StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Two-Tier Healthcare - Admission/Application Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
TWO-TIER HEALTHCARE Few can deny that healthcare is one of the most important things we require as citizens. Without our health, we have reduced capacity and a reduced enjoyment of life. It is therefore very important that we find a way to access the best possible healthcare…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Two-Tier Healthcare
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Two-Tier Healthcare"

Download file to see previous pages

Canada is a fortunate country as it guarantees healthcare for all. But again the problem of costs arises. The government pays for everything, no matter how expensive. The result is that the Canadian healthcare budget is growing out of control. We need reform. The most moral and just kind of reform would be to implement a two-tier or mixed system of healthcare delivery. This will lower costs and ensure that healthcare does not become unaffordable for all. The truth is that healthcare is as Norman Daniels puts it “a special good” (146).

It it not like other things in our economy and society. The economist Brian Lee Crowley puts the issue succinctly as follows: Two-tier health care is a slippery concept. Everybody seems to think they know what it is, but I think that there is a lot more confusion than people realize. As some have already pointed out, we have a lot of angry discussions about “preventing” two-tier access in Canada, and yet we clearly already have multi-tier access, including to insured services. If you are on workers comp, are in the RCMP or the military, if your company has its own salaried physicians, if you use a private hospital like Shouldice in Toronto, if you are a member of the medical professions or know someone who is, or are just articulate and determined, or if you travel abroad to the US or any one of a number of other places, you can get better, faster or more satisfactory care than someone who just lets the wheels of medicare grind on.

Moreover, technology is allowing the remote delivery of more and more health services, so the ability of governments to frustrate patients’ desire to get better and faster treatment than the government is willing to provide them, is declining, and that decline will accelerate. (Crowley) The very phrasing of the debate as one of different tiers suggests something about unfairness. Ideally, this would be a debate about a mixed system which offers public and private, not a system for rich and poor.

There are many in Canadian who consider the healthcare system the thing they are most proud of. But this is an idea that belongs to an earlier phase of Canadian history. Throughout most of Canadian history, Canadians have defined their identity in the negative. They have seen what happened south of the border and had a knee-jerk reaction, saying: We're not like that. They have refused to consider how they can learn from the best examples in the United States. The attitude to many on the left in Canada, is that nothing must change about the healthcare system.

It must remain exactly as it is. Otherwise, Canada will become like the U.S. This is a very simple argument which works best on children and not on reasonable adults. This is, at its heart, an immoral argument. It is based on jingoism, not reality. The truth is that by denying Canadians the rights to choose between public and private healthcare we are limiting freedom and increasing the burden on the public system. The most moral thing to do in this situation is to permit the market to work, permit the market to lower prices and allow competition.

That is the best possible way for consumers to get what they need. The alternative is to continue to allow the healthcare system to be centrally planned and controlled, and to continue the immoral rationing that already happens. It is important to note the Supreme Court of Canada decision in Chaouilli, which stated that not providing

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Two-Tier Healthcare Admission/Application Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1428919-n-canada-is-two-tier-mri-just-is-it-morally
(Two-Tier Healthcare Admission/Application Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1428919-n-canada-is-two-tier-mri-just-is-it-morally.
“Two-Tier Healthcare Admission/Application Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1428919-n-canada-is-two-tier-mri-just-is-it-morally.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Two-Tier Healthcare

The Points-Based System Makes Migration Work in Britain

The Points Based System Makes Migration Work in Britain Britain has remained as a leading industrial and naval power in 19th century.... Over one-fourth of the earth's surface was under ‘The British Empire'.... The two world wars and the withdrawal of Irish republic from its union in 19th century, showed the depletion in Britain's strength....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Inequality in the Mexican Health Care Organization

2013) Inequality in the Mexican health care organization and how it can be addressed Introduction Mexico is one of the few countries that has made major strides towards providing accessible healthcare services for all citizens, through a system of both private and public healthcare arrangement that has seen 50% of the countries population being covered by the public healthcare system, while the rest of the 50% is financing the healthcare services from their own pockets (Barraza-Llorens et al....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Health Care System in the United Kingdom and its Features

healthcare in United Kingdom is a wholesome system that has developed remarkably in the past few years and the process is continuing till date.... The World Health Organization ranked UK healthcare system as the 15th best in Europe and 18th across the world.... They monitor and maintain the quality of services and development plans for area based improvement in healthcare industry.... There are trusts and other entities that monitor further healthcare requirements....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

International Environment Policy: U.K. and Germany

The paper “International Environment Policy: U.... .... and Germany” discusses some similarities and differences based on the four main policy areas.... This paper seeks to analyze these similarities and differences and thereafter draws a conclusion based on the findings.... hellip; The author states that the UK has a number of specialized programs available for various types of work such as; training and work experience, business entrepreneurs, highly skilled migrants; however, the workhorse option for most companies sending U....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

The Future of Health Care Delivery in Canada

The Canadian health delivery system is structured in such a way that it is a mixed public-private health care delivery system, with the government being responsible for financing the healthcare services.... First, the healthcare system in Canada lacks equity and fairness among the population, an issue that needs to be addressed in future.... The Canadian health delivery system is structured in such a way that it is a mixed public-private health care delivery system, with the government being responsible for financing the healthcare services, while the private sector is responsible for providing the healthcare services to the patients, with very little funding of such services (Turnbull, 2011)....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Employee Benefits-Medical Plans and Health Care

healthcare benefits cost-sharing has become very strained.... In the paper “Employee Benefits-Medical Plans and Health Care” the author analyzes several factors that are associated with the increase in the cost of health care.... The rising cost of health care in the USA can be traced to the underlying spending on doctors, specialists, dentists and physicians....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Comparison of the American and Canadian Healthcare Systems

The paper "Comparison of the American and Canadian healthcare Systems" states that the multi-layered system in the United States still leaves some Americans without health care coverage a factor that denies them an opportunity to access health care services even when they need them.... Since it is universal, the Canadian health care system ensures that people can access healthcare services when in need.... The single-layer healthcare system seems to deliver outcomes, which are more positive, explaining why members of the public have exhibited preferences for it....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

History of Managed Care in the US

He raised money to start the cooperative through selling shares and fixed annual fees to pay by the patients to cater for their healthcare costs (National Council of Disability, 2013).... At the same year, two physicians- Donald Ross and Clifford Loos - entered into a contract of providing comprehensive healthcare services to 2,000 employees from a water company, which was in the neighborhood.... Most such healthcare plans have been introduced in the past 40 years....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us