StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Philosophy - Freedom, Responsibility, and Human Action - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper 'Philosophy - Freedom, Responsibility, and Human Action" focuses on the fact that intuition is referring to a mental process that enables a thinker to gain new knowledge. Intuition can be used as a tool in gaining new knowledge, it is not considered as a reliable source of information. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
Philosophy - Freedom, Responsibility, and Human Action
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Philosophy - Freedom, Responsibility, and Human Action"

Philosophy - Freedom, Responsibility, and Human Action Table of Contents I. Introduction ……………………………………………………………. 3 II. Researcher’s Personal View: Intuition’s Role on Human Action and Moral Responsibility …………………………….. 3 III. Does Recent Empirical Evidences of Major Causes of Human Action and Moral Intuitions Undermines the Role of Intuition in Philosophical Discourse on Human Freedom and Responsibility? …………………………………………………………. 5 IV. Conclusion ……………………………………………………………… 6 References ……………………………………………………………………… 7 Introduction According to Burtt (1953), the word intuition is referring to a mental process that enables a thinker to gain new knowledge. Even though intuition can be used as a tool in gaining new knowledge, intuition is not always considered as a reliable source of information based on experimental philosophy due to lack of scientific evidences that verifies the truth behind the new information. After reading ‘The Illusion of Conscious Will’ written by Wegner (2002) and ‘Does Consciousness Cause Behavior?’ as edited by Pockett, Banks, and Gallagher (2006), the researcher will discuss his/her own personal views with regards to the role of intuition on human action and moral responsibility. Eventually, the researcher will discuss whether or not the recent empirical evidences related to the major causes of human action or the variable status of certain moral intuitions undermines the role of intuition in philosophical discourse on human freedom and responsibility. Regardless of whether the researcher agrees or disagree with the claims that these recent empirical evidences weakens the role of intuition in philosophical point-of-view on human freedom and responsibility, the researcher will provide examples or possible alternatives as a way of defending the researcher’s answer to the question. Researcher’s Personal View: Intuition’s Role on Human Action and Moral Responsibility Even though most of the human actions are controlled by environmental and genetic factors, intuition also has a role in controlling some of our actions. Basically, intuition serves as our inner higher guidance. Even before we perform an action, intuition tells us to whether or not to proceed with our intended action. Based on a person’s final judgment or decision, his or her moral responsibility as a human being will be greatly affected by his own actions. For example: A man who needs a large sum of money for his child’s heath care needs and surgery bill may end up thinking about robbing a bank or stealing something that costs a large sum of money from a stranger. Even before the man decides on whether to push through with his plan, the man will have to undergo a mental balancing between the benefit and consequences as well as the moral issues behind his intended action. At this point, intuition would normally hold the man from doing something that is morally unacceptable. Another example will be a student who is in danger of failing a subject at the end of the semester. In order to avoid failing the subject, the student may end up either choosing between copying his or her seatmate’s paper or simply put in extra effort in doing his homework and studying more in order to enable him to get a higher grade during the final exam. In line with this scenario, the student may also think about seeking special teaching-learning guidance from his or her professor to enable him to get a better idea and understanding about the subject matter. Based on the second example, the student’s intuition may restrict him from doing a morally unacceptable action. Instead, his intuition enabled him to develop optional ways wherein he could get higher marks on homework and quizzes during the last quarter of the semester. Does Recent Empirical Evidences of Major Causes of Human Action and Moral Intuitions Undermines the Role of Intuition in Philosophical Discourse on Human Freedom and Responsibility? There are a lot of recent empirical evidences that could explain the causes of human actions. Most of these empirical evidences can be explained with the use of different studies related to the human anatomy and physiology. Pockett, Banks, & Gallagher (2006: p. 237) published a philosophical statement stating that ‘it is not possible for an idea to move a muscle since ideas does not have any form of mass and there is no solid object that could connect ideas to the muscle fiber or the neuron of a muscle’. The researcher finds this statement true in the sense that ideas are normally considered as purely thoughts. Basically, it is the brain that produces ideas and thoughts including the control of the muscle movements. For this reason, the absence of the brain makes it impossible for an idea to move a muscle. Considering all the recent empirical evidences that can be used in explaining the major causes of human action does not necessarily undermines the role of intuition related to the philosophical discourse on human freedom and responsibility. Scientific-based evidences can only explain how motor functions in the human body works but not necessarily within the context of intuition. According to Wegner (2002: p. 2), there is a clear distinction between how human intuition can cause human actions from the mechanical explanation that explain how body movement works in order to perform an action. Basically, it is the willingness of a person to perform an action that causes him to perform an action. However, there will always be a limitation to the rule such that not all individuals who are willing to perform an action will eventually perform the acts. For example: Joe is a very poor man who earns only US$1 per day out of begging from the side walks. Joe heard about the recent news on China’s earthquake that killed more than 50,000 people. Because of Joe’s kind heart, his intuition gave him the idea to financially help the victims. Due to financial limitations, Joe did not do anything about it. Even though Joe is totally free and is very much willing to make a morally good action by financially helping the victims in China’s recent earthquake, his financial limitations left him with no option but to chose not to take actions at all. Conclusion Based on the examples presented on this study, the researcher concludes that the recent empirical evidences that causes human action and moral intuition does not necessarily undermines the role of intuition in terms of philosophical discourse in human freedom and responsibility. Empirical evidences that explains the physical or mechanical body movements is totally a different context when it comes to the subject that focuses on how intuition affects the human action and his moral responsibility as a human being. For this reason, the researcher finds it impractical and senseless to compare the two. *** End *** References: Burtt, E.A. "Intuition in Eastern and Western Philosophy." Philosophy East and West (1953): Vol. 2, No. 4, pp. 283 - 291. Pockett, Susan, William P. Banks and Shaun Gallagher. Does Consciousness Cause Behavior? Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 2006. Wegner, Daniel M. The Illusion of Conscious Will. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 2002. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Philosophy - Freedom, Responsibility, and Human Action Essay, n.d.)
Philosophy - Freedom, Responsibility, and Human Action Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1546956-philosophy-freedom-responsibility-and-human-action-please-see-the-attachment-for-detail
(Philosophy - Freedom, Responsibility, and Human Action Essay)
Philosophy - Freedom, Responsibility, and Human Action Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1546956-philosophy-freedom-responsibility-and-human-action-please-see-the-attachment-for-detail.
“Philosophy - Freedom, Responsibility, and Human Action Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1546956-philosophy-freedom-responsibility-and-human-action-please-see-the-attachment-for-detail.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Philosophy - Freedom, Responsibility, and Human Action

The philosophical ideas of determinism, compatibilism and libertarianism

Determinist believes that irrelevant to the action and thoughts of a person, the events happen according to a predetermined frame work of deeds.... These are certain concepts which are largely connected to human lives and the way they contemplate life.... Determinism and compatibilism are two philosophical concepts which are strongly connected to human acts, behavior and events happening as a result.... In the same way, determinism is exclusively related to the freedom of human to act or react, just as compatibility....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

French Philosopher Sartre on Consciousness

(O'Donohoe, 2005)Sartre wrote about many things, mainly the essence of what it is to be human.... However, among his earliest concepts and for which he based his theory of "existentialism" involved the structure and nature of human consciousness, which he eventually attempted to explain in what is considered his masterpiece, "Being or Nothingness.... His importance lies, however, in the defence of his stand on the absolute right of humans to freedom and responsibility....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Compare and contrast the ideas about human nature in two theorists Hobbes and Locke

Modern form of this theory, known as 'ethical egoism', postulates that a self-interested action should be regarded as a standard of good (Rachels, 2008).... John Locke and Thomas Hobbes were both outstanding thinkers who studied human society and laws that governed the realm of social relations but their views on human nature, power and authority contrasted sharply.... hellip; Despite certain similarities that were largely due to similar historic and intellectual context of the Enlightenment, the philosophers maintained dramatic differences in their views on social structure, political organization and the nature of human being. Hobbes did not share the recognized assumption that man was a social animal by his nature claiming that society could not exist without the power of the state and proper government....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The role of evil in Aristotle, Kant and Hannah Arendt

Having crated the source of the amorality not in some separate psychological ability, but in the insufficient abnormal development of any of them (or all of them), Aristotle has closely come to the understanding of the systematic inner world of the human being.... The aim of this work is to discuss the evil from the viewpoint of Aristotle, Kant and Arendt, and to see how the concept of genocide applies to their ideas....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

David Hume: The Free Will and Responsibility Debate

The report analyses the relationship between 'Freedom of action' and Moral Responsibility.... Whether David Hume believes that freedom of action is sufficient for moral responsibility has become a point of much contention amongst Hume scholars.... To ascertain whether freedom of action is sufficient for moral responsibility it is necessary to examine both interpretations.... It is in A Treatise of human Nature (1777) that Hume first engages with these debates and positions himself between the poles of determinism and voluntarism....
34 Pages (8500 words) Book Report/Review

Determinism Versus Libertarianism

The argument is that the phenomenon of the big bang would unleash every action using the system of cause and effect.... The paper "Determinism Versus Libertarianism" discusses that libertarianism argues that the decisions of human beings are not caused.... hellip; Libertarians argue that free will allows human beings to be attracted by what is good.... Evil and misery is something which human beings would not desire.... The good is present in many forms which give human beings a wide variety of actions to choose from....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

The Philosophy of Human Nature

This term paper "The Philosophy of human Nature" focuses on one of the most important aspects of the study of philosophy.... Different philosophers have explained the characteristics of human nature in different ways.... nbsp;… Freedom is regarded as the central theme in Descartes' philosophy of human nature, where it has been associated with “the theme of the infinite”.... According to Descartes: “it is through the freedom of the will, experienced as unlimited, that the human understands itself to bear the "image and likeness" of the infinite God”....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

A Vision of the Good Life

This school of thought holds that the outcome of action has a greater value than the action.... On the contrary, the deontology school of thought holds that action is dependent on the scriptures, which entail moral laws, rules, and intuition (Goodin, 1995).... In this theory, the course is that the action and outcome must both be ethical.... Thus, according to the deontological theory, an action must accomplish the duty for the sake of duty....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us