computer programming, health care, financial Life skills training and counseling, elements of GoodWills core services, help to prepare individuals for the demands of the workplace....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

A Comparison of Aquinas and Maximus' Theories of Human and Divine Will

Thomas aquinas and St.... This Thomas aquinas and St.... aquinas and Maximus agree that humans have a will, or choice when dealing with issues of God.... aquinas asserted “that for the knowledge of any truth whatsoever man needs Divine help, that the intellect may be moved by God to its act.... ??1 Despite this statement, aquinas thought that humans have a natural instinct to have knowledge without Divine revelation....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Augustine and Aquinas

o the act of Rhonda may be considered evil as it was intentional and done by the her own will and not forced, as defined by the aquinas's philosophy while it was leading to an evil outcome as her friends might feel bad if they know that they were part of the daily gossip activities of their supposed friend, ‘Rhonda'.... Although his absenteeism was allowed by the management Augustine and aquinas of the of Augustine and aquinas Page I believe that the ethical motive of the office workeris that the he is obliged to stay at his job till his duty requires....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Aquinas on the Virtue of Charity

In light of the analysis of the aquinas's sources of information, this paper answers the following question: For what principle reason or reasons is the moral life, animated by supernatural charity, a life enlivened by the Holy Spirit?... Aristotle explains this idea clearly in chapter eight of his ethics, the Nicomachean Ethics, “But for those who thus good we ascribe only goodwill if the wish is not reciprocated; goodwill when it is reciprocated being friendship....
9 Pages (2250 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us